Va. Senate passes school prayer bill

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Supreme Court will probably say it’s unconstitutional.
I doubt the case would even reach the Supreme Court. The lower courts will declare it unconstitutional and the Supreme Court would see no reason to review the matter.

Students already have the right to voluntary prayer and religious activities on school grounds, so long as it doesn’t take away from class time or interfere with instruction.

The Virginia bill would require students to listen to religious speeches. Such speeches to a captive audience constitute involuntary religious participation. Prior court rulings, all the way to the US Supreme Court, forbid that.
 
I went to a public HS in rural VA and we routinely sat through prayers before games at pep-rallies and graduation ceremonies. I was never comfortable with it.
 
Think about it, what if these speeches do not sit with Catholic belief?

I am sure an Atheist would feel uncomfortable receiving a lecture on Christ from one of the Cardinals, but wouldn’t you feel equally at unease being lectured by the president of the Watchtower (Jehovas witnesses) and his beliefs?

I do not think this decision bodes well, I would be wary of what qualifies as “prayer”.
 
I am a Catholic. I worship in a way which I feel most comfortable. I don’t feel comfortable being forced to sit through distinctly low-church protestant prayers and I was attending a public school.
 
I am a Catholic. I worship in a way which I feel most comfortable. I don’t feel comfortable being forced to sit through distinctly low-church protestant prayers and I was attending a public school.
I always think about this when people talk about wanting prayer back in schools.

I have no problem with student lead prayer to a volunteer student group. That way, a group of Catholics could get together and pray a rosary without interference. Or a group of Protestants could get together and pray.

But I would not want teacher or administrator lead prayer.

As a bumper sticker said, "As long as there are math tests in school, there will be prayer in school.
 
If it makes the Governor’s desk it may well die there. If not, as said before, it is DOA in the courts. There is no need for the law as the story describes it because student-initiated religious speech is already protected.

John
 
Think about it, what if these speeches do not sit with Catholic belief?

I am sure an Atheist would feel uncomfortable receiving a lecture on Christ from one of the Cardinals, but wouldn’t you feel equally at unease being lectured by the president of the Watchtower (Jehovas witnesses) and his beliefs?

I do not think this decision bodes well, I would be wary of what qualifies as “prayer”.
I am sympathetic to what you’re saying, Ringil. I have never been one to jump on the “prayer in schools” bandwagon as I see it driven by evangelicals mostly. Furthermore, what is to keep someone from praying in a school? That said, I think there is not enough prayer in Catholic schools! Wasn’t there a Catholic university that removed its crucifixes from the classrooms to not offend Islamic students?

Ishii
 
I am sympathetic to what you’re saying, Ringil. I have never been one to jump on the “prayer in schools” bandwagon as I see it driven by evangelicals mostly. Furthermore, what is to keep someone from praying in a school? That said, I think there is not enough prayer in Catholic schools! Wasn’t there a Catholic university that removed its crucifixes from the classrooms to not offend Islamic students?

Ishii
I agree that too many Catholic schools do not present the faith enough.

Fortunately, my daughters’s school does a good job. Starting in Kindergarten she will go to mass once a week, with the other students.

I kind of wish they would talk more about specifically Catholic stuff in her pre-K programs such as the Pope and Priests and whatnot. They are learning the Hail Mary so this is nice.
 
I agree with most everyone here that forced prayer makes me very uncomfortable. Evangelical Protestantism has a history of using the Catholic Church when it needs it (e.g. for monetary resources to fight ballot measures) and then spitting at the Church when it doesn’t (the rampant anti-Catholicism of the early 1900s where Protestants sought to forcibly remove Catholic schools from the country, the rampant bigotry spewed at JFK, etc.). I have no doubt that, if SS’M’ and abortion were not such pressing issues, Catholics would become one of the first targets of Protestant fire again.

Also, there is the whole issue of having JWs, SDAs, Pentecostals, Mormons, etc. leading a captive audience made up partially of Catholic students in decidedly anti-Catholic doctrinal prayer.
 
I am a Catholic. I worship in a way which I feel most comfortable. I don’t feel comfortable being forced to sit through distinctly low-church protestant prayers and I was attending a public school.
Exactly. I too went to a public HS in Texas. We had prayers at football games, pep rallies and daily over the PA system. Those prayers were always Baptist and Evangelical in character, not once was a Catholic prayer allowed not even a Protestant Our Father.

The night before graduation we were forced to attend a bacculariate service. The preachers at that service were always Protestant. A Baptist would preach a Methodist and church of Christ preacher would give the extempore prayers at the beginning and end. Catholics were left out completely along with Main Line Protestants.

Personally I think that fundamentalists and Catholics make for very odd bedfellows. We have nothing in common other than being anti-abortion and having conservative politics. Our beliefs are extremely different. While so many snub the Protestants we have much in common with theologically.

