"We Believe Scripture, Except When It Supports Catholic Dogma"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Although I agree with your reasoning, I disagree with your cataloging of Tobit as Apochrypha. Different thread, of course.
It was just a generic term to refer to the works outside of commonly accepted scripture in the non-Roman-Catholic/Eastern-Orthodox realm.
 
There is a big difference between the use of the term Apocrypha and the Deuterocanonicals. Apocrypha is not inspired, where the Deuterocanonicals are.

By referring to Tobit as Apocrypha, PC Master is trying once again to insult the Catholic Church.

This is a Catholic forum, the proper language should be used.
 
There is a big difference between the use of the term Apocrypha and the Deuterocanonicals. Apocrypha is not inspired, where the Deuterocanonicals are.

By referring to Tobit as Apocrypha, PC Master is trying once again to insult the Catholic Church.

This is a Catholic forum, the proper language should be used.
I’m just giving the brother the benefit of the doubt. Some times we should be Christian, even if (no, especially if) we think someone else is not.

If PC intends to insult, he will continue to, but if its an honest mistake, then we can let our brother know that we can be charitable Christians.
 
He will continue to insult. This is not the first time I’ve addressed this, nor the first time that I’ve reported this behavior.

I know what you are saying, but I feel that supporting my Church is being Christian.
 
He will continue to insult. This is not the first time I’ve addressed this, nor the first time that I’ve reported this behavior.

I know what you are saying, but I feel that supporting my Church is being Christian.
Maybe so. But you know, St. Paul was the biggest anti-Christian around. And he came around.

I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt.

BTW, PCMaster, I’m still ready to stock up on Honey Roasted Peanuts should the need arise!!! 😉
 
"We Believe Scripture, Except When It Supports Catholic Dogma"
:rotfl:

DrBible1611 needs to look at his KJV closer. I just bought a copy of the alleged 1611 Edition…it contains the deuterocanonical texts. The original contained the same in the same order as the “Catholic bible”. I put quotes around it because in reality they’re all Catholic bibles when you get down to it. It’s just that some of them have a little “doctoring” going on to justify their non-Catolic agendas.

If it helps. Drbible sounds a lot like me. Understanding us requires a lot of patience and enduring. The dynamics are complicated. I thought I knew a lot too and then wham…upside the head comes the didache, ancheint church fathers and a new line educated Catholic converts right off the shelf. Scott Hahn, Bruce Sullivan, Tim Staples, etc… Before I left the Church I was reading Karl Keatings book and it was having the opposte effect on me. Can’t explain it but God used it for good. I returned with the wife who proselytized me along with her family, beating me upside the head with their KJV’s while isolated in the military away from my resources…Catholics and priests willing to help me. I was a seminarian. If you don’t think you should DEFEND the faith…keep this in mind. Had I had support then I’d be wearing a black shirt with a white collar today. I am a former seminarian. Our seminarians need to learn apologetics the way fundamentalist do. We, the Church, need it to help us get through all this trouble.

Tiber Swim Team 2007 left as one returned as five.

Pax Christi tecum
 
By referring to Tobit as Apocrypha, PC Master is trying once again to insult the Catholic Church.
No, the term reflects what the writings are in his belief system. Why should he use your language.

Let me flip this around.

Say you are having the same discussion on Baptist Boards or something like that. If you referred to the writings as the Deuterocanonicals instead of the apocrypha, would it be fair for them to consider that an insult.

Calling this an insult reeks of hypersensitivity.
 
No, the term reflects what the writings are in his belief system. Why should he use your language.

Let me flip this around.

Say you are having the same discussion on Baptist Boards or something like that. If you referred to the writings as the Deuterocanonicals instead of the apocrypha, would it be fair for them to consider that an insult.

Calling this an insult reeks of hypersensitivity.
I would call them “the deuterocanonicals” (what you guys fondly refer to as “the Apocrypha”). I think that explains my belief while respecting theirs.
 
I would call them “the deuterocanonicals” (what you guys fondly refer to as “the Apocrypha”). I think that explains my belief while respecting theirs.
Bingo.👍

Then PCMaster is doing the same thing (not that you are the one that said PCMaster was insulting y’all)
 
Bingo.👍

Then PCMaster is doing the same thing (not that you are the one that said PCMaster was insulting y’all)
Let’s remember the Scriptures - “How many times should I forgive my brother, 7 times?” (I bet Peter was so proud of showing how magnanimous he was before being shot down with the 70 times 7 reproach!) - and give PCM the benefit of the doubt. If he continues to do it, then you can treat him like a gentile or a Tax Collector!
 
No, the term reflects what the writings are in his belief system. Why should he use your language.

Let me flip this around.

Say you are having the same discussion on Baptist Boards or something like that. If you referred to the writings as the Deuterocanonicals instead of the apocrypha, would it be fair for them to consider that an insult.

