Truly Trinity

  • Thread starter Thread starter tGette
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What about Jesus in us Body and Blood? You do believe He has a body right? How do I receive this aspect of God?

Jesus has a glorified body we (those that believe)will get one when we go to heaven.We do do not get this in communion.

This talks about salvation…not having Christ in us.

This is how we recieve the New Covenant. The New Covenant is that God will dwell in us.

So, are you saying once I walk in a Temple, God is not there? Based on your statements, God should still be there, even if He is not there in the way those who believe in the True Presence believe He is there. Also, since your house and bed are man made, can’t I say the same thing about you?

Do you believe that Christ abides within you? That all the fullness of God abides in Christ who lives within you? If you do believe How do you emonstrate this belief?

I must state, I am not against focusing on God as He dwells in us, by for me, faith life is more dynamic than being alone with Him.

Look at your OP on this thread my original comment was to a poster who was alone in a perpetual adoration chapel.

I look outside myself just as much as Thomas the Apostle did when He had to see the wounds himself to believe Christ had risen.

Thomas did not have the God within Him until Pentecost.

Are you against worship in fellowship?
Not at all

I would appreciate it if this discussion remained charitable, thank you!

I do not mock God and I do not worship a temple. I go to a place where I worship God along with the rest of His sheep.

I do believe faith can enter us into this New Covenant, but obviously we believe differently here. We believe Baptism can enter us into this New Covenant by the indwelling present of the Holy Spirit; where we are born of water and the Spirit. (You do believe Jesus and the Holy Spirit are different right? Actually…do you believe in the Holy Trinity? That would help our discussion.)

I believe baptism is important --by immersion. We are baptised into Christs crucifiction, death to the old self again another way how we are crucified with christ and when we aare lifted out of immersion we are baptised into Christs reserection.I believe in the three persons of the Godhead

Again, I look outside myself just as the Apostle Thomas did. Jesus came in the flesh for a reason, so people could look outside themselves for Him. Of course, this is not the only way to find Him. God became visible, for us!

Wrong, do you only need to eat one meal and then live the rest of your life? I would think not. Just as one should perseveringly pray, one should receive Christ as often as possible because we always need more of Him because He is infinite and we cannot stop receiving Him.

“I will never leave you nor never foresake you”

By your same use of logic, I could say that all you had to do was ask Jesus in to your heart just once and you should be good. Are you telling me that since you have done this that you are unable to sin? I mean, shouldn’t that asking of Christ into your heart just once been enough and you now be a wholly righteous person? (I apologize beforehand, I do not know exactly what your beliefs are either.)
I am glad we actually agree on something! 🙂

The Christ in us is the hope of glory—we cannot save ourselves it is God working within us that sanctifies us and turns us from a person steeped in sin to a saint of God made holy it is a process not an event.

So, if it is Christ the Spirit who lives in us, then who was it that Jesus sent after He ascended into Heaven? He explicitly states that this someone, the Paraclete, is someone different than Him.

We have both the Paraclete and Christ --if we believe.

I do acknowledge the presence of God in me by separating Him from everything else that is in me, I also recognize that God is Father, Son and Holy Spirit and He dwells in me in uniquely different ways.

Amen

Please explain to me how I was twisting Scripture.

Jesus said that He and the Father are One, but He never said that He is the Father. The Trinity is equally God, but there is no denying the unique persons of the Trinity.

Are you saying Jesus was the Bodily form of the Trinity or just the Bodily form of the second person of the Trinity, who is equally God with the Father and the Holy Spirit?

I still will ask, how do we receive the Bodily form of God that is found in Christ?

Peace be with you!
The Father is in Christ as Christ is in us. Jesus is not the Father nor are we Christ Im sying that we do not see the Father nor the Holy Ghost but those fortunate enough saw Jesus. Of the trinity Jesus is the one who was in bodily form, I dont believe we recieve the flesh form of Jesus.
 
It seems to me, Hisalone, that your point of view limits how God offers grace. The means of grace are various, in my view. The Holy Spirit first comes to us through the sacrament of Holy Baptism, or through the word. God continues to offer himself to us for the forgiveness of sins through Confession and Absolution and in other ways.

I do not believe that the Holy Spirit dwells in those that have not given their consent.

One could then say you only need to hear the word once and Christ would be in you and there would be no more need to hear it. This interpretation would be correct only if we were free of all sin after receiving His body and blood once, or hearing His word once. But that is not the case. The means of grace are provided to us by God through the Church regularly to bring us back to Him after we have sinned.

Do you believe that Christ lives in your heart? If so how does this play out in faith?
The Sacrament is more than just a remembrance, as the Gospels and St. Paul tell us explicitly, Christ said it is His body and blood, given and shed for the remission of sins, and He encouraged us to receive it often.

I agree that many churches do not recieve it often enough.Yes it is more than remembrance it is not the literal flesh nor the blood of Jesus.
Jon
 
Okay I’ll bite (or try to anyhow).

To me, this thread doesn’t make a lot of sense. As I understand it, it’s about this quote:

Why can’t both be true? Was it not the same Christ who said of the Eucharist “This is my body … this is my blood.” and who said “Wherever two or three of you are gathered in my name, there am I in you midst.”? I see no contradiction between those 2 statements.
Do you believe Christ live in your heart?
Do you ever pray to Christ who lives in your heart?
Do you ever worship Christ that is in you heart?
 
