Understanding Mormonism

  • Thread starter Thread starter David
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Saw that episode. Very detailed explanation on the differences between Mormonism and the Reorganized LDS.

Interesting as well, Holders’ description of why the Church baptizes Mormons.
 
Saw that episode. Very detailed explanation on the differences between Mormonism and the Reorganized LDS.

Interesting as well, Holders’ description of why the Church baptizes Mormons.
I found it interesting the his father wanted to convert to Catholicism, but was afraid of what it might do to his son. Mormons must be under a lot of peer pressure or control, to have the father feel that way.
Peace
David
 
I found it interesting the his father wanted to convert to Catholicism, but was afraid of what it might do to his son. Mormons must be under a lot of peer pressure or control, to have the father feel that way.
Peace
David
Well, Mormons have been taught for generations that the Catholic church is the Great and Abominable Whore. Not “officially” for a while but there’s still that underlying feeling. I was baptized in 1994 when I was 21 and my first real friend in the church was the first one to tell me about that.
 
I just have one comment. The thread title is an oxymoron (aka: a contradiction in terms). Even Mormons can’t do it. 🤷
 
I just have one comment. The thread title is an oxymoron (aka: a contradiction in terms). Even Mormons can’t do it. 🤷
Indeed, as well might we undestand the mind of God, as all the truth “mormonisim” contains! 🙂
 
So, Jandrich, does that mean there really are men on the moon dressed like Quakers?

Armstrong never mentioned it when he returned from the moon in 1969…
 
Part of the difficulty I have in understanding Mormonism is that it is malleable and changes over time. In fact, continuing revelation is built in to their system.
 
Part of the difficulty I have in understanding Mormonism is that it is malleable and changes over time. In fact, continuing revelation is built in to their system.
It’s built into Catholicism as well.
 
Part of the difficulty I have in understanding Mormonism is that it is malleable and changes over time. In fact, continuing revelation is built in to their system.
You should read some Catholic literature on “Doctrinal Development” (e.g., Cardinal Newman). The main difference is that LDS frankly admit that revelation is received by humans, who can misunderstand things, so we very well might learn something that requires us to reconsider our interpretations. On the other hand, Catholics (at least those with enough historical knowledge to understand why they can’t really claim Catholic beliefs have always been the same in every respect) want to claim that the doctrine really has always been there, it’s just that nobody recognized it. I personally don’t see that much difference in the two positions.

In any case, I find it amusing that people who believe in a God who is Three distinct Persons in a single Being that is completely “simple” (i.e., homogeneous) in Substance would complain about how incomprehensible Mormonism is. I think maybe you haven’t tried very hard to understand us.
 
You should read some Catholic literature on “Doctrinal Development” (e.g., Cardinal Newman). The main difference is that LDS frankly admit that revelation is received by humans, who can misunderstand things, so we very well might learn something that requires us to reconsider our interpretations. On the other hand, Catholics (at least those with enough historical knowledge to understand why they can’t really claim Catholic beliefs have always been the same in every respect) want to claim that the doctrine really has always been there, it’s just that nobody recognized it. I personally don’t see that much difference in the two positions.

In any case, I find it amusing that people who believe in a God who is Three distinct Persons in a single Being that is completely “simple” (i.e., homogeneous) in Substance would complain about how incomprehensible Mormonism is. I think maybe you haven’t tried very hard to understand us.
Wrong. I WAS you. I just had to finally come to grips with the fact that the LDS doctrine has changed more in 180 years than the Catholic Church has in 2000 years. I had to come to grips with the fact that Joseph, a convicted con man, had 9 different versions of his first vision. That, in itself, should raise flags. As an attorney, when a witness has two different versions of a story, I can destroy him on the stand. I would have loved to cross examine a guy with 9 different versions of a story. There is little wonder why Joseph ran from every possibility of a trial.
 
