U.S. Deficit Commission Recommends Changes to Social Security

  • Thread starter Thread starter bbarrick8383
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bbarrick8383

Guest
A draft proposal by the deficit commission suggests curbing Social Security benefits and raising the retirement age.
The co-chairmen of the panel appointed by President Obama to cut the U.S. deficit recommend raising the retirement age to 68. It is currently 67 years for retirees to receive full benefits. The panel leaders also propose reducing the annual cost-of-living increases in Social Security.
The increase to age 68 would be implemented by 2050 and then would increase again to 69 by 2075. A “hardship exception” would be provided for certain occupations where older retirement would be unrealistic.
According to a source who spoke to Fox News, the 18-member panel led by former Wyoming Republican Sen. Alan Simpson and former Clinton Chief of Staff Erskine Bowles, also may propose reducing the base rate on corporate taxes, phasing in spending cuts over time, reducing foreign aid by $4.6 billion, freezing federal salaries for three years and banning congressional earmarks. It is unclear how the commissioners would define a congressional earmark.
foxnews.com/politics/2010/11/10/deficit-commission-recommends-changes-social-security/
 
They also propose to eliminate the interest deduction for home ownership. I guess the housing market hasn’t crashed hard enough yet.
 
At some point, tough decisions will had to be made. The pain must be spread around, and should not be a case where the generations that created the problem get to escape the fix of the problem.

The irresponsibility of politicians spending money they did not have in the past, or do not have now, has put our country in this position.

Now, just watch the current politicians turn this into a political hot potato.
 
:yawn:

Same old, same old. They have been talking about raising the retirement age to 70 since I was in high school, graduated in '93. In fact we where told we would have to be 70 before receiving benefits. 🤷

Of course my generation and the younger ones are all being told that Social Security will not be there for us because of lack of money.

Fine then let’s set a shut down date and be done with it.
 
:yawn:

Same old, same old. They have been talking about raising the retirement age to 70 since I was in high school, graduated in '93. In fact we where told we would have to be 70 before receiving benefits. 🤷

Of course my generation and the younger ones are all being told that Social Security will not be there for us because of lack of money.

Fine then let’s set a shut down date and be done with it.
Hey that’s not good. I’ve been paying into all my life. I think I should get at little piece of the pie in my old age.😦
 
Hey that’s not good. I’ve been paying into all my life. I think I should get at little piece of the pie in my old age.😦
That’s just it, our generation is being told it won’t be there. So why are we continuing to pay into to something that won’t be there? Set a shut down date and be done with it. Let us keep our money so we can decide where it should go. Obviously we are going to have to come up with something else for retirement.
 
That’s just it, our generation is being told it won’t be there. So why are we continuing to pay into to something that won’t be there? Set a shut down date and be done with it. Let us keep our money so we can decide where it should go. Obviously we are going to have to come up with something else for retirement.
We’re really paying for the people who are using it now. It’s not really for our retirement. It’s for current retirees and disabled people. When I retire, other workers will be paying for me. That’s how it works.
 
Maybe they should advise families to have more kids.
Oh no, can’t do that. That would make it harder on mother earth and her limited resources. We are overpopulated as it is. We must find ways to kill off the old people along with the babies.

:rolleyes:

Felt I needed the :rolleyes:, just in case someone thought I was serious.
 
We’re really paying for the people who are using it now. It’s not really for our retirement. It’s for current retirees and disabled people. When I retire, other workers will be paying for me. That’s how it works.
Quite true. It might be observed that some people, particularly professionals and high-end white collar workers, are perfectly fit for the workplace at 70. Some are not, most notably people who are in very physically demanding or dangerous occupations. While veterinarians, for example, are professionals properly speaking, large animal vets are usually physically shot well before age 70 because they take a lot of hits. But they can still do small animal work.

But you take the guys who work the chutes in the stockyards. They don’t have some other profession they can go to when their discs start giving out 30 years before they should. People like that are shot even before they’re 65.

To me, SS is just a government welfare program. Always was, always will be. Current taxpayers have always supported the retirees and Congress spent the excess on other things, pretending there was some kind of “trust fund”. SS ought to be means tested. There is absolutely no reason for the government to ever pay a dime to, say, Bill Gates, Jamie Dimon, or even someone who draws dividends off a 5 million dollar portfolio. And most definitely, it should not be paid to anyone with a generous pension from some other source. It’s just wrong to burden working people who are trying to get by and raise families to pay some retired judge, for example, who draws over $100,000/year just for existing.

But they won’t means test SS because everybody wants to keep pretending that it’s not just another welfare program.
 
Soclal Security is a Ponzi scheme. If I was a college student I would take to the streets. Perhaps the younger generation doesn’t understand what we’ve done to them with our profligate spending. Perhaps they will wake up one day and realize they have been had. I don’t get it.

The irony is that many young people worked hard for Obama and he is working diligently to saddle them with even more debt. “Thank you sir, may I have another??” :rolleyes:
 
We’re really paying for the people who are using it now. It’s not really for our retirement. It’s for current retirees and disabled people. When I retire, other workers will be paying for me. That’s how it works.
And it’s going BROKE!!! You do realize that the government also likes to dip their hands into it as well? So you have a program that’s being paid for by only the people who work. It’s not being paid for those on welfare or the unemployed. It’s being paid out to all the retirees, widows with children, and the disabled, as well as the government who likes to dip their hands into it. There is more going out than coming in.

