T
Tommy_B
Guest
Can unbaptized infants go to heaven? Is Limbo a settled issue?
“Limbo of the Infants” was/is a way of explaining the teaching of the Church, which is : Scripture specifically says “No unbaptized person can enter Heaven.” But that God wills all to be saved. So we hope that there might be a way for God to supply the Grace of Baptism outside of the Sacrament of Baptism. We don’t know.Can unbaptized infants go to heaven? Is Limbo a settled issue?
This may sound weird, but as I read your post I wondered if there is any theological reason we have to wait for the birth to baptize the infant? We teach that the baby is fully human from conception and that civil rights should be granted it, why not the religious right (or rite) of baptism? We have Catholic funerals and/or burials for children who died before birth, don’t we?The Church in the Catechism strongly urges all parents to have their children Baptized as soon as possible after birth, and not take a chance of the child dying without Baptism.
The Sacraments are individual encounters with Christ. All the Sacraments require the person to be physically present and for the action to take place on the physical person receiving the Sacrament. This relates to the “Form and Matter” spoken of by Trent.This may sound weird, but as I read your post I wondered if there is any theological reason we have to wait for the birth to baptize the infant? We teach that the baby is fully human from conception and that civil rights should be granted it, why not the religious right (or rite) of baptism? We have Catholic funerals and/or burials for children who died before birth, don’t we?
If we don’t do it because we have to touch the child with oil and pour water, I would think theologians could figure a way around that since we can even use proxies for godparents.
Alan
Dear Br. Rich,Personal opinion here:
I believe that there is a big difference between a child who dies without Baptism when there was no possibility of receiving Baptism, such as a miscarriage. And the child who dies without Baptism because of human failure to approach the Sacrament on the part of the parent, priest or other person who should have Baptized the child.
Then, why are you here? If you believe in the word Trinity–it is not found in the Bible. Even the word “bible” is not found in the Bible. The Bible doesn’t even lists the sacred books that should be in the Bible. So, what do you want to believe?Where in the word of God is baptism of an infant mentioned ? its like babies that are aborted they still go to heaven they werent baptized. *also i dont want to hear about the catholic bible.
*
Thanks![]()
Acts 16:15Where in the word of God is baptism of an infant mentioned ? its like babies that are aborted they still go to heaven they werent baptized. also i dont want to hear about the catholic bible.
Thanks![]()
You acted correctly any time anyone especially a child is in danger of death or serious illness and is not Baptized. Anyone who knows how should Baptize the child and notify the local parish that this has taken place. Your child was not Baptized by the priest but by you. The priest only supplied the additional Rites of Baptism.Very soon after her birth my daughter was ill in hospital and she was so sick I baptised her prior to her baptism ( a nun years ago told us if ever a child was seriously ill to do this if they had not been already baptised and I remembered it sitting in the hospital) Obviously when she was better I had her baptised by a Priest.
Maybe ‘baptism of desire’ is the wrong term to use in cases of unborn chidlren who die without baptism, maybe there should be another term for it, or maybe there is a doctrine already established by the Majesterium.
I would appreciate anything you can tell me about this in relation to a child that is not born but the parent would also have had that child baptised had they lived.
Yes this is found in many places in the Old Testament. It has also been used to explain Original sin.Dear Br. Rich,
I respect this is your personal opinion, but you touched on another of many things that I’ve wondered about for a long time. I’ve always heard (dunno exactly where it comes from) that “a child suffers for the sins of its parents.” I seem to remember that in the OT there were some places where misdeeds were punished for many generations, but I’ve hardly read or studied OT.
My question is, based on either Church teachings or your personal opinion, what is the deal with God allowing the fate of an innocent child being left completely in the hands of its parents? My wife told me of a friend whose “Catholic” children would not baptize their children, so she did it herself when they weren’t around. Does this really make the difference between whether a baby goes to heaven or hell? If so, an atheistic view that they simply quit existing seems more comforting than to think an innocent child is going to endure eternal suffering (presumably as some sort of cruel punishment) for something totally beyond its grasp, much less control. Perhaps this is just my wordly mind and not my spiritual mind, but this has been quite a stumbling block for me.
I can’t stand to see people get punished on this earth unless two criteria are met, 1) they knew what they were doing (or not doing) was wrong when they did it (or should have done it), and 2) based on their situation they knew how they could have avoided it, or as a very minimum are instructed along with the punishment how they might avoid it in the future. Without meeting those criteria, I call any punitive action “abuse” rather than “punishment.” Those are “Alan’s rules” for just punishment, not God’s. If God’s are less forgiving than mine, then what am I to believe about love and forgiveness?
Sorry for laying this all on you; you just triggered up some old memories involving some of the nuns who ran my grade school.
Alan
Dear Br Rich SFOAs to your last paragraph. We can only hope and trust in Gods mercy. Maybe instead of trying to make “Baptism of Desire” apply to infants we need a new term like “A Hope of Baptismal Grace”. The Catechism speaks of the funreal Rites of the Church for children and infants. Many do not realize that there are TWO different funeral rites for children and infants. One for Baptized children and one for unbaptized children and they have different wording in the prayers.
Dear Br. Rich,The Church condemns the idea that a child or infant suffers in Hell for only Original Sin. Innocent children who die with only Original Sin on their soul are not condemned to suffering in Hell. That is a teaching of the Church according to a Universal Council.