Was sexual PERVERSION the original sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ziggamafu
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Please explain: How is it not Catholic?
As opposed to most Protestants, Catholics and Orthodox believe that humans are intrinsically GOOD and made GOOD by God in His image and likeness…

We suffer because of the Fall, but were redeemed, and our nature is still under the effects of concupiscence, but this does not mean our nature is depraved.

Catholics and Orthodox defend the goodness intrinsic in humanity because we feel this affect belief in the full humanity of Jesus. The Incarnation would not occur if our nature was intrinsically -by nature- depraved. We were made for Him, through Him and in Him.

Our nature is GOOD! It is under concupiscence, though, because of our sin. This weakens our Will and darkens our Intellect…
 
As opposed to most Protestants, Catholics and Orthodox believe that humans are intrinsically GOOD and made GOOD by God in His image and likeness…

We suffer because of the Fall, but were redeemed, and our nature is still under the effects of concupiscence, but this does not mean our nature is depraved.

Catholics and Orthodox defend the goodness intrinsic in humanity because we feel this affect belief in the full humanity of Jesus. The Incarnation would not occur if our nature was intrinsically -by nature- depraved. We were made for Him, through Him and in Him.

Our nature is GOOD! It is under concupiscence, though, because of our sin. This weakens our Will and darkens our Intellect…
If we are essentially good, why, unlike immaculate Mary, did Eve sin, on her first real test, in the story of Adam and Eve?

The Catholic Church teaches, “The LORD looks down from heaven upon the human race, to see if even one is wise, if even one seeks God. *All *have gone astray; *all *alike are perverse. Not one does what is right, not even one.”

Jesus would be excepted-out because the corruption of the human race taught by our Church is the reason why He came; Mary would be excepted-out because while the Church teaches that Mary was immaculately conceived, this state was achieved by the grace won by Christ on the cross. I.e., but for the grace of the cross, Mary, also, would have a perverse heart, gone astray.
 
If we are essentially good, why did Eve sin, on her first real test, in the story of Adam and Eve?
We are essentially good because we have a spiritual, immortal soul, created by God. This soul includes the intellect and will.

Eve sinned because she made an informed choice.
The Catholic Church teaches, “The LORD looks down from heaven upon the human race, To see if even one is wise, if even one seeks God. *All *have gone astray; *all *alike are perverse. Not one does what is right, not even one.”
This is from Scripture. Without the citation, one cannot discern the context. .
Jesus would be excepted-out because the corruption of the human race taught by our Church is the reason why He came; Mary would be excepted-out because while the Church teaches that Mary was immaculately conceived, this state was achieved by the grace won by Christ on the cross.
There is no need for exaggeration about the human race. For really good information about the human race, check out this link.
www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
 
We are essentially good because we have a spiritual, immortal soul, created by God. This soul includes the intellect and will.

Eve sinned because she made an informed choice.
Huh! I have never seen it put that way before, Granny!

In truth, Eve sinned because she was like the rest of us – “All have gone astray; all alike are perverse. Not one does what is right, not even one.”
This is from Scripture. Without the citation, one cannot discern the context.
The inspired Roman Catholic Magisterium, which gives us our Bible Canon by approving it, hammers-home this message several times. Psalm 14:2-3. Romans 3:9-12. Jeremiah 17:9. Psalm 53:3-4.
 
If we are essentially good, why, unlike immaculate Mary, did Eve sin, on her first real test, in the story of Adam and Eve?
Because she chose differently. That’s all there is to it. Jesus’ sacrifice did not make Eve free of original sin before the Fall, Jesus’ sacrifice was not originally needed.
The Catholic Church teaches, “The LORD looks down from heaven upon the human race, to see if even one is wise, if even one seeks God. *All *have gone astray; *all *alike are perverse. Not one does what is right, not even one.”
Is this passage speaking about humans before the Fall, or after?
Jesus would be excepted-out because the corruption of the human race taught by our Church is the reason why He came; Mary would be excepted-out because while the Church teaches that Mary was immaculately conceived, this state was achieved by the grace won by Christ on the cross. I.e., but for the grace of the cross, Mary, also, would have a perverse heart, gone astray.
Jesus would be “excepted-out” because He, first of all, is God. Second of all, He needed to be completely perfect and guilt free of His own accord for the sacrifice to “work”.
 
