"We Believe Scripture, Except When It Supports Catholic Dogma"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, had to look that up.

n. a member of an Eastern church that is in union with the Roman Catholic Church, acknowledges the Roman pope as supreme in matters of faith, but maintains its own liturgy, discipline, and rite.
:confused: Isn’t that right? Does it depend on the tone of voice used that determines whether it’s meant as an adjective or an insult?
Yea…
They may not mean it to be offensive, but that is saying it charitably. I know to many stories about it now…I’ve talked to several Orthodox priests now and I find many of them to be in need of a personality adjustment;) .

Imagine being a person of color and someone who grew up in the 40 talking to you. Do you think the choice of words would be offensive like 'boy" or someother offensive word, even though said nicely. No difference here. The same logic is when someone calls me “Roman”…I hate that. I am Catholic in the Latin Rite. It’s petty but its my preference. I put up with it, but I don’t have to like it.
 
Yea…
They may not mean it to be offensive, but that is saying it charitably. I know to many stories about it now…I’ve talked to several Orthodox priests now and I find many of them to be in need of a personality adjustment;) .

Imagine being a person of color and someone who grew up in the 40 talking to you. Do you think the choice of words would be offensive like 'boy" or someother offensive word, even though said nicely. No difference here. The same logic is when someone calls me “Roman”…I hate that. I am Catholic in the Latin Rite. It’s petty but its my preference. I put up with it, but I don’t have to like it.
It will be interesting to see how this fares once the Orthodox and Catholic Churches are in full union again. What could be more ludicrous than telling a Greek he is Roman?
 
Misapplying Scripture is one of the things we need to correct you on, sandusky. We Catholics are Christians, after all, are we not?
Speaking for my church only, we do Mt 18 members; however, I’ve never heard of any Catholic Church doing that; granted, I’ve not talked to members of every Catholic Church on the planet, but those whom I’ve asked if they Mt 18’d, didn’t understand what I was talking about; therefore, in my post, I didn’t refer to Mt 18.

Besides, protestants aren’t under the authority of the CC, so there’d be no point in using Mt 18.
 
I ask you again, who says I haven’t? You seem to be quick in judging me.
Who says you haven’t?

Why, you do!
Code:
  			Originally Posted by **sodak** 					 				
  		*As for forgiving - you can't forgive when people don't apologize and continue to insult*. You want to call that hypersensitivity - fine. I'll continue to call it as I see it
 
Do you mean sandusky instead of Sandy? 🤷
:whistle:Oops!!! My bad! I was calling Sandusky “Sandy” for short. I had no clue that your name is Sandy. Maybe I should pay more attention to people signatures, eh?
 
Speaking for my church only, we do Mt 18 members; however, I’ve never heard of any Catholic Church doing that; granted, I’ve not talked to members of every Catholic Church on the planet, but those whom I’ve asked if they Mt 18’d, didn’t understand what I was talking about; therefore, in my post, I didn’t refer to Mt 18.

Besides, protestants aren’t under the authority of the CC, so there’d be no point in using Mt 18.
We simply call it “ex-communicated”. But it takes people way higher up than our congregation to do it.

Isn’t the church for the sick, though? When someone gets excommunicated, it’s because they were teaching heresy.

BTW, just because you deny being subject to the Law of Physics, doesn’t mean you can jump off a cliff and expect to float! 😉
 
We simply call it “ex-communicated”. But it takes people way higher up than our congregation to do it.
Not in all cases. One can excommunicate him/herself. If a Catholic person has an abortion (kind of an oxymoron), it is an automatic excommunication from the Body of Christ. They have to go to Confession in order to be back in the Catholic Church.
Isn’t the church for the sick, though? When someone gets excommunicated, it’s because they were teaching heresy.
Or committed a mortal sin. Confession is the only thing that can cure them. So yes I agree that the Church is for “sick people.” Didn’t Jesus call the sinners and not the righteous? Yes. So the Catholic Church is for the “sick.” So the best place to go when you are sick is to Confession.
BTW, just because you deny being subject to the Law of Physics, doesn’t mean you can jump off a cliff and expect to float! 😉
😃 LOL
 
Not in all cases. One can excommunicate him/herself. If a Catholic person has an abortion (kind of an oxymoron), it is an automatic excommunication from the Body of Christ. They have to go to Confession in order to be back in the Catholic Church.
Be that as it may, they can still attend Mass, even while in a state of Mortal Sin.

When Sandusky says they MT 18’d someone, it means they’ve tossed them out of the Church and are no longer allowed to attend… Locally, that entails a public announcement at the Church.
 
He will continue to insult. This is not the first time I’ve addressed this, nor the first time that I’ve reported this behavior.

