Twilight movies?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jason3477
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For me, it just didn’t seem to flow as well for some reason. When they did the bit with the wolf pack’s voices, I almost started laughing out loud in the theater. And when they were showing the transformation, it just seemed too “X-Men” for me. Maybe I should take my own advice and remember that it’s a fantasy movie, haha! 😛
Well never having seen “X-Men”, I didn’t have anything to compare it to. But yes, the wolves voices were strange, I probably relied more on my memory of the book at that point in the movie.

And yes, it is only a fictional fantasy!
 
Well, not to toot my own horn, but I did start a topic in Popular Media about the books, which I’ll link here:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=615431

I won’t repeat everything I’ve already wrote about this subject. I’ve actually not seen any of the movies, but I think the books are poorly written and send mixed messages.

BOOK SPOILERS AHEAD

As for Edward being controlling. Some people have excused this by saying it’s justified in the context of Werewolves vs Vampires. But seriously, Edward at one point literally kidnaps Bella, holding her against her will, in order to prevent her from seeing Jacob. Saying that’s justified because werewolves can be dangerous seems to be the old “end justifies the means” argument that most people around here reject for other issues (for example, most people here would say that while abortion is immoral, that doesn’t make it okay to kidnap a woman to keep her from having one).

It also shows his condescending “I know better than you, a mere human who can’t read minds like I can” attitude, which he shows up at many other times, such as when he leaves Bella in the second book. He does this because he thinks he and his family are a threat to Bella, but he also does so expecting Bella to quickly move on and forget him, because that’s what humans do. Now, Edward has the power to read people’s minds, resulting in him having a pretty jaundiced view of the human race in general as superficial and selfish. But he can’t read Bella’s mind, likely one of the reasons he’s attracted to her in the first place. So, he just assumes she’s like any other human.

But, Bella is so devastated when Edward leaves that she becomes extremely depressed, almost suicidal, engaging in many risky activities, because when she does so she hallucinates that she can hear Edward’s voice telling her not to act that way. The relationship does seem quite unequal for most of the series. Perhaps Meyer meant for Bella to see Edward almost in a fatherly role at times, especially since she really doesn’t see either of her biological parents as authority figures at all. She thinks of them as Renee and Charlie, not Mom and Dad, and if anything, she sees herself as taking care of them, not the other way around. Problem is, that whole dynamic of a girl seeking a father figure in an older boy/man is usually quite unhealthy in real life, and tends to result in a lot of unwed pregnancies, a young single mom raising a kid alone without any real support, a father who’s either completely out of the picture or a Disneyland Dad, and the perpetuation of the cycle… 😦

I suppose another disturbing context is that the books really do seem to glamorize suicide, and suicidal behavior as an appropriate response to romantic heartache. When Edward mistakenly thinks that Bella has committed suicide, he tries to commit suicide himself. Edward’s rival, Jacob, hints to Bella that he’s thinking of killing himself, as a way to emotionally blackmail her into kissing him. Many Twilight fandom people tried to excuse away Bella’s actions as not really “cheating” on Edward, because “OMG she thought her BFF was gonna KILL himself! Of course she’d do whatever she could to keep him from doing that!” Now, some others did point out that in real life, this is NOT how people should respond to suicidal threats. Indeed, this is considered abusive, for someone to threaten to commit suicide. But many people just didn’t get it.

All that being said, though…I wouldn’t say that the books are to blame for people’s attitudes, certainly not their behavior. I think it’s the other way around, the books are popular because they contain elements people already find attractive. Certainly, parents who are considering whether to let their children read the books or see the movies should really think about it hard. It also depends on the age and maturity of the child. Or adult, I guess, in light of all the middle-aged “TwilightMOMS” out there.
 
Catholic author Michael O’Brien has written a superb critique of the “Twilight” phenomenon:

studiobrien.com/writings_on_fantasy/twilight-of-the-west.html
This quote:

“I’m the world’s most dangerous predator. Everything about me invites you in. My voice, my face, even my smell… I’m designed to kill… I’ve wanted to kill you. I’ve never wanted a human’s blood so much in my life… Your scent, it’s like a drug to me. You’re like my own personal brand of heroin.”

:rolleyes:

This is delivered in the low, breathless voice of an impassioned lover. This is sensual desire, this is barely restrained lust. This is definitely a new kind of vampire. There are no fangs dripping blood, no black capes, no ritual commerce with the dead, no terror of daylight, just an aversion to direct sunlight because under its rays his skin glitters like diamonds. “You’re beautiful!” exclaims Bella when Edward opens his shirt and reveals his sparkling flesh.

