Twilight movies?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jason3477
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
All that being said, if I had a teenage daughter who wanted to read the books or watch the movies, I certainly wouldn’t totally ban them. I would try to use them as learning opportunities to discuss what are healthy romantic relationships, and what aren’t.
Exactly and I probably wouldn’t allow anyone younger then 13 to read them and only after a a frank discussion with her about relationships.
 
(clipped)
Now, some people criticize Twilight for being poorly written. Others criticize it because of the messages in the work. **Personally, I find that Twilight really does play into a social phenomenon that is actually harmful in the vast majority of cases. That being, the teenage girl bereft of guidance and authority in her family life turning to an older man to meet her needs for love and affection.

Bella fits this profile in that she is the child of divorced parents, the scatterbrained Renee and the workaholic Charlie. She is portrayed as seeing herself more as the caretaker for both her parents than the other way around, thinking of them by their first names, etc. **Her tendency to see Edward as an authority figure (such as in the second book, when she finds that engaging in risk-taking behavior makes her hallucinate that Edward is chiding her) makes a lot of sense when considering that.

**In real life, such girls, while not in danger of being stalked by or turned into vampires, are in danger of becoming the victims of real life sexual predators who really do cause damage. ** (clipped)
Some excellent points are raised in your post. This phenomenon of parentless children was started by Disney films - the hero is frequently orphaned or is wiser, smarter, more savvy than his or her parents. I see it all the time on television now days, but the father especially is portrayed as totally clueless and idiotic. Many popular books for teens have the same scenario. The authors just say, “Well, I am writing it to reflect what society really looks like,” but why not have some good, decent parents as characters then? The books would not be written, because the hero has to be on his/her own in order to move the plot forward. The Harry Potter books have the same premise - the kids on their own, especially Harry. But at least Harry is on a quest to destroy an evil force. Bella wants to mate with evil.

😦

Yes to the sexual predator atmosphere of the books/movies. It is a thin veneer of “love” or “caring,” with a whole lot of sickness inside. Just the very idea of a guy sneaking into (breaking into) a girl’s room and watching her sleep is creepy and frightening, yet this is put forward as Edward’s “love” for Bella. Having experienced just that sort of “love,” I can assure you that it’s destructive and scary. Young girls have no idea what that kind of obsession really means, and so they must accept the author’s premise and continue reading or watching. All of these messages are under the surface, unquestioned, unexamined.

Girls who have fathers in their lives - caring, wholesome, faithful and kind men, who treat their wives and daughters with respect - at least have something to compare the books with. Without a father’s true and honorable love for her, a fatherless daughter absorbs the worst lessons from junk like this.
 
Ok… first let me say. I do not compare the writing skills AT ALL with my next example.
Romeo and Juliet anyone?

I mean the writing is WAY better. And well, it makes an amazing ballet. But just what do you all think about a young lustful couple who refuse to hold out for marriage to whomever their parents chose for them.

Who FAKE their own deaths. Who KILL themselves?

I think ToeIntheWater had some insightful analysis… Would it not apply to such a great classic?

Just curious.
 
That’s the approach I took with the books and the movies. Sometimes I just want “fluff”, nothing more. Similar to wanting some potato chips, every once in awhile its an indulgence that I let myself have. I recognize the books and the movies for what they are.
Amen!!!👍
 
Some excellent points are raised in your post. This phenomenon of parentless children was started by Disney films - the hero is frequently orphaned or is wiser, smarter, more savvy than his or her parents. I see it all the time on television now days, but the father especially is portrayed as totally clueless and idiotic. Many popular books for teens have the same scenario. The authors just say, “Well, I am writing it to reflect what society really looks like,” but why not have some good, decent parents as characters then? The books would not be written, because the hero has to be on his/her own in order to move the plot forward. The Harry Potter books have the same premise - the kids on their own, especially Harry. But at least Harry is on a quest to destroy an evil force. Bella wants to mate with evil.

😦

Yes to the sexual predator atmosphere of the books/movies. It is a thin veneer of “love” or “caring,” with a whole lot of sickness inside. Just the very idea of a guy sneaking into (breaking into) a girl’s room and watching her sleep is creepy and frightening, yet this is put forward as Edward’s “love” for Bella. Having experienced just that sort of “love,” I can assure you that it’s destructive and scary. Young girls have no idea what that kind of obsession really means, and so they must accept the author’s premise and continue reading or watching. All of these messages are under the surface, unquestioned, unexamined.

Girls who have fathers in their lives - caring, wholesome, faithful and kind men, who treat their wives and daughters with respect - at least have something to compare the books with. Without a father’s true and honorable love for her, a fatherless daughter absorbs the worst lessons from junk like this.
I disagree with the comparison to HP, though I think your point overall is a good one. Harry has several excellent adult role models - but, as we all do when we grow older, we realize that even good people make mistakes. And sometimes these people leave us and we must go on without them (which, admittedly, does happen to Harry a lot - almost every adult role model he has dies at some point during the series…but he still learns from them all.)

Actually, the fleshing out of the adult characters was one of the things I really enjoyed about HP, instead of presenting them as two-dimensional idiots. As far as I can tell with Twilight (I only read half of the first book before I put it down…I couldn’t take it anymore), every character was two-dimensional. Didn’t the author at one point basically admit she wrote a Mary Sue vampire story? (A “Mary Sue” is an idealized portrayal of the author, usually of a fanfiction story, as a main character.) She also claimed that Gilbert Blythe (of Anne of Green Gables) was one of her inspirations for Edward. Um, no…not in the slightest. Gilbert had a sense of humor, was not dark and mysterious - one of the reasons Anne thought she could never fall in love with him - and was not a stalker or manipulative in any way. (I did kind of crush on him when I was younger, I’ll admit it!)
 
