Undocumented immigrant acquitted in Kate Steinle death

  • Thread starter Thread starter ucfengr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It appears that the actual story in the case did not conform to Trump’s bad hombre narrative. Surprised?
I can totally see a completely innocent and accidental shooting by an illegal immigrant felon, illegally carrying a firearm, that retails for about $600 (Sig Sauer is fairly high end). Happens everyday. And Kate Steinle? She’s just collateral damage in the left’s war on Trump…
 
Last edited:
Did you read your own link? Your story is not compatible with the one presented in court.
Did you?
But Garcia Zarate’s defense attorney said the shooting was accidental and the bullet ricocheted off the ground and traveled about 80 feet before hitting Steinle.
Jurors convicted the Mexican citizen of being a felon in possession of a firearm, which could bring a three-year sentence.
 
Last edited:
I don’t understand why the verdict wasn’t manslaughter. Seems appropriate if you fire off a gun in a public space, you are responsible for where it ends up.
 
She’s just collateral damage of America’s gun death cult.
 
An american citizen is killed by an ILLEGAL immigrant who had been previously deported several times. This is NOT “gun death cult”! This is the result of a broken immigration system. Deportation means should NOT be allowed back in!

Now an innocent woman is DEAD!
 
So-- I didn’t catch.
Jose Ines Garcia Zarate, 45, was acquitted of murder and involuntary manslaughter charges, as well as assault with a deadly weapon.
I can see being acquitted of murder, because murder would require them proving intent.

Were they trying a murder charge and an involuntary manslaughter charge simultaneously/in the same case? Wouldn’t it have been more prudent to just try the lower charge, so that the threshold of proof was more attainable?
 
Were they trying a murder charge and an involuntary manslaughter charge simultaneously/in the same case? Wouldn’t it have been more prudent to just try the lower charge, so that the threshold of proof was more attainable?
I understood the jury was given the option of convicting for manslaughter,
so I can’t understand why he was acquitted, since he confessed.
 
The Red State article goes into this a little bit. Basically prosecutors pushed hard for first degree murder which is hard to prove, and prosecutors don’t like to say “Even if it was an accident it was still manslaughter” because that encourages juries to go for the lower charge. And then when you spend no time or effort saying it could be manslaughter too because you want the murder charge the jury doesn’t have any arguments or reasons to convict for manslaughter, leaving them with just the conviction for the gun possession.

Basically it’s a matter of jury instruction.
 
Last edited:
Yeah. I’ve seen it around here-- you have something high-profile; you go for the flashy charge that’s hard to prove; you end up failing to prove it; and then everyone gets mad at you because the guy walks off free. Whereas if you just kept your head down, and ignored the media’s lights and attention and the noise, and just treated it like an ordinary case— you’d be less likely to make that kind of fumble.
 
Jury in a sanctuary city in a sanctuary state fails to convict a 5 time deported, convicted felon of negligent homicide in the death of a young women. Gee, what a surprise.
 
I am not assuming anything about anyone who has posted, but I am wondering if the first outrage expressed over this news story is about the victim or the accused? Are we outraged over the senseless death or the acquittal of an illegal immigrant with a long rap sheet?

Had the accused been a “dreamer” with a clean record, would the outrage be the same ?
 
I could understand the acquittal on the murder charge as that requires intent. But it is dang hard to understand why they didn’t even get an involuntary manslaughter conviction. He confessed to firing the gun, someone died from the bullet, okay he didn’t mean to kill anyone I get that, but firing a gun in a public place and someone ends up dead gets nothing but illegal possession of said gun? And what’s going to keep this guy from coming back here once he’s deported following the sentence for possession?

Either the prosecution fell down on this or there were stick in the mud, stubbornly in favor of sanctuary city types on the jury. Or both.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top