I mean … Really??? People fall for this junk??? I need to start writing again!

😛
 
…*Or *because they’ve seen a “ghost” and don’t have any foundation to understand it properly
If your talking about the people doing their own thing, i agree.
on the Twilight topic; I agree the books have some serious issues, but the very strong pro-life message at the end should not be overlooked.

Everyone wants Bella to give up the baby, but she gets her way and keeps it. Would that more women were able to stand up to such social pressure.
Also she is very strong in the face of the unknown.
good point.
 
I will say, though, that I do give the author credit for good judgement in picking the name for the character of Leah. She is the high school sweetheart of the werewolf Sam, who leaves her for her cousin Emily after “imprinting” on Emily. (Which is a very creepy way that a werewolf finds his mate, basically he sees his “imprintee” and, even if he’s never met her before, she suddenly becomes the center of his world. All other emotional ties are either cut completely, or over-ridden.) Leah is portrayed, much like the Biblical character, to be frustrated and bitter over her situation. Although she also has similarities to the biblical Rachel in that Leah herself later becomes a werewolf (in Twilight-verse this happens because of an inborn genetic propensity activated in puberty by the proximity of vampires, not through a wolf bite), and believes herself to be infertile.

I still think the pro-life message re unborn babies is over-ridden by the end by the moral relativism about the morality of vampires killing humans.
 
I’ve seen the twilight series and I would say that this film especially Breaking dawn , the latest series is an "only for adult " film. However , I do admit that I really like the story and find the movie very romantice. The character of Edward portrays a traditional type of guy who strongly believes in marriage. The film is also pro-life and the actor is soo cute :D:D:D By the way he is CATHOLIC !!!
 
This quote:

“I’m the world’s most dangerous predator. Everything about me invites you in. My voice, my face, even my smell… I’m designed to kill… I’ve wanted to kill you. I’ve never wanted a human’s blood so much in my life… Your scent, it’s like a drug to me. You’re like my own personal brand of heroin.”

:rolleyes:

This is delivered in the low, breathless voice of an impassioned lover. This is sensual desire, this is barely restrained lust. This is definitely a new kind of vampire. There are no fangs dripping blood, no black capes, no ritual commerce with the dead, no terror of daylight, just an aversion to direct sunlight because under its rays his skin glitters like diamonds. “You’re beautiful!” exclaims Bella when Edward opens his shirt and reveals his sparkling flesh.

I mean … Really??? People fall for this junk???

😛
:sad_yes:
 
It is just a movie and most girls are amazed with it cause of the love story, as long as you clarify that it is just that it should be just fine… People like to set wierd tags, interpretations and make things bad when they think they see “Evil” and cant accept what it is, a MOVIE.

That is why we have a rating system in this case if I am not mistaking PG-13. How many times really bad situations have occurred in the catholic church and people dont even acknowledge this or just skip the subject… eg “Pope Joan”. We still here believing and following cause we know that church is not guilty for the actions of a few right?

So dont over react and explain the movie in a good way for them to understand, if you restrict this it will create more expectation out of nothing and then they will definitely find a way to watch it without giving you a chance of guidance 😉
 
“Pope Joan” never existed: an Italian suburb made up a tourist trap.
Carry on.
 
“Pope Joan” never existed: an Italian suburb made up a tourist trap.
Carry on.
Could you please tell me in what facts you are basing your opinion? Or you just like to believe that she never existed? I did not want to bring it up but how about child molesting that has never existed either? or the inquisition? I mean, we cant cover the sun with one finger and we have to be strong if we want to prevail…
 
Could you please tell me in what facts you are basing your opinion? Or you just like to believe that she never existed? I did not want to bring it up but how about child molesting that has never existed either? or the inquisition? I mean, we cant cover the sun with one finger and we have to be strong if we want to prevail…
This article should help you see the silliness of the “Pope Joan” claims:

catholic.com/magazine/articles/the-popess-who-just-won%E2%80%99t-go-away. There is nothing to “cover up”.
 
Could you please tell me in what facts you are basing your opinion? Or you just like to believe that she never existed? I did not want to bring it up but how about child molesting that has never existed either? or the inquisition? I mean, we cant cover the sun with one finger and we have to be strong if we want to prevail…
The Inquisition is recorded and attested to by people of that time, there are account of the trials of child molesters. Those are good, primary historical sources. We can read about them in the Non-Fiction section of the bookstore. Historians use criteria such as this when they look at the pat to determine which stories are fake, and which are supported by solid evidence.
Pope Joan, on the other hand, shows up as a legend hundreds of years after it allegedly happened, in an Italian suburb which sold the story and “souvenirs” to gullible tourists. The date actually occurs in the middle of another Pope’s reign. The Catholic Church keeps records of who has been Pope going back to Peter. The story is so full of holes; and has no evidence for it at all. Serious historians don’t just believe whatever story they hear, they research and weigh the evidence. And there is none.
 
