"We Believe Scripture, Except When It Supports Catholic Dogma"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually I understand what PCMaster is saying.

Why should he use language that is not reflective of what he believes. For that matter why should you.

To have a fair debate, you must be fair in allowing what language is used. You have two choices: (1) agree in neutral terminology or (2) allow some slack in what both sides use for terms and not take offense when either side uses these terms in good faith.

What must not be allowed in order to have a fair debate, is censoring the terminology used to reflect one side of the debate only. It would be like having an abortion debate where the only allowable terms are 'pro-choice" and “anti-choice”.

So to address this issue on the nature of the church.

I have read often here where you refer to Protestant churches as ecclesiastical communities. Now I could choose to take offense at that as showing a lack of respect (in the same way that some of you choose to take offense when the term Roman Catholic is used). However, I understand that you use those words because in your belief system we are somewhat less than churches.

So if you do not call us churches, I understand and do not take offense. You are just not conceding the language here. You are not trying to be offensive.

In a very similar vein PCMaster does not want to call you all Catholic because to him, you are not the universal church. He likewise is just not conceding the language, not trying to be offensive.

Although I think much of this is silly, refusing to concede the language is not the same as deliberately causing offense. On both sides. If we don’t take offense when you call our churches ecclesiastical communities, you should not take offense if we don’t use the word catholic to describe your churches.

For the record, I personally don’t have a problem using the word Catholic. However, once and a while I get ornery and refuse to concede the language, particularly when those who disagree with me are doing the same. When that occurs I use the word Catholic denomination.

Now I have been “corrected” when I use the word denomination with “Catholic”. However, the dictionnary definition of the word denomination supports its use here.
 
Actually I understand what PCMaster is saying.

Why should he use language that is not reflective of what he believes. For that matter why should you.

To have a fair debate, you must be fair in allowing what language is used. You have two choices: (1) agree in neutral terminology or (2) allow some slack in what both sides use for terms and not take offense when either side uses these terms in good faith.

What must not be allowed in order to have a fair debate, is censoring the terminology used to reflect one side of the debate only. It would be like having an abortion debate where the only allowable terms are 'pro-choice" and “anti-choice”.

So to address this issue on the nature of the church.

I have read often here where you refer to Protestant churches as ecclesiastical communities. Now I could choose to take offense at that as showing a lack of respect (in the same way that some of you choose to take offense when the term Roman Catholic is used). However, I understand that you use those words because in your belief system we are somewhat less than churches.

So if you do not call us churches, I understand and do not take offense. You are just not conceding the language here. You are not trying to be offensive.

In a very similar vein PCMaster does not want to call you all Catholic because to him, you are not the universal church. He likewise is just not conceding the language, not trying to be offensive.

Although I think much of this is silly, refusing to concede the language is not the same as deliberately causing offense. On both sides. If we don’t take offense when you call our churches ecclesiastical communities, you should not take offense if we don’t use the word catholic to describe your churches.

For the record, I personally don’t have a problem using the word Catholic. However, once and a while I get ornery and refuse to concede the language, particularly when those who disagree with me are doing the same. When that occurs I use the word Catholic denomination.

Now I have been “corrected” when I use the word denomination with “Catholic”. In that case my response has always been the dictionary.
 
The very fact that you make a statement like that shows you have an axe to grind. I really just don’t understand this. Why is this the case?
You really don’t understand logic, do you?

Pointing out that you’re the least objective, fact-based inquisitor around here is hardly axe-grinding. Anyone who reads enough of your posts gets it. For you to claim anyone else is insufficiently objective is amusing.
Precisely because it is not sufficient. To use the term catholic as opposed to Catholic would require me to explain the use frequently, lest I be confused as one who considers the church headquartered in Rome as the true universal (catholic) church of Christ. The RCC, in my belief, has members who are a part of the catholic church. Likewise, Eastern Orthodoxy and others also contain the same, in my view.
Well, Pope PCM, that’s a very comforting thing!