List a few truths of Mormonism so that I can marvel with you…👍
Alas, if only all people would marvel with us. None the less, here are some of the simple, but profound, truths.
  • We are spirit sons and daughters of our Heavenly Father. Before this earth life we, as spirits, learned and progressed.
  • In order to progress further we came to earth to gain a body.
  • While here, through the gospel plan, we work to gain exaltation. This will allow us to continue our family relationships throughout eternity.
  • Following mortal life, all sons and daughters of God will be resurrected, the spirit reuniting with the body.
  • Each person will go to a kingdom of glory more beautiful then they can possibly imagine. With few exceptions even the very wicked will go to a lesser, but still marvelous, kingdom of glory.
 
Alas, if only all people would marvel with us. None the less, here are some of the simple, but profound, truths.
  • We are spirit sons and daughters of our Heavenly Father. Before this earth life we, as spirits, learned and progressed.
  • In order to progress further we came to earth to gain a body.
  • While here, through the gospel plan, we work to gain exaltation. This will allow us to continue our family relationships throughout eternity.
  • Following mortal life, all sons and daughters of God will be resurrected, the spirit reuniting with the body.
  • Each person will go to a kingdom of glory more beautiful then they can possibly imagine. With few exceptions even the very wicked will go to a lesser, but still marvelous, kingdom of glory.
they are certainly profound something…but not truths
 
Alas, if only all people would marvel with us. None the less, here are some of the simple, but profound, truths.
  • We are spirit sons and daughters of our Heavenly Father. Before this earth life we, as spirits, learned and progressed.
  • In order to progress further we came to earth to gain a body.
  • While here, through the gospel plan, we work to gain exaltation. This will allow us to continue our family relationships throughout eternity.
Tell me, Janderich, if I and all of my family members were to end up in the Telestial kingdom, would we cease to recognize one another? Would we cease to love one another? Would our family relationships not continue? If I met my mother on the street, would I not embrace her?

Paul (formerly LDS, now happily Catholic)
 
they are certainly profound something…but not truths
I agree with you TexanKnight,

The trouble I have is Mormons use traditional Christian terminology, to mean something entirely different than we do. They redefine words like heaven, Jesus, and God just to name a few. It is just about impossible to even have a rational discussion.

Heb 13:8: "Jesus Christ, the same yesterday, and today, and forever.

Peace
David
 
Tell me, Janderich, if I and all of my family members were to end up in the Telestial kingdom, would we cease to recognize one another? Would we cease to love one another? Would our family relationships not continue? If I met my mother on the street, would I not embrace her?
Paul, I don’t think that we have any official doctrine about what, exactly, such relationships will be like. But since the “eternal family” thing for us is about being bound together by covenant, I think it’s fair to say that such relationships won’t be the same as if everyone had kept their covenants. In other words, we’re talking about something more than “recognizing,” “embracing,” or “loving” one another, so your question is a red herring.
 
Wrong. I WAS you. I just had to finally come to grips with the fact that the LDS doctrine has changed more in 180 years than the Catholic Church has in 2000 years. I had to come to grips with the fact that Joseph, a convicted con man, had 9 different versions of his first vision. That, in itself, should raise flags. As an attorney, when a witness has two different versions of a story, I can destroy him on the stand. I would have loved to cross examine a guy with 9 different versions of a story. There is little wonder why Joseph ran from every possibility of a trial.
I’ve seen people do a fairly good job of showing contradictions between the Gospels, too. If I thought that the aim of lawyers in general was to discern truth, maybe I would be impressed with your pronouncement.
 
Paul, I don’t think that we have any official doctrine about what, exactly, such relationships will be like. But since the “eternal family” thing for us is about being bound together by covenant, I think it’s fair to say that such relationships won’t be the same as if everyone had kept their covenants. In other words, we’re talking about something more than “recognizing,” “embracing,” or “loving” one another, so your question is a red herring.
You mean that your celestial family relations will include sex and procreation, while ours will not. That’s what Mormonism boils down to in the end - eternal sex.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top