Calling this an insult reeks of hypersensitivity.
Perhaps you will reflect that in this thread, I, a Catholic, am:

a) willing to argue a key Scripture passage concerning the most important sacrament of the Church, the Eucharist;

b) willing to do so using Scripture alone, despite my belief in the validity of the Magisterium and Tradition which produced said Scripture;

c) willing to do so using the strictest sense of “Scripture alone”; namely, relying on not one extra-Scriptural word to make the case;

d) willing to do so using the favored Protestant translation of the Bible, despite it being unauthorized by the Church and riddled with translation and other errors.

Where is drbible1611, to whom I’ve gone to great lengths to accommodate with this thread, and to whom I’ve granted the most favorable ground a Protestant fundamentalist KJV-onlyer could have?

The trouble with Protestants, in my view, is that you insist upon whatever terminology and whatever limits you must have to feel most comfortable within your particular envelope of theological cognitive dissonance, thereby excluding extant evidence to the contrary of your favored position, then cry foul whenever someone from the Church doesn’t adjust to the chimera sufficiently.

It is a rare occasion indeed for a Protestant apologist to cheerfully grant the Catholic the favor of inoffensive terminology, much less attempt to argue their case from ALL the evidence.

Are Protestants, and particular Protestant fundamentalists, such hothouse flowers that mere good manners toward a Catholic might wilt their faith?
 
Let’s remember the Scriptures - “How many times should I forgive my brother, 7 times?” (I bet Peter was so proud of showing how magnanimous he was before being shot down with the 70 times 7 reproach!) - and give PCM the benefit of the doubt. If he continues to do it, then you can treat him like a gentile or a Tax Collector!
I’ve seen enough of this ill-mannered silliness from him that he’s already an IRS agent bereft of a mitzvah.

Honest inquirers need no such crutches.
 
I’ve seen enough of this ill-mannered silliness from him that he’s already an IRS agent bereft of a mitzvah.
What???:hmmm:… Oh, Ahhhhhhhhhhh!!! :rotfl:
He’s a tax collector AND a gentile!!! We’ll see.
Honest inquirers need no such crutches.
I like to shorten people’s names when addressing people sometimes, Tef. One time I referred to Protestant101 as “Prot101”. I didn’t mean any disrespect, but the warning I received from our friendly neighborhood moderators pointed out the error of my ways. I didn’t intend to insult anyone, and pointed this out to P101 (is that better, mods?). He understood and laughed about it.

I’d prefer to give PCM the benefit of the doubt. But if the leopard continues to show his spots…
 
Let’s remember the Scriptures - “How many times should I forgive my brother, 7 times?” (I bet Peter was so proud of showing how magnanimous he was before being shot down with the 70 times 7 reproach!) - and give PCM the benefit of the doubt. If he continues to do it, then you can treat him like a gentile or a Tax Collector!
Continues to do what? Use the word “apocrypha”?

The word “apocrypha” just represents his belief system that these books are not canonical and are apocryphical writings.

Why should this be considered an insult? Whether these books are apocryphical or deuterocanonical is the subject of the debate. Why should either of you concede your language.
 
What???:hmmm:… Oh, Ahhhhhhhhhhh!!! :rotfl:
He’s a tax collector AND a gentile!!! We’ll see.
I like to shorten people’s names when addressing people sometimes, Tef. One time I referred to Protestant101 as “Prot101”. I didn’t mean any disrespect, but the warning I received from our friendly neighborhood moderators pointed out the error of my ways. I didn’t intend to insult anyone, and pointed this out to P101 (is that better, mods?). He understood and laughed about it.

I’d prefer to give PCM the benefit of the doubt. But if the leopard continues to show his spots…
Of course, your mileage may vary, and PCM might well prove us mistaken yet.

A good test of this in my view will come whenever drbible1611 shows up. If PCM doesn’t attempt to derail the thread, stock in your assessment will shoot up dramatically.
 
Teflon> You amuse me. You could use some objectivity.
There is a big difference between the use of the term Apocrypha and the Deuterocanonicals. Apocrypha is not inspired, where the Deuterocanonicals are.

By referring to Tobit as Apocrypha, PC Master is trying once again to insult the Catholic Church…This is a Catholic forum, the proper language should be used.
First, I wasn’t speaking as to the inspired status of the works, which I believe I clarified, so I’m not sure why this is such a big deal for you. I was merely speaking of a work outside what I was raised as considering as scripture.