You haven’t read closely enough, apparently. My suggestion was to use “catholic” with a capital, not a small, C when referring to the Church. That way it is easily distinguished from whatever invisible church you aScripturally claim to belong to. But that’s not the point of using RC for you, is it?
Also, you’ll note that I usually refer to the Eastern Orthodox, and not simply “orthodox”. Why? Because to say orthodox in reference only to the Eastern Orthodox churches is to imply that I believe they are orthodox, and by extension, that everyone else is not orthodox. I don’t believe this to be true, so I won’t say it this way.
Sounds like you’ve got plenty of axes to grind, PCM. Log. Eye. Remove.

I myself have no trouble using Orthodox. Nor do I have any trouble using Baptist despite the fact they don’t perform infant baptisms, Pentectostal although they were 1,800 years too late for Pentecost, Episcopal although their bishops aren’t valid, etc.
Which is it? Roman or Latin Rite? If Roman is truly this confusing, then please tell me what other descriptive term I can add to “Catholic” to prevent the confusion I seek to prevent, while still not being offensive. I’ve offered several possibilities, and it seems like you guys are just not happy with anything except people conceding to your view that you are the one and only universal church. This is a position I do not accept, however.
Add nothing. Catholic suffices, with a capital C. The capital has nothing to do whatsoever with the veracity of the Church’s claim. This is why those of us who are more familiar with your posts think you’re being disingenuous. One presumes you don’t agree with nor belong to other Protestant denominations, yet employ descriptive labels for them.
Right. At least Roman and Catholic are both valid (at least by your own view) descriptors of that church. You are subject to Rome (as opposed to any of the other “catholic” churches which have authority seated elsewhere). You also claim to be catholic.
The Vatican is not Rome. The Papal States have been gone for a long time. It is not accurate to use the term in this sense. As has been noted, many times. You simply don’t care to be accurate.
Yes – see, these terms are in line with “Protestant” in terms of being offensive. I intentionally avoid very offensive terms, including papist, etc, as my goal is not, nor ever was, to insult. Interestingly, I do still see use of terms like “fundies”, “schismatics”, “heretics”, etc.
As your own posts demonstrate, Protestant is an accurate label. Perhaps when you manage to show enough obedience and unity to whittle down the thousands upon thousands of denominations, it will be less useful of an umbrella term. Given all the Anything But Catholics among your ranks, you’ll be Protesting a long time.
You have not noted, however that I and others have expressed complete awareness of the other rites housed within the RCC umbrella.
Yes, and I and others have noted you continue to use inaccurate formulations like the one above. Eastern Catholics are not under the “RCC umbrella”—there is no such thing. They are Catholics of a different rite than the Roman or Latin.
I’m sure it is – I’m also sure that others, like the “Old Catholics”, and various other “Catholic” groups, have their own documents which refer to them as being “The Catholic Church”. This is precisely the kind of thing that makes me avoid inaccurate and nonspecific terms.
Yet you continue to embrace “Roman Catholic” when speaking of 1.3 billion Catholics, millions of which belong to non-Roman rites. Why not quit weaseling out of explaining why, since accuracy is clearly not it?
So if you were in a Baptist forum, you’d be willing to refer to the RCC as Satan’s Playground if that’s what the members there believed? Would you clarify every time you used the term Catholic that you were referring to the church headquartered in Rome if they believed they were part of the one true universal church? Or would you hold to what you personally believe to be true?
Everyone except you, PCM, uses Catholic quite well. Even The New York Times, which is no friend to the Church. Your bigotry is showing.
At least I’m not intentionally being offensive like some have done in the past.
I’m sure you have an odd definition of “intentionally”. You persist in error, despite giving offense, and despite being corrected. You’ve crossed the line into “intentionally being offensive” a long time ago, you just lack the intestinal fortitude to say so.
Seventy times seven, anyone?
Heathen and publican, anyone?
Why not try to make peace, instead of sitting at your computer insisting on being offended? If my use of the term Roman Catholic and Apocrypha have offended you, I am truly sorry for the offense. It was not, and is not, my intent. However, if this is something so serious to you, I ask that you understand how serious a matter it is to me. I also ask that you prayerfully consider some middle ground on which we can agree.
Ah, the completely insincere apology. Hint, PCM----sincere apologies are never preceded by “If…” clauses. The middle ground is well-trodden: “Catholic”, capital C. It’s good enough for everybody else, it’s good enough for you.
I’m not tied to describing the RCC as “Roman”. I just wish to avoid confusion with the generic meaning of the word, and using a capital letter just isn’t good enough, in my mind.
Unfortunately, etiquette involves considering the opinions of others, not just yourself. You place too high a value on what you think versus what others think, which is why you perpetually offend.
To what end? What is it you hope to accomplish? Why the animosity toward non-Roman-Catholics? Surely this only hurts both you and individuals like myself and drbible, instead of promoting unity, wouldn’t you agree?
This is a discussion forum—we discuss. A false unity requiring that Truth go undefended may be the ideal in your community, but we respect Truth here. As anyone not blinded by their own prejudice can see, drbible1611 requested this thread—I posted his chain of responses in another. And as anyone can see, he’s a no-show. Wonder why?
Correction in love is appreciated. Correction with animosity and self-righteousness is not. Now why don’t we stop bickering, and start communicating, eh? 🙂
Why don’t you stop using Roman Catholic when talking about the teachings of the Catholic Church? THAT’s what keeps derailing threads.

