Trump's ignorance about DACA is stunning

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sy_Noe
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So, the Democrats should be negotiating with Trump and only Trump? Great.
not at all, but both sides need to compromise on something he will sign. he already flipped by offering amnesty to 1.8 mil
. But it’s ok…since the Republicans control both Houses, they could have passed the bill without Democratic support.
how many votes do the repubs have? how many do they need?
Neither was acceptable to whom? Who can speak for the Republicans?
it wasn’t acceptable to enough on both sides because it didn’t pass. i am looking at both sides, not just one. it has to have the support of both sides.
the Republicans. As soon as they get their act together, we should be good.
who speaks for the dems? what are their demands?
the dems also need to get their act together.
we need both parties.
 
daca was an executive order, it can always be recast to include newer immigrants.
Then it would be smart for Republican lawmakers to take the chance to pass it as a law now before the Democrat who wins in 2020 expands the protections.
both sides are using these people. why didn’t the dems take the 1.8 million person amnesty? who is holding them hostage? who is using them for their own ends? both sides.
The beauty is since it is as you said an executive order there doesn’t have to be anything about “both sides”. Trump is president, he can reinstate DACA protections without needing Congress at all. Trump is using these people, as are the Republican leadership who refuse to let a clean DACA bill make it to the floor.
how many votes does it take to pass immigration reform?
It is the majority’s responsibility to craft legislation that will get enough votes. That’s what the committees they control are for. That’s what governing is. Maybe the Republicans spent a little too much time as the Party of No.
 
Then it would be smart for Republican lawmakers to take the chance to pass it as a law now before the Democrat who wins in 2020 expands the protections.
agreed
Trump is using these people, as are the Republican leadership who refuse to let a clean DACA bill make it to the floor.
yes they are.
however,so is schumer who passed on amnesty for 1.8 mill illegal immigrants
It is the majority’s responsibility to craft legislation that will get enough votes. That’s what the committees they control are for. That’s what governing is. Maybe the Republicans spent a little too much time as the Party of No.
trump doesn’t have a majority. the repubs may but trump doesn’t: too many rino’s
 
It is not the Democrats’ job to fix the immigration system.
Why not? IT is the job of congress!
Republicans control the House, Senate, and Presidency. If they are unable to govern when they are given the power to govern then they have failed and are unfit to lead the country.
Yes, but the Dems had the power before, and they didn’t fix immigration then ,either.
The beauty is since it is as you said an executive order there doesn’t have to be anything about “both sides”. Trump is president, he can reinstate DACA protections without needing Congress at all. Trump is using these people, as are the Republican leadership who refuse to let a clean DACA bill make it to the floor.
You have to admit, it is a smooth political move. Throwing it to Congress insures that they get to be blamed instead!
Maybe the Republicans spent a little too much time as the Party of No.
Realistically, what possible advantages are there to Republicans to support illegal immigrants?
Their constituents overwhelmingly support DACA. They are representing their constituents.
I wish they were. Instead I think they are more invested in supporting their own political careers.
 
Last edited:
For anyone who thinks the Dems are angels in this and Trump is holding people hostage: Pelosi: "What do you think? I mean, should we give a border wall for nothing? No, I don’t think so.” (Newsroom | The Office of Majority Leader Steny Hoyer)

Pelosi.thinks 1.8 million young people brought here illegally by their parents are “nothing.”
 
WRT Trump’s rejection of Schumer’s proposal, Trump would have been agreeing to a permanent situation for the DACA students for a temporary, incomplete situation vis a vis the border wall. Funding one year of the wall? What a joke!

This has been going on since the time of Reagan, who signed a bill with a permanent amnesty but never-to-be funded border security. The result? Five amnestiies later and we have almost 4 times the number of illegal immigrants here, and still greatly flawed border security.

So this is why Trump rejected Schumer’s proposal: all of what Trump offered in exchange for a small amount of what he asked for and a promise.