It is just a movie and most girls are amazed with it cause of the love story, as long as you clarify that it is just that it should be just fine.… People like to set wierd tags, interpretations and make things bad when they think they see “Evil” and cant accept what it is, a MOVIE.

That is why we have a rating system in this case if I am not mistaking PG-13. How many times really bad situations have occurred in the catholic church and people dont even acknowledge this or just skip the subject… eg “Pope Joan”. We still here believing and following cause we know that church is not guilty for the actions of a few right?

So dont over react and explain the movie in a good way for them to understand, if you restrict this it will create more expectation out of nothing and then they will definitely find a way to watch it without giving you a chance of guidance 😉
But that is what we are discussing - the emotional attachments in these books/movies are NOT LOVE and have nothing to do with love!!! Having a guy break into your house and watch you while you sleep??? That’s NOT LOVE!!! It’s stalking, and creepy to the max. If girls are thinking that this shows LOVE, then what will they expect from their boyfriends?? “Oh, it’s so ROMANTIC, he broke into my house and took my picture while I slept!”

:eek:
 
I would say they’re not so much “evil” as banal and morally ambiguous. Entertaining for some, perhaps (though not me!) but not edifying.

While I won’t fire any anathemas at someone who enjoys the series, I personally wouldn’t recommend it 😃

Also, some critics (can’t find a reference right now, sorry!) have seen veiled and not-so-veiled allusions to Mormonism in the original books, particularly the idea of “man becoming a god” - which is probably true, since the series author is a practicing Mormon. With this in mind, I’d say caveat lector.
 
But don’t they send a bad/wrong message?
No.

They have a very pro life message and a strong saving sex for marriage message. They also promote chivalry, strength against temptations, and traditional moral values.
 
I know some people here are saying some pretty negative things about Edward and how he’s so controlling and creepy and everything.

To those people, I just have to say they need to put things into perspective. You write “Edward won’t let Bella go see her friends.”… But that’s not the point of it and is being taken completely out of context. Edward INITIALLY wouldn’t let Bella go see Jacob because Jacob is a werewolf who could accidentally harm Bella. He is concerned for her safety. However, at the end of the 3rd book Edward changes and tells Bella that he loves her and wants her to be happy and trusts her judgement - and decides to go ahead and LET her do what she wants with Jacob.

The “violent sex” they had at their honeymoon wasn’t really “violent sex” at all. You have to take into account that Edward is a vampire and has extreme strength. It is common for people to lose some physical control while having an orgasm (involuntary spasms, etc etc), but when someone as strong as Edward loses control, things around him get destroyed because he is so strong. The bruises on Bella were accidental, and he feels horrible about himself and actually stops having sex with her for a while out of fear of hurting her like that again.

Edward is an old fashioned gentleman who treats Bella very well and refuses to have sex with her before they are married. There are so many good things about Edward, yet some folks here seem to only see the bad… this is a reflection of the general attitude around here of some of the members only seeing the negative things in others - only the things that can be condemned.

Twilight is a fantasy novel for young adults. The characters aren’t all going to be perfect, holy people. If you want to read a book about holy people, read biographies of saints.

I think Twilight has a lot of very good things in it that most books for young adults now a days don’t have. Prior to Twilight, I don’t even remember reading a fiction book or seeing a fiction movie that promoted chivalry, saving sex for marriage, and pro life sentiments.

There are a lot of other things here I’ve seen people writing that I’m just like “oh my gosh… really?? REALLY??” Because it is taken SOOO out of context and is so condemned for the perceived imperfections, rather than looking at the whole picture and praising it or at least giving it credit for all the GOOD messages it has. I won’t touch on everything, but it really does amaze me how quick people here are to look at the (perceived) negative side of things and completely overlook the Christian message the books get across. 🤷

More thoughts here- forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=617557
 
Catholic author Michael O’Brien has written a superb critique of the “Twilight” phenomenon:

studiobrien.com/writings_on_fantasy/twilight-of-the-west.html
From this cirtique Bolding, and red = mine (in reference to the writers dream that Edward came to her and told her he was much more evil than she was writing him to be):

