US bishops’ lawyers accuse Obama Administration of ‘an unprecedented attack on religious liberty’

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

_Abyssinia

Guest
The general counsel of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) has called on the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to rescind its mandate forcing private insurance plans to cover contraception—including abortifacients—and sterilization, calling the mandate “unprecedented in federal law and more radical than any state contraceptive mandate.”

The USCCB also criticized the narrow “religious employer” exception to the mandate, explaining that it provides “no protection at all for individuals or insurers with a moral or religious objection to contraceptives or sterilization,” instead covering only “a very small subset of religious employers.”

In their August 31 comment to the HHS, Anthony Picarello, USCCB general counsel, and Michael Moses, associate general counsel, noted that the mandate to cover “all FDA-approved contraceptives” and “emergency contraceptives,” including at least one drug called Ella that can cause abortions, entails “nationwide government coercion of religious people and groups to sell, broker or purchases ‘services’ to which they have a moral or religious objection.” This represents “an unprecedented attack on religious liberty,” they wrote.

As to the exemption, Picarello and Moses detail how it “is narrower than any conscience clause ever enacted in federal law, and narrower than the vast majority of religious exemptions from state contraceptive mandates.”

“By failing to protect insurers, individuals, most employers, or any other stakeholders with a religious objection to such items and procedures, the HHS exemption, like the mandate itself, violates” the U.S. Constitution and various federal statutes, they argue.

lifesitenews.com/news/us-bishops-conference-accuses-obama-administration-of-an-unprecedented-atta
 
Teach the people the laws of God and we don’t have to go through such horror.
 
Here’s the memo that the USCCB General Counsel sent to the HHS.

HHS will probably give it the same consideration that it gives to the bishop’s opinions on most matters involving pro-life issues, i.e. little to none.
 
Apparently the bishops are suffering from buyers’ remorse.

Ender
 
It’s not apparent at all. What do you mean?
Did you not read the long list of complaints the bishops’ lawyers raised against Obamacare? It seems to me they are now discovering how bad the bill is that they supported in principle even while they opposed (just) one small section. It may be clear only now (to them) just how misguided their actions in this issue were.

Ender
 
Well, the contraceptives the Bishops are opposing are legal, so are vasectomies and tubectomies.

That being the case, the Bishops are barking up the wrong tree.

Just because Insurance companies will be mandated to cover these things, doesn’t mean people have to use them.

So, the Bishops should be speaking out to the public on WHY it is wrong to use these things.

If they can’t convince the public, than mandating the government to do anything contrary is useless for the government is following the will of the people in this case.

Jim

Jim
 
Catholics must stop voting for -
immoral Politicans who support and/or vote in favor of abortion, gay marriage, euthanasia, contraception including everyone financing them, etc.
These evil politicans appoint evil judges and evil department administrators.

Bishops must strongly promote the reading of the “Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition” for all Catholics over age 15.
This will promote a well formed conscience in all matters.

We all have an obligation to promote reading of the CCC.

When governments or insurance companies are forced to pay for contraceptives, that means through our taxes or insurance premiums we are all forced to pay for them, not just the users.
Immoral sexual activity (whether legal or not) should be at the complete expense of the individual.

The USCCB is correct that forcing everyone to pay for immoral activity is WRONG.
 
Did you not read the long list of complaints the bishops’ lawyers raised against Obamacare? It seems to me they are now discovering how bad the bill is that they supported in principle even while they opposed (just) one small section. It may be clear only now (to them) just how misguided their actions in this issue were.

Ender
And they’re going to discover in the future a lot more, and not just in Obamacare.
 
Just because Insurance companies will be mandated to cover these things, doesn’t mean people have to use them.
With the “individual mandate” provision of the health care law, requiring everyone to purchase insurance, while it’s true people don’t have to use them, they still have to pay for OTHERS to use them.
 
With the “individual mandate” provision of the health care law, requiring everyone to purchase insurance, while it’s true people don’t have to use them, they still have to pay for OTHERS to use them.
We do that now, including the Bishops who have private health insurance and who provide health insurance to diocesan employees.

Jim
 
We do that now, including the Bishops who have private health insurance and who provide health insurance to diocesan employees.

Jim
Not exactly. My insurance through my archdiocese has a very specific rider attached that prohibits coverage for birth control. I can not use my prescription benefits to pay for birth control in any form.

Kris
 
Not exactly. My insurance through my archdiocese has a very specific rider attached that prohibits coverage for birth control. I can not use my prescription benefits to pay for birth control in any form.

Kris
It may prohibit coverage of birth control for people working for the archdioceses, but not for people insured outside of diocesan employment.

Here in MA, the three big insurance companies which the dioceses use, pay for birth control for those not working for the dioceses.

Jim
 
I just want to say that this is a result of all the disobedience to Church’s teaching for so many years by the Clergy. Is anyone surprised that this is happening?. I am concerned about me following the Teachings of the Church than fighting government actions.

We are at fault. the best thing to do is for the Clergy Catholics to repent and turn to God once again. As God says, without me you can do nothing. they can fight all day long, nothing is going to change as long as they remain stubborn on their own efforts.
 
Catholics must stop voting for -
immoral Politicans who support and/or vote in favor of abortion, gay marriage, euthanasia, contraception including everyone financing them, etc.
These evil politicans appoint evil judges and evil department administrators.

Bishops must strongly promote the reading of the “Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition” for all Catholics over age 15.
This will promote a well formed conscience in all matters.

We all have an obligation to promote reading of the CCC.

When governments or insurance companies are forced to pay for contraceptives, that means through our taxes or insurance premiums we are all forced to pay for them, not just the users.
Immoral sexual activity (whether legal or not) should be at the complete expense of the individual.

The USCCB is correct that forcing everyone to pay for immoral activity is WRONG.
Now THIS makes sense to me ! What a novel idea … we could all start LIVING our Catholic faith !

👍
 
It may prohibit coverage of birth control for people working for the archdioceses, but not for people insured outside of diocesan employment.

Here in MA, the three big insurance companies which the dioceses use, pay for birth control for those not working for the dioceses.

Jim
But this new twist on Obamacare is going to make it illegal for the archdiocese to exclude payment for a procedure it defines as immoral. That’s what the griping is about.

Kris
 
Teach the people the laws of God and we don’t have to go through such horror.
Amen,

And while were at it teach them the wording for the Declaration of Independence is based on the teachings of a Doctor of the Church, copied by the US forefathers, then enforce the US Constitution and “maybe” we can walk with the youth, and teach LIFE.

The preconceived notion of instant gratification is the lie bought into daily by the unthinking mass.

Had anything been more important than the SOUL, I’m positive Christ wouldn’t have died on a Cross.

What did JP-II say? We have become a society of Death? Because life is perceived as an inconvenience. Unreal.

Peace
 
But this new twist on Obamacare is going to make it illegal for the archdiocese to exclude payment for a procedure it defines as immoral. That’s what the griping is about.

Kris
No the griping is about those working in the heath care field who own their own practice/business, by law have to either go against their religion, find a new career, or cooperate with Evil. And that my friend is in direct conflict with the principles the US is built on. And that is exactly the grip.

Enough is enough of the nonsense.

Peace
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top