Unions Sue Over Right to Work

  • Thread starter Thread starter Trader
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Trader

Guest
indianabarrister.com/archives/2012/02/unions_sue_over_right_to_work.html

It is no surprise that unions do not like Indiana’s new right to work law. I makes us unique in the rust belt. What really surprises me is the story in our local paper that not being able to take dues from non-members is a free speech issue: If the unions can’t force non-members to pay them, they may be unable to speak against the wishes of the people who don’t want to pay dues.:confused:

Indiana’s new right-to-work law should be struck down because it infringes upon unions’ free-speech rights by depriving them of the dues that fund their political speech, attorneys for a union challenging the law contend, citing the U.S. Supreme Court’s so-called Citizens United ruling that eased restrictions on corporate campaign spending.
From the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, 4-10-2012. Sorry, but to get the whole article, I would have to pay a fee.😦

I am, by the grace of God, not a lawyer, but this reasoning seems really strange for someone who passed a logic course.
 
indianabarrister.com/archives/2012/02/unions_sue_over_right_to_work.html

It is no surprise that unions do not like Indiana’s new right to work law. I makes us unique in the rust belt. What really surprises me is the story in our local paper that not being able to take dues from non-members is a free speech issue: If the unions can’t force non-members to pay them, they may be unable to speak against the wishes of the people who don’t want to pay dues.:confused:

Indiana’s new right-to-work law should be struck down because it infringes upon unions’ free-speech rights by depriving them of the dues that fund their political speech, attorneys for a union challenging the law contend, citing the U.S. Supreme Court’s so-called Citizens United ruling that eased restrictions on corporate campaign spending.
From the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, 4-10-2012. Sorry, but to get the whole article, I would have to pay a fee.😦

I am, by the grace of God, not a lawyer, but this reasoning seems really strange for someone who passed a logic course.
It is interesting that many of the jobs being created now days are going to states that have “right to work” laws. Seems to me that unions have outlived their usefulness.🤷
 
Unions take a portion of what little money people do have, so people aren’t happy about them. Plus, nowadays there are lawyers so you can sue if you are being mistreated at work. And there are minimum wage laws.
 
I receive a good wage as a result of being a member of a union. Because I make approximately 2 times as much compensation as non-union workers in the same occupation, my wife is able to be at home with the kids. We also have good health care insurance and a decent pension because of my union. A living wage supports stable families, and this is one of the prime reasons for establishing unions. Along with the protection of human dignity of the worker.
Experience confirms that there must be a social re-evaluation of the mother’s role, of the toil connected with it, and of the need that children have for care, love and affection in order that they may develop into responsible, morally and religiously mature and psychologically stable persons. It will redound to the credit of society to make it possible for a mother-without inhibiting her freedom, without psychological or practical discrimination, and without penalizing her as compared with other women-to devote herself to taking care of her children and educating them in accordance with their needs, which vary with age. Having to abandon these tasks in order to take up paid work outside the home is wrong from the point of view of the good of society and of the family when it contradicts or hinders these primary goals of the mission of a mother26. vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091981_laborem-exercens_en.html
Before all the union bashers jump in, here is a short list of Catholic Social Teaching on Labor, Unions, and Workers Rights.
icpj.net/resources/Catholic-Teaching-on-Labor.pdf
**Of particular interest is Laborem Exercens (On Human Work), from Pope John Paul II. Especially:
Section 20. Importance of Unions **
All these rights, together with the need for the workers themselves to secure them, give rise to yet another right: the right of association, that is to form associations for the purpose of defending the vital interests of those employed in the various professions. These associations are called labour or trade unions. The vital interests of the workers are to a certain extent common for all of them; at the same time however each type of work, each profession, has its own specific character which should find a particular reflection in these organizations.
 
I receive a good wage as a result of being a member of a union. Because I make approximately 2 times as much compensation as non-union workers in the same occupation, my wife is able to be at home with the kids. We also have good health care insurance and a decent pension because of my union. A living wage supports stable families, and this is one of the prime reasons for establishing unions. Along with the protection of human dignity of the worker.
Like you, I work union; as a matter of fact, the only jobs I have ever worked in were union represented. I’d have it no other way. Because of my union, I make far superior wages compared to my non-union counterparts, who while saving money in dues, make a third less then what I make and have absolutely no job security nor protection. My union dues are 1.333% of my gross wages, a small pittance for what I receive in return from being union.

