Twilight movies?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jason3477
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jason3477

Guest
What do you all think of those twilight series of movies? I notice that a lot of young people-including young adult like these movies=Twilight…

But don’t they send a bad/wrong message?
 
I think they present a horrible message. A downright abusive and controlling relationship is glorified. The main character has no life outside of her infatuation with a boy who treats her like a 3 year old. He takes parts out of her car so that she can’t go see her friends, he up and leaves her for months without saying a word (and she spends the next 9 months in a heartbroken daze and is unable to even start to move on), etc. In my opinion the books and movies are very anti-women.
 
I think they present a horrible message. A downright abusive and controlling relationship is glorified. The main character has no life outside of her infatuation with a boy who treats her like a 3 year old. He takes parts out of her car so that she can’t go see her friends, he up and leaves her for months without saying a word (and she spends the next 9 months in a heartbroken daze and is unable to even start to move on), etc. In my opinion the books and movies are very anti-women.
Thanks for saving me the time to right similar! 😉 My cinnamons exactly.
 
I object to these books/movies for non-religious reasons. I object because they are stupid and portray terrible values. Try HP or LoTR instead!
 
These are bad movies, but one reason the infatuation of vampires and the undead arises in our society is because (as stated by Father Barron before) When Religious values are oppressed, they don’t just disappear, they resurface but in a distorted and deformed way. and thats why this crazy addiction to the undead is rising up in our society.

Thats also why some people believe in “ghosts” or spirits, but dont fully belong to a church, its either suppresed religious values that are distorted, or just a rebelous kind of acting (not wanting to belong to any religion) which makes no sence because then your not looking for the Truth, you just want to feel like your in charge.
 
I love the Twilight series! Some people on this post have talked about how it promotes a controlling relationship. I disagree, and I’ve read all the books and have seen all the movies to date. Though the idea of Edward not allowing Bella to see certain friends seems controlling at first glance, you have to consider the fantasy aspect of the series: These friends may be dangerous— new werewolfs like Jacob can be quite explosive and could hurt Bella. The books’ fantasy side must be taken into consideration when judging Edwards actions. They are warranted in the world the book creates.
 
Meh…they are fiction, and there is nothing about the characters that even closely resembles reality. Unless you’ve read them, or seen the movies, I don’t see how you can form an opinion on them. I see a story about self-control, a refusal to give in to the worldly view of pre-martial sex, and a woman who chooses to give birth to a baby in a situation that could cost her her life. Then a man who has no intentions of being a dad and wants nothign to do with a baby ends up feeling love for his daughter and risks his own “life” for her.

I’ve heard that the books can be dangerous because they can make young pregnant mothers see their babies as monsters inside them. Please, someone speek up if, after seeing that movie or reading the book, you feel like you baby inside you is a monster.

I’ve heard it suggested that fanatic fans can be led, by watching the movies or reading the stories, to act inappropriately. Um, whatever happended to people being responsible for their own actions. If a person is going to do somethign inappropriate, or bizarre, or outlandish, or unhealthy…it won’t be a movie or a book that makes them do it.
 
I just think the books were badly written. I have yet to see the most recent Twilight movie. Although the other movies were ok, I just hate how Belle’s character doesn’t change. Throughout the books she is a whinny girl.

I read the books and in some cases skimmed through them. I don’t think the books are as good as people make them out to be. People may criticise the Harry Potter books, but at least those books are extremely well written. JK. Rowling’s writing ability is leagues above the twilight books in terms of character development, plot, setting and more. Her stories progressively get better, the Twilight books aside for the last one, you read one, you’ve read them all. The last one simply ends a rather pointless series.
 
I think they present a horrible message. A downright abusive and controlling relationship is glorified. The main character has no life outside of her infatuation with a boy who treats her like a 3 year old. He takes parts out of her car so that she can’t go see her friends, he up and leaves her for months without saying a word (and she spends the next 9 months in a heartbroken daze and is unable to even start to move on), etc. In my opinion the books and movies are very anti-women.
You left out the very creepy section where he breaks into her house and watches her sleeping. That’s called STALKING and criminal trespass, at the very least.

The new movie implies that the 2 main characters had violent harmful sex on their wedding night (Bella is bruised the next morning) and their baby is toxic to her. Having the baby causes her spine to break and she has to become a vampire to survive. The messages are that babies are nasty pieces of work that will kill you - that being pregnant is like carrying an alien.

Very sick and sad messages to give to young girls. The books themselves are also poorly written.
 
I think they are alright as long as they’re viewed for what they are–fantasy and fiction. I do see the point that people make about Edward being controlling. He is extremely controlling of Bella. At the same time, I see it inside the context of the fantasy world of Vampires vs. Werewolves. Edward isn’t just keeping Bella from her friends, he’s trying to keep her away from his mortal enemies. Enemies who, even at their best, are unpredictable and incredibly dangerous. He does encourage her to spend time with her human friends, it’s only the werewolves that he doesn’t want her spending time with. It does, however, bother me that Bella seems to have nothing on her mind apart from finding a way to be with Edward. She’s completely dependent on him until she becomes a vampire herself.