Unless derailing threads is your aim, PCM.

:tsktsk:
 
For the record, I personally don’t have a problem using the word Catholic. However, once and a while I get ornery and refuse to concede the language, particularly when those who disagree with me are doing the same. When that occurs I use the word Catholic denomination.

Now I have been “corrected” when I use the word denomination with “Catholic”. In that case my response has always been the dictionary.
It is a question of inaccuracy, not conceding the language.

What PCM and other who insist on using Roman Catholic when speaking of the Catholic Church as a whole is to diminish the size, scope, and unity of the Church. There are 1.3 billion of us, all recognizing the authority of the Vicar of Christ on Earth, Pope Benedict XVI. Moreover, we share common Tradition and Scripture.

Those who obstinately insist on “RCC” aren’t doing so out of some purity of semantics, but because they seek to treat the Catholic Church as though she were a mere aggregation of different communities, exactly as the Protestants are.

It is therefore an attempt to ignore the fact that unity does exist, and the Catholic Church exemplifies it.

It is not a refusal to “concede language”, but to foster the phony argument promulgated in the deceitful propaganda of “Trail of Blood” and other things.

Holding onto “Roman” is important to anti-Catholics for one other reason: Revelation.

THAT is the discussion they won’t cop to, lest their bigotry rear its ugly head in too bold a fashion.
 
Who says you haven’t?

Why, you do!
No, that statement was intended to be a reflection of the other person’s refusal to admit to wrongdoing. You can try and forgive someone who doesn’t think they are wrong, but it doesn’t go very far. That doesn’t mean you still don’t try.
Greetings,

Just catching up in this thread. While I am not a Roman Catholic I appreciate your zeal sodak. I didn’t realize RC’s get insulted when others refer to the the books we consider apocryphal as that. The question raised in my mind, which perhaps can be taken to a different thread or answered here is are you equally offended when the ECF’s state the same convictions as protestants on this issue of what they consider to be apocryphal?

Kind regards,
theLogos
No, of course not. This is a valid discussion. What would come up, however, is how the ECF would come in line with the Magesterial teachings, admit they were wrong, and submit to the Church. Once that is brought out, then continuing to use the ECF to “prove” certain Scriptures are not inspired would then be disingenuous and offensive.

It’s all in context, as well as whether or not someone is repeatedly trying to slander the Church. I would have thought that was clear.
So if you were in a Baptist forum, you’d be willing to refer to the RCC as Satan’s Playground if that’s what the members there believed? Would you clarify every time you used the term Catholic that you were referring to the church headquartered in Rome if they believed they were part of the one true universal church? Or would you hold to what you personally believe to be true?

At least I’m not intentionally being offensive like some have done in the past.

Seventy times seven, anyone?

Why not try to make peace, instead of sitting at your computer insisting on being offended? If my use of the term Roman Catholic and Apocrypha have offended you, I am truly sorry for the offense. It was not, and is not, my intent. However, if this is something so serious to you, I ask that you understand how serious a matter it is to me. I also ask that you prayerfully consider some middle ground on which we can agree.

