UT Panel: Relocate Confederate Statues or Add Plaques

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
The Texas Tribune:
UT Panel: Relocate Confederate Statues or Add Plaques
A task force on Monday recommended the University of Texas at Austin either relocate statues of Confederate leaders or add explanatory plaques. The 12-person advisory panel of students, alumni and administrators issued recommendations to UT-Austin President Gregory Fenves, who commissioned the report in June, on the same day three statutes were vandalized.
The report suggested five options, four of which involve moving one or more statues from the South Mall to a history center on campus. A fifth option suggested leaving the statues in place and adding plaques to explain historical context. The panel considered the placement of six statues on UT’s campus, four depicting Confederate leaders including President Jefferson Davis, one of U.S. President Woodrow Wilson and one of former Texas Gov. James Hogg.**
**
**
**
Fenves will review the report before making a final decision, according to the university.
“Statues have layers of meaning: aesthetic, historical, aspirational, and educational. History is not innocent; it is the living foundation for the present,” the report said. “The university’s approach to changing and replacing monuments on campus should be conservative but not uncritical.”
I’d go for leaving the statues in place but with explanatory plaques.
 
I worry about the ability of UT students to function in the “real world” if a statue is too offensive for them. I said as much this morning in the newspaper, and a faculty member responded that this was a legitimate worry. The students seem to find “being offended” a more worthy goal than learning about and learning from history. It is sad, really.
 
Universities are the last place you’ll get the truth, or at least the whole truth. Academia, particularly the sciences, pride themselves on promoting controversial viewpoints that differ with received tradition. It is funny how on this issue they just go with the common opinion. But, that is why they are institutions of half-truths.
 
I think it would makes sense to move the statue to a historical display in a museum.
 
The decision was made to move at least the Jefferson Davis statue to the museum. I tried to post a link, but for some reason couldn’t. The article was in today’s Austin American Statesman (the city newspaper).
 
… The students seem to find “being offended” a more worthy goal than learning about and learning from history. It is sad, really.
With the introduction of politically correct victimhood as a vocation, whole new horizons were opened up. Ordinary complaining became an academic endeavor. Among the early candidates for the trash bin was truth itself. Millennia of Western thought was dismissed outright as bigotry by white males, particularly dead ones. The new academics gave us relativism à la polylogism. We saw the re-emergence of Nietzscheism whereby truth was inverted, and a sort of nihilism resulted. An example of this is the VA Tech shootings of a few years ago. James Lewis asks, “Was Cho taught to hate?”
… that answer is readily available on the websites of Cho’s English Department at Virginia Tech. This is a wonder world of PC weirdness. English studies at VT are a post-modern Disney World in which nihilism, moral and sexual boundary breaking, and fantasies of Marxist revolutionary violence are celebrated. They show up in a lot of faculty writing.
The real enemy is academia.

"When you increase the sensitivity, you increase the false alarm rate.
 
I worry about the ability of UT students to function in the “real world” if a statue is too offensive for them. I said as much this morning in the newspaper, and a faculty member responded that this was a legitimate worry. The students seem to find “being offended” a more worthy goal than learning about and learning from history. It is sad, really.
Yep…and people wonder why our country and the world is going downhill so fast. People are too busy being offended by miniscule things to lead truly productive lives.
 
A fifth option suggested leaving the statues in place and adding plaques to explain historical context.
I guess historical context was not explained in students’ high school United States History and/or AP United States History (or Texas students’ middle school Texas History) classes? What does *that *say about our education system?
 
A fifth option suggested leaving the statues in place and adding plaques to explain historical context.
A number of years ago there was an article in USA Today reporting that according to the US Dep’t of Education, nationwide about a third of college freshmen (and over 40% of students at public two-year colleges) had taken at least one remedial course.

Kinda makes you wonder if, at this point, anyone would be able to read any of the plaques explaining historical context*** 🤷

 
A number of years ago there was an article in USA Today reporting that according to the US Dep’t of Education, nationwide about a third of college freshmen (and over 40% of students at public two-year colleges) had taken at least one remedial course.
About 10 years ago, some students at the University of Michigan sued over the use of a chart for deciding whom to admit under their diversity program. The chart had two categories for non-minority applicants, “Admit” and “Postpone Decision.” Minority applicants had a third category, “Admit to remedial program.” Now, I ask you, what is a top university doing teaching remedial courses?
 
