What do you tell someone who accuses you of worshipping statues?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kevin_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you want to have a bit of fun with them… tell them:

“Oh no! You have it all wrong! I’m not worshiping the statue of the saint. I’m worshiping the stone that the statue is made of!”
Haha, that’s pretty good.
 
Someone told me the other day that Catholics are idolaters because we kneel in front of statues to pray, which means we are worshipping the statue.

I told him that meant kneeling by your bed to pray is worshipping your bed, and praying at the table before meals must be worshipping your food. That actually helped him understand that you aren’t always praying to whatever is in front of you, and I used the opportunity to tell him that we worship God, but we simply ask saints to worship God on our behalf.

Of course this individual was not converted, but I honestly think he has more understanding of our faith than before. I always find it useful to use humor to get people to see your side of an issue. I just thought I’d like to share that, and see what others have experienced in issues like this.
If you have the opportunity go to Walshingsham, England sometime. I was there several years ago and witnessed busloads of dear souls worshipping that statue of Mary.
Grace and Peace,
QC
 
If you have the opportunity go to Walshingsham, England sometime. I was there several years ago and witnessed busloads of dear souls worshipping that statue of Mary.
Grace and Peace,
QC
Of course - just like the bus loads of tourists you see in Washington every day worshipping those big old statues of Jefferson, Lincoln et al 😉
 
Came across this once in a forum…and this is how I retorted:

From Rev 8…4 The smoke of the incense, together with the prayers of God’s people, went up before God from the angel’s hand.
…snip…
So I asked…who is bringing the prayers to God in this passage?
The former passage is acutally quite strong; NOTICE: The angels are around the throne, yet people adore God bowing to where the angels stand! Bowing before them proximately.

Also: In the second passage, the Priests who are between the people and God are also the ones who offer the sacrifice of prayer as incense; These are falling down before the angels, and they themselves are acting as angels (message bearers) to God.

More, later in the post…
I had a thought about this statue question the other day.

Strict protestants may not have statues of Jesus, but they certainly watch movies and about Him. …snip… If making statues of Jesus is blasphemous, then is not watching a movie - where actors (living statues) are dressed-up like Him - even more blasphemous? I
Film is actually a material where chemicals are selectively removed by light – it is technically a graven image – but not a statue. Both were forbidden in Exodus/Duteronomy; I agree with your point.
Please Explain Exodus 20:4-5… Thanks.
Answer later in the post…
If you have the opportunity go to Walshingsham, England sometime. I was there several years ago and witnessed busloads of dear souls worshipping that statue of Mary.
Grace and Peace,
QC
Did you ask them what they were doing? If not, then you don’t really know. Even if you think they are wrong… their ignorance would excuse them from any great sin.

In the Catholic tradition, statues are often placed next to – over-- or under the tabernacle; In that case, one is merely giving adoration (latria) to God in the Eucharist; If one does not belive in the real presence of Jesus in the FLESH (soma/sarks) then such a motion would be considered idol-latria (idolatry).
However, food that one eats is part of the body by a natural conversion – the Eucharist, then, may be understood as something Jesus transforms into his body; just without chewing. 😉 – “This is my body; DO THIS in remembrance of me.”

There are several reasons people bow down in front of stautes, In the O.T. is was expected for people to bow down in front of statues. Pablope, unwittingly, shows the reason why in his first quote from Revelation. There are saints (of which, angels are sanctified/saints.) who are between us and God. God is invisible, and even in heaven can not be seen; hence the Jewish Tradition is that the shekina glory cloud, the burning bush, and several other instances are actually Angels.

usccb.org/bible/psalms/104 (Psalm 104:4)
usccb.org/bible/hebrews/1 (Hebrews 1:7)
Galations 3:19… etc…

It’s not possible to bow down before the sight of God the Father (or Spirit) without either a statue or an angel present; The son, having a body is the only one who can supply a perfect/actual icon of the invisible God. Yet in revelation, that is exactly what they are doing…!

