WA & CO state and Marijuana

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gatekeeper
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gatekeeper

Guest
I know this is a pretty worn out topic but I have been doing some thinking.

The catechism says:
2291 The use of drugs inflicts very grave damage on human health and life. Their use, except on strictly therapeutic grounds, is a grave offense. Clandestine production of and trafficking in drugs are scandalous practices. They constitute direct co-operation in evil, since they encourage people to practices gravely contrary to the moral law.
I believe in moderation. That is key. I also believe alcohol is a drug and can be very damaging to mental health, physical health and family life when taken out of moderation.

That being said marijuana is just as natural as alcohol. Since Washington and Colorado have legalized marijuana and will regulate what is being sold the “clandestine” portion of this part of the catechism doesn’t really apply to marijuana in those states because it is sanctioned.

The next question is whether or not the actual use of marijuana would be sinful. I understand loosing your ability to reason is wrong. People will argue that marijuana is hard to moderate while using, which I agree with, if you are buying from a place that doesn’t have THC percentage and are inhaling large amounts. Inhaling a small amount only gets you a little buzz, just like drinking a little. From there gage.

I’ve heard arguments for and against usage. For and against legalizing. I think there are arguments on both sides that are generally made in moral fashion. But considering marijuana buying and selling is no longer “clandestine” in WA or CO, the regulations on the product and the fact that you can actually moderate yourself in its use, newer science on cannabis both for and against, wouldn’t it just be fair to say Marijuana use is an act of prudential judgement if used morally use just like alcohol?

Any thoughts?
 
I’m sympathetic to the view, but I think there are two obvious problems.

One, alcohol has a sacramental use.

Two, drinking alcohol does not in and of itself lead to inebriation. With marijuana, impairment is pretty well immediate and unavoidable. (And if you can avoid it, why are you taking it?)

I do wonder how this relates to, say, cigarettes.
 
One, alcohol has a sacramental use.
Two, drinking alcohol does not in and of itself lead to inebriation. With marijuana, impairment is pretty well immediate and unavoidable. (And if you can avoid it, why are you taking it?)
I understand alcohol has a sacramental use, but it has to be wine. What about 75% alcohol clear springs? Or just a beer?

I would argue about inebriation. Smoking a little can just give as much of a buzz as a little alcohol, just a different feeling and still be fully functional.
 
I understand alcohol has a sacramental use, but it has to be wine. What about 75% alcohol clear springs? Or just a beer?
Well, I’d tack on it has more than a sacramental use. It has all kinds of uses utterly detached from metabolizing it. Rubbing alcohol, etc.
I would argue about inebriation. Smoking a little can just give as much of a buzz as a little alcohol, just a different feeling and still be fully functional.
Except can a little alcohol give zero buzz? That seems to be the case for some/most people. If your marijuana gives zero buzz, it’s time to find a new dealer.

I’m not saying this being anti-marijuana. I actually think it likely isn’t a big deal, morally, with some obvious caveats. But I think alcohol and marijuana aren’t supremely comparable in this context. I think you’re far better off with a comparison to tobacco.
 
I’m not saying this being anti-marijuana. I actually think it likely isn’t a big deal, morally, with some obvious caveats. But I think alcohol and marijuana aren’t supremely comparable in this context. I think you’re far better off with a comparison to tobacco.
/QUOTE]
I see what you are saying. I agree. I was just trying to frame the question and point out that it is still possible to use it and maintain reason. I was using alcohol as a comparison in terms of effects.
I think if someone was going to smoke marijuana morally they would probably be healthier then someone that smoke tobacco morally, long term. Assuming the tobacco smoker smokes at least a couple cigarettes a day minimum, maybe even one. Smoking that much marijuana daily would be hard to use morally.
Any dissenting arguments out there?
 
I do not think Marijuana or alcohol in moderation is bad from a worldly perspective.

I do feel that from a spiritual perspective, such substances separate us from God. (The blood of Christ is not wine anymore during the Holy Sacrament)

This I have concluded from experience, not supposition. 😊
 
I do not think Marijuana or alcohol in moderation is bad from a worldly perspective.
I do feel that from a spiritual perspective, such substances separate us from God. (The blood of Christ is not wine anymore during the Holy Sacrament)
This I have concluded from experience, not supposition.
Even though the wine becomes the Blood of Christ the substance remains, meaning there is still alcohol content. Jesus presumably drank wine at the wedding at Cana, as did the Virgin Mary. “They have no wine.” Even if they didn’t, Jesus turned water into wine for others to drink. So alcohol is morally acceptable if used in moderation.

That being said I agree that alcohol, marijuana and other substances, even coffee can separate us from God if not used in moderation. That is why prudence in use and moderation is required.
 
Even though the wine becomes the Blood of Christ the substance remains, meaning there is still alcohol content. Jesus presumably drank wine at the wedding at Cana, as did the Virgin Mary. “They have no wine.” Even if they didn’t, Jesus turned water into wine for others to drink. So alcohol is morally acceptable if used in moderation.

That being said I agree that alcohol, marijuana and other substances, even coffee can separate us from God if not used in moderation. That is why prudence in use and moderation is required.
There is no wine in the Holy Eucharist. What you said right there is a Lutheran belief.
 
There is no wine in the Holy Eucharist. What you said right there is a Lutheran belief.
Your right. The bread and wine fully become the body and blood of Christ, a new substance. But the accidents remain, meaning the appearance of bread and wine, which means there is still alcohol.

