M
mozart-250
Guest
Actually I understand what PCMaster is saying.
Why should he use language that is not reflective of what he believes. For that matter why should you.
To have a fair debate, you must be fair in allowing what language is used. You have two choices: (1) agree in neutral terminology or (2) allow some slack in what both sides use for terms and not take offense when either side uses these terms in good faith.
What must not be allowed in order to have a fair debate, is censoring the terminology used to reflect one side of the debate only. It would be like having an abortion debate where the only allowable terms are 'pro-choice" and “anti-choice”.
So to address this issue on the nature of the church.
I have read often here where you refer to Protestant churches as ecclesiastical communities. Now I could choose to take offense at that as showing a lack of respect (in the same way that some of you choose to take offense when the term Roman Catholic is used). However, I understand that you use those words because in your belief system we are somewhat less than churches.
So if you do not call us churches, I understand and do not take offense. You are just not conceding the language here. You are not trying to be offensive.
In a very similar vein PCMaster does not want to call you all Catholic because to him, you are not the universal church. He likewise is just not conceding the language, not trying to be offensive.
Although I think much of this is silly, refusing to concede the language is not the same as deliberately causing offense. On both sides. If we don’t take offense when you call our churches ecclesiastical communities, you should not take offense if we don’t use the word catholic to describe your churches.
For the record, I personally don’t have a problem using the word Catholic. However, once and a while I get ornery and refuse to concede the language, particularly when those who disagree with me are doing the same. When that occurs I use the word Catholic denomination.
Now I have been “corrected” when I use the word denomination with “Catholic”. However, the dictionnary definition of the word denomination supports its use here.
Why should he use language that is not reflective of what he believes. For that matter why should you.
To have a fair debate, you must be fair in allowing what language is used. You have two choices: (1) agree in neutral terminology or (2) allow some slack in what both sides use for terms and not take offense when either side uses these terms in good faith.
What must not be allowed in order to have a fair debate, is censoring the terminology used to reflect one side of the debate only. It would be like having an abortion debate where the only allowable terms are 'pro-choice" and “anti-choice”.
So to address this issue on the nature of the church.
I have read often here where you refer to Protestant churches as ecclesiastical communities. Now I could choose to take offense at that as showing a lack of respect (in the same way that some of you choose to take offense when the term Roman Catholic is used). However, I understand that you use those words because in your belief system we are somewhat less than churches.
So if you do not call us churches, I understand and do not take offense. You are just not conceding the language here. You are not trying to be offensive.
In a very similar vein PCMaster does not want to call you all Catholic because to him, you are not the universal church. He likewise is just not conceding the language, not trying to be offensive.
Although I think much of this is silly, refusing to concede the language is not the same as deliberately causing offense. On both sides. If we don’t take offense when you call our churches ecclesiastical communities, you should not take offense if we don’t use the word catholic to describe your churches.
For the record, I personally don’t have a problem using the word Catholic. However, once and a while I get ornery and refuse to concede the language, particularly when those who disagree with me are doing the same. When that occurs I use the word Catholic denomination.
Now I have been “corrected” when I use the word denomination with “Catholic”. However, the dictionnary definition of the word denomination supports its use here.