Actually, I think the red line threat was one of the better things Obama did, though I admit that’s a low bar. But you are right to criticize him if he wasn’t willing to follow through.The problem here is that in his own bellicose way Trump is making the same mistake Obama did over Syria; drawing a red line that everyone knows he will not honor, indeed cannot honor. Obama couldn’t keep his red line commitments in Syria because it would mean the strong potential, if not outright likelihood of direct confrontation with Russian forces, and Trump won’t attack North Korea because to do so would see a devastating retaliatory attack by the North Korean regime that would cause massive damage to South Korea, potentially killing hundreds of thousands and disrupting one of the most important economies on the planet (even worse if Japan becomes a target as well).
Trump’s comments were predicated on the event of an attack by Kim. “If [the US] is forced to defend itself or its allies, we will have no choice but to totally destroy North Korea.”Attacking North Korea is out of the question, and the generals know it. It’s also impossible for Kim Jong-un to publicly back down, because to do so would weaken him in the eyes of his own regime, and that is often fatal to a tyrant. So at the end of the day, all parties concerned will be back at the table, hammering out an agreement, not unlike the Clinton Administration did, and t he cycle of North Korean relations which has ruled the peninsula since the Cease Fire will continue.
That is the stance that kept the peace all through the cold war - Mutually Assured Destruction - except that Kim could not completely destroy the USA.
The agreement Clinton hammered out is exactly why we are where we are today.