There is one other important thing to add; lest one think that revealtion is just a “vision”, and hence these people aren’t really doing these things – but they are symbolic;

In the O.T. people routinely bowed down before statues and graven (woven tapestries) at the Temple in Jerusalem. On the Ark of the covenant – they did not leave it bare with a chair; rather, they placed two angels on either end of it; angels made of pure Gold. The tapestries of the angels (Cherubim) could be seen through the main door from the Bronze altar and from the porch of the Men of Israel. They would bow down and pray, right there in full sight.

Psalm 95:6 (Consider:Where else could one bow down before the LORD?)
Psalm 5:7 is explicit

KJV:
Psalm 5:7 But as for me, I will come into thy house in the multitude of thy mercy: and in thy fear will I worship toward thy holy temple.

NAB:
Psalm 5:8 (usccb.org/bible/psalms/5)
… I will bow down toward your holy sanctuary
out of fear of you.

Never has the worship of God been without statuary – it has been without foreign Idols, though – it is these which were sinful. Priests minister between God and man – and in heaven there are 24 of them offering our prayers; so it is, even in heaven, our prayers demonstratively go through priests unto God the Father. In the O.T. the queen mother, too, presents the petitions of the people to her son, the King. Just so, Mary can present (not that Jesus must listen) our petitions.

I personally don’t find bowing down before statuary comfortable. However, I do recognize that not everyone has the same feelings as I do. Feelings are neither right nor wrong – it’s what one does with them that is moral or immoral.

Treating angels themselves as objects of latria is wrong (Galatians 2:18); although adoring the one whom they make an image of (a cloud of Glory, the feet of the Father, etc.) is not.

The same is true of statues. If I had a statue with me, i’d be more inclined to touch it’s carved toe (not kiss it) when thinking about what I’d like to say… but, that’s just me… I’m more tactile than visual… But I don’t condemn those who kneel when hoping someone with high dignity before God might use their influence to bring the prayer more speedily to an answer from God.

🙂
 
Someone told me the other day that Catholics are idolaters because we kneel in front of statues to pray, which means we are worshipping the statue.
Tell him the Truth, No we do not worship anything other than God. Then give him the citation from The Catechism;
2135 “You shall worship the Lord your God” (Mt 4:10). Adoring God, praying to him, offering him the worship that belongs to him
 
I had a thought about this statue question the other day.

**Strict protestants **may not have statues of Jesus, but they certainly watch movies and about Him. They may soon be watching those movies in 3-D (like a play), but my larger point is this. If making statues of Jesus is blasphemous, then is not watching a movie - where actors (living statues) are dressed-up like Him - even more blasphemous? If a statue of Jesus composed of stone or wood is blasphemous, then is not a “living statue” composed of flesh even more blasphemous?

If you object to pictures and icons then movies become even more of a problem. A movie is simply a series of pictures that are linked together to produce the illusion of motion. Hence, if making a picture of Jesus is blasphemous then watching a movie about Jesus - which involves thousands of pictures being shown simultaneously - is even more blasphemous (I think 🙂 ).
Please define “strict protestants”. We in the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod are often characterized as rather strict, rather conservative, and yet this video featuring our Synod President (bishop):
youtube.com/watch?v=lizfznY63Yk

Jon
 
Well I usually point out that the statue is made of plastic or plaster. I even show it to them up close.

Then I ask them the following…

“you mean to say that YOU believe that Catholics think a piece of plastic is GOD, creator of the universe? YOU believe that???”

I go on…

"I certainly don’t believe this piece of plastic is GOD… but YOU believe Catholics think it is GOD, creator of the universe! (Here I laugh a little) How can you believe that?

It does take them a little while to work this out but this is precisely what is going on.
 
If you have the opportunity go to Walshingsham, England sometime. I was there several years ago and witnessed busloads of dear souls worshipping that statue of Mary.
Grace and Peace,
QC
Do you have the ability to see into the hearts and minds of others? If not, then you have no way of knowing if these people are “worshiping” the statue of the Blessed Virgin Mary.