I do not believe that the Holy Spirit dwells in those that have not given their consent.
Do you believe we are capable of “giving consent” without Grace?
When I was baptized, I was marked with the cross of Christ. Through water and the word, the HS entered and made it possible for me to believe. Of course, free will would permit me to “usher him out”.
Do you believe that Christ lives in your heart? If so how does this play out in faith?
I believe that by grace alone through faith in Jesus Christ I am justified. I believe the HS is within me to guide my sanctification.
I believe that in the Sacrament, I receive the true and substantial body and blood of Christ, just as He promised at the Last Supper. I see no reason to doubt His words, “This IS my body”.
As Luther said, “ist ist ist”. Is is is.

Jon
 
The writters of the gospels were indeed saints.
Jesus said I am the sheepgate, I am the door, I am the true vine,

What part of I am do you not understand?
the only way to the Father is through the Son,therefore the Son is a door…the only way to have enternal life is through Jesus,therfore He is the vine of our life and we live off Him,through the Eucharist,as per His promise “who so ever shall eat the FLESH on the Son of man shall have eternal life in them”…it is only through Christ that we can enter inot His church therfore He is the gate to His church…when refering to the writers of the gospels then please quote them with the full respect of their title…for example St. Mark 12:12…
 
Peace be with all!

Sorry this is tardy, I have not been online much.
Jesus has a glorified body we (those that believe)will get one when we go to heaven.We do do not get this in communion.
I will answer with John Chapter 6 (especially verses 22-71). I know, I am sure you have heard the Catholic response with this innumerable times, but the chapter speaks for itself. Especially verses 49 through 51:
"Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died; this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die. I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world"Since Jesus’ body is glorified, it explains more so how His Body is able to become bread because, as with God nothing is impossible.

Also, if it is symbolic, why does Jesus say “THIS IS MY BODY”, did He just want to confuse the Apostles?
This is how we recieve the New Covenant. The New Covenant is that God will dwell in us.
I agree that because of the New Covenant (Testament) God dwells among us and can dwell in us, but the New Covenant encompasses a lot. Please expound…thank you.
Originally Posted by tGette
Code:
                 [forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons/viewpost.gif](http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=4396458#post4396458)
So, are you saying once I walk in a Temple, God is not there? Based on your statements, God should still be there, even if He is not there in the way those who believe in the True Presence believe He is there. Also, since your house and bed are man made, can’t I say the same thing about you?Do you believe that Christ abides within you? That all the fullness of God abides in Christ who lives within you? If you do believe How do you emonstrate this belief?

I do believe that Christ abides within me.
I believe that Jesus Christ is truly God and truly man, but I do not believe that Jesus is the Trinity. I believe that Jesus is the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity and that when I receive Christ it is different than receiving the Holy Spirit.
I demonstrate this by how I live my life and how I strive to grow closer in union with God and for Him to perfect me in holiness.

I do not think you really addressed my statement though.
Originally Posted by tGette
Code:
                 [forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons/viewpost.gif](http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=4396458#post4396458)
I must state, I am not against focusing on God as He dwells in us, by for me, faith life is more dynamic than being alone with Him.Look at your OP on this thread my original comment was to a poster who was alone in a perpetual adoration chapel.

I am not saying being alone with God is wrong, I am just saying that there is more to faith than JUST being alone with God. I know we are all familiar with the word fellowship.
Originally Posted by tGette
Code:
                 [forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons/viewpost.gif](http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=4396458#post4396458)
I look outside myself just as much as Thomas the Apostle did when He had to see the wounds himself to believe Christ had risen.Thomas did not have the God within Him until Pentecost.

Actually…Thomas received Jesus at the Last Supper (‘This IS My Body’).

I do not quite understand your response as a defense though. Could you please explain?
I believe baptism is important --by immersion. We are baptised into Christs crucifiction, death to the old self again another way how we are crucified with christ and when we aare lifted out of immersion we are baptised into Christs reserection.I believe in the three persons of the Godhead
I am assuming baptism for you is not “regenerative”. Why, then, does baptism have to be done by a certain method if it is only symbolic for you? Also, where does the Bible say that baptism should only be done by immersion? Remember when the household was baptized, do you think they were immersed? If so, where does the Bible tell you this?

(continued at next post…)
 
(…continued from previous post)
“I will never leave you nor never foresake you”
This does not mean that we cannot receive more of Jesus.
The Christ in us is the hope of glory—we cannot save ourselves it is God working within us that sanctifies us and turns us from a person steeped in sin to a saint of God made holy it is a process not an event.
Yes! So, then what if someone has not finished this process of becoming holy by time they die? Does God just automatically make them holy after their death? Basically, what if this process is not finished and we are not perfectly holy? Does God take away our free will causes us to become instantly holy upon or death?
We have both the Paraclete and Christ --if we believe.
Do you have ALL of Christ? Because part of Christ is His glorified body. His same body which was able to consume food after His Resurrection. If you are receiving Him only spiritually, then aren’t you missing out on part of Christ?
The Father is in Christ as Christ is in us. Jesus is not the Father nor are we Christ Im sying that we do not see the Father nor the Holy Ghost but those fortunate enough saw Jesus. Of the trinity Jesus is the one who was in bodily form, I dont believe we recieve the flesh form of Jesus.
Then if you do not believe you receive the flesh form of Jesus, then you are not receiving ALL of Jesus because Jesus has flesh.
 
baptism is regenerative…seee St.Paul’s epistle to Titus…3:5"…but according to His mercy,He saved us through the bath of regeneration and renewal by the Holy Spirit"…we will not recieve a glorified body when we get to heaven,at least not until the last day that is…🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top