I know what you are saying, but I feel that supporting my Church is being Christian.
Greetings,

Just catching up in this thread. While I am not a Roman Catholic I appreciate your zeal sodak. I didn’t realize RC’s get insulted when others refer to the the books we consider apocryphal as that. The question raised in my mind, which perhaps can be taken to a different thread or answered here is are you equally offended when the ECF’s state the same convictions as protestants on this issue of what they consider to be apocryphal?

Kind regards,
theLogos
 
Oy… are folks here offended if the term Roman Catholic is used? I sincerely don’t mean that as an offense. If so, please fill me in and I’ll be happy to accommodate.

Regards,
Logos
 
Oy… are folks here offended if the term Roman Catholic is used? I sincerely don’t mean that as an offense. If so, please fill me in and I’ll be happy to accommodate.

Regards,
Logos
Works for me, not so sure about all the Easten Catholics.

Chuck
 
Oy… are folks here offended if the term Roman Catholic is used? I sincerely don’t mean that as an offense. If so, please fill me in and I’ll be happy to accommodate.

Regards,
Logos
Not all Catholics are Roman Catholic, that’s all.
 
Thanks guys. 😃

As I study history I know I would be considered “catholic” (not sure if capital or small) in the sense that the early church used the term. I also realize prior to 100AD I would be considered by the Roman government an atheist and a convert to Judaism! 😃

Peace and thanks,
Logos
 
Thanks guys. 😃

As I study history I know I would be considered “catholic” (not sure if capital or small) in the sense that the early church used the term. I also realize prior to 100AD I would be considered by the Roman government an atheist and a convert to Judaism! 😃

Peace and thanks,
Logos
Why not just use Catholic with a capital C for the 1.3 billion of us in communion under the authority of the Vicar of Chist on Earth, Pope Benedict XVI?

Not only does it save you typing, it’s more accurate.
 
Greetings,

Just catching up in this thread. While I am not a Roman Catholic I appreciate your zeal sodak. I didn’t realize RC’s get insulted when others refer to the the books we consider apocryphal as that. The question raised in my mind, which perhaps can be taken to a different thread or answered here is are you equally offended when the ECF’s state the same convictions as protestants on this issue of what they consider to be apocryphal?

Kind regards,
theLogos
one will most likely notice that none of the EFC’s will agree with the protestant position after the council’s decsion on which books are to be in the canon of the bible.after the yr 400 aprox
 
Thanks guys. 😃

As I study history I know I would be considered “catholic” (not sure if capital or small) in the sense that the early church used the term. I also realize prior to 100AD I would be considered by the Roman government an atheist and a convert to Judaism! 😃

Peace and thanks,
Logos
The study of history could best help the search of the many for the true church, since there have been more than thirty three thousand christian churches in the whole world, and some of them are claiming that they are also catholic. For the first one thousand years, since Christ built His church, as seen in Mat. 16: 18, christianity was united and obedient to the Bishop of Rome, which we called the Pope. But in the succeeding years there have been many desertions naming their respective churches they founded.
Not all Catholics are Roman Catholic, that’s all.
If these people, by accident or by chance, happened to read these two prominent standard references (internationally known), they might have the second thought.

" There are two equally valid definitions of the Catholic Church, comparable to the two fold nature of Jesus Christ, its founder, who was both human and divine."
( International Encyclopedia Vol. 15 pp. 520 )

" The Catholic Church…is the divine society founded by Jesus Christ, endowed by the outpouring of the Holy Spirit on the day of the Pentecost. This name denotes the body of the faithful in communion with the Bishop of Rome hence it is often called the Roman Catholic Church. "
( Grollier’s Encyclopedia Vol. 5 pp. 106 )
 
I’ll remove the splinter from my eye when you pull the log from yours. Deal?
The very fact that you make a statement like that shows you have an axe to grind. I really just don’t understand this. Why is this the case?
Catholic with a capital C is sufficient to both avoid offense and to avoid confusion (such as may be) with catholic with a small C. Lots of your brethren do it. So why don’t you?
Precisely because it is not sufficient. To use the term catholic as opposed to Catholic would require me to explain the use frequently, lest I be confused as one who considers the church headquartered in Rome as the true universal (catholic) church of Christ. The RCC, in my belief, has members who are a part of the catholic church. Likewise, Eastern Orthodoxy and others also contain the same, in my view.