Many of these people would be better served by their local community and not a beaucrate in Washington D.C.
 
Quite true. It might be observed that some people, particularly professionals and high-end white collar workers, are perfectly fit for the workplace at 70. Some are not, most notably people who are in very physically demanding or dangerous occupations. While veterinarians, for example, are professionals properly speaking, large animal vets are usually physically shot well before age 70 because they take a lot of hits. But they can still do small animal work.

But you take the guys who work the chutes in the stockyards. They don’t have some other profession they can go to when their discs start giving out 30 years before they should. People like that are shot even before they’re 65.

To me, SS is just a government welfare program. Always was, always will be. Current taxpayers have always supported the retirees and Congress spent the excess on other things, pretending there was some kind of “trust fund”. SS ought to be means tested. There is absolutely no reason for the government to ever pay a dime to, say, Bill Gates, Jamie Dimon, or even someone who draws dividends off a 5 million dollar portfolio. And most definitely, it should not be paid to anyone with a generous pension from some other source. It’s just wrong to burden working people who are trying to get by and raise families to pay some retired judge, for example, who draws over $100,000/year just for existing.

But they won’t means test SS because everybody wants to keep pretending that it’s not just another welfare program.
Very true. :sad_yes:
 
Very true. :sad_yes:
I read these sentiments and they make me sick. The government has been robbing me, other just like me and our employers since we were teens, I’m now 66. All these comparisons to a Ponzi scheme are idiotic, a Ponzi scheme implies the investors are willing, SS victims had no choice under penalty of law, the money was taken from us every payday. Comparisons to welfare are idiotic, we unwillingly paid into an insurance plan with the government promise of a defined retirement income in return, well it’s time to pay up. We didn’t treat the SS trust account like a private slush fund, the government did so like it or not America, you are on the hook, pay up. Revise the system for future generations if you want but you owe those of us who paid for decades, even when we couldn’t afford to, and are now retired.
 
I read these sentiments and they make me sick. The government has been robbing me, other just like me and our employers since we were teens, I’m now 66. All these comparisons to a Ponzi scheme are idiotic, a Ponzi scheme implies the investors are willing, SS victims had no choice under penalty of law, the money was taken from us every payday. Comparisons to welfare are idiotic, we unwillingly paid into an insurance plan with the government promise of a defined retirement income in return, well it’s time to pay up. We didn’t treat the SS trust account like a private slush fund, the government did so like it or not America, you are on the hook, pay up. Revise the system for future generations if you want but you owe those of us who paid for decades, even when we couldn’t afford to, and are now retired.
I agree Bob, I bet I will be repeating these exact same words in 34 years.
 
We’re really paying for the people who are using it now. It’s not really for our retirement. It’s for current retirees and disabled people. When I retire, other workers will be paying for me. That’s how it works.
That sounds like a bancrupt Ponzi scheme to me.
 
At some point, tough decisions will had to be made. The pain must be spread around, and should not be a case where the generations that created the problem get to escape the fix of the problem.

The irresponsibility of politicians spending money they did not have in the past, or do not have now, has put our country in this position.

Now, just watch the current politicians turn this into a political hot potato.
What do you mean “generations that created the problem”. I have been paying into this “system” for 50 years against my will. So I created the problem and shouldn’t get any of my money back?
 
I read these sentiments and they make me sick. The government has been robbing me, other just like me and our employers since we were teens, I’m now 66. All these comparisons to a Ponzi scheme are idiotic, a Ponzi scheme implies the investors are willing, SS victims had no choice under penalty of law, the money was taken from us every payday. Comparisons to welfare are idiotic, we unwillingly paid into an insurance plan with the government promise of a defined retirement income in return, well it’s time to pay up. We didn’t treat the SS trust account like a private slush fund, the government did so like it or not America, you are on the hook, pay up. Revise the system for future generations if you want but you owe those of us who paid for decades, even when we couldn’t afford to, and are now retired.
Darn good point. If is worse than a Ponzi scheme. It has been theft pure and simple. Now, I wonder how Obamacare is going to fare down the road??? Medicare is the same. Friggin government needs to quit helping us.
 
Darn good point. If is worse than a Ponzi scheme. It has been theft pure and simple. Now, I wonder how Obamacare is going to fare down the road??? Medicare is the same. Friggin government needs to quit helping us.
I used to be thankful that I wasn’t getting all the government I was paying for, now I’m wondering how on earth I’m going to pay for all the government I’m getting!
 
That’s just it, our generation is being told it won’t be there. So why are we continuing to pay into to something that won’t be there? Set a shut down date and be done with it. Let us keep our money so we can decide where it should go. Obviously we are going to have to come up with something else for retirement.
I don’t think it’s that simple. What about the millions of hardworking people who barely take the time to read, let alone understand the intracacies of investing wisely? This isn’t a knock on them. It’s just reality. Social Security is a vital safety net for them. What happens to them? How do we tell a high school grad who worked in a factory all his life and for whom the idea of going to college is only a little less strange than the idea of going to Mars…how does such a person fare when told SS won’t be there; go invest your money on your own…?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top