Correction in love is appreciated. Correction with animosity and self-righteousness is not. Now why don’t we stop bickering, and start communicating, eh? 🙂
I’ll address these one by one.

If there was a Baptist forum where such offensive terms were being used, I wouldn’t take part in it.

As for the seventy times seven comments, let me explain. When someone uses a term, I try to read context into it. If it’s non-insulting, usually a post with an explanation will suffice. If it becomes a habitual thing, then the poster is doing things on purpose. Warm and fuzzies don’t work in this case. I’m happy to defend the Church as best as I can seventy times seven.

The term Apocrypha is certainly not offensive in and of itself. But using it to refer to Scripture is offensive (and wrong), and should be called out by Catholics. This should be obvious.

As other Catholic posters have noted, these threads almost never result in everyone agreeing. I’m much more concerned with lurkers and others coming by later and reading the content.

If you think that I’m going to quit arguing for the truth because I might look “mean” or “unforgiving”, then you don’t understand the nature of this forum. Maybe you can silence others that way, but it doesn’t work with me. I might get tired of posting because of repetition, but I’m not going to back off of a stand because someone thinks I’m not “forgiving” enough.

It’s certainly not asking very much of posters to use non-offensive language on this forum. It in no ways displays compromising their beliefs.
 
No, that statement was intended to be a reflection of the other person’s refusal to admit to wrongdoing. You can try and forgive someone who doesn’t think they are wrong, but it doesn’t go very far. That doesn’t mean you still don’t try.
Well then, if that’s the case, I’m sorry. I took it for your adamant refusal to forgive someone else.

I’m sorry. Forgive me? 🤷
 
Of course! But it’s an honest disagreement, so there’s nothing to forgive you for! Sometimes I’m not as clear as I should be, so I do apologize for that also. It’s hard to get things into writing sometimes, but not doing so correctly is my fault, not yours!
 
It is a question of inaccuracy, not conceding the language.
OK…then your choices are
(1) Agree upon an alternative term that is not “conceding the language” to him and is not offensive. Maybe the term “Catholic denomination”.
(2) Cut PCM some slack here
(3) Sanitize this place so that all terms that might be offensive to anybody are banned (including heretic and ecclesiastical community).

What you can not have is a one sided environment in terms of language used. That would be debating abortion in terms of pro-choice and anti-choice.
Those who obstinately insist on “RCC” aren’t doing so out of some purity of semantics, but because they seek to treat the Catholic Church as though she were a mere aggregation of different communities, exactly as the Protestants are.
How do you know that to be the case with all that use the term RCC. Unless you know that to be true for all, then you right now are using the allness fallacy (ascribing to all the characteristics of a few).
It is therefore an attempt to ignore the fact that unity does exist, and the Catholic Church exemplifies it.
The nature and extent of the unity within Catholicism has been a debated item on this board. Unless your intent here is to stifle debate.
It is not a refusal to “concede language”, but to foster the phony argument promulgated in the deceitful propaganda of “Trail of Blood” and other things.

Holding onto “Roman” is important to anti-Catholics for one other reason: Revelation.

THAT is the discussion they won’t cop to, lest their bigotry rear its ugly head in too bold a fashion.
Umm…see my comments about the allness fallacy.

Specifically with PCMaster, given his profile and what little I have read about him, I doubt whether he holds the beliefs you are indicating here. If that is the case, then you are doing the exact same thing I have heard over and over again is objectionable to Catholics…that is Protestants telling them what they believe.
 
BTW, what is the original subject of this thread again?

(I’m surprised we haven’t had a visit from our friendly neighborhood moderators, yet…)
 
OK…then your choices are
(1) Agree upon an alternative term that is not “conceding the language” to him and is not offensive. Maybe the term “Catholic denomination”.
(2) Cut PCM some slack here
(3) Sanitize this place so that all terms that might be offensive to anybody are banned (including heretic and ecclesiastical community).
And here’s the fallacy of excluding options.