The books do have some positive points that are more obvious. Edward is very clear on his desire to wait until marriage to have sex. Bella holds her ground against aborting her baby, even when it seems that her whole family is urging her to do so. I thought the books portrayed the pregnancy very positively, not like the babies are little monsters. Again, this is a fantasy story. In this fantasy story, the baby is likely the first of it’s kind and no one knows what to expect from it. It’s the child of a vampire, and vampires are monsters themselves. But Bella sees it as her baby and loves it instantly. Edward comes around and loves it as well, once he realizes that it is an innocent baby.

I see the books and movies as mindless fluff. They’re not incredibly well-written, but they’re not awful either. If I don’t want to do a lot of thinking, but just want to relax with an easy read, they’re great books for that.
 
Dear Friends,

I’ve talked with a Counselor Friend of mine about Twilight. She summed it up like this.

"When you stand before God for Judgement, she doesn’t think He will ask, “Have you seen the Twilight Saga?”

Plus, I’ve seen only two of the movies, enjoyed them very much and never thought of them again. They did not put a different perspective on my life for I love God more than ever. I take them as fantasy as I see all the things on the SCI FI channel which could be taken in the same light as some members think here. I also think it’s your frame of mind when you watch movies such as these. Plus, I think most children will grow up and as adults think of them no more, knowing it’s not real life.

Further, what about Disney’s “Beauty and the Beast”? To some it may seem Beastiality. Actually, I heard a family member say it was. I see it as what is inside of a person matters more than what is on the outside.

I also think there is more in real life that is more evil than the Twilight Series which kids know is real.

Love ya’ll,
Sheila
 
Enjoyed reading the books, enjoyed seeing the movies. But it was just another movie to me, I watch a lot of stuff other people might not find is their taste. I went yesterday to see it, the theater was filled with women in their 30s and 40s, not a young crowd at all and it was the early evening show. I don’t think the teens and young people are really that into the movies as people think they are. I said in another thread on this subject, t most of the young girls I know through my daughter’s activities think Bella is stupid and would rather go see some other movie at the theater.
 
Meh…they are fiction, and there is nothing about the characters that even closely resembles reality. Unless you’ve read them, or seen the movies, I don’t see how you can form an opinion on them. I see a story about self-control, a refusal to give in to the worldly view of pre-martial sex, and a woman who chooses to give birth to a baby in a situation that could cost her her life. Then a man who has no intentions of being a dad and wants nothign to do with a baby ends up feeling love for his daughter and risks his own “life” for her.

I’ve heard that the books can be dangerous because they can make young pregnant mothers see their babies as monsters inside them. Please, someone speek up if, after seeing that movie or reading the book, you feel like you baby inside you is a monster.

I’ve** heard it suggested that fanatic fans can be led, by watching the movies or reading the stories, to act inappropriately. Um, whatever happended to people being responsible for their own actions. If a person is going to do somethign inappropriate, or bizarre, or outlandish, or unhealthy…it won’t be a movie or a book that makes them do it**.
exactly, finally someone says that, thank you lol
 
Enjoyed reading the books, enjoyed seeing the movies. But it was just another movie to me, I watch a lot of stuff other people might not find is their taste. I went yesterday to see it, the theater was filled with women in their 30s and 40s, not a young crowd at all and it was the early evening show. I don’t think the teens and young people are really that into the movies as people think they are. I said in another thread on this subject, t most of the young girls I know through my daughter’s activities think Bella is stupid and would rather go see some other movie at the theater.
This was my observation at the theater also. It was mostly women my age and older, with a few of the husbands tagging along. I saw one teen girl who came with her parents.

On another note, I didn’t think this most recent movie was put together as well as the past ones were. There were some things in it that I just thought were overdone to the point of being so cheesy that it distracted me from the plot.
 
This was my observation at the theater also. It was mostly women my age and older, with a few of the husbands tagging along. I saw one teen girl who came with her parents.

On another note, I didn’t think this most recent movie was put together as well as the past ones were. There were some things in it that I just thought were overdone to the point of being so cheesy that it distracted me from the plot.
Really? I actually enjoyed this one than the last two. I thought the camera shots and visuals they used were better for telling the story. Then again, I was prepared to be bored because “Breaking Dawn” was my least favorite out of the whole series.
 
Really? I actually enjoyed this one than the last two. I thought the camera shots and visuals they used were better for telling the story. Then again, I was prepared to be bored because “Breaking Dawn” was my least favorite out of the whole series.
For me, it just didn’t seem to flow as well for some reason. When they did the bit with the wolf pack’s voices, I almost started laughing out loud in the theater. And when they were showing the transformation, it just seemed too “X-Men” for me. Maybe I should take my own advice and remember that it’s a fantasy movie, haha! 😛
 
…Thats also why some people believe in “ghosts” or spirits, but dont fully belong to a church, its either suppresed religious values that are distorted, or just a rebelous kind of acting (not wanting to belong to any religion) which makes no sence because then your not looking for the Truth, you just want to feel like your in charge.
…*Or *because they’ve seen a “ghost” and don’t have any foundation to understand it properly.

On the Twilight topic; I agree the books have some serious issues, but the very strong pro-life message at the end should not be overlooked.

Everyone wants Bella to give up the baby, but she gets her way and keeps it. Would that more women were able to stand up to such social pressure.
Also she is very strong in the face of the unknown.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top