Venezuela is Starving

  • Thread starter Thread starter NickyMaz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Venezuela isn’t socialist. Socialism is the abolition of capital, wage labour and commodity production.
I last refuge is the ‘it’s not real socialism’ line. Hugo Chavez’s political movement was named the United Socialist Party, his entire program was socialism. But after it all comes tumbling down we hear, ‘well…that’s not real socialism.’
 
I think the big issue with Venezuela has been the price controls. In the article it discusses a pig farmer who can’t sell his pigs at a price to keep up with his expenses. Farmers are abandoning their farms because they can’t sell their commodities at a price to cover their expenses. It’s basic economics but socialism ignores that in the hopes that magic will kick in.
 
Wasn’t Jesus a hard socialist?

Source: The Bible
I kind of missed the part where He suggested that Rome regulate all business and trade. Could you give me the verse where He calls for that?
 
I last refuge is the ‘it’s not real socialism’ line. Hugo Chavez’s political movement was named the United Socialist Party, his entire program was socialism. But after it all comes tumbling down we hear, ‘well…that’s not real socialism.’
Would that make it a “no real Scotsman” fallacy?

In any case, the problem is lack of food and it was the farms, the production of food, that was nationalized.
 
Would that make it a “no real Scotsman” fallacy?

In any case, the problem is lack of food and it was the farms, the production of food, that was nationalized.
I guess it would. They use it as an excuse to try it again somewhere, and it fails again. I think the only thing we’ve gotten from socialism/communism is a handful of jokes.

Two Russians are conversing with each other, and the first one says, “Did we achieve it? Is this full communism?” The second one says, “No, things still need to get a lot worse first.” 😃
 
I kind of missed the part where He suggested that Rome regulate all business and trade. Could you give me the verse where He calls for that?
Government regulation is not socialism, it exists in capitalism as well.
 
ANV;14631612]Wasn’t Jesus a hard socialist?
No, Jesus was for people making personal sacrifices to follow God. Socialism is (in theory, never in practice) equal distribution. Jesus was not for exact equal distribution at the point of the sword, which is what socialism is.
Source: The Bible
Appeal to authority…and a fail since that’s not even in the Bible.
 
wsj.com/articles/venezuela-is-starving-1493995317

“Her country was once Latin America’s richest, producing food for export. Venezuela now can’t grow enough to feed its own people in an economy hobbled by the nationalization of private farms, and price and currency controls.”

Much has been said about this but there has been conspicuous silence from the Catholic Church. It seems we get daily condemnations of western materialism, capitalism and, the latest boogieman, libertariansm. Where is the condemnation of the Venezuelan government and their horrendous policies?

More and more I grow frustrated with this pope and his ideology.
It is in unison with the ideas of some nationalists movements in Eastern European countries- to nationalize the wealth, to distribute wealth honestly, to build an independent state of prosperous citizens, but in practice, everything will go upside down. I think that the example of Venezuela should be instructive. It’s like in those expressions:
‘‘For which of you, desiring to build a tower, does not first sit down and count the cost, whether he has enough to complete it?’’
‘‘Or what king, going out to confront another king in battle, will not sit down first and determine whether he is able with ten thousand to oppose the one coming against him with twenty thousand?’’
 
I used to have great sympathy for socialism.
before I was philosophizing on different subjects.
youtube.com/watch?v=PowWAGKh7d8
But strangely enough, I was disappointed in socialism during visits to one monastery.
There is one monastery very rich. (I personally do not agree with spiritual orientation, precisely because of the Moscow-oriented ideologies, these ideological guidelines affect the life adjustment, but what is interesting is that in this monastery - everything is free for everyone- you can stay there for a few days, you can eat there unlimited, some later prefer to stay there for a long term. and what is interesting that tour operators come there on large buses, People come to the city as business tourists and as simply tourists but also at the same time save a lot of money by stopping at the monastery. Over time there for a very long term there began to dwell a ‘‘free-loaders’’, and now looking at these crowds of tourists and these tenants living there for a long term. I realized that man is an ungrateful being and wants everything for him to be free.
But in state socialism there is still such a hidden detail as the type of people who build it.
On the one hand, the world of the tropicana jungles is a constant danger, and it affects the mentality, on the other hand in countries where it is always warm the fruit can fall into your mouth even when you simply lie, and besides slogans and populism, intellectual potential is also needed - that is,’’ very able national brains ‘’ that can embody the embodiment of socialist ideas. That’s why there is a need to seriously weigh the slogans of revolutionaly-nationalistic-charismatic leaders who think that they are the political messiahs, or national Davids fighting with Goliaths, and eventually lead the state аnd the millions of its citizens to a catastrophe.
 
