Transubstantiation and Catholic Scientists

  • Thread starter Thread starter brb3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I remembered this miracle from before. All I did was googled Lanciano and chose this particular link. Like the Shroud of Turing you will links with in depth knowledge and others with not so much. Here are some others:

miraclerosarymission.org/lanciano.html

trosch.org/inx/lanciano.html

michaeljournal.org/eucharist3.htm
Thanks … scanned them quickly, very interesting !! Printed them out, will review more thoroughly later today.

I’m a scientist, but have no problem believing in miracles. I’ve had several happen in my life … in recent years. The interesting thing is I never experienced a miraculous event sign from God] before I converted to Christianity. In my younger days, I would challenge God to ‘prove Himself’ to me via some sign [such as breaking one of the laws of nature for me to ‘observe’.] I promised God if he would do something like this, give me a sign … I would be a believer. Never happened for me in those days. However, God did do something to help my faith, through people. Sent several people into my life who could explain the Plan of Salvation, which led to full confession/conversion.

Now, much later in life, with a strong faith over last 2 years, since converting from Protestant to Catholic Church, God has shown me several amazing Signs, to confirm / fortify my faith. I’m not unique in this regard, so if God would allow me to witness/experience amazing evidences of ‘supernatural’ events [things clearly outside the realm of science to explain] … he is giving similar signs to others. I’m coming to learn that other Christians also admit to receiving miraculous signs / events in their lives … which they know were of God. Things they cannot attribute to coincidence. Answered prayers especially … but, ever so often an amazing ‘sign’ from God that is done not to ‘impress us’, but to fortify and strengthen us IN CHRIST.

Now, the Eucharist is the HEART of Catholicism. Apart from the host, we have no life in us [per Words of Christ in John’s Gospel]. If we can’t perceive & receive ALL of Christ in the Eucharist … we have a major ‘faith’ problem. Thus, it is of no surprize to me that God in his Grace/Mercy would of allowed amazing signs/miracles to occur over time regarding the Eucharist.
 
I remember reading this one website once where an atheist was railing against how silly and stupid the belief in the real presence was. He argued that if you took a consecrated host it still looks, tastes, smells and feels like it did before the consecration. Any chemical analysis would indisputably show it was still bread. Therefore transubstantiation didn’t happen and was a silly belief.

Later on a commenter made the correct observation that: “You realize nothing you wrote is contradicted by Catholic theology.” Of course he was merely speaking about the physical and chemical properties, but there really wasn’t much in the way of rebuttal other than uninformed ex-catholics then trying to tell everybody what they were taught by Sister in 3rd grade and how they were told it really did become flesh and blood etc. etc.

ChadS
 
Someone just told me today that they read an article in a Catholic newspaper that said that some scientists did look at the host and they did find DNA in it. She said she will cut out the article and bring it to me. After I read it, I will come back to this thread and give you the details.
 
Someone just told me today that they read an article in a Catholic newspaper that said that some scientists did look at the host and they did find DNA in it. She said she will cut out the article and bring it to me. After I read it, I will come back to this thread and give you the details.
Wheat does have DNA 🙂 But presumably they were asserting that the host in this particular case contained identifiably human DNA.

If so, that would be a (very strange and microscopic) Eucharistic miracle, not something we expect with every incident of transubstantiation.

Usagi
 
I am a scientist, a physicist, and I believe in the real presence and in the physical presence of Christ in the Eucharist. There is one main thing that a lot of people do not understand when it comes to the theology and the physics of the sacrament of the Eucharist. We all believe (or at least we should) in Jesus’ sacramental presence in the Eucharist. When it comes to physics a lot of people loose track of two common constraints. The first is that as human beings with a corporal reality we are bound by the laws of physics. The second is that a glorified body is subject to the will and that such will is completely aligned with the will of God and it shares in His divinity, thus we have a change of constraints and now the laws of physics are bound by the power of the will. We can verify that the last statement is true by simply looking at Jesus’ corporal actions after the resurrection, His ascension, and the assumption of the BVM, those physical actions would have not being possible if the laws of physics were not bound by the power of the will. However, that does not mean that the laws of physics stop existing.
 
Thanks … scanned them quickly, very interesting !! Printed them out, will review more thoroughly later today.

I’m a scientist, but have no problem believing in miracles. I’ve had several happen in my life … in recent years. The interesting thing is I never experienced a miraculous event sign from God] before I converted to Christianity. In my younger days, I would challenge God to ‘prove Himself’ to me via some sign [such as breaking one of the laws of nature for me to ‘observe’.] I promised God if he would do something like this, give me a sign … I would be a believer. Never happened for me in those days. However, God did do something to help my faith, through people. Sent several people into my life who could explain the Plan of Salvation, which led to full confession/conversion.

Now, much later in life, with a strong faith over last 2 years, since converting from Protestant to Catholic Church, God has shown me several amazing Signs, to confirm / fortify my faith. I’m not unique in this regard, so if God would allow me to witness/experience amazing evidences of ‘supernatural’ events [things clearly outside the realm of science to explain] … he is giving similar signs to others. I’m coming to learn that other Christians also admit to receiving miraculous signs / events in their lives … which they know were of God. Things they cannot attribute to coincidence. Answered prayers especially … but, ever so often an amazing ‘sign’ from God that is done not to ‘impress us’, but to fortify and strengthen us IN CHRIST.

