Was sexual PERVERSION the original sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ziggamafu
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There is no way Song of Songs refers to oral sex. Not a chance.
To eat the fruit of something means to accept it with all consequences and risks; to eat the fruit of knowledge (personal determination of) good and evil is to accept the results of guessing what is right and wrong rather than finding out what God says about it. To eat the fruit of the Tree of Life is to accept life with its difficulties and so to be a life-giving, immortal living creature, as we were meant to be. This applies to far more than sex.
Was it a literal fruit? Who cares? It was a literal event, because it was a moment of change.
The earliest Christians believed in Original Sin, and discussed the doctrine of Original Sin with their Jewish friends, families and neighbors, who knew what they were talking about. This suggests the absence of such a doctrine in modern Judaism postdates a Judaism in which Original Sin was understood to be real.
 
There is no way Song of Songs refers to oral sex. Not a chance.
Song of Songs is a fairly raunchy love poem, finding typological references to God’s theology within sex.

It’s an effective motif – not for the kid’s but effective.

And, it ennobles human sexuality.
 
Not a single basis for considering Adam and Eve created perfect. Not a shred of evidence from the narrative, nor a shred of much else.

Of course, the definition of perfect should be clarifyed here by believers. It is my understanding it can only truly be fit for God. 🙂
 
On Monogenism this might be interesting to you: jimmyakin.typepad.com/defensor_fidei/2006/01/a_reader_writes.html
I believe in “Original Sin,” but I deny that Original Sin was an event in time.

I believe that the proper Catholic view of Original Sin should be that Original Sin is that state of alienation from God in the absence of grace endemic to all flesh, such that we are innately inclined to sin, and will only sin, in the absence of grace, on every moral question, and that therefore Christ had to suffer and die to purchase grace from His Own justice.
If I understand you correctly (hopefully not), you’re saying that sin is not a defect introduced by man but basically part of man’s nature. That is absolutely false, sin does not make us human. Otherwise Jesus was not truly man by your definition as he was like us in everything but sin.

On how original sin was transmitted, here’s the Catechism:
404 How did the sin of Adam become the sin of all his descendants? The whole human race is in Adam “as one body of one man”. By this “unity of the human race” all men are implicated in Adam’s sin, as all are implicated in Christ’s justice. Still, the transmission of original sin is a mystery that we cannot fully understand. But we do know by Revelation that Adam had received original holiness and justice not for himself alone, but for all human nature. By yielding to the tempter, Adam and Eve committed a personal sin, but this sin affected the human nature that they would then transmit in a fallen state. It is a sin which will be transmitted by propagation to all mankind, that is, by the transmission of a human nature deprived of original holiness and justice. And that is why original sin is called “sin” only in an analogical sense:** it is a sin “contracted” and not “committed” - a state and not an act.**

I’m disturbed by all your “corrections” to the Church’s teachings. I can only assume bad catechesis and/or improper understanding. I don’t claim to know it all, but I also certainly don’t claim to be pope so as to dictate what is the “true teaching” of things that the Church gets wrong.

@Strawberry: I agree that only God is truly perfect but Adam and Eve were in a state of “original justice” which means they were originally ordered to the will of God, but because of the fall they lost their gifts.

As for Genesis on Adam and Eve. End of Genesis 1, Genesis 1:31
God looked at everything he had made, and he found it very good
 
The earliest Christians believed in Original Sin, and discussed the doctrine of Original Sin with their Jewish friends, families and neighbors, who knew what they were talking about. This suggests the absence of such a doctrine in modern Judaism postdates a Judaism in which Original Sin was understood to be real.
And the evidence for this assertion is what, exactly?
 
As for Genesis on Adam and Eve. End of Genesis 1, Genesis 1:31
God looked at everything he had made, and he found it very good
Re your last point, look at Genesis more closely…

**4 God saw how good the light was…
10 God called the dry land “the earth,” and the basin of the water he called “the sea.” God saw how good it was…
12 the earth brought forth every kind of plant that bears seed and every kind of fruit tree on earth that bears fruit with its seed in it. God saw how good it was.
16 God made the two great lights, the greater one to govern the day, and the lesser one to govern the night; and he made the stars…18 God saw how good it was.
21 God created the great sea monsters and all kinds of swimming creatures with which the water teems, and all kinds of winged birds. God saw how good it was,…
25 God made all kinds of wild animals, all kinds of cattle, and all kinds of creeping things of the earth. God saw how good it was…
27 God created man in his image; in the divine image he created him; male and female he created them. [Hereafter, no statement that God sees good, pertaining to man specifically, is set forth.] **

So, it’s only the TOTALITY which is said to be good – NOT MANKIND SPECIFICALLY.

7 the LORD God formed man out of the clay of the ground…
Literally that verse reads…
7 the LORD God formed man out of the aphar of the adamah…
aphar is the ancient Hebrew term for dust, the symbol for sin in Bible typology. Man, in other words, is made of “sinful stuff.”

21 So the LORD God cast a deep sleep on the man, and while he was asleep, he took out one of his ribs and closed up its place with flesh.
Here we see that Eve is made out of “sleeping stuff.” “Sleep” is a Biblical type symbolizing “dead” or “dead in sin.”

One more hint…

27 God created man in his image; in the divine image he created him; male and female he created them. 31 Evening came, and morning followed–the sixth day.