Huh! I have never seen it put that way before, Granny!
Seriously?
In truth, Eve sinned because she was like the rest of us – “All have gone astray; all alike are perverse. Not one does what is right, not even one.”
Eve was not like the rest of us. If you’re going to claim that the Church teaches this, please back it up with official references.
The inspired Roman Catholic Magisterium, which gives us our Bible Canon by approving it, hammers-home this message several times. Psalm 14:2-3. Romans 3:9-12. Jeremiah 17:9. Psalm 53:3-4.
That’s funny, you’re claiming that your personal interpretation is approved by the Magisterium simply because the Magesterium gave us the Scriptures. I’ve never seen that angle before, clever.
 
Because she chose differently. That’s all there is to it. Jesus’ sacrifice did not make Eve free of original sin before the Fall, Jesus’ sacrifice was not originally needed.
The Catechism, in treating Adam and Eve as nonhypothetical people, and their sin as a nonhypothetical event, says that Adam and Eve were “graced.” See Para. 375-376. As far as I know, all grace was paid for by Christ.

Hypothetical Eve, in my view, was ungraced. That’s the point of the story. Nonhypothetical Mary was graced from conception in a mysterious way.
Is this passage speaking about humans before the Fall, or after?
In my view, the passage is unclear on the point of your question because the Fall is a hypothetical event. The passage, Psalm 14:2-3, is talking about reality. The Original Sin story does not.
Jesus would be “excepted-out” because He, first of all, is God. Second of all, He needed to be completely perfect and guilt free of His own accord for the sacrifice to “work”.
I don’t fully understand the sinlessness of Jesus. I’m not sure anyone does. I agree that He needed to be perfect for His sacrifice to work. Good for you, for your insight on that point. That’s the “blemishless lamb” concept. Good for you.
 
Seriously?

Eve was not like the rest of us. If you’re going to claim that the Church teaches this, please back it up with official references.
Actually, Bookgirl, you have it perfectly backwards.

Grace rains upon us today. The Church claims that Eve, too, was “graced.” See Catechism, Para. 375-376. I say that Eve was a perfectly ungraced hypothetical person. Thus, hypothetical Eve had no chance in the face of temptation.
That’s funny, you’re claiming that your personal interpretation is approved by the Magisterium simply because the Magesterium gave us the Scriptures. I’ve never seen that angle before, clever.
If we view Scripture as a kind of “foreign language” with an inspired meaning essentially unreachable by Joe Schmoe, reading Scripture is useless.

Even the Church claims that the Magisterium frequently perceives and articulates doctrine only slowly.

Sometimes, correct doctrine emerges by virtue of the grace of the Holy Spirit from down below, before it emerges up above, despite the Church’s authority in interpreting Scripture.

How the Church’s authority in interpreting Scripture is manifested, within the course of the pushing and shoving of human events, is a gray area.

Hopefully, my interpretation is within the gray area.

God knows that I am speaking honestly, here, and that I think like that.
 
The Catechism, in treating Adam and Eve as nonhypothetical people, and their sin as a nonhypothetical event, says that Adam and Eve were “graced.” See Para. 375-376. As far as I know, all grace was paid for by Christ.

Hypothetical Eve, in my view, was ungraced. That’s the point of the story. Nonhypothetical Mary was graced from conception in a mysterious way.
In this and other similar posts, there has been a generic usage of the word grace. In the Catechism’s paragraph 375, Adam and Eve were in an original “state of holiness and justice”. Following paragraphs explain this. In order to understand the meaning of paragraphs 375-376, One has to place them in the context of the entire “IV. Man in Paradise” pages 95 -96. Then one needs to look up the various kinds of grace which occurs in Catholicism.
In my view, the passage is unclear on the point of your question because the Fall is a hypothetical event. The passage, Psalm 14:2-3, is talking about reality. The Original Sin story does not.
First of all, it is important to understand the genre of *Psalms *which is not the same as Genesis. This is usually contained in the Bible’s introduction to the book of Psalms. Psalms should be read completely. When this is done, one finds that the Psalm 14 also refers to good people who belong to God who calls them “my people” and in verse 5 “God is with the company of the just.” Last verse identifies the righteous poor with God’s people.

However, when one calls the “Fall” an hypothetical event, it becomes very difficult to interpret Scripture correctly.
 
