Trusting the Catholic Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Truthstalker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I trust the Catholic Church because as a Lutheran, I was led by the Holy Spirit to the only True Holy and Apostolic Church. I trust the Church because as Scripture states, it is the only Church founded by Christ and it is the only Church that is protected by the Holy Spirit from teaching error, from being damaged by the gates of hell, (Matt 16:18). Because of its apostolic authority given to it by Christ, which has survived in our Bishop, the Pope, from its foundations in Peter, we are the only Church, with the exception of the Orthodox, that has valid sacraments. The Church was founded by Christ, and that is clearly evident in Scripture.

Will I lose my distrust because of a few perverted priests, murderous monarchs, or unfaithful members? Of course not. I have the stain of original sin, and will sin throughout my life, as will all Catholics. Why should I lose trust in the One, True Church because its members are not free of sin? Tradition shows us that the Church, as Scripture stated, will never teach error regarding faith and morals; however, it does not say it will be sinless, as we are human! Nevertheless, sin committed by the Church will never separate me from the true doctrine and sacramental life that was given to us by Christ. I think that is quite a good reason to trust the Church. If one loses trust in the Church, they lose trust in God himself. For it was God, our Lord Jesus Christ, who founded the Church. To lose trust in what He built is to lose trust in Christ Himself.
Thank you, those are positive reasons for trusting the Church.
 
I agree. There has been too much condemnation throughout history, and not only on this forum.

But like Stephen C said, we are a Church of sinners. We have the example of Christ to follow, not only His commands, but His actions as well. Understanding the protestant position can go a long way in helping them understand ours - but the “guns” on both sides, so-to-speak, have to be put down first before any sort of real dialogue can take place.

Pope Benedict XVI, I feel, knows this. His focus on this trip was not only to steer the American Church back and make amends (re: the sexual abuse scandal), but to also continue to foster an understanding amongst Catholics, non-Christians, and other Christian traditions. Let’s hope and pray that we can all take up the call towards understanding.
And this thread was started, oddly enough, in an attempt to deal with the real issues of separation, as B-16 is doing (so I am following the Pope here, and the Catholics are protesting. Nice). Not as a head-count of how many saints and scoundrels are on each side. I was attempting to list issues that are practical problems that separate us.

Someone mentioned CARM. I had a several month stint there arguing for Catholicism, to proof the intellectual value of the Catholic position I was then embracing. I found apologetics easy there, not because I was good at it, but because they are bad at theirs. I constantly ask myself, in reading posts here, whether, despite the hysteria, ignorance and prejudice of the post, whether they might be right anyway. I don’t want some Catholic fool to keep me from Catholic wisdom. Here there is a mix of the wise and the foolish, and one never knows what kind of a response a post will draw.

We have worked hard to erect the barriers of separation. It will be no less difficult to bring them down.
 
Let’s see…
I should trust the Catholic Church because I must forgive them.
I didn’t say that you should trust the Church because you must forgive them. I said that all the things you pointed out applied to the Jews of the Old Testament as well. I also said that the Church will not experience unity amongst denominations until we all learn to forgive each other.

If you’re asking for reasons to trust the Catholic Church then you need to be clearer. My simple answer is that the Catholic Church is true even despite the downfalls of those who have not lived according to the teachings of the Catholic Church. This is plainly stated many times in the Bible in many different ways over and over again.

The Jews of old did the same things that the Catholic Church has done. In fact, Protestants have done these things as well. And I’m sure the Orthodox Church has had skeletons in their closet too. So I’m not sure why you would discreetly ask for reasons to trust the Catholic Church by plainly stating all the negative reasons for not trusting the Church to begin with.

What exactly are you asking for?
 
By the way, in terms of majority apathy, I went to the Holy Thursday service at the local parish this year. Membership: some 1,400 families. Attendence at this Day of Obligation (as the priest stated it was) was less than 200 individuals, including me. It was the only service that day. I would assume that most if not all Catholics understand that they are supposed to hear Mass on a DoO, and that missing it is a mortal sin, etc. The implication is that they don’t care, or don’t trust the Church to help them with their salvation, or are in rebellion, or something. I was expecting the place to be packed and it was less than on a typical Sunday.

This does not help the credibility of the Church, when the vast majority of its members disregard basic teachings.
Are you sure you heard that priest right? Holy Thursday is not now, nor has it ever been, a Holy Day of Obligation.

Please get your facts right.
 
