Vain and Repetitious prayer

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dchsknight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know that Jesus’ disciples asked Him how they should pray, and He gave them
a general form to follow – not exactly, but some of the contents that should be in
a prayer, but I haven’t seen any examples of any of the disciples every praying,
at least it wasn’t described in the Holy Bible – maybe somewhere in Paul’s writings
there is some prayers he did, if you have some passages where the disciples prayed
please let me know.
I don’t say “prayers” in what most people would consider a prayer. I talk intimately
to Jesus and the Holy Spirit daily and tell of my feelings and my needs and desires.
I read the Holy Bible daily and feel that in some way that’s a form of showing love
and respect to Father, Jesus and the Holy Spirit.
I know that God knows what’s in my heart at all times, I just like talking to God
informally and I know He likes that. I don’t like saying the same types of things
all the time, I don’t think that means much to God.
 
I was taught that prayer was the lifting of the heart and mind to God. I also really appreciated wht CS lewis said about prayer in that he said “I pray not to change God, but to change myself.” These two, for me, have constitued a reasonable and uesful approach to prayer.

That being said, I am in no way in favor of asking for particular aoutcomes or reuslts in the sense of petitioning God as a Person with the intent of changing an event by intervention. There may be entities, angels, saints, whatever, that do that, but that is not, I feel, something done by God Himself. In fact I think it is an insult to Divinity to ask for a particular result from God. We have, as I have seen, opposing teams each asking God for victory, whether in sports, politics, finance or war–Nonsense. That of course does not mean we do not wish safety for those in peril of war or disaster. It does mean though that we know that the outcome is in greater hands than our own, and that we know to bow to that while doing our level best for good. So, praying to do one’s best according to their best conscience, invoking God as the ideal, yes, by all means. But God does not take sides. He is Truth and Life and Love. It is nonsensical to expect that He would take sides against His own children because one said “better” prayers. If you are a parent, you decide by what is right and proper to the situation, not by the pleadings of your children, no matter how dramatic, sincere, or impasssioned.

As for repetative prayer, it has definite advantages. At least two. One is that if you are repeating a prayer of deep significance, the meaning of the words unfolds into a deeper understanding with that repetition. That even works when you are trying got remember something, such as where you left something or what you did on Thursday after 3. The mind adds details each time until you say “Aha!” Same with prayers that have as their object the unfolding of the understanding of holiness, by whatever understanding one might be currently limiting that.

The other use of repetition is like the rosary, or a mantra, or watching and appreciating your breath. These activites have as one of their ends the quieting of the mind. This quieting is a doorway to self understanding and even revelations beyond our ordianry way of thinking, beause they access the peaceful state behind our workaday concerns. It is my favorite way, as it seems to be an avenue for intuition to be active in the concerns of my life. It has to do with the idea of “Be still, and know that I AM. God.”

So I guess that covers petition, contemplation, and meditation. It is sketchy, but it is my two cents worth. But the main part is the raising up of the heart and mind to God. In the Presence of God, is there any concern pertinent to personality? If the bliss of that realization is melded with a practicality of good work done in good conscience, perhaps our part is done, and God can “do” His.
 
When I pray, I usually say Our father and Hail Mary and then I ask both Mary and Jesus to help guide me to be a better person, to help me resist temptation and do what is pleasing and righteous to him.

I also ask for the conversion of friends or loved ones who are not Catholic and I ask that all souls may go to heaven.

Is that the wrong kind of praying?
 
No prayer is vain as long as we do it for the love of God and/or are leaning on God for support. Remember we can do NOTHING without God. He is our life. When we are in distress and pray to God it can be difficult to concentrate because our mind is spinning, we must remember God knows what we are thinking and what our needs are and he is listening. We must pray without questioning God, we must trust Him for our salvation. No prayer is vain or repititious.
 