Who was this “Edward”? Was it the author’s subconscious telling her that she was attempting to tame what cannot be tamed? Or was it an evil spirit manifesting through the image, urging her to give her readers less moralism and more blood? Is it weird for this CATHOLIC critic to even guess that an evil spirit had manifested itself to the writer in effort to get her to write a more gruesome tale?However one interprets it, the question remains: **Why did she not realize that the second dream was warning her about something? **Is it weird for this Catholic Critic to insinuate her dream was telling her something? I mean, I GET creating a story out of something you dreamt of. I DON’T get the idea that her dreams are MORE than dreams. More than your mind wondering? In her interviews she merely reported it without offering an assessment of what it might mean, then continued to write more of the same. Why did she respond to the first dream and not to the second?'Cause one spawned an idea? The other probably a stress dream? She’s deep in her characters and her mind wonders? an EVIL SPIRIT??? REALLY??? Was it because the first was extremely pleasurable and the second disturbing to the point of terror? Was it because pleasure had become her good and unhappy feelings a thing to be dismissed as bad? Conscience cannot be entirely eradicated in human nature, and when it raises its painful, unwelcome truths, the individual (or the culture in which he lives) must either pay attention to it or counteract it with a strategy of denial. This is just a huge stretch IMO. Has NO ONE had awful dreams? Man maybe I just need some serious therapy. Attention is redirected away from the truth about his condition, focusing on overcoming symptoms and ignoring the root cause of the symptoms.'Cause this is NOT REAL, RIGHT? I mean, I don’t understand taking a pretend existance, and then insisting that it only follows a certain formula. Not unless we’re saying Vampires are real, and we can’t go and color them as anything but evil driven REAL beings???

Within the story, I gathered many of the vampire characters NEVER would have become vampires given the choice. They never wanted the existance forced on them. Should they have killed themselves? In a pretend world that Vampires exist, whose CREATION would they be? I imagine satan’s. BUT, if even they are disgusted by their own existance. And refuse to live in a fashion they were designed to, by eating human’s. Then WHOSE creation would they be. Can a demon of sorts choose to be good? Would a demon ever choose to be good? If not a demon, should they take their own life?

The books, certainly not scholarly. Would I let my teen watch it? I’m not sure, mine are still kids. And well, I haven’t even let them watch Star Wars. I guess I’d rather watch with, than have them watch at a friends. Even now, when they watch a cartoon, I’m talking over it. Wow, that wasn’t nice was it? You know that’s pretend right?

The fact is, this story exists. It’s popular. Can’t ignore it. May as well talk about it. Let your kids know where you stand on it I suppose.
 
I’m glad I have boys. Well, young men now, 20 and 18. The 18 year old saw one of the Twilight movies with a girlfriend and hated every minute of it. He read the first book and thinks it’s total junk, and insists that Edward is a stalker and creepy. And that if HE did anything like that, the girl would have her parents throw him in jail. It’s an odd kind of chivalry that includes breaking into a house and watching your girlfriend sleep.

I guess you never saw “Bella” then, Debora? I mean the movie, not the Bella from Twilight.
 
I’m glad I have boys. Well, young men now, 20 and 18. The 18 year old saw one of the Twilight movies with a girlfriend and hated every minute of it. He read the first book and thinks it’s total junk, and insists that Edward is a stalker and creepy. And that if HE did anything like that, the girl would have her parents throw him in jail. It’s an odd kind of chivalry that includes breaking into a house and watching your girlfriend sleep.

I guess you never saw “Bella” then, Debora? I mean the movie, not the Bella from Twilight.
You’re glad you have boys because you’re glad you don’t have a daughter like me who would like such “junk” as twilight?? Lol. My mom actually watched the first movie with me and liked it. I think she was glad she had a girl to watch it with. 🤷

You’d honestly have to read all the books yourself to understand, Julianne. I can see why you’d think badly of it if all you heard about it was that a guy “broke into” someone’s house to watch her sleep. Especially taken out of context like that makes it sound really bad.

Of course your son doesn’t like Twilight and thinks it’s junk. It’s a women’s novel! My husband doesn’t like them either. He just thinks they’re boring, which I kinda do too actually, but I appreciate the sense of morale in the stories, and I like the chaste romance between the 2 characters.

I agree that the fact that Edward climbed into Bella’s window to watch her as she slept is a little weird. But like I said, there are a lot of other very VERY positive things Edward portrays, that I don’t see very often at all in popular young adult books/movies. I’m not going to condemn his character or the entire series because of ONE thing I found to be a little weird.

Perhaps you should read all 4 books so that you can figure it out for yourself?

And no, I have not seen “Bella.” Never heard of it to be honest…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top