But that’s their decision and if they are happy working under those conditions, then i say God Bless them. Me, I’ll stick with working union and have the knowledge that my working conditions, benefits and pay are tops in the industry.

Btw, like you, because of my union-based wages, my wife was able to stay at home and raise our two children to adulthood. 🙂
 
I receive a good wage as a result of being a member of a union. Because I make approximately 2 times as much compensation as non-union workers in the same occupation, my wife is able to be at home with the kids. We also have good health care insurance and a decent pension because of my union. A living wage supports stable families, and this is one of the prime reasons for establishing unions. Along with the protection of human dignity of the worker.

Before all the union bashers jump in, here is a short list of Catholic Social Teaching on Labor, Unions, and Workers Rights.
icpj.net/resources/Catholic-Teaching-on-Labor.pdf
**Of particular interest is Laborem Exercens (On Human Work), from Pope John Paul II. Especially:
Section 20. Importance of Unions **
Trouble is that most people in the Social Justice movement stop where you did with Laborem Exercens. You should keep reading:

…the role of unions is not to “play politics” in the sense that the expression is commonly understood today. Unions do not have the character of political parties struggling for power; they should not be subjected to the decision of political parties or have too close links with them…

And perhaps you should go back a few years:
  1. Now, concerning workingmen’s associations, even though their purpose is to obtain earthly advantages for their members, nonetheless those associations are to be most approved and considered as most useful for the genuine and permanent advantage of their members which are established chiefly on the foundation of the Catholic religion and openly follow the directives of the Church. We have repeated this declaration on several previous occasions in answer to question from various countries. Consequently, such so-called confessional Catholic associations must certainly be established and promoted in every way in Catholic regions as well as in all other districts where it can be presumed that they can sufficiently assist the various needs of their members. However, when there is a question about associations which directly or indirectly touch upon the sphere of religion and morality, it would not be permitted to foster and spread mixed organizations, that is, associations composed of Catholics and non-Catholics, in the areas just mentioned. Over and above other matters, in such organizations there are or certainly can be for our people serious dangers to the integrity of their faith and the due obedience to the commandments and precepts of the Catholic Church.
…
  1. Furthermore, if Catholics are to be permitted to join the trade unions, these associations must avoid everything that is not in accord, either in principle or practice, with the teachings and commandments of the Church or the proper ecclesiastical authorities. Similarly, everything is to be avoided in their literature or public utterances or actions which in the above view would incur censure.
The Bishops, therefore, should consider it their sacred duty to observe carefully the conduct of all these associations and to watch diligently that the Catholic members do not suffer any harm as a result of their participation.** The Catholic members themselves, however, should never permit the unions, whether for the sake of material interests of their members or the union cause as such, to proclaim or support teachings or to engage in activities which would conflict in any way with the directives proclaimed by the supreme teaching authority of the Church, especially those mentioned above.**

Pius X, Singulari Quadam (1912)​

So the questions for you (and any other union member who cares to speak up) are:
  1. How many members of a party other than the Democratic Party have your unions endorsed over the years? (I am sure there is a token, but think about the ratio) How much money has your union contributed to people other than the Democratic party (vs how much to the Democratic Party)? (cf Laborem Exercens quote above)
  2. How many social issues does your union support that are not in line with the Teachings of the Church? Does your union support abortion rights? Does your union support homosexual unions? And so on and so forth… (cf the Singulari Quadam quote above)
(And for reference, my wife, when she was working, was a member of the local unit of the NEA. until she became aware of how deeply entrenched they were with forces that were utterly opposed to any sort of morality)
 
…1) How many members of a party other than the Democratic Party have your unions endorsed over the years? (I am sure there is a token, but think about the ratio) How much money has your union contributed to people other than the Democratic party (vs how much to the Democratic Party)? (cf Laborem Exercens quote above)
  1. How many social issues does your union support that are not in line with the Teachings of the Church? Does your union support abortion rights? Does your union support homosexual unions? And so on and so forth… (cf the Singulari Quadam quote above)
(And for reference, my wife, when she was working, was a member of the local unit of the NEA. until she became aware of how deeply entrenched they were with forces that were utterly opposed to any sort of morality)
Here is an answer to your first question: Top All-Time Donors, 1989-2012
with a break down by party.