“Six” is the Bible type, or symbol, for “evil.”

So, again and again and again and again, the Bible actually hints that man is evil!

That’s why we needed salvation!
 
If I understand you correctly (hopefully not), you’re saying that sin is not a defect introduced by man but basically part of man’s nature. That is absolutely false, sin does not make us human. Otherwise Jesus was not truly man by your definition as he was like us in everything but sin.

On how original sin was transmitted, here’s the Catechism:
404 How did the sin of Adam become the sin of all his descendants? The whole human race is in Adam “as one body of one man”. By this “unity of the human race” all men are implicated in Adam’s sin, as all are implicated in Christ’s justice. Still, the transmission of original sin is a mystery that we cannot fully understand. But we do know by Revelation that Adam had received original holiness and justice not for himself alone, but for all human nature. By yielding to the tempter, Adam and Eve committed a personal sin, but this sin affected the human nature that they would then transmit in a fallen state. It is a sin which will be transmitted by propagation to all mankind, that is, by the transmission of a human nature deprived of original holiness and justice. And that is why original sin is called “sin” only in an analogical sense:** it is a sin “contracted” and not “committed” - a state and not an act.**
First, note that despite your lengthy quotation, the Catechism actually FAILS to explain how Orginial Sin is transmitted, declaring it a mystery.

I do maintain that being human means that we have a propensity to sin IN THE ABSENCE OF GRACE.

In fact, precisely contrary to your inference, Scripture never clearly assigns to Adam and Eve specifically a state of original goodness. It never says that they were perfect.

In fact, Eve is portrayed as sinning after two cents worth of temptation.

The POINT of the text is that they were created sin-prone!

Why should this be so?

I think that the problem lies in perfect God’s perfect sovereignty.

It is against God’s nature to create equals. God’s Own innate sovereignty prohibits creation of beings identical to Himself. (Thus, even in the Beatific Vision, we are not “at” God’s level, but below it.) So, we are less than God, and dependent on God. As Aquinas says, we are “contingent.”

Apparently contingent beings with an intellect and free will apprehend their contingency, and so they are jealous of God, rebel, and sin.

There is a cure: Grace. But God’s perfect justice prohibits “something-for-nothing,” “pennies from Heaven.”

So, God cured that problem too by paying the price for grace exacted by His Own justice! – Jesus’ Own suffering and death!

Note that because grace is nopn-compulsive, we can still opt-out of the plan.

We can, if we want, opt for the pleasure and security of sin, and march to Hell, flags flying.
 
First, note that despite your lengthy quotation, the Catechism actually FAILS to explain how Orginial Sin is transmitted, declaring it a mystery.
Just a tiny suggestion if anyone would like to know the part of the mystery which is understandable. “transmitted” is explained toward the end of the paragraph which was quoted.
 
Hi, Granny.

Having no specific opinions is a very safe thing. Congratulations on your safety.

Peter
I do prefer safety within Catholic Church teachings. Thank you. I also recommend the peace of Catholicism to everyone, including you.
 
Just a tiny suggestion if anyone would like to know the part of the mystery which is understandable. “transmitted” is explained toward the end of the paragraph which was quoted.
Good. Explain it to us in words not used in the paragraph, so that you reflect true understanding – not the ability to be a tape recorder.
 
I do prefer safety within Catholic Church teachings. Thank you. I also recommend the peace of Catholicism to everyone, including you.
Granny, you always quote the Catechism generally – but not specifically.

I don’t think that you actually read it.
 
Song of Songs is a fairly raunchy love poem
Contradiction in terms
, finding typological references to God’s theology within sex.
I’ve read it. Of course it discusses sex. But there is no way it glorifies oral sex. Not a chance.
It’s an effective motif – not for the kid’s but effective.
Of course it’s effective. It’s God’s Word. But there is still no relation between that fact and the notion of perverse activity being glorified in it.
And, it ennobles human sexuality.
Of course. And still no reason to imagine references to oral sex in it.
 
…
5. Concupiscence from original sin seems especially driven toward the perversion of sex
…
I am not sure of where you got this from, but no, not necessarily. The effect of concupiscence is to darken the Intellect and to weaken the Free Will…our two powers.

These can be applied to anything, including sex, but as Jesus seemed to imply, sex was the least of our worries. He was more upset at pride than at sexual sins.

The Church has also taught that of all deadly sins, LUST is the least offensive in that it as least somehow resembles love, while PRIDE is the most hurtful and most offensive to God for we attempt to be like God.

Now, notice the language when speaking of PRIDE -to be like God- does it remind anyone of the serpent’s pitch? Precisely!

If anything, seeking power and pride and self-glorification -as opposed to God’s- should be the clue.

Some Protestants, such as the Puritans, later developed the idea of sexual perversion being the worst thing possible…due to Dualism, which for Catholics is a HERESY…

No, nothing to do with sex whatsoever…and it doesn’t even seem that Adam & Eve had sex before the Fall, because the Genesis account explains that after the Fall, they had ‘relations’ and conceived. They could have had sex, it doesn’t specify. It wouldn’t have been wrong, and there is no mention even after the Fall, that they sinned sexually in any way.

Again, that notion comes from some Protestant theological strains, which Catholicism rejects as Dualism. Spirit = Good; Body = Bad This attacks the Incarnation and the full humanity of Jesus.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top