Well for those who think that praying repetatively is vain, they forget that Jesus prayed the same prayer 3 times in a row while in the Garden of Gethsemini. And if a protestant says that a rosary is repetitious, then I want to know something. If you pray 10 our fathers a day, when is it vain? Is it if you pray one right after the other? Whats the time requirement between each prayer for it not to be vain? If there is exactly 2 seconds in between each prayer, is it still vain? If its 1/2 a second between each, is it vain? In my view, if you let scripture interpret scripture, that verse is referring to things such as Elijah vs. the priests of Baal. The priests of Baal called upon their false god many times in different ways, because they felt they couldn’t be heard (Elijah actually made fun of them).

I think its all in intention. If you are praying repetatively because you don’t think God is listening, then you are praying in vain. But if you are doing it because it helps your focus and allows you to focus more on God (vs. Him focusing on you) then its fine.

Little Catholic:)
 
I
That being said, I am in no way in favor of asking for particular aoutcomes or reuslts in the sense of petitioning God as a Person with the intent of changing an event by intervention. There may be entities, angels, saints, whatever, that do that, but that is not, I feel, something done by God Himself. In fact I think it is an insult to Divinity to ask for a particular result from God.
Jesus prayed saying, "Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass away from me; yet not as I will, but as thou willest".
And I don’t that Jesus was insulting Divinity when he asked that t*he cup pass away
*
 
I see your point there. It certainly is natural to wish to avoid a horrific death, and all that involves. Quite a bit would have had to be different, in that instance, for a “passing” to happen, though, if one accepts the Bible as history. I wonder if the prayer was really intended as a petition for avoidance, though from a human perspective who would want to go through that? But according to dogma, it was fate. Did He not know that? Was He really asking in sincerity that all of history from Adam on be changed? Is that consistent with teaching? I don’t know.

I’m not arguing against expressing a wish, that is only natural and normal. We do that all the time in any event, since it is our way to want avoid hardship, threat, or suffering. I think it is natural to express our wish to one we love. I think, though, that as CS Lewis said, such a prayer is yet made in order to allign our own resouces we have recieved as gifts to meet the challenge. That is why it is so useful to understand the difference between pain and suffering, and to identify correctly. All things difficult, though possibly even very painful, can be met without suffering if the prayer is efficacious. In that dynamic, the prayer is for the re-allignment of onself in order to best meet the challenge.
 
PS. I thihk that the spelling of "Repestious in the thread title is precious! It reminds me of the incessant redundancy of untrained children in their whining. Good job, OP!
 
I see your point there. It certainly is natural to wish to avoid a horrific death, and all that involves. Quite a bit would have had to be different, in that instance, for a “passing” to happen, though, if one accepts the Bible as history. I wonder if the prayer was really intended as a petition for avoidance, though from a **human perspective **who would want to go through that? But according to dogma, it was fate. Did He not know that? Was He really asking in sincerity that all of history from Adam on be changed? Is that consistent with teaching? I don’t know.
Whatever other things you would like to imagine, that would not change the fact that Christ prayed in Gethsemani asking God to let the cup pass away. And it was not an insult to Divinity. Besides, where did you find a (Church) dogma that says it was fate? No, it was not fate. But it was God’s will. And mentioning of human perspective. You certainly are aware that Jesus was true man. Hence he prayed to the Father.
 
PS. I thihk that the spelling of "Repestious in the thread title is precious! It reminds me of the incessant redundancy of untrained children in their whining. Good job, OP!
I am sorry, i stink at Spelling, which is funny cause i want to be a Writer, I guess that is why God invented Editors.
 
I am sorry, i stink at Spelling, which is funny cause i want to be a Writer, I guess that is why God invented Editors.
Actually, spelling should not matter much in this forum for so long as the reader gets what the writer is saying. They are negligible errors. What is dangerous is when a writer, although he has perfect spelling, could not express accurately into writing what it is that he wants to communicate to his readers.
 