As I’m sure you know, bowing before something or someone does not equate to worship. 😉
 
If you have the opportunity go to Walshingsham, England sometime. I was there several years ago and witnessed busloads of dear souls worshipping that statue of Mary.
Grace and Peace,
QC
Maybe they were worshipping God in front of that statue of the Blessed Virgin. Sometimes I pray while in bed looking at the ceiling, but I’m not worshipping the ceiling.
I’m not Catholic, but I am always moved when I see an image of the Blessed Virgin, as she is the mother of our Lord. She always makes me think of Him.

Jon
 
If you have the opportunity go to Walshingsham, England sometime. I was there several years ago and witnessed busloads of dear souls worshipping that statue of Mary.
Grace and Peace,
QC
Did you really? Did you ask those dear souls, "Oh dear souls, are you all worshipping Mary as your god?"and did each and every one of them respond, "yes, we are and all Catholics have been programmed to do so on the Vatican supercomputer" or did you just assume that they were doing so because that’s what you’ve been told Catholics do?

Somehow I have the feeling you’re going to say that they were ‘bowing down’ and 'everybody knows you bow down to what you worship". . .

Yeah and I worship my square dance partner. . .:rolleyes:
 
When people were ignorant but were having the thought of nature’s power, they made idols representing Sun or Wind or Water and worshipped. Later when religions or cultures emerged, some started making the idols of their gods or leaders and worshipped them But when people have normal thinking as of now, they make pictures or statues of their religious leaders or saints and pay respect or worship the real God looking at the statues fully knowing that they are lifeless and not god or heavenly bodies. So I feel there is no idol worship these days among the civilised people. Still catholics are stamped as idol worshippers by protestents. It may be due to their refusal to accept the truth. However I also feel that too much prominence should not be attached to statues. If statues are attired in attractive dresses or believing that miracle will happen if we touch or kiss the statues … these may help confuse the mind and stray from the right faith
 
Did you really? Did you ask those dear souls, "Oh dear souls, are you all worshipping Mary as your god?"and did each and every one of them respond, "yes, we are and all Catholics have been programmed to do so on the Vatican supercomputer" or did you just assume that they were doing so because that’s what you’ve been told Catholics do?

Somehow I have the feeling you’re going to say that they were ‘bowing down’ and 'everybody knows you bow down to what you worship". . .

Yeah and I worship my square dance partner. . .:rolleyes:
Kissing! Bowing to! Prostrating themselves before the statue! Kneeling and praying to! Sure looked like worshipping to me.
QC
 
Kissing! Bowing to! Prostrating themselves before the statue! Kneeling and praying to! Sure looked like worshipping to me.
QC
Washing, polishing and waxing the paint. Putting expesive oils on the leather seats and expensive dressings on the tires. Standing in awe of the beauty of the vehicle as it gleams in the summer sun and driving down the road as if it makes you more powerful/important/smarter/attractive because you own it, even though you don’t really own it but the finance company does… Sure looks like worship to me.

Spending two hourse every day in the gym. Shopping for the latest fashion. Looking in the rear view mirror to make sure teeth are white or to make sure that every lock of hair is perfectly placed. Constantly adjusting clothing, and worrying about what people think of how we look… sure looks like worship to me.

Ignoring the fact that one is sitting on a plane with dozens of people, not saying hello to a single one and instead spending the entire flight in silence looking at a $650 battery powered box with a three inch screen… that sure looks like worship to me.

Believing that Mitt Romney, or Barack Obama, or any other human is going to save our country… sure looks like worship to me.

I’ll stop here.

-Tim-
 
Kissing! Bowing to! Prostrating themselves before the statue! Kneeling and praying to! Sure looked like worshipping to me.
QC
I think your definition of worship is a little eschewed.
On my locker at my work I have my favorite picture of my husband and son. I work night shift and I miss them terribly. There are times when I’m in front of that picture, usually around my lunch time, I’m just reminded of the incredible love that I have for my family. Sometime I feel sad because I wish I could be with them during the night. Often times I bow my head in front of the picture and pray for them. I pray for their wellbeing. I pray that my son is sleeping…and not keeping his Daddy up throughout the night. Then when I’m done I kiss my fingers and touch their faces. I just love them.

