What do you think about Harry Potter?

  • Thread starter Thread starter pauljmaxmi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I took my ten year old grandson to see the first Harry Potter movie, He said he liked it. A couple of years later I asked him if he wanted to go see the latest HP movie and he said no. Im not sure if it was the second one or not, I asked him why and he said he thought the HP movies were silly. Maybe the kids know more than the adults and Im told by the sales clerk at the bookstore that a lot of adults read the HP books.
 
My 15 and 12 year old nephew and niece really got excited about reading with those books. They would tell me all this detail about the books that I couldn’t get straight…seemed like good brain exercise. I enjoyed watching the movies with them and they would get all excited telling me how the books differed. Harmless fun.
 
if someone is securely founded in the faith, I don’t understand why everyone gets so upset/threatened by some fantasy.(book,movie,game)
 
What do I think about Harry Potter?
I Don’t Think about Harry Potter.
 
Good grief…have you ever noticed the HUGE influence of witchcraft that’s in Star Wars. As a very knowledgeable one of pagan culture, Star Wars has waaay more Pagan overtones than Harry Potter.

I would worry more about nursery rhymes than HP books (which I love btw)…rub a dub dub, 3 MEN in a tub??? hmmm…and of course the story of Beauty and the Beast (beastiality??), and the other disney movies such as Tarzan and Jane who live together on the island by themselves married by whom??? there was NO priest there?? I could go on and on…
 
40.png
pauljmaxmi:
With the announcement that the 6th book is going to be released on July 16th, I would like to know what the general opinion on the book series is. Is it evil? Is not good, but not something you would not classify as evil? Or is it good entertainment?
I’m not sure it’s evil but it’s certainly rubbish. Kids would be far better off reading the tried and true earlier classics.
 
40.png
romano:
I’m not sure it’s evil but it’s certainly rubbish. Kids would be far better off reading the tried and true earlier classics.
Earlier classics, many of which, have undergone the same criticism as this one…

Certain aspects of the story become the focus rather than the overall intent of the story…

Scarlett Letter
To Kill a Mockingbird
Huckleberry Finn
Tom Sawyer
and the list goes on…
 
*iono about the books. i agree classics would feed ur brain better. i mean i’ve only seen the movies, which are AWESOME by the way… and my bfriend and i have fun saying “expeliamus” and flicking our pencils in the air. it’s really entertaining if u glue a pencil to your hand with paintball gun glue. anyway. that’s my blurb. can’t wait for the fourth movie!! there **is *going to be one right?
 
definitely read the books…once you do you will poo-poo the movies.

I am looking forward to C.S. Lewis’ Chronicles of Narnia movie-make of his books that is due to come out in December 2005.That series was marvelous and very captivating. I remember reading the Narnia series and being totally transported. Kind of like Lord of the Rings for Younger Kids.
 
I think the books have great moral lessons for kids and adults alike. I rememebr one of them talke about a mirror of desire, which was called desire spelled backwards, and how easy it is to get caught up in wishes of how life shouls be, instead of focusing on what to do that we can actively make life better now. How some people live a life paralyzed by always wishing for things to be different.

I also remember another book discussing how it is a better judge of a man’s character to watch how he treats those that he does not regard as his social equals.

That being said, I think that parents or adults should read the books they encourage or permit their kids, or children under thier influence to read.

I know some peopel panic and wory that kidfs who read the books might start thinking about magic and satanic cults, but the books don’t talk about spells using body parts or sacifices. There is a great emphasis on overcoming evil. Growing up, I liked fantasy books, but never ended up wondering about cults, or practicing magic or using ouja board. I think it was large because I translated that there is a distinct difference between the imaginary and reality, and in the real world, only God is all powerful and that the saints who were in tune with God’s will were/are a parallel to the magic workers in fiction books, and those who sought to thwart the bad guys.
 
Cath ChavaBeLLa said:
* anyway. that’s my blurb. can’t wait for the fourth movie!! there **is ***going to be one right?

I read in the news somewhere that “The Goblet of Fire” was to be released as a movie in November 2005.
 
40.png
romano:
I’m not sure it’s evil but it’s certainly rubbish. Kids would be far better off reading the tried and true earlier classics.
Kids can read both. THere is no law that states that a child that reads Harry Potter can never read the classics.🙂 I assigned my oldest son, Great Expectations and my 12 year old Treasure Islands. Both good books and classics. THey-along with myself-have read and reread all the Harry Potter books.

One thing that disturbs me among some Christians is the dislike of any sort of fantasy. I am not certain where this knee jerk reaction is coming from. Long before our time, children were listening to fairy tales-some of the original fairytales are quiet violent- and no one worried that they would grow up to be witches or involved in the occult.
 
Forgetting the Evil/Wizardry issue…
  1. I may have the wrong impression, but how do traditional authority figures fare in Harry Potter? Is it a fair take, if you get the impression that it’s best not to trust elders whom God has put in your life?
  2. Is there a sort of bigotry at work in the stories: Of all the people in them who don’t believe in magic, are many of them good or sympathetic? Are any of them?
  3. Is the magic in Harry Potter of the same flavor as say, The Wizard of Oz? Some say it’s no worse. Which one, though, is a sort of triumphant indulgance in magic?
Peace.
John
 
I’m with Fr. Amorth, who thinks HP is from the evil one.
I also have had some frightening experiences with the occult.
One of them was with a children’s game sold in toy stores. When I was in high school, my friend and I, who thought we were just playing, asked this thing who was talking to us. It spelled out, “THE DEVIL.” Both of us took our hands off the thing immediately and threw the game away, never to play it again.
 
deb, you said this, and i quote:“Long before our time, children were listening to fairy tales-some of the original fairytales are quiet violent- and no one worried that they would grow up to be witches or involved in the occult.”
…and some of them did!!
I have never read a book about that Harry Potter stuff, and from what I have heard about them, I never intend to. I personally wouldnt waste money on them, I would prefer to read and have my children, grand-children read stories about the Saints, and things that can help them in this journey. I seriously doubt that those HP books can help them.-just my opinion since it was asked.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top