In this and other similar posts, there has been a generic usage of the word grace. In the Catechism’s paragraph 375, Adam and Eve were in an original “state of holiness and justice”. Following paragraphs explain this. In order to understand the meaning of paragraphs 375-376, One has to place them in the context of the entire “IV. Man in Paradise” pages 95 -96. Then one needs to look up the various kinds of grace which occurs in Catholicism.
Okay, Granny, tells us what in the Catechism indicates that Eve was UNgraced. (Note, by the way, that if you say that she was ungraced, you would, ironically, be agreeing with me.)
First of all, it is important to understand the genre of *Psalms *which is not the same as Genesis. This is usually contained in the Bible’s introduction to the book of Psalms. Psalms should be read completely. When this is done, one finds that the Psalm 14 also refers to good people who belong to God who calls them “my people” and in verse 5 “God is with the company of the just.” Last verse identifies the righteous poor with God’s people.
I actually agree that Psalm 14:2-3 is INTENDED to apply to all, both saved and unsaved.

That’s the point. The heart of ALL – saved and unsaved – which is the thing grace acts upon is deperately wicked.

How often you are agreeing with me today!
However, when one calls the “Fall” an hypothetical event, it becomes very difficult to interpret Scripture correctly.
Nah! All of a sudden, the story makes perfect sense!
 
So, again and again and again and again, the Bible actually hints that man is evil!

That’s why we needed salvation!
So then you do say Jesus was not fully human, and you WERE saying that man is evil. You’re in fact saying that God made bad things, that He didn’t make everything good (despite saying it was ALL VERY GOOD).

You’re saying we are by nature evil and that is the reason for our salvation, instead of what actually happened: God made man, man was good but soon fell, and because of His mercy and love He didn’t destroy His creation but instead came to die for our sins so that we could be saved.

We are indeed saved by His grace and can do nothing good without it or to merit it, but that’s concupiscence.

On your other point of God making us broken, God cannot make another God as you said, but Genesis clearly said “in His IMAGE”. That is to say God didn’t try to make an imperfect copy of Himself. We are LIKE Him, simple as that.

Why did Eve sin? Because she had free will to choose for or against Him. Mary was the opposite in that she made the choice FOR Him.

Why not go a step further and ask why Lucifer and other angels sins, creatures with much MUCH higher intellects than ours, creatures who also happened to actually know God.

Peter, you continue to worry me. You speak of understanding but are showing me none. You’re showing me “your” understanding, under “Pope Peter Dawson’s” authority, instead of aligned to the Church as is required of Catholics. We are called to reason and think for ourselves, but the Church is there to guide us, not to serve as an obstacle to some “truth” you can only discover of your own authority. Your interpretation is most certainly not in the gray area as you continue to think you’re right and the Church isn’t. How’s that gray?

I’ll assume you have read the Catechism as you mock/bother Granny about it. You’re blind to it but there’s a reason several have mentioned you not being Catholic in your words and actions here. I’d ask for you to humbly read the Catechism over again.

Many say pride was the biggest sin, but the sin that started it all, the true root of all evil was DISOBEDIENCE.

May the Lord enlighten you, Peter and open your heart to true wisdom. Peace be with you and God bless you.
 
The Catechism, in treating Adam and Eve as nonhypothetical people, and their sin as a nonhypothetical event, says that Adam and Eve were “graced.” See Para. 375-376. As far as I know, all grace was paid for by Christ.
Well, you’re right that the Church regards the first parents as nonhypothetical, at least you’ll admit that. Correct me if I’m wrong, but grace isn’t really “paid for” by anyone, even Christ. Grace is a free gift, always has and always will be. What the Fall did was cut off our access to this gift, and what Chris did was “open the gates of Heaven” so to speak, He made this free gift accessible to us again. Saying that Christ “paid for” our grace sounds very Protestant to me. The whole infused vs. imputed rightousness thing. Maybe I’m interpreting you wrong. And if I’m misrepresenting official Catholic teaching, someone please let me know. But I think I’ve got it right.
Hypothetical Eve, in my view, was ungraced.
I know, in your view.
In my view, the passage is unclear on the point of your question because the Fall is a hypothetical event. The passage, Psalm 14:2-3, is talking about reality. The Original Sin story does not.
Again Peter, this is your own idea. It’s not the Church’s. I’m not trying to change your mind, but of course we’re going to have very different views on this Psalm if your starting premise to all of Scripture and Salvation history is that the original couple was hypothetical.
I don’t fully understand the sinlessness of Jesus. I’m not sure anyone does. I agree that He needed to be perfect for His sacrifice to work. Good for you, for your insight on that point. That’s the “blemishless lamb” concept. Good for you.
It wasn’t really my insight, it’s something that I was taught and believe to be true.
 