Thirdly, many Protestants have had extremely negative experiences with Catholics in their own lives. The people who have hurt me the most have been Catholics. Practicing Catholics have done the most damage. On a personal level Protestants find Catholics are untrustworthy.
I’m a but worried about this. Any one saying the same of any group that is not Catholics would be called a bigot.
Maybe the problem is on the OP.
People do not trust people that do not trust them.
Call a cop a pig and he will become a pig for you as Bob Dylan said.
Maybe the OP proyects his disgust at Catholics in a non consciuos way and them complains when chickens come home to roost.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthstalker
I just read an article on B16’s visit to the US. For Catholics, I suppose, it is implicit to trust the Church.
Protestants think of trust and the Catholic church as antithetical. Calvin and Luther both thought of Hus’s betrayal. Calvin knew many reformers who were burned in France, which contributed to his anger against the Church. There is a long and sad history of Catholic malevolence against Protestants, too long to go into here. The point is that Protestants look at the historical record and conclude that the Church is untrustworthy.
What about the killing of thousands of Catholics by the Protestants under the reign of Elizabeth I of England?
Or Crownwell or Lord Trevellian behavior in Ireland, a behavior that was informed by Protestantism.
Or Slavery and Jim Crow laws in the US South or Apartheit in South Africa. Again behaviors in wish were justified by Protestantism. Not only Catholics has their clothes covered in blood.
Maybe the OP is too busy looking at the other guy eye.
 
I’m a but worried about this. Any one saying the same of any group that is not Catholics would be called a bigot.
Maybe the problem is on the OP.
People do not trust people that do not trust them.
Call a cop a pig and he will become a pig for you as Bob Dylan said.
Maybe the OP proyects his disgust at Catholics in a non consciuos way and them complains when chickens come home to roost.

Or Crownwell or Lord Trevellian behavior in Ireland, a behavior that was informed by Protestantism.
Or Slavery and Jim Crow laws in the US South or Apartheit in South Africa. Again behaviors in wish were justified by Protestantism. Not only Catholics has their clothes covered in blood.
Maybe the OP is too busy looking at the other guy eye.
Did you even bother reading the whole OP before posting this trash? What a knee-jerk reaction of blaming the victim. Welcome to my Ignore list.
 
Part 1
Just as you have had bad experiences with catholic members, I too have had bad experiences with almost every Protestant regardless of denomination. This is never going to change because some Catholics and Protestants, by behaving offensively choose to ignore Jesus’ number 1 command: “Love your neighbour as yourself.” Colossians 4:5-6 “Act wisely with outsiders, making the best of the present time. Always talk pleasantly and with a flavour of wit but be sensitive to the kind of answer each one requires.” I would like touch on each of your claims/complaints but first I would like to establish what, I think everyone believes.

Jesus Christ started and declared: Matthew 16 “…you are Peter (kepha) and on this rock (kepha) I will build My Church and the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against it’…” (As history clearly shows, outsider/“insider” attacks on the Church have proven to be a complete and total disaster for each and every one of those who incite them) —which means, He will defend it from within and from without, against all adversaries for all time. --GOD has said He will be with His Church (Ecclesia, “assembly, congregation, council”) forever! I will never leave you, neither will I forsake you. Heb13:5; John 14:16 “…And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Counselor to be with you forever.” --In Mt 28:20, Jesus said, “and I am with you all days, even until the end of the world." Jesus also said --“to him be glory in the church and in Christ Jesus throughout all generations, for ever and ever! Amen.” Ephesians 3:21 That means He will be with His Church every day in every century until the end of time, no matter how often the devil interferes, which he obviously did/does due to some of the dishonest and corrupt clergy members through the centuries; After all the devil, A.K.A. accuser is seething with pent up rage towards Jesus’ Church: “And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.” Revelations 12:17 Jesus even predicted such corruption was inevitable: “It is impossible that scandals should not come: but woe to him through whom they come!” Luke 17:1 "And a man’s foes shall be they of his own household.” Matthew 10:36. "Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?’ Then I will tell them plainly, 'I never knew you: Away from me, you evildoers!” Matthew 7:21-23 “Take heed unto yourselves, and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit hath made you bishops, to feed the church of the Lord which he purchased with his own blood. I know that after my departing grievous wolves shall enter in among you, not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away the disciples after them…” Acts 20:28 Let us not forget the scandals and human weaknesses of Jesus Christ’s very own inner circle. They are His personally chosen Apostles, the very foundation of His Church: “…built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the chief cornerstone” (Ephesians 2:19-22). One betrayed Him (Luke 22:48). One denied Him, not once but three times (Matthew 26:69-75). One doubted Him (John 20:24-29). All ran away from Him (Mark 14:50). Note that all of them, except one, are now saints. Any merely human organization with such members would have collapsed long ago. I believe that God will protect His Church from error as HE has promised, even though he uses fallible, sinful men for that purpose. And if sinful men such as David and Peter could write inspired Scripture; the very words of God, then it is utterly plausible that God could grant the gift of infallibility concerning the correct collection and selection of doctrine to men in certain well-defined situations. The second scenario is easier to believe than the first, yet somehow Protestants have no problem adhering to the first, while vehemently denying the second proposition as “impossible,” “implausible,” “unbiblical,” etc.
 
