C
chrisb
Guest
![40.png](https://forums.catholic-questions.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/a/7bcc69/40.png)
The Buddha’s teachings aren’t beyond the reach of English, but it’ll take some time, in my opinion, to develop a language that incorporates the nuances of the Buddha’s teachings.
If by “self-hood” you mean the process of clinging-to-aggregates, then yes, dukkha is not only related to self-hood, dukkha is self-hood.
My point is that one can still live as a body-mind, a human being, a person, a “self” (defined as a body-mind, not defined as clinging-to-aggregates), while living free of dukkha. The use of the term “self-hood” implies that nibbana necessarily involves a loss of “self”, a word in English that carries so many conno- and denotations, including “a sense of wholness”, “a sense of dignity,” etc, which is definitely not the case.
![40.png](https://forums.catholic-questions.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/a/7bcc69/40.png)
If by “self-hood” you mean the process of clinging-to-aggregates, then yes, dukkha is not only related to self-hood, dukkha is self-hood.The Buddha’s teachings aren’t beyond the reach of English, but it’ll take some time, in my opinion, to develop a language that incorporates the nuances of the Buddha’s teachings.
In nomine Jesu I offer you peace,
Yes, this is how I understand it.
These are all dualistic notions that the Buddha would dismiss are illusions of the five-aggregates. Once “all” notions of the self are transcended will one reach enlightenment and then only partially until one passes from this life. I can supply quotes from Buddha to explain this if you’d like.My point is that one can still live as a body-mind, a human being, a person, a “self” (defined as a body-mind, not defined as clinging-to-aggregates), while living free of dukkha. The use of the term “self-hood” implies that nibbana necessarily involves a loss of “self”, a word in English that carries so many conno- and denotations, including “a sense of wholness”, “a sense of dignity,” etc, which is definitely not the case.
Peace, Love and Blessings,