How about:
  1. PCM use the commonly accepted term, Catholic (capital C)?
It’s not an issue of political correctness. This is a Catholic forum. It’s not called “Roman Catholic Answers” for a reason.
What you can not have is a one sided environment in terms of language used. That would be debating abortion in terms of pro-choice and anti-choice.
That would be irrelevant. We are talking out accuracy.
How do you know that to be the case with all that use the term RCC. Unless you know that to be true for all, then you right now are using the allness fallacy (ascribing to all the characteristics of a few).
The allness fallacy is when someone insists upon a binary all-or-nothing position where none exists, as you are doing. It is not necessary for ALL Protestants to do anything in order for a generalization to be true. You might recall the concept “the exception proves the rule”. I work with statistics all day long. We deal in probabilities. They are almost never 1 or 0. That doesn’t mean we can’t make a lot of money generalizing on the basis of how close to 1 and 0 something may be in the probability space.

Likewise, it is not necessary for something to be true of ALL Protestants for it to be true of PCM.
The nature and extent of the unity within Catholicism has been a debated item on this board. Unless your intent here is to stifle debate.
Completely destroyed your own argument----if it’s to be debated, why should the Catholic “concede the language” by adopting the language of the non-Catholic?
Umm…see my comments about the allness fallacy.
Saw them; misapplied.
Specifically with PCMaster, given his profile and what little I have read about him, I doubt whether he holds the beliefs you are indicating here. If that is the case, then you are doing the exact same thing I have heard over and over again is objectionable to Catholics…that is Protestants telling them what they believe.
You have read little indeed. Stick around and see whether you change your mind.

He’s trolled enough of my threads that I know what he’s about.

You’ll note I predicted above he would attempt to derail this one:
Of course, your mileage may vary, and PCM might well prove us mistaken yet.

A good test of this in my view will come whenever drbible1611 shows up. If PCM doesn’t attempt to derail the thread, stock in your assessment will shoot up dramatically.
Looks like it, huh?

That’s what I mean by playing the probabilities, my friend. 👍
 
NotWorthy [/quote said:
We simply call it “ex-communicated”. But it takes people way higher up than our congregation to do it.

Well, you don’t understand Mt 18 either, IMO. It’s not the congregation that “ex-communicates, but the elders, and that after a lengthy process of counselling and calling to repentance; in fact, the one being disciplined is not put out of the church, but his sin, and his refusal to repent of it is “told” to the church, as the passage instructs. You’re church doesn’t do that, at least, not in my experience, and the experience of those I’ve talked with.

Most who are disciplined will leave, but they’re not forcibly removed.

The whole point of Mt 18 is repentance and restoration.
40.png
NotWorthy:
Isn’t the church for the sick, though? When someone gets excommunicated, it’s because they were teaching heresy.
You Catholics are very captivated with things heretical, aren’t you?

No, the most common discpline with respect respect to Mt 18 has to do with marital infidelity and abandonment.
40.png
NotWorthy:
BTW, just because you deny being subject to the Law of Physics, doesn’t mean you can jump off a cliff and expect to float!
I’m not talking physics, but authority; usually those who claim to have it don’t; the group who claims its authority the loudest is the one whose authority is found to be a pretense.
 
BTW, what is the original subject of this thread again?

(I’m surprised we haven’t had a visit from our friendly neighborhood moderators, yet…)
drbible1611 hasn’t bothered to show up for the thread he requested, which to PCM is a great sign of unity, but to the rest of us speaks of an unattractive evasiveness.

For those keeping score, the same thing happened the last time we tried to put “Scripture interprets Scripture” and “Scripture alone” to the test—PCM attempted to derail, and we tried mightily to get anyone to take up the cause (SyCarl, to his credit, did.) You can check out that thread if it doesn’t feel too much like Groundhog Day; you’ll also find my good faith attempt to meet this challenge, which represented some 8-10 hours of my life I’ll never get back.

I suppose all we can do is continue to call on the carpet those who make such claims. Perhaps some day they’ll try to back them up.
 
Well, you don’t understand Mt 18 either, IMO. It’s not the congregation that “ex-communicates, but the elders, and that after a lengthy process of counselling and calling to repentance; in fact, the one being disciplined is not put out of the church, but his sin, and his refusal to repent of it is “told” to the church, as the passage instructs. You’re church doesn’t do that, at least, not in my experience, and the experience of those I’ve talked with.

Most who are disciplined will leave, but they’re not forcibly removed.