Division and dissension runs amok outside the Catholic Apostolic Church; Instead of castigating the catholic church as a whole for something done long ago by individual apostates claiming to be catholic within the church, show me a protestant church that adheres to following! You can’t because the protestant reformation jettisoned institutional authority, in favour of sola scriptura and private interpretation which inevitably led to the thousands of disparate churches we see today.

You said “…these are problems Catholics must overcome if they ever hope for unity :confused: with
their separated brethren.” Out of the thousands of separated brethren (denominations) which one should I embrace, if the C.C. overcomes her shortcomings? As a former protestant (Lutheran) I couldn’t find “truth” with the sola scriptura mindset because there are literally thousand of them all based on the tradition of men! (a direct violation of the bible)

The Bible says the Church Must be One:

Jn 10:16; – there shall be one fold and one shepherd
Eph 4:3-6; – one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father
Rom 16:17; – avoid those who create dissensions
1 Cor 1:10; – I urge that there be no divisions among you
Phil 2:2; – be of same mind, united in heart, thinking one thing
Rom 15:5; – God grant you to think in harmony with one another
Jn 17:17-23; – I pray that they may be one, as we are one
Jn 17: 23; – that they may be brought to perfection as one
1 Cor 12:13; – in one spirit we were baptized into one body
Rom 12:5; – we, though many, are one body in Christ
Eph 4:4; – one body, one Spirit, called to one hope Col 3:15; – the peace into which you were called in one body
Mt 16:18-19; – upon this rock I will build my Church
Mt 18:17-18; – if he refuses to listen even to Church…
Mt 28:18-20; – go baptise and teach all nations
Mk 16:16; – go to the whole world and proclaim the gospel
Lk 10:16; – whoever hears you, hears Me; rejects you, rejects Me
Jn 14:16,26; – Holy Spirit is with you always, teach and remind everything…
Jn 16:12; – Spirit of truth will guide you to all truth
1 Tim 3:15; – Church is the pillar and foundation of truth
Jn 15:16; – Jesus chose special men to be his apostles
Jn 20:21; – Jesus gave the apostles their own mission
Lk 22:30; – Jesus gave them a kingdom
Mt 16:18; – Jesus built Church on Peter, the rock
Jn 10:16; – one shepherd to shepherd Christ’s sheep
Lk 22:32, Jn 21:17; Peter appointed to be chief shepherd
Eph 4:11; – church leaders are hierarchical

The Pseudo-Isidorian Decretals (also known as the False Decretals)

catholicapologetics.org/ap040400.htm
 
Division and dissension runs amok outside the Catholic Apostolic Church; Instead of castigating the catholic church as a whole for something done long ago by individual apostates claiming to be catholic within the church, show me a protestant church that adheres to following! You can’t because the protestant reformation jettisoned institutional authority, in favour of sola scriptura and private interpretation which inevitably led to the thousands of disparate churches we see today.

You said “…these are problems Catholics must overcome if they ever hope for unity :confused: with
their separated brethren.” Out of the thousands of separated brethren (denominations) which one should I embrace, if the C.C. overcomes her shortcomings? As a former protestant (Lutheran) I couldn’t find “truth” with the sola scriptura mindset because there are literally thousand of them all based on the tradition of men! (a direct violation of the bible)

The Bible says the Church Must be One:

Jn 10:16; – there shall be one fold and one shepherd
Eph 4:3-6; – one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father
Rom 16:17; – avoid those who create dissensions
1 Cor 1:10; – I urge that there be no divisions among you
Phil 2:2; – be of same mind, united in heart, thinking one thing
Rom 15:5; – God grant you to think in harmony with one another
Jn 17:17-23; – I pray that they may be one, as we are one
Jn 17: 23; – that they may be brought to perfection as one
1 Cor 12:13; – in one spirit we were baptized into one body
Rom 12:5; – we, though many, are one body in Christ
Eph 4:4; – one body, one Spirit, called to one hope Col 3:15; – the peace into which you were called in one body
Mt 16:18-19; – upon this rock I will build my Church
Mt 18:17-18; – if he refuses to listen even to Church…
Mt 28:18-20; – go baptise and teach all nations
Mk 16:16; – go to the whole world and proclaim the gospel
Lk 10:16; – whoever hears you, hears Me; rejects you, rejects Me
Jn 14:16,26; – Holy Spirit is with you always, teach and remind everything…
Jn 16:12; – Spirit of truth will guide you to all truth
1 Tim 3:15; – Church is the pillar and foundation of truth
Jn 15:16; – Jesus chose special men to be his apostles
Jn 20:21; – Jesus gave the apostles their own mission
Lk 22:30; – Jesus gave them a kingdom
Mt 16:18; – Jesus built Church on Peter, the rock
Jn 10:16; – one shepherd to shepherd Christ’s sheep
Lk 22:32, Jn 21:17; Peter appointed to be chief shepherd
Eph 4:11; – church leaders are hierarchical

The Pseudo-Isidorian Decretals (also known as the False Decretals)

catholicapologetics.org/ap040400.htm
Another non-reader of the OP.
 