Exactly and I probably wouldn’t allow anyone younger then 13 to read them and only after a a frank discussion with her about relationships.
Depends upon the child in question. My daughter read Romeo and Juliet in the 4th grade and held her own in discussions with my husband. Some kids won’t be able to handle that material or the material of “Twilight” even when they are 14. The rating of PG and PG-13 is at the discretion of the parent, some kids younger than that guideline can handle more mature material than others.
 
I disagree with the comparison to HP, though I think your point overall is a good one. Harry has several excellent adult role models - but, as we all do when we grow older, we realize that even good people make mistakes. And sometimes these people leave us and we must go on without them (which, admittedly, does happen to Harry a lot - almost every adult role model he has dies at some point during the series…but he still learns from them all.)

Actually, the fleshing out of the adult characters was one of the things I really enjoyed about HP, instead of presenting them as two-dimensional idiots. As far as I can tell with Twilight (I only read half of the first book before I put it down…I couldn’t take it anymore), every character was two-dimensional. Didn’t the author at one point basically admit she wrote a Mary Sue vampire story? (A “Mary Sue” is an idealized portrayal of the author, usually of a fanfiction story, as a main character.) She also claimed that Gilbert Blythe (of Anne of Green Gables) was one of her inspirations for Edward. Um, no…not in the slightest. Gilbert had a sense of humor, was not dark and mysterious - one of the reasons Anne thought she could never fall in love with him - and was not a stalker or manipulative in any way. (I did kind of crush on him when I was younger, I’ll admit it!)
I always saw the “mary sue” in the series, that’s the main appeal to even the older women that are so obsessed with the books and movies.

But now that you mentioned Gilbert Blythe, I never considered him as a reference but I can see it in some aspects. More in the books though, because the reference to the time period Edward was supposedly “turned” that is not hardly mentioned in the movies.

Didn’t Anne say that she didn’t want a boy that was bad, but a boy that had the potential to be bad? Maybe that’s the reference to Edward.
 
I always saw the “mary sue” in the series, that’s the main appeal to even the older women that are so obsessed with the books and movies.

But now that you mentioned Gilbert Blythe, I never considered him as a reference but I can see it in some aspects. More in the books though, because the reference to the time period Edward was supposedly “turned” that is not hardly mentioned in the movies.

Didn’t Anne say that she didn’t want a boy that was bad, but a boy that had the potential to be bad? Maybe that’s the reference to Edward.
She did. And considering that Gilbert spent time tormenting girls (pranks) as a flirtation device, maybe that counts (he was also 13/14 then, so…you know, that makes sense.)

But Gilbert could never have been bad! He was a good-hearted doctor after all, when he grew up!

(I am wandering off topic here…but when I read that quote from Meyer about their similarities, I just had to start building the wall of separation right there. I loved those books - still kinda do, I think they’re great for older children - and I just got so MAD about it. 😛 I do not normally think of myself as a book “purist” but when it comes to this I just have to put my foot down. ;))
 
She did. And considering that Gilbert spent time tormenting girls (pranks) as a flirtation device, maybe that counts (he was also 13/14 then, so…you know, that makes sense.)

But Gilbert could never have been bad! He was a good-hearted doctor after all, when he grew up!

(I am wandering off topic here…but when I read that quote from Meyer about their similarities, I just had to start building the wall of separation right there. I loved those books - still kinda do, I think they’re great for older children - and I just got so MAD about it. 😛 I do not normally think of myself as a book “purist” but when it comes to this I just have to put my foot down. ;))
Now that I know there’s a connection, it actually makes me want to go back and reread the “fluff”. I wish she had put some Anne into Bella, Bella is such a wimp.
 
Re the comparison between Twilight books and Romeo and Juliet, I think that the difference is that R+J is a tragedy in the end, more than a romance, and I don’t think the audience is meant to think that Romeo and Juliet killing themselves was a good thing. I remember reading that play in high school and the overall impression I got is that the actions of the lovers are meant to be tragically misguided, not romantic and justified. Especially in Elizabethan England, where suicide was definitely considered a serious sin. But as in most of Shakespeare, there is much room for disagreement as to what he himself thought about suicide.

However, I think that in general, he was against it, though he portrays many of his tragic characters resorting to suicide. For example, when Othello commits suicide after he finds out that he wrongfully killed his wife for adultery when she was innocent, a witness to his actions makes a comment that his suicide negates the effect of his confession, that “all that’s spoke is marred”. It’s actually not meant to be a noble way to punish himself for his acts against his wife, but a sign of despair, and notably, Othello is a Moor, and likely was raised in a non-Christian environment (though he is likely a convert, as Desdemona’s father doesn’t accuse him of being a pagan or Muslim, though he accuses him of many other things).

Meyer actually has compared her books to many classic romances, including Romeo and Juliet. She’s also mentioned Pride and Prejudice and Wuthering Heights. But even those works have been the subject of much controversy. For example, does Elizabeth Bennett truly come to love Darcy, or is she just won over by his wealth and her gratitude to him (for saving her sister’s reputation)? Do Heathcliff and Cathy really love each other, or do they just have an unhealthy obsession for each other?

I don’t think that movies or books have to be boringly black and white in terms of the author browbeating the reader with the Moral of the Story. I am not in favor of banning Twilight or saying that the subject matter itself makes it unfit for Catholics or other audiences. But I do think that the popularity of the series is disturbing in what it reveals about many young (and not so young) women these days.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top