Was I being slothful?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nat_c1990
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Roseeurekacross said:
Are you really asking Don Ruggero what evidence he has ?

I mean seriously?
Click to expand...
This is pretty remarkable, I would say.

It is a question so simple in canon law that a first year…even first day student should educe the answer to it.

But I thank you for the rally of support. It is appreciated.
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
Yes, unfortunately the easter vigil is on saturday not sunday. You did not fulfill your obligation.
Click to expand...
Ok so you just affirmed that the 2 Priests on this thread are right. And you were not. With your thread link to A Third Priest.

I will pray for you.
 
Don_Ruggero said:
This is pretty remarkable, I would say.

It is a question so simple in canon law that a first year…even first day student should educe the answer to it.

But I thank you for the rally of support. It is appreciated.
Click to expand...
You are very welcome Father. Its good Trinity has just affirmed you as right too. I feel so umm Irish!
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
I have a PH.D in religious studies
Click to expand...
Well…if you have a Ph.D in religious studies, may I suggest you take a moment to analyse the arguments you are making and decide which side of the case you wish to present?

In your first posts, you have said that the obligation is not fulfilled. To wit
Yes, unfortunately the easter vigil is on saturday not sunday. You did not fulfill your obligation.
Click to expand...
And
Is easter vigil on sunday? If not it does not satisfy the sunday obligation, regardless of your protests.
Click to expand...
The sources you are citing, however, are all confirming the canon I quoted. I suggest you need to re-visit the matter.
 
Don_Ruggero said:
Well…if you have a Ph.D in religious studies, may I suggest you take a moment to analyse the arguments you are making and decide which side of the case you wish to present?

In your first posts, you have said that the obligation is not fulfilled. To wit

And

The sources you are citing, however, are all confirming the canon I quoted. I suggest you need to re-visit the matter.
Click to expand...
I believe my post 26 adresses this concern.
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
Easter Vigil fulfills the EASTER OBLIGATION, but not the Sunday obligation.

Peace.
Click to expand...
Pretty sure it says here Easter Sunday
Default Re: Does the Easter Vigil Count?
Hi,

The Easter Vigil does indeed fulfill the Easter Sunday Mass requirement. I don’t know why your grandmother would think otherwise, since the Saturday night vigil Mass throughout the year fulfills the Sunday obligation.

Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.

You did a
Ph.D on Peace?
What topic?
 
Roseeurekacross said:
Pretty sure it says here Easter Sunday
Default Re: Does the Easter Vigil Count?
Hi,

The Easter Vigil does indeed fulfill the Easter Sunday Mass requirement. I don’t know why your grandmother would think otherwise, since the Saturday night vigil Mass throughout the year fulfills the Sunday obligation.

Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.

You did a
Ph.D on Peace?
What topic?
Click to expand...
Right. I do not think we are actually disagreeing. It indeed suffices the easter sunday obligation, but since you went on saturday instead of saturday you still have the obligation for the next day and it will count as a normal sunday. I think we can all agree on this.
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
Right. I do not think we are actually disagreeing. It indeed suffices the easter sunday obligation, but since you went on saturday instead of saturday you still have the obligation for the next day and it will count as a normal sunday. I think we can all agree on this.
Click to expand...
Ok from the top
  1. Op asked if Sat night Easter Vigil Mass would fulfil Easter Sunday obligation . They were tired from the late night and zeAl and excitement.
  2. FrDavid said yes it Did. He is a Priest.
  3. You said no it didn’t
  4. Don Ruggero said you were wrong, and that the Easter Vigil SaTurday night did indeed fulfill that obligation for Easter Sunday.
  5. Canon law was provided for you
  6. You pulled up a thread from a third Priest affirming the othe 2 Priests are correct . Again affirming you are in error
  7. You have a Doctorate in RS.
Am I missing something here?
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
Right. I do not think we are actually disagreeing. It indeed suffices the easter sunday obligation, but since you went on saturday instead of saturday you still have the obligation for the next day and it will count as a normal sunday. I think we can all agree on this.
Click to expand...
No.

The obligation for Sunday is fulfilled by attending the Mass on Saturday evening. It is not that attendance on Saturday somehow “suffices” or that one would “still have the obligation for the next day.”

The obligation has been fulfilled.
 
Don_Ruggero said:
No.

The obligation for Sunday is fulfilled by attending the Mass on Saturday evening. It is not that attendance on Saturday somehow “suffices” or that one would “still have the obligation for the next day.”

The obligation has been fulfilled.
Click to expand...
I am trying to find some middle ground so we can all agree.
 
Roseeurekacross said:
Ok from the top
  1. Op asked if Sat night Easter Vigil Mass would fulfil Easter Sunday obligation . They were tired from the late night and zeal and excitement.
  2. FrDavid said yes it did. He is a Priest.
  3. You said no it didn’t
  4. Don Ruggero said you were wrong, and that the Easter Vigil Saturday night did indeed fulfill that obligation for Easter Sunday.
  5. Canon law was provided for you
  6. You pulled up a thread from a third Priest affirming the other 2 Priests are correct . Again affirming you are in error
  7. You have a Doctorate in RS.
Am I missing something here?
Click to expand...
I should say that sums it up very smartly indeed.
 
Roseeurekacross said:
Ok from the top
  1. Op asked if Sat night Easter Vigil Mass would fulfil Easter Sunday obligation . They were tired from the late night and zeAl and excitement.
  2. FrDavid said yes it Did. He is a Priest.
  3. You said no it didn’t
  4. Don Ruggero said you were wrong, and that the Easter Vigil SaTurday night did indeed fulfill that obligation for Easter Sunday.
  5. Canon law was provided for you
  6. You pulled up a thread from a third Priest affirming the othe 2 Priests are correct . Again affirming you are in error
  7. You have a Doctorate in RS.
Am I missing something here?
Click to expand...
No, but you did not correctly represent Fr Serpa’s arguement.
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
No, but you did not correctly represent Fr Serpa’s arguement.
Click to expand...
Father Sherpa replied

Default Re: Does the Easter Vigil Count?
Hi,

The Easter Vigil does indeed fulfill the Easter Sunday Mass requirement. I don’t know why your grandmother would think otherwise, since the Saturday night vigil Mass throughout the year fulfills the Sunday obligation.

Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.

? What is his argument?
 
Roseeurekacross said:
Father Sherpa replied

Default Re: Does the Easter Vigil Count?
Hi,

The Easter Vigil does indeed fulfill the Easter Sunday Mass requirement. I don’t know why your grandmother would think otherwise, since the Saturday night vigil Mass throughout the year fulfills the Sunday obligation.

Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.

? What is his argument?
Click to expand...
We can conclude his arguement is as follows:

Going to easter vigil fulfills the easter sunday obligation as a holy day of obligation, but it does not satisfy our weekly sunday requirement. Therefore we must attend mass on sunday to fulfill our weekly requirement.

This is coming from a PH.D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top