It seems to me the mere existence of Judas as one of Christ’s hand-picked apostles should be enough to neuter anything in the OP. http://www.forumsextreme.com/imgs1/sCo_idk3.gif

If one wants to disprove the trueness of the Catholic Church, he must demonstrate a fallacy in its teaching on faith or morals.
 
Issue number 1

TruthstalkerYou said…

“I just read an article on B16’s visit to the US. For Catholics, I suppose, it is implicit to trust the Church. Protestants think of trust and the Catholic church as antithetical. Calvin and Luther both thought of Hus’s betrayal. Calvin knew many reformers who were burned in France, which contributed to his anger against the Church. There is a long and sad history of Catholic malevolence against Protestants, too long to go into here. The point is that Protestants look at the historical record and conclude that the Church is untrustworthy.”

Respectfully… Yes they are completely antithetical; diametrically opposed at the very core. The catholic apostolic church, the only church that can trace its descent all the way back to the apostles, adheres to the authority of the church, just as Jesus instructed; apostolic tradition, just as Saint Paul instructed and sacred scripture which was codified by that same church, and the protestant churches defer the sacred scripture, again a product of the catholic church as their sole authority, and private interpretation which is the reason why we see so many different and disparate protestant churches in the world today. Jesus said, “Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother’s eye.” Perhaps after seeing the truth about Calvin an M.L. you might have a change of heart:
sullivan-county.com/identity/reformers.htm geocities.com/paulntobin/luther.html

64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:C83a3MkSeXwJ:www.urlfan.com/local/john_calvin/34405833.htm

l+John+Calvin+tortured&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=10&gl=us&client=firefox-a

Martin Luther said: “The Jews deserve to be hanged on gallows, seven times higher than ordinary thieves” —“If I had to baptize a Jew, I would take him to the river Elbe, hang a stone around his neck and push him over with the words `I baptize thee in the name of Abraham’.”

John Calvin’s reprehensible approval of torture is an issue most modern day Calvinists do not deny but do disavow. Calvin vehemently rejected Papal authority yet…! “…if he comes here, if my authority is worth anything, I will never permit him to depart alive.” quote John Calvin John Calvin was a “malevolent” man who did his fair share of torture!

If Protestants look at the historical record, instead of the bible which plainly says: “It is impossible that scandals should not come: but woe to him through whom they come!” Luke 17:1 "And a man’s foes shall be they of his own household.” (The bible says the church is the house of the living god meaning there will be good and bad people in it) Matthew 10:36 ---------and conclude that the Church is untrustworthy, then the protestant churches stemming from the protestant reformation are untrustworthy as well, and should be judged by the same standard, "Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.” Matthew 7:1

So, I can either reject Christianity as a whole, or I can embrace the catholic church established by Jesus Christ and recall the words spoken by Him: “It is impossible that scandals should not come: but woe to him through whom they come!” Luke 17:1 "And a man’s foes shall be they of his own household.” Matthew 10:36. "Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?’ Then I will tell them plainly, 'I never knew you: Away from me, you evildoers!” Matthew 7:21-23 “Take heed unto yourselves, and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit hath made you bishops, to feed the church of the Lord which he purchased with his own blood. I know that after my departing grievous wolves shall enter in among you, not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away the disciples after them…” Acts 20:28

I choose to forge ahead despite all of these individual atrocities that befell the catholic church and the fledgling protestant churches in these very dark ages. Blaming any one church as a whole is simply being irresponsible.

Regarding the false Isidorian decretals…
angelfire.com/ms/seanie/forgeries/pseudoisidore.html
 
Posted by Truthstalker:
If this thread goes the way of most threads, each of these points will be hotly challenged. Instead I ask Catholics to realize this is how Protestants view their church, and that these are problems Catholics must overcome if they ever hope for unity with their separated brethren. So I ask Catholics how they plan to overcome these barriers if they really look for reunification and are not out simply to condemn Protestants. There’s been way too much of that on this Forum.
I think I see where you are coming from Truthstalker. It seems you are not so much championing the protestant view as right or wrong, but simply stating why protestants don’t trust Catholicism and, point blank… what are we gonna do about that? I wanted to respond to each of your points in depth, but my posts just kept going past the limit. 🙂 So, here goes my take on what we can do to overcome barriers. It may not address your individual points, but I think if the majority of Catholics would do the following, it would go a long way toward healing the breach.