Actually, Bookgirl, you have it perfectly backwards.

Grace rains upon us today.
And grace, in the Garden of Eden, while they were physically with God and walking with Him, did not reign on them? Do you understand the Catholic concept of Purgatory? If you do understand it correctly, then you would understand that the fact that God is physically with them in the Garden means that they were in a state in which they could be with God.
The Church claims that Eve, too, was “graced.” See Catechism, Para. 375-376. I say that Eve was a perfectly ungraced hypothetical person. Thus, hypothetical Eve had no chance in the face of temptation.
If we view Scripture as a kind of “foreign language” with an inspired meaning essentially unreachable by Joe Schmoe, reading Scripture is useless.
Unreachable by Joe Schmoe by himself, yes. Reachable by Joe Schmoe if reading through the “glasses” of the authoritative interpretation of the Church.
Even the Church claims that the Magisterium frequently perceives and articulates doctrine only slowly.
Where? Where does it claim this? Again, you’re saying all these things but not offering any references. Articulates, yes. But you say perceived as if some parts of the truth have yet to be revealed, and this isn’t the case.
Sometimes, correct doctrine emerges by virtue of the grace of the Holy Spirit from down below, before it emerges up above, despite the Church’s authority in interpreting Scripture.
This is pretty vague. What do you mean by “down below” and “up above”? Is down below your own ideas that you think the Church will eventually agree with? :rolleyes:
How the Church’s authority in interpreting Scripture is manifested, within the course of the pushing and shoving of human events, is a gray area.
Again, where do you come up with these conclusions? You keep making all these claims for the Church, yet you sometimes admit they’re your own claims that you think the Church will agree with someday.
 
So then you do say Jesus was not fully human, and you WERE saying that man is evil. You’re in fact saying that God made bad things, that He didn’t make everything good (despite saying it was ALL VERY GOOD).
Because Christ was the Hypostatic Union, He did not face the problem of being less than God, since He was God.

Thus, He was fundamentally different, though, in addition to being fully man, He was fully God.

It was the combination of things on Earth which was very good, not the individual elements, unless God stated that the individual element referred to was “good.”

What is significant is that the Holy Spirit refrained from saying, of the pinnacle creation, “He saw that it was good.”
You’re saying we are by nature evil and that is the reason for our salvation, instead of what actually happened: God made man, man was good but soon fell, and because of His mercy and love He didn’t destroy His creation but instead came to die for our sins so that we could be saved.
Your summary here is rough in several respects. We aren’t “by nature evil.” We are PRONE to evil. Absent grace, nothing will come out of us BUT evil.

To say otherwise is to be a Pelagian.
We are indeed saved by His grace and can do nothing good without it or to merit it, but that’s concupiscence.
I agree.
On your other point of God making us broken, God cannot make another God as you said, but Genesis clearly said “in His IMAGE”. That is to say God didn’t try to make an imperfect copy of Himself. We are LIKE Him, simple as that.
We are “like” God – we are “in His image” – but not in any kind of perfection.

God was aware that a human with an intellect that perceived self-continency and a free will, without the Beatific Vision and without grace, was a “sin machine.”

Thus God intended grace as “a final ingredient.” He didn’t begin to “suddenly intend” His saving sacrifice only after – surprise! surprise! – Eve sinned. He intended grace as the “final ingredient” from all eternity.

You can actually see this portrayed in John’s gospel: Note that the waters of salvation activated by the sacrificed blood of Christ followed Eve out of the side of the New Testament Adam, as He hung on the cross.
Why did Eve sin? Because she had free will to choose for or against Him.
No. Immaculate Mary also had a free will with which to sin. So, just HAVING a free will does not explain Eve’s sin.

Eve was ungraced.