There is a shortage of food; but there is no shortage of tear gas.
 
“Even at that, Venezuela has some of the largest oil reserves in the world.”

It’s kind of a detail, but not all oil reserves are created equal, and Venezuela’s are a lot more like Canada’s oil sands than Saudi Arabia’s light sweet crude, which means they are technically and economically challenging to get out of the ground. Nevertheless, the political power is an important factor as well. I think Daniel Yergin once wrote that Albertans should erect a monument to Hugo Chavez in downtown Calgary to thank him for driving investment away from his country to theirs.
Only 50% correct.

Venezuela has TWO kinds of oil.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_reserves_in_Venezuela

The proven oil reserves in Venezuela are recognized as the largest in the world, totaling 297 billion barrels (4.72×1010 m3) as of 1 January 2014.[1] In early 2011, then-president Hugo Chávez and the Venezuelan government announced that the nation’s oil reserves had surpassed that of the previous long-term world leader, Saudi Arabia.[2] OPEC said that Saudi Arabia’s reserves stood at 265 billion barrels (4.21×1010 m3) in 2009.[3]

Venezuela’s development of its oil reserves has been affected by political unrest in recent years.[when?] In late 2002, nearly half of the workers at the state oil company PDVSA went on strike, after which the company fired 18,000 of them. Venezuela’s crude oil is very heavy by international standards, and as a result much of it must be processed by specialized domestic and international refineries. Venezuela continues to be one of the largest suppliers of oil to the United States, sending about 1.4 million barrels per day (220×103 m3/d) to the U.S. Venezuela is also a major oil refiner and the owner of the Citgo gasoline chain.[4]

In October 2007, the Venezuelan government said its proven oil reserves had risen to 100 billion barrels (16×109 m3). The energy and oil ministry said it had certified an additional 12.4 billion barrels (2.0×109 m3) of proven reserves in the country’s Faja del Orinoco region.[5] In February 2008, Venezuelan proven oil reserves were 172 billion barrels (27×109 m3).[6]

By 2009, Venezuela reported 211.17 billion barrels (3.3573×1010 m3) of conventional oil reserves, the largest of any country in South America.[7] In 2008, it had net oil exports of 1.189 Mbbl/d (189,000 m3/d) to the United States.[8] As a result of the lack of transparency in the country’s accounting, Venezuela’s true level of oil production is difficult to determine, but OPEC analysts estimate that it produced around 2.47 Mbbl/d (393,000 m3/d) of oil in 2009, which would give it 234 years of remaining production at current rates.

Orinoco Belt[edit]

**Orinoco Belt assessment unit, USGS
In addition to conventional oil, Venezuela has oil sands deposits similar in size to those of Canada, and approximately equal to the world’s reserves of conventional oil. Venezuela’s Orinoco tar sands

As with anything else, resources need to be managed.

The head people in Venezuela choose to NOT manage their oil; they install cronies who have absolutely no idea how to manage anything, much less oil fields.
 
Only 50% correct.

Venezuela has TWO kinds of oil.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_reserves_in_Venezuela

The proven oil reserves in Venezuela are recognized as the largest in the world, totaling 297 billion barrels (4.72×1010 m3) as of 1 January 2014.[1] In early 2011, then-president Hugo Chávez and the Venezuelan government announced that the nation’s oil reserves had surpassed that of the previous long-term world leader, Saudi Arabia.[2] OPEC said that Saudi Arabia’s reserves stood at 265 billion barrels (4.21×1010 m3) in 2009.[3]

Venezuela’s development of its oil reserves has been affected by political unrest in recent years.[when?] In late 2002, nearly half of the workers at the state oil company PDVSA went on strike, after which the company fired 18,000 of them. Venezuela’s crude oil is very heavy by international standards, and as a result much of it must be processed by specialized domestic and international refineries. Venezuela continues to be one of the largest suppliers of oil to the United States, sending about 1.4 million barrels per day (220×103 m3/d) to the U.S. Venezuela is also a major oil refiner and the owner of the Citgo gasoline chain.[4]