I think that there are some things that Catholics can and should do to change perceptions. Firstly, they must learn their faith and practice it. This is something all Catholics should be doing for their own salvation, of course, but it would be the most powerful witness to Catholicism if all or at least most Catholics were living their lives according to their faith. No one respects a hypocrite and frankly, us pointing the finger and saying to protestants “your history is as ugly as ours” is child-like and not going to solve anything. If Catholics were to devoutly follow the faith, I think they would be so filled with Grace that it would help protestants overcome many of their misgivings.

Secondly (included in the “learning of the faith” process), I think Catholics should spend more time studying the Bible and not assuming that the Sunday readings are going to tell them all they need to know. Though we may not agree with what a particular verse means, I think that non-Catholics would have more respect for us if it was clear that we are actively studying scripture. I have to say that I personally have seen a great deal of improvement in the area of Scripture study among Catholics.

Thirdly, I think that it is important for anyone dialoguing with a non-Catholic Christian to maintain charity at all times. There is no excuse for the triumphalism that occurs in these forums. The fact that the actions of some self righteous Catholics can lead others, like yourself, away from the Church is sad and it is something that will need to be answered for on judgement day.

Fourthly, when it comes to the atrocities of the past, I think that all Christians need to remember the words of the Our Father “Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us.” That means we are asking Our Father to forgive us in the same way we have forgiven others. Yikes… those that are holding grudges (on both sides), better think long and hard about this issue. I was actually delighted by both Pope John Paul II’s numerous pleas for forgiveness on behalf of the Church as well as Pope Benedict’s recent apologies. I think it signals a shift in the mentality of the Church and the lay people have to follow that example. We need to recognize the wrongs of the past and ask for forgiveness. We should be the first to ask for forgiveness in an effort to practice humility.

Fifthly, we should pray. A LOT.

I want you to know that I personally feel sorry and sad for any offenses and injuries you have received as a result of some Catholic posters here. I hope you will continue to research the faith and meditate upon the teachings of the Church. Know that even though there are nasty posters (on most forums, it seems), there are many, many Catholics that are the real deal. They know their faith, the speak with only kindness and love while not compromising their beliefs, they reverently receive the Eucharist, they go to daily Mass, they study Scripture, etc. These are the types of Catholic folks I “hang” with. They are sinners too, but they are really trying to live the Gospel. In my opinion, living the Gospel is the best way to overcome the perceptions.
 
@Truthstalker
Thanks for the post. I too have had problems with same in past but most people who hurt me were not Catholics unless I go way, way back.

Still in all I have not lost my true devotion to Jesus Christ and as I return to my spiritual home I realize that I have to look beyond the sins of the perpetrators and forgive them.

Many people don’t understand Catholicism and reject and criticize it from what they have heard. They know not.
I know that’s oversimplified and probably misses the point.

Frankly, now I don’t care about all those criticisms that I struggled with and transgressions of others against me,
I am coming home. But it took a long time.I will be defending the Church from now on.

@Joe
that geocities link about Martin Luther was quite eyeopening. I watched a movie about his life.
imdb.com/media/rm2877332736/tt0309820
called “Luther” starring Joseph Fiennes.
It was clear from the very first scene that Luther suffered from bouts of mania.

However the link you provided is to a website that documents a poor soul’s journey from Christianity to atheism which I found rather sad.
 
Part 1
“Another non-reader of the OP.” original point…

I USED UPPER CASE TO HELP MAKE THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN YOUR COMMENTS AND MINE!

You said: I just read an article on B16’s visit to the US. For Catholics, I suppose, it is implicit to trust the Church. Protestants think of trust and the Catholic church as antithetical. Calvin and Luther both thought of Hus’s betrayal. Calvin knew many reformers who were burned in France, which contributed to his anger against the Church. There is a long and sad history of Catholic malevolence against Protestants, too long to go into here. The point is that Protestants look at the historical record and conclude that the Church is untrustworthy.

THE SAME CAN BE SAID OF JOHN CALVIN AND MARTIN LUTHER; THEY DID HORRIBLE THINGS TO PEOPLE IN THE NAME OF GOD, AS I HAVE ALREADY POINTED OUT, AND AS I SAID BEFORE: IF PROTESTANTS LOOK AT THE HISTORICAL RECORD, INSTEAD OF THE BIBLE WHICH PLAINLY SAYS: “IT IS IMPOSSIBLE THAT SCANDALS SHOULD NOT COME: BUT WOE TO HIM THROUGH WHOM THEY COME!” LUKE 17:1 "AND A MAN’S FOES SHALL BE THEY OF HIS OWN HOUSEHOLD.” (THE BIBLE SAYS THE CHURCH IS THE HOUSE OF THE LIVING GOD MEANING THERE WILL BE GOOD AND BAD PEOPLE IN IT) MATTHEW 10:36 ---------AND CONCLUDE THAT THE CHURCH IS UNTRUSTWORTHY, THEN THE PROTESTANT CHURCHES STEMMING FROM THE PROTESTANT REFORMATION ARE UNTRUSTWORTHY AS WELL, AND SHOULD BE JUDGED BY THE SAME STANDARD, "DO NOT JUDGE, OR YOU TOO WILL BE JUDGED. FOR IN THE SAME WAY YOU JUDGE OTHERS, YOU WILL BE JUDGED, AND WITH THE MEASURE YOU USE, IT WILL BE MEASURED TO YOU.” MATTHEW 7:1