:)I realy don’t think any prayer is vain unless you stand on street corners to be seen and keep repeating the same thing over and over like Jesus said they are hippocrites because they want to be seen as good or rightous,go to your Father in secret and he will reward you openly Jesus said when you pray “Pray like this”“Our Father which art in heaven Hallowed be thy name(let your name be sanctified) thy Kingdom come thy will be done on earth as it is in Heaven(we are to do the will of the Father on earth) give us this day our daily bread(be thankful in all he gives you) and forgive us our trespasses,as we forgive those who trespass against us( show mercy or you will not be shown any) and lead us not into temptation(lead,guide,direct,touch) but deliver us from the evil one.”:)Love of Christ Nancy
 
Just as much, praying in the intent of becoming sincere in prayer is not vain by any means. Most of us can relate by the rosary. If you don’t want to pray the rosary daily, pray that you will want to!
Even when you pray the Lord’s Prayer (Our Father), you should sincerely try to mean each phrase you say. Whether it is returning God’s title to him, asking for your spiritual needs to be met, asking for forgiveness, forgiving others, and asking for guidance.
By truly wanting these things, you should recieve them.
Remember that each one of us is only human. No more.
We have our wants, and our dislikes. Our wants generally have short term rewards,
(i.e. you eat chocolate and it tastes good). But God’s wants ALWAYS have long term rewards, or else he would not want them for us in the first place. Prayer is an excercize for the mind, spirit, and health of the body. It is an essential part of our every day lives, but should not be posted on a schedule. Pray for a purpose always, because if you pray for no purpose, what are you asking for?
“Ask and it will be given to you; seek and you will find; knock and the door will be opened to you.” Matthew 7: 7-8
 
I am sorry, i stink at Spelling, which is funny cause i want to be a Writer, I guess that is why God invented Editors.
You are not sorry at all.

YOU don’t care, or you would go back and edit your first post in this thread and fix it.

There are many options available to you.

You could use a browser which has a spell checker. Or you could do your posts in a word processing program and spell check before posting. Better still, you might consider the idea of downloading and installing Aspell, and then drag and drop your posts and replies onto that and get an instant spell checking.

There is no reason to inflict on us your vain and repetitious laziness.
 
Wow–Saieditor: Cool down…Yes, we should edit. And the OP ought rightly to be his own editor. I go back sometimes three times to do that. since my own spell checker doesn’t work in word, I just cuut an paste into “compose” in my e-mail program. But after 20-30 minutes, you don’t have the edit option on here.

It frys me too that people don’t read their own post. It is like going to church in jeans and holy (pun) T-shirt. But I wonder if change is attractive to someone pounced on like that.(stick a sai* in it?) I think you protest too much. Just be an example of what you want.

Besides, asking folks to edit their work goes, as far as my experience counts, under “vain and repetitious prayer,” as it is resoundingly answered by the laziness you mentioned.

Bindar Doondat
  • bad joke. For those who don’t know, sai are those tridet like knives you see bandied about in martial arts movies. And I know; singular: sais. I said it was bad, lol!
Also consider this:

SPELL CHECKER

Eye halve a spelling chequer
It came with my pea sea
It plainly marques four my revue
Miss steaks eye kin knot sea.

Eye strike a key and type a word
And weight four it two say
Weather eye am wrong oar write
It shows me strait a weigh.

As soon as a mist ache is maid
It nose bee fore two long
And eye can put the error rite
Its rare lea ever wrong.

Eye have run this poem threw it
I am shore your pleased to no
Its letter perfect awl the weigh
My chequer tolled me sew.

–Sauce unknown
 
Vain and repetitious laziness it is.

I work as an editor for a living, and I would send this fellow’s work back to him to clean it up himself. Editing is not about cleaning up other people’s messes. He has the wrong notion of modern-day editing.
 
You are not sorry at all.

YOU don’t care, or you would go back and edit your first post in this thread and fix it.

There are many options available to you.

You could use a browser which has a spell checker. Or you could do your posts in a word processing program and spell check before posting. Better still, you might consider the idea of downloading and installing Aspell, and then drag and drop your posts and replies onto that and get an instant spell checking.