In October 2007, the Venezuelan government said its proven oil reserves had risen to 100 billion barrels (16×109 m3). The energy and oil ministry said it had certified an additional 12.4 billion barrels (2.0×109 m3) of proven reserves in the country’s Faja del Orinoco region.[5] In February 2008, Venezuelan proven oil reserves were 172 billion barrels (27×109 m3).[6]

By 2009, Venezuela reported 211.17 billion barrels (3.3573×1010 m3) of conventional oil reserves, the largest of any country in South America.[7] In 2008, it had net oil exports of 1.189 Mbbl/d (189,000 m3/d) to the United States.[8] As a result of the lack of transparency in the country’s accounting, Venezuela’s true level of oil production is difficult to determine, but OPEC analysts estimate that it produced around 2.47 Mbbl/d (393,000 m3/d) of oil in 2009, which would give it 234 years of remaining production at current rates.

Orinoco Belt[edit]

**Orinoco Belt assessment unit, USGS
*In addition to conventional oil, ***Venezuela has oil sands deposits similar in size to those of Canada, and approximately equal to the world’s reserves of conventional oil. Venezuela’s Orinoco tar sands

As with anything else, resources need to be managed.

The head people in Venezuela choose to NOT manage their oil; they install cronies who have absolutely no idea how to manage anything, much less oil fields.
I think I read some time ago that all or some of Venezuela’s oil requires a lot of processing in a specialized way and one of the few places where it can be processed is the U.S. Possibly that’s part of the reason the U.S. is the biggest customer.

I also recall, a number of years back, being told by a fellow who had been in the Peace Corps teaching engineering to Venezuelan students that the most responsible jobs in the oil industry there were held by foreigners, largely Americans. Had to do with skill levels and the oddly low status level of engineers in Venezuela. A lot of talented potential students just didn’t want to be engineers. They wanted to be doctors or lawyers or government officials.

But I imagine the leftists have driven out the best trained local engineers and managers, and I imagine the foreigners are long gone.
 
I think word you’re looking for is populism rather than socialism. In countries where people are being reasonable they manage to pragmatically adjust ideologies which are either more capitalist or socialist in the face of reality and create a mixed economy while maintaining lip service to the more abstract ideals.
Periodically however, those less able to understand nuance build up enough momentum to get everyone fired up enough to elect someone offering moronicly simplistic solutions; usually involving blaming elites and foreigners. Depending on the time and place it can either be “let’s be socialist and nationalize industry” or “let’s show them big bankers and city folk by abolishing the national bank.” Usually turns out badly either way.
 
Socialism is (in theory, never in practice) equal distribution.
That would be egalitarianism.

Socialism is by Merriam Webster’s definitions,
Code:
1  any of various economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and administration of the means of production and distribution of goods

2  a :  a system of society or group living in which there is no private property
    b :  a system or condition of society in which the means of production are owned and controlled by the state

3  a stage of society in Marxist theory transitional between capitalism and communism and distinguished by unequal distribution of goods and pay according to work done
If we use the last definition and we use the Parable of the Workers in the Vineyard, Jesus was no socialist.
 
From Catholic World Report:
If you want to see where socialism takes a country, go to today’s Venezuela. After 18 years of a left-wing populist regime committed to “21st Century Socialism,” a once-wealthy and relatively stable nation is coming apart.
For months, thousands of Venezuelans—tired of food shortages, denied free elections, subject to unambiguously socialist economic policies, forced to watch opposition leaders being jailed, burdened by the all-pervasive presence of Cuban “advisors,” and brutalized by security forces—have been protesting in the streets of all major Venezuelan cities. And what they want is clear: President Nicolás Maduro and his regime must cease behaving like a dictatorship and allow free and fair elections. The government’s response has been equally clear: fiery denunciations of its opponents as “enemies of the people” and, above all, repression, repression, repression.
catholicworldreport.com/Item/5648/as_venezuela_burns_many_latin_americans_ask_where_is_pope_francis.aspx
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top