It’s far from monotonous when Trevor Pinnock and the English Concert play it on period instruments in the original instrumentation and in historically-informed style and with the accompanying gigue…
Agree with you, Guitar.
Also, when musicians treat a piece that they’ve played millions of times like it’s the first time they played it with the same zeal as when they first heard it or learned it, that beauty definitely comes out. Yes, we get asked all the time to play almost the same pieces for each wedding, and, yes, it would be preferable if they chose other pieces that we either suggested, etc. but why give them a half-hearted ‘performance’?
Some pieces become monotonous to us because we hear them all the time, where as these people don’t. Even when I don’t like a piece of music that I’m hired to sing (whether it is a good or bad composition), I do my best to find what good or smidgeon of good there might be in the music. I can’t say this of all of my colleagues with whom I work and with whom I am friends, but some, including myself, will do our darndest to make a piece beautiful or less cheesy or fresh and inspiring no matter how many times we’ve played it or how much we dislike it. That’s one of the challenges of being a musician and the beauty of being an artistic musician.
Anyway… getting back to wedding music. Sacred is always the best, but “absolute” music can be permitted, such as the Pachelbel “Canon in D”. It has no sacred nor secular connotation. It is considered just pure music. The Wagner “Bridal Chorus” and Mendelssohn “Wedding March” should not be played because they are from an opera and a ballet respectively, so they would not be considered just pure, absolute music.
This is what we had for our mass. Music liturgy is very important to my husband and I as it helps us with our prayer and because we were both members of the choir where we got married. We had a choir, soloist and organist, so most of everything was with choir.
Bridesmaids - 18th Variation from “Goldberg Variations” (on organ, and played at more of an Andante tempo - worked very beautifully) - J.S. Bach
Bride - O God Beyond All Praising (Just on organ)
Kyrie & Gloria - Missa “Aeterna Christi Munera” - Palestrina
Psalm 145 - Gelineau psalmody
Gospel Acclamation - Alleluia from “O Filii et Filiae”
Prayer of Intercession - Chanted
Offertory - A New Commandment - Thomas Tallis
Acclamations - We had them chanted in Latin, including the Our Father. Amen had a choral expansion by Thomas Luis de Victoria.
Agnus Dei - Missa “Aeterna Christi Munera” - Palestrina
Communion - Ave Verum Corpus - Gabriel Faure
Laudate Dominum from “Vesperae Solemnes de confessore in C” - Mozart
Presentation to the Blessed Mother - Ave Maria - Gabriel Faure
Recessional - Organ Fugue in D-Major - J.S. Bach
One of my favorite motets is “Sicut Cervus” by Palestrina, so we had that as one of the preludes.