Now, the Eucharist is the HEART of Catholicism. Apart from the host, we have no life in us [per Words of Christ in John’s Gospel]. If we can’t perceive & receive ALL of Christ in the Eucharist … we have a major ‘faith’ problem. Thus, it is of no surprize to me that God in his Grace/Mercy would of allowed amazing signs/miracles to occur over time regarding the Eucharist.
There have been studies of some of the Eucharistic miracles and together with some of the Shroud research, I know His blood type is AB+

The flesh of the Eucharist, studied, is a human heart muscle…which completlt threw me for a moment, until I realised its significance. Not sure what I expected, but Christ Wills that organ to ‘materialise’ as He Wills.

WYATT - is a non-Catholic researcher who reminds us that God owns ALL creation and His Truth and revelations are not only through the Catholic Church, or her members. Every human soul ever born has a part to play in God’s plan and timing and things revealed may come through any of His children, and indead His created universe itself.

Keep your minds as open as your eyes.

I haven’t the links (or time - late here) but they’re not hard to find, as I found.

:cool:
 
There have been studies of some of the Eucharistic miracles and together with some of the Shroud research, I know His blood type is AB+
I have read, though, that all very old blood samples test as AB, no matter the original type. Sadly, then, that aspect of Lanciano and the Shroud may not serve as cross-confirmation of the miracles in the way we hoped.
The flesh of the Eucharist, studied, is a human heart muscle…which completlt threw me for a moment, until I realised its significance. Not sure what I expected, but Christ Wills that organ to ‘materialise’ as He Wills.
You may wish to clarify that the miraculous Host of Lanciano, specifically, has been studied and found to consist of human endocardial tissue. Under most circumstances, as has already been mentioned in the thread, the Real Presence is not amenable to medical study, and the Church teaches that the Host and wine mysteriously become the entire living Jesus, “Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity,” not any specific piece of Him.

Usagi
 
Snippet from;
(Corpus Christi homily on Eucharistic Miracles)
by Fr. Tommy Lane

…in the year 700. A monk who feared he was losing his vocation was celebrating Mass, and during the consecration the host turned into flesh and the wine turned into blood. Despite the fact that the miracle took place almost 1300 years ago, you may still see the flesh in a monstrance which is exposed every day and the blood in a glass chalice. (The glass chalice is beneath the monstrance on the right.) I also had the privilege of seeing that eucharistic miracle during my time in Italy. The blood has congealed and is now in five clots in the glass chalice. In 1971 and 1981 a hospital laboratory tested the flesh and blood and discovered that the flesh is myocardium, which is heart muscular tissue, so we could say it is the heart of Jesus, the Sacred Heart, and the blood is of the blood group AB. In 1978 NASA scientists tested the blood on the Turin Shroud and interestingly also discovered that it is of the blood group AB. (The Sudarium, Face Cloth of Christ, in John 20:6 is also of the blood group AB.) Despite the fact that human flesh and blood should not have remained preserved for 1300 years the hospital lab tests found no trace of any preservatives. One final interesting point about the five blood clots in the chalice is that when you weigh one of them, it is the same weight as all five together, two of them together weigh the same as all five. In fact no matter what way you combine the blood clots individually or in a group to weigh them, they always weigh the same. (This shows that the full Jesus is present in a particle of the Eucharist no matter how small.)

These are two eucharistic miracles I have seen and which have been authenticated by the Church after investigation. …]

FYI
:cool:
 
Eucharistic miracles like Lanciano are “worthy of belief,” according to the Church; but that’s not scientific proof of anything. It’s a very good indication, but it’s only an indication.

Running around saying, “I know for sure that Jesus’ blood type is AB positive because of Lanciano” seems a bit presumptuous; and it’s not the only and best argument for everything. Loving Lanciano is a good thing, but it’s not the key for every lock.

Lanciano isn’t the Bible and isn’t Church teaching; it’s a nice lagniappe to help us believe the Bible and Church teaching. A visual aid, if you will.
 
Eucharistic miracles like Lanciano are “worthy of belief,” according to the Church; but that’s not scientific proof of anything. It’s a very good indication, but it’s only an indication.

Running around saying, “I know for sure that Jesus’ blood type is AB positive because of Lanciano” seems a bit presumptuous; and it’s not the only and best argument for everything. Loving Lanciano is a good thing, but it’s not the key for every lock.

Lanciano isn’t the Bible and isn’t Church teaching; it’s a nice lagniappe to help us believe the Bible and Church teaching. A visual aid, if you will.
Evidence is a human venture for objective truth. Based on Lanciano and the Shroud of Turin, both have yielded AB as the blood type. Taken together, the evidence available thus far STATES so!

That said, there are ‘murmurs’ that old blood become AB! This is not our experience in forensics but it depends on how old ‘old’ is, because some of our cases are decades old and still test whatever blood type was when originally found or taken. I am not talking of the computer conversion of a blood ‘profile’ but the actual swap retested from the gathered evidence.

Visual aid?!
Go there! Yes, it’s still there in Italy …or Google is your friend.

:cool:
 
Evidence is a human venture for objective truth. Based on Lanciano and the Shroud of Turin, both have yielded AB as the blood type. Taken together, the evidence available thus far STATES so!

That said, there are ‘murmurs’ that old blood become AB! This is not our experience in forensics but it depends on how old ‘old’ is, because some of our cases are decades old and still test whatever blood type was when originally found or taken. I am not talking of the computer conversion of a blood ‘profile’ but the actual swap retested from the gathered evidence.

Visual aid?!
Go there! Yes, it’s still there in Italy …or Google is your friend.

:cool:
I hate to tell you this, but in this case Science is your friend. There is no such thing going on here at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top