Regardless, there is solid proof in the bible that people enjoy alcohol.
 
Your right. The bread and wine fully become the body and blood of Christ, a new substance. But the accidents remain, meaning the appearance of bread and wine, which means there is still alcohol.

Regardless, there is solid proof in the bible that people enjoy alcohol.
That’s true, people did use alcohol in the bible, but Alcohol there way more passages about the abuse of alcohol in the bible than vague passages maybe hinting towards causal drinking of it.

Alcohol is a substance that was substituted for water when the water was too dirty, and has profound religious significant with it.

Weed has no such thing, you use weed to get high, enough send. This comes from someone who activity used weed.
 
That’s true, people did use alcohol in the bible, but Alcohol there way more passages about the abuse of alcohol in the bible than vague passages maybe hinting towards causal drinking of it.

Alcohol is a substance that was substituted for water when the water was too dirty, and has profound religious significant with it.

Weed has no such thing, you use weed to get high, enough send. This comes from someone who activity used weed.
All good points.

John 2:10 - and said to him, “Everyone serves good wine first, and then when people have drunk freely, an inferior one; but you have kept the good wine until now.”

You think that wine would have had a 100 rating?
 
Does the federal govt have the right to make drug use illegal (or clandestine)? Or is the war on drugs (which is forty years old this year by the way ) an illegal usurpation of the peoples power? The govt bases its power on a perversion of the i

clause .

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
Does the federal govt have the right to make drug use illegal (or clandestine)? Or is the war on drugs (which is forty years old this year by the way ) an illegal usurpation of the peoples power? The govt bases its power on a perversion of the i

clause .

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
There are solid arguments for and against prohibition, both of which I think depend of the climate of the culture in their implementation (while still keeping the rule of law). But I also do think the states should have more of say. I guess legalization of marijuana in Washington and Colorado will serve as an experiment for the rest of the United States. Federalism is cool.
 
why marijuana should NOT be legalized ever for recreation!

1011now.com/home/headlines/Norris-Students-Caught-Selling-Pot-Brownies-at-School-196346091.html

Marijuana is NOT legal in my state, and one girl who ingested a lot of marijuana ended up in the ER!

If this happens when its illegal, imagine what could happen if it was legal in all 50 states!

Drugs are a DEAD END. I’ll listen to the “kids from Bayside High” when they say there’s “no hope with dope!” (Saved by the Bell reference, but still very important)
 
why marijuana should NOT be legalized ever for recreation!

1011now.com/home/headlines/Norris-Students-Caught-Selling-Pot-Brownies-at-School-196346091.html

Marijuana is NOT legal in my state, and one girl who ingested a lot of marijuana ended up in the ER!

If this happens when its illegal, imagine what could happen if it was legal in all 50 states!

Drugs are a DEAD END. I’ll listen to the “kids from Bayside High” when they say there’s “no hope with dope!” (Saved by the Bell reference, but still very important)
That girl probably knew what she was getting into if she payed 15 dollars for a brownie.

I understand your point of view completely. I’m sure she went to the hospital out of procedure just in case and to test her blood to see what she consumed.
 
40.png
Gatekeeper:
Quote:

Originally Posted by flaco40

Does the federal govt have the right to make drug use illegal (or clandestine)? Or is the war on drugs (which is forty years old this year by the way ) an illegal usurpation of the peoples power? The govt bases its power on a perversion of the i

clause .

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android

There are solid arguments for and against prohibition, both of which I think depend of the climate of the culture in their implementation (while still keeping the rule of law). But I also do think the states should have more of say. I guess legalization of marijuana in Washington and Colorado will serve as an experiment for the rest of the United States. Federalism is cool.
Please explain to me what you mean by a solid argument for the federal govt making these kind of laws ?

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
40.png
flaco40:
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gatekeeper

Quote:

Originally Posted by flaco40

Does the federal govt have the right to make drug use illegal (or clandestine)? Or is the war on drugs (which is forty years old this year by the way ) an illegal usurpation of the peoples power? The govt bases its power on a perversion of the i

clause .

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android

There are solid arguments for and against prohibition, both of which I think depend of the climate of the culture in their implementation (while still keeping the rule of law). But I also do think the states should have more of say. I guess legalization of marijuana in Washington and Colorado will serve as an experiment for the rest of the United States. Federalism is cool.

Please explain to me what you mean by a solid argument for the federal govt making these kind of laws ?

keeping the tenth amendment in mind . I don’T BELIEVE THAT there are any reasonable arguments for federal inrevrntion .

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
40.png
jediliz:
why marijuana should NOT be legalized ever for recreation!

1011now.com/home/headline…196346091.html

Marijuana is NOT legal in my state, and one girl who ingested a lot of marijuana ended up in the ER!

If this happens when its illegal, imagine what could happen if it was legal in all 50 states!

Drugs are a DEAD END. I’ll listen to the “kids from Bayside High” when they say there’s “no hope with dope!” (Saved by the Bell reference, but still very important)
Not to be disrespectful at all but gum disease in our country is at about 90%. Does that mean that we need the federal govt to institute flossing laws? I am just trying to point out that people need to take responsibility for their own actions at some point . I am from the same state that you are apparently . So please don’t start a push for federal agents or state agents to start inspecting our bodily orifices for diseases .

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top