A number of years ago there was an article in USA Today reporting that according to the US Dep’t of Education, nationwide about a third of college freshmen (and over 40% of students at public two-year colleges) had taken at least one remedial course.

Kinda makes you wonder if, at this point, anyone would be able to read any of the plaques explaining historical context*** 🤷

This is because the public school system no longer teaches how children. They teach them how to pass tests, but they don’t teach.

History isn’t appreciated, and more importantly, is twisted depending on the teacher. I still remember learning in 10th grade from my history teacher that the Protestant Reformation was a great time in history, where heroes like Luther and Calvin saved people from a corrupt Catholic Church, and that the Catholic Church would not be what it is today without the Reformation. :rolleyes:
 
I guess historical context was not explained in students’ high school United States History and/or AP United States History (or Texas students’ middle school Texas History) classes? What does *that *say about our education system?
Adding to the irony is the fact that, in Texas public schools, the entirety of Social Studies in THREE years is dedicated to Texas history. Historical context should be second nature to the students.
 
Now, I ask you, what is a top university doing teaching remedial courses?
Probably has to do with money. More students can attend if they can just come as they are, and retake whatever they don’t know. I do not know for sure, but I would think that hiring professors for remedial courses would be less expensive, and students can be charged at the same price as students taking “normal” classes.
 
About 10 years ago, some students at the University of Michigan sued over the use of a chart for deciding whom to admit under their diversity program. The chart had two categories for non-minority applicants, “Admit” and “Postpone Decision.” Minority applicants had a third category, “Admit to remedial program.”** Now, I ask you, what is a top university doing teaching remedial courses**?
Even back in the 70s, when I was at Michigan, there were two well-regarded “remedial” programs. One was for Native Americans who graduated from reservation high schools and the other for students of color coming from inner city Detroit. These aren’t remedial in the sense of helping students who can’t perform but rather a chance to make up for having been raised in a really bad school system. Often these were kids that scored really high on aptitude tests but had not been given educational opportunities. These programs were “carved out” for minorities.

Michigan is a “top” university, but it is first and foremost a state university. Nothing wrong with a state university making sure that more state residents are given consideration.
 
Probably has to do with money. More students can attend if they can just come as they are, and retake whatever they don’t know. I do not know for sure, but I would think that hiring professors for remedial courses would be less expensive, and students can be charged at the same price as students taking “normal” classes.
But remedial instruction is a main function of community colleges. UM is a public institution as are community colleges; why do taxpayers have to pay for the same thing twice? Look. We both know that the UM lowered standards for minorities to enable more to qualify, as though college education can be had only at a top school. The sad part is those minorities who fail in a top university will be replaced next year by other students of similar racial background to keep the numbers “correct”. BTW, one statistic that higher ed in general keeps secret is the graduation rate of those admitted under affirmative action.

"Diversity is diametrically opposed to quality.” – Dinesh D’Souza
 
Even back in the 70s, when I was at Michigan, there were two well-regarded “remedial” programs. One was for Native Americans who graduated from reservation high schools and the other for students of color coming from inner city Detroit. These aren’t remedial in the sense of helping students who can’t perform but rather a chance to make up for having been raised in a really bad school system. Often these were kids that scored really high on aptitude tests but had not been given educational opportunities. These programs were “carved out” for minorities.

Michigan is a “top” university, but it is first and foremost a state university. Nothing wrong with a state university making sure that more state residents are given consideration.
And what was their graduation rate?
 
Yep…and people wonder why our country and the world is going downhill so fast. People are too busy being offended by miniscule things to lead truly productive lives.
Like the display of a Satanic statue in St. Louis- or that something to REALLY get offended over?
 
Even back in the 70s, when I was at Michigan, there were two well-regarded “remedial” programs. One was for Native Americans who graduated from reservation high schools and the other for students of color coming from inner city Detroit. These aren’t remedial in the sense of helping students who can’t perform but rather a chance to make up for having been raised in a really bad school system. Often these were kids that scored really high on aptitude tests but had not been given educational opportunities. These programs were “carved out” for minorities.

Michigan is a “top” university, but it is first and foremost a state university. Nothing wrong with a state university making sure that more state residents are given consideration.
WOWSERS! I agree with your post!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top