Secondly, Protestants compare Church teachings against Scripture and conclude that the Church has added or ignored certain things. The conclusion is that the Church is untrustworthy as an interpreter of Scripture.

THIS IS A FALSE CONCLUSION! THE CHURCH HAS ADDED NOTHING. HOWEVER, ACCORDING TO MY EXHAUSTIVE RESEARCH AS A FORMER LUTHERAN, THE PROTESTANT REFORMATION LED TO THE REMOVAL OF 7 BOOKS FROM THE O.T. --WHICH I AM SURE YOU ARE WELL AQUAINTED. MARTIN LUTHER EVEN TRIED TO JETTISON 2 BOOKS FROM THE N.T. THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE UNCHANGING DOGMA OF THE C.C. AND THE ESTABLISHED DOCTRINES AND DISCIPLINES OF THE C.C. IF THE C.C. ISN’T A TRUSTWORTHY INTERPRETER, THEN WHO IS? SOLA SCRIPTURA CERTAINLY ISN’T THE ANSWER! THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF COMPETING CHURCHES IN THE WORLD TODAY USING SOLA SCRIPTURA AS THEIR SOLE AUTHORITY.

Thirdly, many Protestants have had extremely negative experiences with Catholics in their own lives. The people who have hurt me the most have been Catholics. Practicing Catholics have done the most damage. On a personal level Protestants find Catholics are untrustworthy.

THE SAME CAN AND IS SAID OF THE DIFFERENT PROTESTANT DENOMINATIONS; THINGS LIKE THE C.C. IS THE ANTICHRIST AND THE WHORE OF BABYLON AND YOU ARE GOING TO HELL; WOULDN’T YOU AGREE?
 
Fourthly, Protestants visit Catholic churches and observe how Catholics behave during Mass: disrespectfully leaving after the Eucharist or talking or not participating, slovenly receiving the Eucharist and otherwise behaving in a less than impressive manner.

THIS IS VERY SUBJECTIVE AND SHOULD NOT BE REFLECTIVE ON THE THE C.C. AS A WHOLE; WOULDN’T YOU AGREE.

Fifthly, some of the most strident, over-the-top posters on this Forum are ignorant of Catholicism and totally ignorant of Protestant belief. Some have pushed me away from Catholicism because I certainly do not want to drink out of whatever well they are drinking from.

I HOPE I HAVE NOT DONE THE SAME; I’M ONLY TRYING TO DILLINIATE THE TRUE FACTS.

Sixthly, Protestants look at Catholic claims for unity. While there seems to be a Catechism, it is widely disregarded. Many Catholics, as polls indicate, disbelieve it: Catholics don’t believe their own faith. I have attended Catholic homilies and teachings that are counter to basic Christianity, let alone Catholicism. At the last Mass I attended the priest’s homily centered around the point that God did His part, now it is totally up to us. Claims to teach truth ring very hollow.

TRUE, THERE IS SOME INTER-DIVISION REGARDING THE C.C. BUT THE DEPOSIT OF FAITH ENTRUSTED TO THE C.C. HAS REMAINED THE SAME FOR 2000 YEARS. AS FAR AS INDIVIDUAL PARISHES TEACHING THINGS THAT ARE COUNTER T0 BASIC CHRISTIANITY AND CATHOLICISM, WELL THAT’S SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE ADDRESSED WITH THE LOCAL BISHOP AND CORRECTED. COULD NAME A FEW OF THEM? BTW WHO IN YOUR MIND HAS THE RIGHT TO TEACH TRUTH?

Seventhly, Catholics seem to put the onus for the separation entirely on Protestant shoulders. An examination of history reveals there were mistakes on both sides. If an army unit falls apart, who gets the most blame? The leader. Instead Catholics seem to see their Church as sinless in this and nothing but sin in reformers.

THE C.C. DOESN’T SEE ITSELF AS SINLESS; WHERE DID YOU GET THAT IDEA? I AGREE BOTH SIDES MADE THEIR SHARE OF MISTAKES, BUT THE BIBLE STILL SAYS THE C.C. IS THE CHURCH GUIDED BY THE HOLY SPIRIT IN PERPETUITY, OR IS IT ANOTHER THAT I AM NOT AWARE OF?