Obviously, I’m well aware of the status of these other writings in history, which is a part of why I intend to read them (at some point).
I’m just giving the brother the benefit of the doubt. Some times we should be Christian, even if (no, especially if) we think someone else is not.
Thank you. 🙂
If PC intends to insult, he will continue to, but if its an honest mistake, then we can let our brother know that we can be charitable Christians.
Unfortunately, it seems like some people intend to be insulted. 😦
He will continue to insult. This is not the first time I’ve addressed this, nor the first time that I’ve reported this behavior.
I don’t recall having addressed the deuterocanonical/apocrypal issue before. What makes you so sure I intended it as an insult, especially when I’m saying that I did not?
I know what you are saying, but I feel that supporting my Church is being Christian.
Putting aside that I wasn’t meaning the statement to reflect a belief system – Are you saying I should defer to your (personal) beliefs? And if so, on what grounds? I’ve said nothing insulting, and even clarified my use of a potentially offensive term when I realized it might cause offense. What more do you expect from me? Or is it that you also have an axe to grind (again, for what reason this might be, I just don’t understand)?
…St. Paul was the biggest anti-Christian around. And he came around…I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt.
Well, I wouldn’t consider myself anti-Christian, so I’m not sure the analogy quite compares. In any case, thanks for not taking offense at something that wasn’t meant to be offensive.
BTW, PCMaster, I’m still ready to stock up on Honey Roasted Peanuts should the need arise!!! 😉
I’m sure you are. Honestly, I find that very disturbing.

Then again, maybe it’s not that serious to you because you like peanuts. How about something you dislike?
Say you are having the same discussion on Baptist Boards or something like that. If you referred to the writings as the Deuterocanonicals instead of the apocrypha, would it be fair for them to consider that an insult.

Calling this an insult reeks of hypersensitivity.
Unfortunately there are hypersensitive people on both sides of most issues. There are quite a few here, and I’m sure there are some on just about every forum you might visit – especially religiously-focused ones. People would do well to try to have a bit more objectivity and charity all around.
I would call them “the deuterocanonicals” (what you guys fondly refer to as “the Apocrypha”). I think that explains my belief while respecting theirs.
While that’s probably ideal, it would get to be a bit of a mouthful. I used to call the RCC the “church which calls itself Catholic and is in communion with the Bishop of Rome” but that got to be a bit too much to use regularly. When I came here, I just used “Roman Catholic”. I’ve explained the use, and what I mean by it, probably a dozen times now, yet people still take offense. Some people look for problems, and will find fault no matter what you do. 😦 And of course, it’s not only Roman Catholics that do this.
 
Teflon> You amuse me. You could use some objectivity.
I’ll remove the splinter from my eye when you pull the log from yours. Deal?
While that’s probably ideal, it would get to be a bit of a mouthful. I used to call the RCC the “church which calls itself Catholic and is in communion with the Bishop of Rome” but that got to be a bit too much to use regularly. When I came here, I just used “Roman Catholic”.** I’ve explained the use, and what I mean by it, probably a dozen times now, yet people still take offense. **Some people look for problems, and will find fault no matter what you do. 😦 And of course, it’s not only Roman Catholics that do this.
And some people are simply rude because they are incapable of making a compelling, reasoned argument.

Catholic with a capital C is sufficient to both avoid offense and to avoid confusion (such as may be) with catholic with a small C. Lots of your brethren do it. So why don’t you?

Might it be intent to offend? Or to derail discussion threads when the topic doesn’t suit you?
 
Just one comment/question…

Why is the term “Roman Catholic” that offensive anyway?

In my small community there is a road sign “St. Anthony’s Roman Catholic Church” with a left arrow pointer (it might be abbreviated RC I forgot) to a small Roman Catholic church.

It would seem to me that if St. Anthony’s Roman Catholic Church can call themselves Roman Catholic that y’all shouldn’t get all hot under the collar if an anonymous internet poster calls you that.
 
Just one comment/question…

Why is the term “Roman Catholic” that offensive anyway?

In my small community there is a road sign “St. Anthony’s Roman Catholic Church” with a left arrow pointer (it might be abbreviated RC I forgot) to a small Roman Catholic church.

It would seem to me that if St. Anthony’s Roman Catholic Church can call themselves Roman Catholic that y’all shouldn’t get all hot under the collar if an anonymous internet poster calls you that.
The adjective “Roman” refers to the liturgical rite in use by a particular person or a particular small-c church. In its strict technical sense, the term excludes the Eastern Catholic Churches, which are in communion with the Bishop of Rome but have different liturgical traditions. This exclusion sometimes offends some people, though it requires that they use the most technical sense of the term “Roman Catholic.”

St. Anthony’s is right to call itself what it does because it does, in fact, use the Western liturgy; it could also be a Chaldean Catholic, Byzantine Catholic, or Maronite church (for example), and in those cases it would describe itself accordingly.

IMVHO, in practice most people equate the term “Roman Catholic” with “everyone who is in communion with the Bishop of Rome,” so when they use the term that way I’m willing to assume they meant it in that sense. I’d rather save my energy for getting offended at the terms “Romanist” and “Romanism.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top