Similarily,
When I pray my Rosary, I like to do it in front of a statue of the Blessed Mother. I like to pray in front of the statue because it helps me to keep my mind focused on the mysteries. I pray the Sorrowful mysteries on my knees and when I’m deep in meditation of the mysteries, I’m sometimes moved to tears. The mystery of the Carrying of the Cross has moved me to tears. I don’t know what it is about that mystery, it always fills me with thoughts of God’s incredible love for us.

Anyways, I suppose that any protestant or evangelical can come into my room during that mystery and do you know what they will see?
A woman on her knees, praying in front in a statue of the Blessed Mother, crying.
And I suppose that they would erroneously come to the conclusion of,
“why is that woman worshiping that statue?” When in reality, I’m thinking about my Lord carrying his cross up to Calvary for me, about to be hung on a cross for me, and so loved me that he gave up his life for me.

I just want to reiterate what other people have told you.
Don’t pretend to know the hearts of people when they pray.
 
Film is actually a material where chemicals are selectively removed by light – it is technically a graven image – but not a statue. Both were forbidden in Exodus/Duteronomy; I agree with your point.
I was thinking more along lines of when the actors in a movie dress-up like Jesus and purposefully make themselves look like him; or when kids dress up like angels in a Christmas play. If statues are wrong, this should be more wrong. A person imitating things in heaven should be more wrong than a person making a statue of things in heaven.
 
Please define “strict protestants”. We in the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod are often characterized as rather strict, rather conservative, and yet this video featuring our Synod President (bishop):
youtube.com/watch?v=lizfznY63Yk

Jon
My use of the word “strict” was simply meant to indicate that when it comes to this issue there is a wide variety of Protestant opinion. Some are more “strict” on this issue than others in terms of what they allow. If the usage is incorrect, then my apologies. However, I think the meaning was clear. Nit-picking at the language a person used to express his position does not make your position more compelling.
 
Kissing! Bowing to! Prostrating themselves before the statue! Kneeling and praying to! Sure looked like worshipping to me.
QC
Ah, there’s your problem. You’re attempting to put yourself in God’s place, without having God’s attributes. YOU are attempting to put a narrow and modern definition of ‘worship’ on an ACTION without having any idea of the heart of the person making the action.

So, when two people in Japan bow to each other, they are worshipping each other right?

When I ‘bow to my partner’ in square dancing, I’m worshipping him, right?

When I pray to a person, I am not simply talking to him, I am treating him as god, right? :rolleyes::eek:

EVEN If in every single situation cited above, the person had absolutely no intention of treating the idol, the person, or the action as that of worship of almighty God., . .

such a narrow and indeed inaccurate viewpoint of yours, historically speaking, is very dangerous. . .both to us as recipients of your wrong assumptions and ‘scoldings’ and to you in holding such and by doing so, in your mind though not in reality, elevating ‘you’ to a status of god-like power to choose exactly how anybody should 'worship God.'
 
Which is the more tolerant attitude, one wonders:

The attitude of a Church which says, "Worship God alone. There are many ways you may choose to do so, for He has given us examples and helps in His Word and His Spirit to guide us. Whether you worship Him alone or in groups, with reading, with song, with dance, with gifts OF ANY KIND which are offered to Him as ultimate Creator, worship God and love your fellow men and women.:

Or the attitude of a person who says, “Worship God alone. But do it MY way, and my way only, for I alone in the last 2000 years am wholly qualified, by grace of MY word on a message board, to determine what is and what is not ‘worship’. Anything which I have determined based solely on my judgment no matter what knowledge I have (usually quite little) to be wrong, stop! Only I am the one to tell you what you are doing, who can read your heart and find you evil, evil, wrong and evil. . . You must do what I say and only what I say. . .”

Hmmm.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top