Eighthly, there have been numerous historical falsifications in the cause of Catholicism, including the Isidorian decretals and interpolations in ancient texts to benefit the Catholic cause. Catholics cannot be trusted, it seems, to present an honest case for their religion.

THE “Isidorian decretals” ARE FORGED DOCUMENTS! WHAT HISTORICAL FALSIFICATIONS ARE YOU REFERRING TO? PROVE TO ME CATHOLICS IN GENERAL (OR DO YOU MEAN THE C.C.) CAN’T BE TRUSTED, AND MAYBE I’LL HAVE SOMETHING TO WORK WITH TO CLOSE THE BARRIER! angelfire.com/ms/seanie/forgeries/pseudoisidore.html

Ninthly, Protestants observe things such as the abuse scandal and how Church officials covered it up. Kudos to B-16, but it was an awfully late response.

I TOTALLY AGREE!!! SHOULD WE JUST GIVE UP ON THE C.C. ESTABLISHED BY JESUS, BECAUSE SOME TWISTED PEDEPHILES INFESTED THE CHURCH WHICH IS JESUS’ BODY; THE HOUSE OF THE LIVING GOD; THE PILLAR AND FOUNDATION OF TRUTH? CAN YOU IMAGINE HOW JESUS MUST FEEL! JESUS KNEW THIS WOULD HAPPEN LONG BEFORE THE CHURCH WAS ESTABLISHED: “Take heed unto yourselves, and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit hath made you bishops, to feed the church of the Lord which he purchased with his own blood. I know that after my departing grievous wolves shall enter in among you, not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away the disciples after them…” Acts 20:28

Are you speaking from a protestant perspective, not your own!:confused: “The people who have hurt me the most have been Catholics. Practicing Catholics have done the most damage. On a personal level Protestants find Catholics are untrustworthy.”

If I am correct, your OP is to remind “Catholics to realize this is how Protestants view their church, and that these are problems Catholics must overcome if they ever hope for unity with their separated brethren. So I ask Catholics how they plan to overcome these barriers if they really look for reunification and are not out simply to condemn Protestants. There’s been way too much of that on this Forum.”

Don’t you think the protestant churches have some problems and barriers themselves to overcome if they ever hope for unity with the church established by Jesus? After all, Jesus did establish a church built on peter, the apostles and the prophets, said it would be infallibly guided by the holy spirit in perpetuity; (regardless of the “grievous wolves”) —not infallibly guide until the 4th century, the 11th century or the 16th century but through every century until his second coming. I wish all Christians regardless of denomination would try to come together and see what took me so long to see; the catholic church is the true apostolic church .
 
40.png
Truthstalker:
Protestants think of trust and the Catholic church as antithetical. Calvin and Luther both thought of Hus’s betrayal. Calvin knew many reformers who were burned in France, which contributed to his anger against the Church. There is a long and sad history of Catholic malevolence against Protestants, too long to go into here. The point is that Protestants look at the historical record and conclude that the Church is untrustworthy.
Truthstalker, don’t you think the Church has a supernatural dimension?
The ancient Jews were not all saints but they kept it together more or less, or rather, it was kept together for them, supernaturally, in spite of themselves, and the reason for that unity of belief eventually became clear.
The very first Christians equally, defended their new born Faith with the sword against threat, and fled, one and all in the face of greater threat.
But something supernatural had glued these ordinary men together, and in the end promised, guaranteed them safety and success against the powers of hell until the end of the world. A divine promise that works for 1,500 years cannot be proven to be wrong, without calling the divine a liar and a fraud. A person cannot have it both ways - you cannot be the Church that was founded by Christ and lasts until the end of time if you at the same time believe the Church ceased to exist for a millenium and a half.
That is, I think, the main issue to overcome. The sins of the Church do not make it cease to exist any more than swinging a sword at a guards head caused Christs mission to cease to be.
 
I think that there are some things that Catholics can and should do to change perceptions. Firstly, they must learn their faith and practice it. This is something all Catholics should be doing for their own salvation, of course, but it would be the most powerful witness to Catholicism if all or at least most Catholics were living their lives according to their faith. No one respects a hypocrite and frankly, us pointing the finger and saying to protestants “your history is as ugly as ours” is child-like and not going to solve anything. If Catholics were to devoutly follow the faith, I think they would be so filled with Grace that it would help protestants overcome many of their misgivings.

Well said indeed…

No one ever wins an argument anyway. Both sides did awful things to each other. That’s not the point of the OP. Catholics have to practice their faith and be that example Christ wanted his followers to be. To be a light unto to the world for all to see. The only way Protestant Christians will ever see the “truth” in our Catholic faith is when we really start living it.(remember what Jesus said about being “lukewarm”?) It only takes a few bad Catholics to destroy the perception of the Church by people on the outside looking in.
B16 recognized that the perception needs to be changed and humbled himself and reached out to people who just wanted the Church to recognize it’s past faults.
The internet and information age are educating Catholics about how rich their faith really is while simultaneously gutting the same tired Protestant misconceptions about the CC.
Nothin to fear all my Christian brothers and sisters…
Unity is on the way, one small step at a time.