The whole point of Mt 18 is repentance and restoration.
It’s a lot harsher in the churches around me that I’m familiar with. Church of Christ is the one that stands out where I live.
You Catholics are very captivated with things heretical, aren’t you?
Well… if you were divinely appointed out to protect and guard the truth… wouldn’t you? 😉
 
drbible1611 hasn’t bothered to show up for the thread he requested, which to PCM is a great sign of unity, but to the rest of us speaks of an unattractive evasiveness.

For those keeping score, the same thing happened the last time we tried to put “Scripture interprets Scripture” and “Scripture alone” to the test—PCM attempted to derail, and we tried mightily to get anyone to take up the cause (SyCarl, to his credit, did.) You can check out that thread if it doesn’t feel too much like Groundhog Day; you’ll also find my good faith attempt to meet this challenge, which represented some 8-10 hours of my life I’ll never get back.

I suppose all we can do is continue to call on the carpet those who make such claims. Perhaps some day they’ll try to back them up.
I thought this thread was looking familiar. :cool: Do you recall who it was that prompted the first thread? I didn’t read through the whole thing to see if that poster ever made an appearance.

It does seem strange that drbible1611 practically begged you to start a thread on John 6 and then hasn’t even posted once to at least thank you for starting the thread he asked for, and perhaps let us know he’s terribly busy and cannot participate as fully as he’d like.
 
OK…then your choices are
(1) Agree upon an alternative term that is not “conceding the language” to him and is not offensive. Maybe the term “Catholic denomination”.
(2) Cut PCM some slack here
(3) Sanitize this place so that all terms that might be offensive to anybody are banned (including heretic and ecclesiastical community).

What you can not have is a one sided environment in terms of language used. That would be debating abortion in terms of pro-choice and anti-choice.
Exactly.

Look, if it makes anyone happy, I’ll use the odd term Vatican Catholic. Is that okay with you, Teflon? The one thing I really won’t use is just “Catholic”, because that is confusing, given that I don’t believe your church constitutes the one true catholic church.
How do you know that to be the case with all that use the term RCC. Unless you know that to be true for all, then you right now are using the allness fallacy (ascribing to all the characteristics of a few).
It doesn’t matter if it applies to all or not. It’s just a matter of whether it applies to someone such as myself, in this case. IT doesn’t. Let’s move on.

Interestingly, prior to here, I’d never heard Roman as a description of a rite – it was always “Latin Rite”.

But anyway, I’ve offered (for the second or third time now) to use another term such as Vatican Catholic. The unwillingness of others to accept it is something I cannot change, unfortunately. My guess is they have no wish to try to meet on a middle ground.
The nature and extent of the unity within Catholicism has been a debated item on this board. Unless your intent here is to stifle debate.
Teflon’s posts do seem to have a large amount of rhetoric in them. I originally took him to be young and overzealous in his defense of Roman Catholicism, but I’m honestly not sure what his motivations are any longer.
drbible1611 hasn’t bothered to show up for the thread he requested, which to PCM is a great sign of unity, but to the rest of us speaks of an unattractive evasiveness.
A sign of unity? What? How does him not showing up reflect on unity either way?
For those keeping score, the same thing happened the last time we tried to put “Scripture interprets Scripture” and “Scripture alone” to the test—PCM attempted to derail, and we tried mightily to get anyone to take up the cause (SyCarl, to his credit, did.) You can check out that thread if it doesn’t feel too much like Groundhog Day; you’ll also find my good faith attempt to meet this challenge, which represented some 8-10 hours of my life I’ll never get back.
You should start by accepting that almost no one among Protestantism adheres to sola scriptura in the sense you believe. Almost all believe that common reasoning and historical information play a part in interpreting scripture. Then again, if you’ve met someone that actually believes no outside reasoning of any kind is required, let me know. Until then, you’re just setting up straw men.
I suppose all we can do is continue to call on the carpet those who make such claims. Perhaps some day they’ll try to back them up.
A dog metaphor? Do you have no respect for non-Roman-Catholics at all?

I’ll continue to pray for you.
 