In a sense I can prove this: Why PROMISE a grace-generating Savior, in response to Eve’s sin, if Eve was already graced, in the Original Sin hypothetical?
Mary was the opposite in that she made the choice FOR Him.
I would say that Mary was thoroughly opposite: Unlike hypothetical Eve, Mary was graced. Unlike hypothetical Eve, Mary made countless decisions in favor of God – not just one. And the “one” you are probably thinking of, the Incarnation, would not have been a sin if she had decided against God.
Why not go a step further and ask why Lucifer and other angels sins, creatures with much MUCH higher intellects than ours, creatures who also happened to actually know God.
I personally believe that the sacrifice of the cross purchased grace for the angels, too, and that their moral dilemma was rendered by grace to be comparable to the decisions of graced humans.

 
Peter, you continue to worry me. You speak of understanding but are showing me none. You’re showing me “your” understanding, under “Pope Peter Dawson’s” authority, instead of aligned to the Church as is required of Catholics. We are called to reason and think for ourselves, but the Church is there to guide us, not to serve as an obstacle to some “truth” you can only discover of your own authority. Your interpretation is most certainly not in the gray area as you continue to think you’re right and the Church isn’t. How’s that gray?

I’ll assume you have read the Catechism as you mock/bother Granny about it. You’re blind to it but there’s a reason several have mentioned you not being Catholic in your words and actions here. I’d ask for you to humbly read the Catechism over again.

Many say pride was the biggest sin, but the sin that started it all, the true root of all evil was DISOBEDIENCE.

May the Lord enlighten you, Peter and open your heart to true wisdom. Peace be with you and God bless you.
Liraco, thank you for your relaxed good will.

You need not worry. I am a humble son of the Church.

Re “Pope Peter Dawson,” do you think that the folks here who just throw out the parts of Munificentissimus Deus which they don’t like (see the Assumption thread) are less “popish”?

In truth, who is more Catholic – the one who goes out on a limb and thinks about and professes particulars, or the one who repeatedly takes the “safe” position…

check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

…without particulars?

Isn’t that like saying to the big angry guy who walks up to you, without knowing WHAT he says, “Hey, I agree with what YOU say, because you’re a big angry guy!”?

Is that line…

check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

…anything but a cruel aspersion, intended to imply, “popishly,” “You’re not Catholic!”?

Do you see why I am acetic with Granny?

Are you certain – dead certain – that my interpretation is not “in the gray area”?

Athanasius condemned all three Arian Trinitarian formulas.

Pope Liberius, surrounded by Arian troops, caved, and said, “No. One formula is acceptable,” and condemned Athanasius.

Jerome groaned something like, “The world went to bed Christian, and awakened Arian.”

The Arian Roman Emperor crowed, “It’s Athanasius against the world!”

Then Liberius suddenly condemned his own condemnation, and accepted Athanasius’ formulation.

Suddenly, “Athanasius against the world!” became Athanasius’ own boast!

No matter what, each of us is faced with having to make the faith decision, to the best of his lights.

God knows that I am making mine. He really does. I am not worried about my position in the belief department.

So, don’t worry. I’m okay.

By the way, I have read the Catechism cover-to-cover. I spent about 3 years reading it to the kids before bedtime stories as they grew up.

I will accept your prayers, however. Please ask God to help me in a way pleasing to Him on the question of “Little Nhu.” He will understand what you mean.
 
Friends, here, I have to say that this is a really, really good thread. Thanks.
 
Is that line…

check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

…anything but a cruel aspersion, intended to imply, “popishly,” “You’re not Catholic!”?

Do you see why I am acetic with Granny?
Actually,
“check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm” means that if one wants actual Catholic teaching, one should go to the source.

I am sure you have noticed that there are a lot of issues in your posts which I do not respond to. For varied reasons, that is my choice. I, too, make decisions about faith.
No matter what, each of us is faced with having to make the faith decision, to the best of his lights.

God knows that I am making mine. He really does. I am not worried about my position in the belief department.

So, don’t worry. I’m okay.
While I do worry about three, maybe four, of your positions in the Catholic belief department, I worry more about the readers. I want to give them a fair chance at finding out about Catholicism.
If that bothers anyone, so be it.
I will accept your prayers, however. Please ask God to help me in a way pleasing to Him on the question of “Little Nhu.” He will understand what you mean.
While I have not read all of your posts, I do remember some written from your heart.
I will keep “Little Nhu” in my prayers.