Also, you’ll note that I usually refer to the Eastern Orthodox, and not simply “orthodox”. Why? Because to say orthodox in reference only to the Eastern Orthodox churches is to imply that I believe they are orthodox, and by extension, that everyone else is not orthodox. I don’t believe this to be true, so I won’t say it this way.
Might it be intent to offend? Or to derail discussion threads when the topic doesn’t suit you?
Not at all.
The adjective “Roman” refers to the liturgical rite…
Which is it? Roman or Latin Rite? If Roman is truly this confusing, then please tell me what other descriptive term I can add to “Catholic” to prevent the confusion I seek to prevent, while still not being offensive. I’ve offered several possibilities, and it seems like you guys are just not happy with anything except people conceding to your view that you are the one and only universal church. This is a position I do not accept, however.
This exclusion sometimes offends some people, though it requires that they use the most technical sense of the term “Roman Catholic.”
Right. At least Roman and Catholic are both valid (at least by your own view) descriptors of that church. You are subject to Rome (as opposed to any of the other “catholic” churches which have authority seated elsewhere). You also claim to be catholic.
I’d rather save my energy for getting offended at the terms “Romanist” and “Romanism.”
Yes – see, these terms are in line with “Protestant” in terms of being offensive. I intentionally avoid very offensive terms, including papist, etc, as my goal is not, nor ever was, to insult. Interestingly, I do still see use of terms like “fundies”, “schismatics”, “heretics”, etc.
The problem is that they say “The Roman Catholic Church believes/teaches…” as if the Maronite, Ruthenian, Byzantine, Alexandrian, Syriac, Armenian, Chaldean, etc. Catholic Churches do not. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I’d say that probably they are not aware of the 22 other Rites that are just as Catholic as the Roman (Latin) Rite.
You have not noted, however that I and others have expressed complete awareness of the other rites housed within the RCC umbrella.
The Catechism is called the Catechism of the Catholic Church,
I’m sure it is – I’m also sure that others, like the “Old Catholics”, and various other “Catholic” groups, have their own documents which refer to them as being “The Catholic Church”. This is precisely the kind of thing that makes me avoid inaccurate and nonspecific terms.
…when statements are made about Church teaching, it’s important to know that these teachings are not exclusively “Roman” teachings.
Has anyone here been confused about this? I don’t believe I have been.
This is a Catholic forum. To refer to the Deuterocanonicals as uninspired literature such as Apocrypha is wrong and continued use of the term is offensive. It degrades the status of the Deuterocanonicals.

If I were on a Baptist Board, I would use their terminology, but in parenthesis explain my position.
So if you were in a Baptist forum, you’d be willing to refer to the RCC as Satan’s Playground if that’s what the members there believed? Would you clarify every time you used the term Catholic that you were referring to the church headquartered in Rome if they believed they were part of the one true universal church? Or would you hold to what you personally believe to be true?

At least I’m not intentionally being offensive like some have done in the past.
I’ll change my opinion when the attacks on my Church stop. As for forgiving - you can’t forgive when people don’t apologize and continue to insult.
Yes, you can, and you should.

Seventy times seven, anyone?
You want to call that hypersensitivity - fine. I’ll continue to call it as I see it.
Why not try to make peace, instead of sitting at your computer insisting on being offended? If my use of the term Roman Catholic and Apocrypha have offended you, I am truly sorry for the offense. It was not, and is not, my intent. However, if this is something so serious to you, I ask that you understand how serious a matter it is to me. I also ask that you prayerfully consider some middle ground on which we can agree.

I’m not tied to describing the RCC as “Roman”. I just wish to avoid confusion with the generic meaning of the word, and using a capital letter just isn’t good enough, in my mind.
And while we meander along, drbible1611 remains elusive…I’ll keep track.
To what end? What is it you hope to accomplish? Why the animosity toward non-Roman-Catholics? Surely this only hurts both you and individuals like myself and drbible, instead of promoting unity, wouldn’t you agree?
As Protestants are our brothers and sisters, we are called upon to correct them:
Correction in love is appreciated. Correction with animosity and self-righteousness is not. Now why don’t we stop bickering, and start communicating, eh? 🙂
 
Correction in love is appreciated. Correction with animosity and self-righteousness is not. Now why don’t we stop bickering, and start communicating, eh? 🙂
😦 It’s too bad that many non-Catholics will not recognize our love when we try to correct them. No matter how charitable we can be with what we believe, they will not see it as love. If they don’t believe the same thing we do, they will not see love even if all the love in the world is used.

I tried that with my protestant brother and he said I was Satan and that I insulted him very much. All I was doing was telling him what I believed. I never once called him any names. I never once called him a devil, or did anything of the kind. I thought I was being as loving as possible but since he didn’t believe the same thing, he took it as an insult and told me outright that I was hurtful and that I was the devil. He said many other cruel things to me that I will not post here.

I forgave him for all the mean things he said to me. And while I was not insulting to him I still apologized over & over again.

So what you think is “self-righteousness” might just be an assurance of what they believe. And they could be portraying it in love but you might not think that just because it is different from what you believe.

So what would help tremendously is if you have an open mind and an open heart and not be so offended right away if we try to correct. I will try to do the same. No. Correction, I will ask the Holy Spirit to motivate me to do the same.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top