Look, if it makes anyone happy, I’ll use the odd term Vatican Catholic. Is that okay with you, Teflon? The one thing I really won’t use is just “Catholic”, because that is confusing, given that I don’t believe your church constitutes the one true catholic church.
I am not offended. I simply correct and continue to correct your errors. I don’t care what term you use; I will continue to point out inaccurate terms.
It doesn’t matter if it applies to all or not. It’s just a matter of whether it applies to someone such as myself, in this case. IT doesn’t. Let’s move on.
The Atomic Church of Me rears its head again.
Interestingly, prior to here, I’d never heard Roman as a description of a rite – it was always “Latin Rite”.
Interestingly, your knowledge of Catholicism is lacking.
But anyway, I’ve offered (for the second or third time now) to use another term such as Vatican Catholic. The unwillingness of others to accept it is something I cannot change, unfortunately. My guess is they have no wish to try to meet on a middle ground.
We believe the Eucharist to be the actual body and blood of Christ and the consumption of it required for salvation.

Will you meet us on the middle ground by adopting consubstantiation?
Teflon’s posts do seem to have a large amount of rhetoric in them. I originally took him to be young and overzealous in his defense of Roman Catholicism, but I’m honestly not sure what his motivations are any longer.
My motivation is to defend the Truth. What’s yours?
A sign of unity? What? How does him not showing up reflect on unity either way?
You apparently believe that conflict precludes unity. He has not shown up; therefore there can be no conflict—behold: unity.
You should start by accepting that almost no one among Protestantism adheres to sola scriptura in the sense you believe. Almost all believe that common reasoning and historical information play a part in interpreting scripture. Then again, if you’ve met someone that actually believes no outside reasoning of any kind is required, let me know. Until then, you’re just setting up straw men.
No, I’m calling blusterers on the carpet. I’ve posted drbible1611’s demands that Catholics argue without any tradition at all, by Scripture alone.

Put aside for the moment that Scripture is the product of Tradition. Put aside that Christ didn’t write the Gospel and hand it to the apostles to read.

Catholics have the honesty to admit that we rely not just on Scripture, but also on Tradition and authority (Magisterium). Most Protestants (exception largely Anglicans) claim to rely on Scripture alone. You do not. You cannot. Which is what these threads seek to establish. That you do not even try is definitive.
A dog metaphor? Do you have no respect for non-Roman-Catholics at all?
I’ll continue to pray for you.
Now you’ve crossed the line into the ridiculous.

It has nothing to do with dogs.

Here is the etymology, lest you embarrass yourself further:
Summon for a scolding or rebuke, as in Suspecting a leak to the press, the governor called his press secretary on the carpet. This term began as on the carpet, which in the early 1700s referred to a cloth (carpet) covering a conference table and therefore came to mean “under consideration or discussion.” In 19th-century America, however, carpet meant “floor covering,” and the expression, first recorded in 1902, alluded to being called before or reprimanded by a person rich or powerful enough to have a carpet.
Do get a grip on yourself.
 
Teflon93,

My apologies for taking so long to post, rest assured I have not been trying to be evasive.

I understand that the Teflon93 v drbible1611 debate was to be restricted PURELY to Scripture alone. Although I have not read all of the posts I have noticed that some have already strayed from the rules, that being the case I will make just one extra-biblical quote:

What and Why of Catholicism, Imprimatur Cardinal Spellman

'The sacrifice of the Mass forms a pivot upon which all else turns. If it is what Catholics believe it is, it is the greatest manifestation of the love of God for man and the most magnificent testimonial to the validity of Catholicism; but if it be false, it is the worst farce and blasphemy ever perpetrated upon God or man, and the Catholic faith collapses into nothingness."

Please note that I am not being disrespectful to Roman Catholic beliefs but simply quoting a Roman Catholic source!
 
drbible1611 claims to be an ex-Catholic who is now a King James Version Only fundamentalist.

He also claims to be familiar with the Catholic Catechism and other Church documents.

He also claims to hew to sola scriptura.

We will put these claims to the test.

Here is John 6. I want to see how KJV-only fundamentalists interpret the clear commands of Christ—using Scripture alone. Not one word of man-made intepretation will be allowed.

Let’s see how someone who claims to cling only to Scripture does when every other aid is removed.