Blessings,
granny

All human life is sacred from the moment of conception.
 
Actually,
“check out this link: www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm” means that if one wants actual Catholic teaching, one should go to the source.

I am sure you have noticed that there are a lot of issues in your posts which I do not respond to. For varied reasons, that is my choice. I, too, make decisions about faith.

While I do worry about three, maybe four, of your positions in the Catholic belief department, I worry more about the readers. I want to give them a fair chance at finding out about Catholicism.
If that bothers anyone, so be it.

While I have not read all of your posts, I do remember some written from your heart.
I will keep “Little Nhu” in my prayers.

Blessings,
granny

All human life is sacred from the moment of conception.
Thank you, Granny. I apologize for misjudging you.
 
And grace, in the Garden of Eden, while they were physically with God and walking with Him, did not reign on them?
Actually, I do believe that grace rained on every single ensouled human being from the first moment our anscestors began to be ensouled.

But I believe that Eve is a hypothetical woman, written-about in a hypothetical to portray to us what each of WOULD do IF grace were not available; and that Adam is a hypothetical man, written-about to portray Christ taking our sins upon Himself.

The Garden of Eden story is about the same speed as a Dr. Seuss story. It isn’t written with details sufficient to answer questions like the one you ask.

Allow me to prove that.

Sin doesn’t really occur the way it is portrayed in the story.

A real Eve would have committed the first sin the instant she glanced at the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, because she was entertaining a near occasion of sin. She would have committed another sin by listening to the serpent’s words after the first sentence. She committed another sin by taking the time to entertain doubts about God’s prohibitions. She committed another sin by forming the intent to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by willing to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by plucking it off the tree and bringing it to her mouth. The actual eating was only the last of many sins.

That’s how complex moral reality really is.

Instead of dealing with such complexities, the story gives us this simple sin of disobedience, ridiculous, undetailed and cartoon-like in its simplicity.

Other corroborrative details: Adam is made of dust from the adamah, “red stuff” meaning “clay,” so that he is the right color to symbolize bloodied Christ.

After Adam calls Eve an ishshah to punningly hint that she is a “herman” (because out of ishah “her man” she was taken), he calls her ewwah, “living,” or “Eve,” because – before she has any children – he knows that she will become “Mother of All the Living.”

This is after she is taken out of a rib to conform to a Babylonian-language pun about her. Nin-ti means both “Lady of the Rib” and “Lady of the Living” in Babylonian.

God is portrayed in a moronic fashion in the story, before Eve is pulled ftom Adam’s side: He tries to match Adam up with animals. That effort fails. God finally conceives of the idea of Eve.

Do you see what I mean? Top to bottom, the story is a detail-less fable, not non-fiction. It is fiction teaching theology.
Do you understand the Catholic concept of Purgatory? If you do understand it correctly, then you would understand that the fact that God is physically with them in the Garden means that they were in a state in which they could be with Gd.
Good for you for that sentence referring to Purgatory. How many Catholics here understand the concept of purgation so well? Few, I bet.

Re your point, notice that God is with them in person AFTER the sin, too. (Remember how He searched them out “at the breezy time of the day”?) This was possible because the inspired author conceiving the story wasn’t concerned with such details.
Unreachable by Joe Schmoe by himself, yes. Reachable by Joe Schmoe if reading through the “glasses” of the authoritative interpretation of the Church.
My Aunt, who was head of the Dominican Ordeer of Nuns in the Western Hemisphere, and a theologian in Catholic University, used to say, “Don’t look to the Church for guidance on Scripture. It has only talked about 5% of it – maybe less.”
Where? Where does it claim this? Again, you’re saying all these things but not offering any references. Articulates, yes. But you say perceived as if some parts of the truth have yet to be revealed, and this isn’t the case.
If you believe in inspiration, it’s philosophically necessary. Every result of inspiration of the Magisterium would be “news” in theology.
This is pretty vague. What do you mean by “down below” and “up above”? Is down below your own ideas that you think the Church will eventually agree with? :rolleyes:
It’s a non-technical reference to the sensum fidelium.
Again, where do you come up with these conclusions? You keep making all these claims for the Church, yet you sometimes admit they’re your own claims that you think the Church will agree with someday.
When I see “X,” should I say, “Look! There’s ‘X’!”? Or should I say, “Look! There’s ‘Not-X’!”?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top