I think belief trumps politics every time.
 
Personally I think that fundamentalists and Catholics make for very odd bedfellows. We have nothing in common other than being anti-abortion and having conservative politics. Our beliefs are extremely different. While so many snub the Protestants we have much in common with theologically.
.
If it ever comes down to it, they’ll hang us all together anyway.
 
Personally I think that fundamentalists and Catholics make for very odd bedfellows. We have nothing in common other than being anti-abortion and having conservative politics. Our beliefs are extremely different. While so many snub the Protestants we have much in common with theologically.
.
I completely agree. Funny that you will see quite a bit of this romance here on CAF. There is quite a bit of praise for the evangelical protestant around here.
 
See Why I’m against pre-game prayers:

Because we worked in the youth department of our church and taught teenage Sunday School classes, we were anxious to be involved in the lives of the students we worked with. So we were quite excited to be able to attend our first football game at Wahiawa High School. Upon our arrival at the stadium it seemed like so many other high school athletic events we had been to in many other places. The teams were warming up, the band was gathering, the ROTC was preparing to raise the colors – a pretty typical fall ritual.

Coming from a fairly traditional Southern upbringing, I was not at all initially surprised when a voice came over the PA and asked everyone to rise for the invocation. I had been through this same ritual at many other high-school events and thought nothing of it, so to our feet my wife and I stood, bowed our heads, and prepared to partake of the prayer. But to our extreme dismay, the clergyman who took the microphone and began to pray was not a Protestant minister or a Catholic priest, but a Buddhist priest who proceeded to offer up prayers and intonations to god-head figures that our tradition held to be pagan.

We were frozen in shock and incredulity! What to do? To continue to stand and observe this prayer would represent a betrayal of our own faith and imply the honoring of a pagan deity that was anathema to our beliefs. To sit would be an act of extreme rudeness and disrespect in the eyes of our Japanese hosts and neighbors, who value above all other things deference and respect in their social interactions. I am sorry to say that in the confusion of the moment we chose the easier path and elected to continue to stand in silence so as not to create a scene or ill will among those who were seated nearby.

As I thought through the incident over the next few days I supposed that the duty of offering the pre-game prayer rotated through the local clergy and we just happened to arrive on the night that the responsibility fell to the Buddhist priest. However, after inquiring I learned that due to the predominance of Buddhist and Shinto adherents in this town, it was the normal practice to have a member of one these faiths offer the pre-game prayer, and Christian clergy were never included. Needless to say that was our first and last football game.

rossum
 
See Why I’m against pre-game prayers:

Because we worked in the youth department of our church and taught teenage Sunday School classes, we were anxious to be involved in the lives of the students we worked with. So we were quite excited to be able to attend our first football game at Wahiawa High School. Upon our arrival at the stadium it seemed like so many other high school athletic events we had been to in many other places. The teams were warming up, the band was gathering, the ROTC was preparing to raise the colors – a pretty typical fall ritual.

Coming from a fairly traditional Southern upbringing, I was not at all initially surprised when a voice came over the PA and asked everyone to rise for the invocation. I had been through this same ritual at many other high-school events and thought nothing of it, so to our feet my wife and I stood, bowed our heads, and prepared to partake of the prayer. But to our extreme dismay, the clergyman who took the microphone and began to pray was not a Protestant minister or a Catholic priest, but a Buddhist priest who proceeded to offer up prayers and intonations to god-head figures that our tradition held to be pagan.

We were frozen in shock and incredulity! What to do? To continue to stand and observe this prayer would represent a betrayal of our own faith and imply the honoring of a pagan deity that was anathema to our beliefs. To sit would be an act of extreme rudeness and disrespect in the eyes of our Japanese hosts and neighbors, who value above all other things deference and respect in their social interactions. I am sorry to say that in the confusion of the moment we chose the easier path and elected to continue to stand in silence so as not to create a scene or ill will among those who were seated nearby.

As I thought through the incident over the next few days I supposed that the duty of offering the pre-game prayer rotated through the local clergy and we just happened to arrive on the night that the responsibility fell to the Buddhist priest. However, after inquiring I learned that due to the predominance of Buddhist and Shinto adherents in this town, it was the normal practice to have a member of one these faiths offer the pre-game prayer, and Christian clergy were never included. Needless to say that was our first and last football game.

rossum
And in a locale such as Deerborn MI, you would likely have Muslim prayers and I suspect many on these forums wouldn’t be so thrilled with that.
 
I completely agree. Funny that you will see quite a bit of this romance here on CAF. There is quite a bit of praise for the evangelical protestant around here.
Yes, when they get it right - such as when they are effectively pro-life why wouldn’t we praise them? Or should we not do so because they’re evangelicals. With so many Catholics voting for pro abortion Democrats we need everyone we can get. If your life was threatened would you refuse help based on theology? I don’t think the unborn would.

Ishii
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top