Trump has learned the lesson that a study of immigration laws in the US teaches: don’t give Wimpy a hamburger today for a promise of payment on Tuesday, because Tuesday never seems to come for the Democrats.
 
Last edited:
For anyone who thinks the Dems are angels in this and Trump is holding people hostage: Pelosi: "What do you think? I mean, should we give a border wall for nothing? No, I don’t think so.” (Newsroom | The Office of Majority Leader Steny Hoyer)

Pelosi.thinks 1.8 million young people brought here illegally by their parents are “nothing.”
Maybe read the previous question and try to understand what she’s actually saying, which is not what you think it is.
 
The question asks if the Dems need to bargain for DACA considering the court ruled to maintain the DACA status, and she apparently.thinks there is no reason to move forward on DACA because the courts so ruled.

Either the DACA students are living in an intolerably tenuous situation due to Trump, or they are not. You can’t have it both ways.
 
Last edited:
No one’s having it both ways. DACA recipients are in a bad situation, but also don’t support the border wall. There’s no reason at this time to give the go ahead to something as comic-book-villain evil as the border wall when people are not in imminent danger of deportation.

Thank you for confirming again that Trump and the Republicans are holding the Dreamers hostage for their own cynical reasons.
 
There’s no reason at this time to give the go ahead to something as comic-book-villain evil as the border wall when people are not in imminent danger of deportation.
thank you for confirming the dems don’t care about the amnesty because of the lack of imminent danger.

it is a shame the dems chose not to give amnesty to 1.8 mil people

let us see if trump uses the military as a wall.
 
Is it the President (no matter which party) that makes immigration laws?
 
If I remember correctly, it came with a bunch of stuff that the Democrats didn’t want. But it’s ok…since the Republicans control both Houses, they could have passed the bill without Democratic support.
Do you really not understand that it takes 60 votes in the Senate to pass most bills? Nothing can happen on immigration that is not truly bi-partisan. For the first two years under Obama the Dems had 60 votes - that’s the only reason Obamacare was able to be passed. They could have passed immigration laws during that window.
 
when Congress starts to make compromises, Trump won’t sign it.
Nothing has come from congress for Trump to sign.
So, it sure looks like the Republicans can’t figure out how to run government and they own this.
This would look more reasonable if you applied it equally. Were the Democrats incapable of running the government when they controlled it, and nothing was passed on immigration, or does this just apply to Republicans? Do the Republicans own it now any more than the Democrats did when they controlled congress? Can we at least recognize that neither side can pass any bill without assistance from the other side?
 
Well, that’s because the Republicans can’t control their own caucus.
Please, you at least understand that without 60 votes no bill can pass the Senate. The Republicans are no more capable of passing a bill without Democrat support than the Democrats could have passed one without Republican support. Is it really that difficult even to acknowledge the fact of the matter?
 
Please, you at least understand that without 60 votes no bill can pass the Senate. The Republicans are no more capable of passing a bill without Democrat support than the Democrats could have passed one without Republican support. Is it really that difficult even to acknowledge the fact of the matter?
Trump himself was in a box created by Obama. Obama wanted to “legalize” the DACA people, but didn’t have a congress that would approve it as a “stand alone” measure. So he just ordered it; an almost certainly unconstitutional action. Trump could have either continued in exceeding his powers or doing what should have been done all along…leaving it up to congress to fix.
 
Please, you at least understand that without 60 votes no bill can pass the Senate. The Republicans are no more capable of passing a bill without Democrat support than the Democrats could have passed one without Republican support. Is it really that difficult even to acknowledge the fact of the matter?
Of course the republicans can change that rule if they want.
 
Then where would the excuse for not getting things done and blaming the other party go?

Before anyone beats up on me, yes, I know both parties use this to blame the other party.
 
The Democrats actually only had about six months of 60 votes. Franken didn’t get sworn in till July and Kennedy died shortly after Christmas. Even then they wouldn’t have had it had Specter not changed parties.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top