Teflon> You amuse me. You could use some objectivity.
There is a big difference between the use of the term Apocrypha and the Deuterocanonicals. Apocrypha is not inspired, where the Deuterocanonicals are.
By referring to Tobit as Apocrypha, PC Master is trying once again to insult the Catholic Church…This is a Catholic forum, the proper language should be used.
First, I wasn’t speaking as to the inspired status of the works, which I believe I clarified, so I’m not sure why this is such a big deal for you. I was merely speaking of a work outside what I was raised as considering as scripture.
Obviously, I’m well aware of the status of these other writings in history, which is a part of why I intend to read them (at some point).
I’m just giving the brother the benefit of the doubt. Some times we should be Christian, even if (no, especially if) we think someone else is not.
Thank you.
If PC intends to insult, he will continue to, but if its an honest mistake, then we can let our brother know that we can be charitable Christians.
Unfortunately, it seems like some people intend
to be insulted.
He will continue to insult. This is not the first time I’ve addressed this, nor the first time that I’ve reported this behavior.
I don’t recall having addressed the deuterocanonical/apocrypal issue before. What makes you so sure I intended it as an insult, especially when I’m saying that I did not?
I know what you are saying, but I feel that supporting my Church is being Christian.
Putting aside that I wasn’t meaning the statement to reflect a belief system – Are you saying I should defer to your (personal) beliefs? And if so, on what grounds? I’ve said nothing insulting, and even clarified my use of a potentially offensive term when I realized it might cause offense. What more do you expect from me? Or is it that you also have an axe to grind (again, for what reason this might be, I just don’t understand)?
…St. Paul was the biggest anti-Christian around. And he came around…I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt.
Well, I wouldn’t consider myself anti-Christian, so I’m not sure the analogy quite compares. In any case, thanks for not taking offense at something that wasn’t meant to be offensive.
BTW, PCMaster, I’m still ready to stock up on Honey Roasted Peanuts should the need arise!!!
I’m sure you are. Honestly, I find that very disturbing.
Then again, maybe it’s not that serious to you because you like peanuts. How about something you dislike?
Say you are having the same discussion on Baptist Boards or something like that. If you referred to the writings as the Deuterocanonicals instead of the apocrypha, would it be fair for them to consider that an insult.
Calling this an insult reeks of hypersensitivity.
Unfortunately there are hypersensitive people on both sides of most issues. There are quite a few here, and I’m sure there are some on just about every forum you might visit – especially religiously-focused ones. People would do well to try to have a bit more objectivity and charity all around.
I would call them “the deuterocanonicals” (what you guys fondly refer to as “the Apocrypha”). I think that explains my belief while respecting theirs.
While that’s probably ideal, it would get to be a bit of a mouthful. I used to call the RCC the “church which calls itself Catholic and is in communion with the Bishop of Rome” but that got to be a bit too much to use regularly. When I came here, I just used “Roman Catholic”. I’ve explained the use, and what I mean by it, probably a dozen times now, yet people still take offense. Some people look for problems, and will find fault no matter what you do.

And of course, it’s not only Roman Catholics that do this.