UCL’s platform for extreme Creationists

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
from the Telegraph:
Extreme Creationists have been given the use of a lecture hall at University College, London, to preach against evolutionary science. Tomorrow’s event has been organised by the college’s Islamic Society as part of “Islamic Awareness Week”. Is that why UCL doesn’t have a problem with it?
Saturday’s Guardian carried a brief report of the story, but adopted the muted tone it reserves for Muslim assaults on scholarship. If these had been Christian Creationists the paper would have gone bananas. Yet the Istanbul-based organisation giving the lecture holds sinister views, and is increasingly powerful in the developing world.
The talk, entitled “the Collapse of the Evolutionary Theory”, was originally booked for the Darwin Lecture Theatre but, after protests from scientists appalled at the insult to Charles Darwin’s memory, has now been moved – to another UCL lecture theatre.
Would they extend the same forum to a Christian creationist group?
 
Probably not. Christians do not have rights these days.
 
Wow… UCL was where Darwin did a lot of his research!

The problem is, evolution is a word which encompasses many theories and common descent is a fact as the sky is blue and the sun is hot. Furthermore, random mutation and natural selction happen and it can be observed.

The idea of random mutation being able to account for all development though, is much more of a stretch. I’m not saying God waved his magic wand, but as a scientific theory, there is a lot of just-so-story and speculation needed to “prove” the mutation theory. My guess is that a better theory, or a much more refined argument (like devo-evo) will take over from the crude idea of mutation.

Darwin had no idea just how complicated cells are and what reproduction really entails.
 
The idea of random mutation being able to account for all development though, is much more of a stretch. I’m not saying God waved his magic wand, but as a scientific theory, there is a lot of just-so-story and speculation needed to “prove” the mutation theory. My guess is that a better theory, or a much more refined argument (like devo-evo) will take over from the crude idea of mutation.

Darwin had no idea just how complicated cells are and what reproduction really entails.
single mutations is Fruit Flies can cause legs to grow where antenna should be. There are critical genes called “body plan” control elements, that when altered, can drastically change appearance, function ect.

There are also stretches of DNA called “locus control elements”, which are like promoters, but control entire chromosonal regions.

The red, green, blue cones of the eye are perfect examples of this. Red and green opsin genes share the same locus control element, while blue has a different one. Red opsins resulted from the duplication of the green opsin gene, but under the same LCE. UV opsins in fish and other animals share the same locus control element as the blue. Blue duplicated and became UV. So we have 2 examples of the same thing happening, and found in many species.

You dont need to mutate and entire genome to see big change. All you have to do is mutate a kinase enzyme, and everything downstream that it affects will change behavior too.

“Evolution” is a blanket term. Natural selection is the mechanism of evolution, and is driven by random genetic mutations that are selected for by the current environment.

Evolution is trashed because we can’t explain the entire mechanism of genetic and natural selection yet. but there was a theory proposed by Kauffman in “Investigations” that states:

“Systems will arrange themselves to maximize the adjacent possible, where the adjacent possible is something that is on the verge of coming into being”.

Natural selection maximizes the genetic diversity of a population, and this has been definitely demonstrated in brine shrimp with sheer elegance. People just get ticked that Evolution calls into question of the Genesis creation story, which is an allegory anyway.
 
Yeah they’re called Hox genes, I know a little bit about them. I want to read Endless Forms Most Beautiful by Carroll.

The interesting thing to me is the modularity of these systems, they are almost like words.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top