And grace, in the Garden of Eden, while they were physically with God and walking with Him, did not reign on them?
Actually, I do believe that grace rained on every single ensouled human being from the first moment our anscestors began to be ensouled.
But I believe that Eve is a hypothetical woman, written-about in a hypothetical to portray to us what each of WOULD do IF grace were not available; and that Adam is a hypothetical man, written-about to portray Christ taking our sins upon Himself.
The Garden of Eden story is about the same speed as a Dr. Seuss story. It isn’t written with details sufficient to answer questions like the one you ask.
Allow me to prove that.
Sin doesn’t really occur the way it is portrayed in the story.
A real Eve would have committed the first sin the instant she glanced at the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, because she was entertaining a near occasion of sin. She would have committed another sin by listening to the serpent’s words after the first sentence. She committed another sin by taking the time to entertain doubts about God’s prohibitions. She committed another sin by forming the intent to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by willing to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by plucking it off the tree and bringing it to her mouth. The actual eating was only the last of many sins.
That’s how complex moral reality really is.
Instead of dealing with such complexities, the story gives us this simple sin of disobedience, ridiculous, undetailed and cartoon-like in its simplicity.
Other corroborrative details: Adam is made of dust from the
adamah, “red stuff” meaning “clay,” so that he is the right color to symbolize bloodied Christ.
After Adam calls Eve an
ishshah to punningly hint that she is a “herman” (because out of
ishah “her man” she was taken), he calls her
ewwah, “living,” or “Eve,” because – before she has any children – he knows that she will become “Mother of All the Living.”
This is after she is taken out of a rib to conform to a Babylonian-language pun about her. Nin-ti means both “Lady of the Rib” and “Lady of the Living” in Babylonian.
God is portrayed in a moronic fashion in the story, before Eve is pulled ftom Adam’s side: He tries to match Adam up with animals. That effort fails. God finally conceives of the idea of Eve.
Do you see what I mean? Top to bottom, the story is a detail-less fable, not non-fiction. It is fiction teaching theology.
Do you understand the Catholic concept of Purgatory? If you do understand it correctly, then you would understand that the fact that God is physically with them in the Garden means that they were in a state in which they could be with Gd.
Good for you for that sentence referring to Purgatory. How many Catholics here understand the concept of purgation so well? Few, I bet.
Re your point, notice that God is with them in person AFTER the sin, too. (Remember how He searched them out “at the breezy time of the day”?) This was possible because the inspired author conceiving the story wasn’t concerned with such details.
Unreachable by Joe Schmoe by himself, yes. Reachable by Joe Schmoe if reading through the “glasses” of the authoritative interpretation of the Church.
My Aunt, who was head of the Dominican Ordeer of Nuns in the Western Hemisphere, and a theologian in Catholic University, used to say, “Don’t look to the Church for guidance on Scripture. It has only talked about 5% of it – maybe less.”
Where? Where does it claim this? Again, you’re saying all these things but not offering any references. Articulates, yes. But you say perceived as if some parts of the truth have yet to be revealed, and this isn’t the case.
If you believe in inspiration, it’s philosophically necessary. Every result of inspiration of the Magisterium would be “news” in theology.
This is pretty vague. What do you mean by “down below” and “up above”? Is down below your own ideas that you think the Church will eventually agree with?
It’s a non-technical reference to the
sensum fidelium.
Again, where do you come up with these conclusions? You keep making all these claims for the Church, yet you sometimes admit they’re your own claims that you think the Church will agree with someday.
When I see “X,” should I say, “Look! There’s ‘X’!”? Or should I say, “Look! There’s ‘Not-X’!”?