Feel free to call foul if either drbible1611 or myself injects so much as one word of interpretation, starting now.
Since I believe the entire Bible to be the INSPIRED WORDS of God I will heed to St Paul’s command in 1 Cor 2:13…“comparing spiritual things with spiritual”

John Chapter 6

51I am the living bread which came down from heaven: if any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever: and the bread that I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.

53Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, ye have no life in you.

54Whoso eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day.

55For my flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed.

Now, these verses 51, 53-55 'IF’ taken literally must mean that the Bible approves of CANNIBALISM: the eating and drinking of a man’s literal flesh and blood.

Please correct me if I am wrong but the consecrated wafer IS the BODY, BLOOD, SOUL and DIVINITY of Christ and is to be worshipped as God Almighty!

If this is the case, then we have a problem for the eating of LITERAL blood is condemned in the Bible by God Almighty Himself:

Before the LAW:

“But flesh with the life thereof, which is the blood thereof, shall ye not eat.” (Gen 9:4)

During the** LAW**: Leviticus 17:

10And whatsoever man there be of the house of Israel, or of the strangers that sojourn among you, that eateth any manner of blood; I will even set my face against that soul that eateth blood, and will cut him off from among his people.

12Therefore I said unto the children of Israel, No soul of you shall eat blood, neither shall any stranger that sojourneth among you eat blood.

14For it is the life of all flesh; the blood of it is for the life thereof: therefore I said unto the children of Israel, Ye shall eat the blood of no manner of flesh: for the life of all flesh is the blood thereof: whosoever eateth it shall be cut off.


After the** Law **(under grace):

“But that we write unto them, that they abstain from pollutions of idols, and from fornication, and from things strangled, **and from blood.” **(Acts 15:20)

Now, Jesus said in Mt 5:17: Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.

If Jesus was commanding His disciples to drink blood He was going against His own commandments as recorded in the Bible and was therefore a liar and a sinner!
*
“Let God be TRUE, but every man a liar”* (Rom 3:4)
 
14For it is the life of all flesh; the blood of it is for the life thereof: therefore I said unto the children of Israel, Ye shall eat the blood of no manner of flesh: for the life of all flesh is the blood thereof: whosoever eateth it shall be cut off.
I am struck by your rendering of verse 14. For my RSV says,
“For the life of every creature is the blood of it; therefore I have said to the people of Israel, You shall not eat the blood of any creature, for the life of every creature is its blood.”

This would seem to fit in very nicely with Jesus’ words in John 6.
a) You shall not eat the blood of the creature - Jesus is NOT a creature, He is the Creator.
b) for the life of every creature is its blood - We share in Jesus’ Life when we partake of the Eucharist.

I’d be interested in the correct rendering of this verse. If I’m correct, the KJV rendering of this verse agrees with the Latin Vulgage - which was translated from the Hebrew (bypassing the Greek Septuagint). The RSV’s rendering of this verse agrees with the Greek Septuagint.

I’m not sure if this is accurate, though. Any scholars out there able to verify this?
 
I am struck by your rendering of verse 14. For my RSV says,
“For the life of every creature is the blood of it; therefore I have said to the people of Israel, You shall not eat the blood of any creature, for the life of every creature is its blood.”

This would seem to fit in very nicely with Jesus’ words in John 6.
a) You shall not eat the blood of the creature - Jesus is NOT a creature, He is the Creator.
b) for the life of every creature is its blood - We share in Jesus’ Life when we partake of the Eucharist.

I’d be interested in the correct rendering of this verse. If I’m correct, the KJV rendering of this verse agrees with the Latin Vulgage - which was translated from the Hebrew (bypassing the Greek Septuagint). The RSV’s rendering of this verse agrees with the Greek Septuagint.

I’m not sure if this is accurate, though. Any scholars out there able to verify this?
2 Cor 5:17: “Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new.”

Well, there’s the problem. My FINAL AUTHORITY is the King James Bible. I believe EVERY WORD is INSPIRED and WITHOUT ERROR!

So if the RSV is correct God forbids the eating of animal blood throughout the Bible but condones and in fact commands the eating of God’s blood and human flesh???

What about Acts 15:20?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top