The first union you see is #3 on the list, the American Fedn of State, County & Municipal Employees (public service union), $47,350,548 in political contributions since 1989, 92% to Democrats, 1% to Republicans (not sure where the other 7% is going).

opensecrets.org/orgs/list.php

Most don’t realize it, but the unions were very happy with the Citizens United ruling.

I don’t have a problem with unions, but people should be free to work union or non as they see fit.
 
I live in a right-to-work state and I am thrilled at having the opportunity to tell unions where they can shove it.
 
Before all the union bashers jump in, here is a short list of Catholic Social Teaching on Labor, Unions, and Workers Rights.
icpj.net/resources/Catholic-Teaching-on-Labor.pdf
Of particular interest is Laborem Exercens (On Human Work), from Pope John Paul II. Especially:
**Section 20. Importance of Unions **
Perhaps you can point out in that document where the Pope says that people must be forced to join a union. I didn’t see it and, since this thread is about right to work, it is the most relevant of points.

The attorneys are arguing that their free speech is threatened because people are not being forced to join the union. It seems to me that a large number of workers are choosing to not be part of the union when given the choice. Why is that?

Peace

Tim
 
I live in a right-to-work state and I am thrilled at having the opportunity to tell unions where they can shove it.
Same here. Myself nor anyone in my family has ever been a part of a union. I don’t get the money grabbing associations. Don’t like the benefits and wages of the job you have? Go get a diffeent one.
 
Greed defies logic. I work with attorneys on a daily basis. Litigators are very low in logic and ethics.
Sorry that they are so in your state. I’ve not found this to be true - with a few exceptions - among my fellow attorneys here in Arkansas, though.
 
Like you, I work union; as a matter of fact, the only jobs I have ever worked in were union represented. I’d have it no other way. Because of my union, I make far superior wages compared to my non-union counterparts, who while saving money in dues, make a third less then what I make and have absolutely no job security nor protection. My union dues are 1.333% of my gross wages, a small pittance for what I receive in return from being union.

But that’s their decision and if they are happy working under those conditions, then i say God Bless them. Me, I’ll stick with working union and have the knowledge that my working conditions, benefits and pay are tops in the industry.

Btw, like you, because of my union-based wages, my wife was able to stay at home and raise our two children to adulthood. 🙂
My wife, a member of the United Federation of Teachers, was pleased with the support it gave its members in disputes with the School administration. As for wages, my BIL, with a job as a mailer for the New York Post earned a six figure income.

I don’t doubt that some people have had bad experiences with their unions, but at least anecdotally, my family is pleased with our experience with them. I’m also a member of the Musicians Union.
 
My wife, a member of the United Federation of Teachers, was pleased with the support it gave its members in disputes with the School administration. As for wages, my BIL, with a job as a mailer for the New York Post earned a six figure income.

I don’t doubt that some people have had bad experiences with their unions, but at least anecdotally, my family is pleased with our experience with them. I’m also a member of the Musicians Union.
I don’t mean to bash unions. If you are fortunate enough to be represented by a union in your work-place, The Lord Bless You. I have never been part of a union anywhere I have ever worked. Just what I see of some unions supporting the “Party of Death” it kind of turns me off. If you are a member of a union are you free to vote for whomever you please or do you have to vote for whomever the union supports?:confused:
 
If you are a member of a union are you free to vote for whomever you please or do you have to vote for whomever the union supports?:confused:
The union makes suggestions, primarily in favor of Democratic politicians, and campaigns strongly for them, but your vote is always your own. No one followed my wife or BIL into the voting booth.
 
The union makes suggestions, primarily in favor of Democratic politicians, and campaigns strongly for them, but your vote is always your own. No one followed my wife or BIL into the voting booth.
A good frind of mine is a retired teacher and a Republican. The stories he would share of being pressured to vote Democrat by union leaders and the shunning he experienced when his peers found out he wasn’t marching hand in hand with the Democratic party was unbelievable.
 
A good frind of mine is a retired teacher and a Republican. The stories he would share of being pressured to vote Democrat by union leaders and the shunning he experienced when his peers found out he wasn’t marching hand in hand with the Democratic party was unbelievable.
Try being a teacher that is a member of AAE instead of the NEA.
 
A good frind of mine is a retired teacher and a Republican. The stories he would share of being pressured to vote Democrat by union leaders and the shunning he experienced when his peers found out he wasn’t marching hand in hand with the Democratic party was unbelievable.
How did they pressure them?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top