Well, not to toot my own horn, but I did start a topic in Popular Media about the books, which I’ll link here:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=615431
I won’t repeat everything I’ve already wrote about this subject. I’ve actually not seen any of the movies, but I think the books are poorly written and send mixed messages.
BOOK SPOILERS AHEAD
As for Edward being controlling. Some people have excused this by saying it’s justified in the context of Werewolves vs Vampires. But seriously, Edward at one point literally
kidnaps Bella, holding her against her will, in order to prevent her from seeing Jacob. Saying that’s justified because werewolves can be dangerous seems to be the old “end justifies the means” argument that most people around here reject for other issues (for example, most people here would say that while abortion is immoral, that doesn’t make it okay to kidnap a woman to keep her from having one).
It also shows his condescending “I know better than you, a mere human who can’t read minds like I can” attitude, which he shows up at many other times, such as when he leaves Bella in the second book. He does this because he thinks he and his family are a threat to Bella, but he also does so expecting Bella to quickly move on and forget him, because that’s what humans do. Now, Edward has the power to read people’s minds, resulting in him having a pretty jaundiced view of the human race in general as superficial and selfish. But he can’t read Bella’s mind, likely one of the reasons he’s attracted to her in the first place. So, he just assumes she’s like any other human.
But, Bella is so devastated when Edward leaves that she becomes extremely depressed, almost suicidal, engaging in many risky activities, because when she does so she hallucinates that she can hear Edward’s voice telling her not to act that way. The relationship does seem quite unequal for most of the series. Perhaps Meyer meant for Bella to see Edward almost in a fatherly role at times, especially since she really doesn’t see either of her biological parents as authority figures at all. She thinks of them as Renee and Charlie, not Mom and Dad, and if anything, she sees herself as taking care of them, not the other way around. Problem is, that whole dynamic of a girl seeking a father figure in an older boy/man is usually quite unhealthy in real life, and tends to result in a lot of unwed pregnancies, a young single mom raising a kid alone without any real support, a father who’s either completely out of the picture or a Disneyland Dad, and the perpetuation of the cycle…
I suppose another disturbing context is that the books really do seem to glamorize suicide, and suicidal behavior as an appropriate response to romantic heartache. When Edward mistakenly thinks that Bella has committed suicide, he tries to commit suicide himself. Edward’s rival, Jacob, hints to Bella that he’s thinking of killing himself, as a way to emotionally blackmail her into kissing him. Many Twilight fandom people tried to excuse away Bella’s actions as not really “cheating” on Edward, because “OMG she thought her BFF was gonna KILL himself! Of course she’d do whatever she could to keep him from doing that!” Now, some others did point out that in real life, this is NOT how people should respond to suicidal threats. Indeed, this is considered abusive, for someone to threaten to commit suicide. But many people just didn’t get it.
All that being said, though…I wouldn’t say that the books are to blame for people’s attitudes, certainly not their behavior. I think it’s the other way around, the books are popular because they contain elements people already find attractive. Certainly, parents who are considering whether to let their children read the books or see the movies should really think about it hard. It also depends on the age and maturity of the child. Or adult, I guess, in light of all the middle-aged “TwilightMOMS” out there.