👍
 
Fourthly, Protestants visit Catholic churches and observe how Catholics behave during Mass: disrespectfully leaving after the Eucharist or talking or not participating, slovenly receiving the Eucharist and otherwise behaving in a less than impressive manner.
I have also noticed this. It might help if the priest posted a set of dress and conduct rules in a conspicuous place, but I haven’t seen them do this in the Catholic Churches, although I have seen this in other Churches, such as the SSPX or Old Calendar Orthodox Churches.
 
Catholic Church can be read in the Bible!!!

Greek NT: Tischendorf 8th Edition with Strong’s Numbers
Act9:31 Ἡ μὲν οὖν ἐκκλησία καθ’ ὅλης τῆς Ἰουδαίας καὶ Γαλιλαίας καὶ Σαμαρίας εἶχεν εἰρήνην, οἰκοδομουμένη καὶ πορευομένη τῷ φόβῳ τοῦ κυρίου, καὶ τῇ παρακλήσει τοῦ ἁγίου πνεύματος ἐπληθύνετο.

Act. 9:31 Hie mein oun Ekklesia Katholis Tes Judaias kai Galalaias kai Samarias eirenen ekenien oikomodo mene

Act9:31 of Greek NT: Byzantine / Majority Text (1995) with Strong’s Numbers
αι μεν ουν εκκλησιαι καθ ολης της ιουδαιας και γαλιλαιας και σαμαρειας ειχον ειρηνην οικοδομουμεναι και πορευομεναι τω φοβω του κυριου και τη παρακλησει του αγιου πνευματος επληθυνοντο

Greek NT: Tischendorf 8th Edition
Ἡ μὲν οὖν ἐκκλησία καθ’ ὅλης τῆς Ἰουδαίας καὶ Γαλιλαίας καὶ Σαμαρίας εἶχεν εἰρήνην, οἰκοδομουμένη καὶ πορευομένη τῷ φόβῳ τοῦ κυρίου, καὶ τῇ παρακλήσει τοῦ ἁγίου πνεύματος ἐπληθύνετο.

Greek NT: Byzantine / Majority Text (2000)
αι μεν ουν εκκλησιαι καθ ολης της ιουδαιας και γαλιλαιας και σαμαρειας ειχον ειρηνην οικοδομουμεναι και πορευομεναι τω φοβω του κυριου και τη παρακλησει του αγιου πνευματος επληθυνοντο

Greek NT: Stephen’s Textus Receptus (1550)
αι μεν ουν εκκλησιαι καθ ολης της ιουδαιας και γαλιλαιας και σαμαρειας ειχον ειρηνην οικοδομουμεναι και πορευομεναι τω φοβω του κυριου και τη παρακλησει του αγιου πνευματος επληθυνοντο

Greek NT: Scrivener’s Textus Receptus (1894)
αι μεν ουν εκκλησιαι καθ ολης της ιουδαιας και γαλιλαιας και σαμαρειας ειχον ειρηνην οικοδομουμεναι και πορευομεναι τω φοβω του κυριου και τη παρακλησει του αγιου πνευματος επληθυνοντο

Greek NT: Westcott / Hort (1881)
η μεν ουν εκκλησια καθ ολης της ιουδαιας και γαλιλαιας και σαμαρειας ειχεν ειρηνην οικοδομουμενη και πορευομενη τω φοβω του κυριου και τη παρακλησει του αγιου πνευματος επληθυνετο

Greek NT: Westcott / Hort with UBS4 variants
η μεν ουν εκκλησια καθ ολης της ιουδαιας και γαλιλαιας και σαμαρειας ειχεν ειρηνην οικοδομουμενη και πορευομενη τω φοβω του κυριου και τη παρακλησει του αγιου πνευματος επληθυνετο

Greek: Modern
Αι μεν λοιπον εκκλησιαι καθ’ ολην την Ιουδαιαν και Γαλιλαιαν και Σαμαρειαν ειχον ειρηνην, οικοδομουμεναι και περιπατουσαι εν τω φοβω του Κυριου, και δια της παρηγοριας του Αγιου Πνευματος επληθυνοντο.
👍
 
Are you sure you heard that priest right? Holy Thursday is not now, nor has it ever been, a Holy Day of Obligation.

Please get your facts right.
He went on and on about it. Maybe HE thought it was.

I am trying to get my facts straight. It’s like herding cats or turning over an infinite set of coffee cups, each of which has a puzzle piece under it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top