There is no reason to inflict on us your vain and repetitious laziness.
:mad:BOY your so Christain it sucks the dog. I spell ****** to,stop picking on people,and what is a browser i hear that alot ,i dont know how to install stuff,get it! Nancy the worst speller on the forum and it isn’t just spelling it’s puntuation to i never know where to put the commas.Not everyone is as smart as you.I give him a A for Effort. Nancy Theres alot of more rotton things in this world then some one who’s english is bad.Have a Happy Good Christain Night:p
 
I’m agein’ that! I four got thee must import ant cat a gory of prayer all together. I guess out of habit, I just don’t notice. That of course would be prayers of gratitude.
 
Seven posts pruned for either being off topic or uncharitable.
Please get back on topic and stay there and maintain the highest standard of charity.

Sincerely,
 
=Dchsknight;4942613]Just want to start a thread on what People think is Vain and Repetitious prayer.
Protestants always accuse us of Vain and Repetitious prayer, so lets Discuss what actually is…Here is my opinion:
I think any kind of Prayer can, become Vain and Repetitious, when, we the people who are praying, are praying with out Authority or when we are jsut praying to pray, Like if mommy and daddy said so as a kid, we pray now as adults. Instead of us as adults chasing after God with all our hearts and praying, knowing full well that we are the children of a Good and Holy God, and he hears us. Also that We as Children of God have the right and privilege to pray to our mother in heaven, the Blessed Virgin Mary, and all those who have gone before us.
For example, I believe that if you just pray the Rosary, just to pray it, or If you pray it because others do it, and have no idea what it is or what it is for that is Vain and repetitious. If you pray it how ever with the Intent to learn and grow in Christ, through a devotional and Sacramental, knowing that meditating on the mysteries with in the Rosary, can bring you closer to God as you recite and meditate on the Rosary. That is not vain and Repetitious.
So what do others think. I look forward to the great and powerful conversations ahead of us.
Your Brother and knight in Christ,
Brother James,

1 Thess. 5: *** 16 “Rejoice always, pray constantly*, give thanks in all circumstances; for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you”**

What is prayer?

CCC #2725 "Prayer is both a gift of grace and a determined response on our part. It always presupposes effort. The great figures of prayer of the Old Covenant before Christ, as well as the Mother of God, the saints, and he himself, all teach us this: prayer is a battle. Against whom? Against ourselves and against the wiles of the tempter who does all he can to turn man away from prayer, away from union with God. We pray as we live, because we live as we pray. If we do not want to act habitually according to the Spirit of Christ, neither can we pray habitually in his name. The “spiritual battle” of the Christian’s new life is inseparable from the battle of prayer"

It has been said that prayer is "the lifting of our minds and heards to God."


Mt. 6: 5 "And when you pray, you must not be like the hypocrites; for they love to stand and pray in the synagogues and at the street corners, that they may be seen by men. Truly, I say to you, they have received their reward. 6 But when you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you.

7* “And in praying do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do; for they think that they will be heard for their many words. 8* Do not be like them, for your Father knows what you need before you ask him. 9* Pray then like this: Our Father who art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name. 10 Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done, On earth as it is in heaven. 11 Give us this day our daily bread; * 12 And forgive us our debts, As we also have forgiven our debtors; 13* And lead us not into temptation, But deliver us from evil. * (Picture) 14* For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father also will forgive you; 15 but if you do not forgive men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.”

What is wrong about “chasing after God?” Are we not to seek a relationship with Him?

I struggle with the idea of vanity and prayer in the same sentence, knowing that if in fact we are praying? Then we are employing our minds and wills to a greater or lesser extent.

Rom.8: "26 Likewise the Spirit helps us in our weakness; for we do not know how to pray as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with sighs too deep for words. 27And he who searches the hearts of men knows what is the mind of the Spirit, because the Spirit intercedes for the saints according to the will of God. "

As for the issue of Repetitious prayer. Are we to stop asking, simply because God has not yet responded?

And the Rosary in Biblically based prayer. If it’s good enough to pray ONCE, is it not good enough to pray often?

Brother James, I’m not really giving you a hard time… just bringing to light some issues in regards to prayer:)

Still I find the issue of “vain prayers” to be a difficulr concept to grasp.

Love and prayers,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top