What happens when only one side defines hate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cathoholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope just telling it like it is regarding the disingenuous regard the dems claim to have for not just blacks but minorities as a whole.As DVDS is so fond of saying.Facts are stubborn
 
Jeanne_S.

I think you are on the right path.

The fact that a given minority group votes for leftist-socialists (democratic party) is irrelevant. (A lot of mega-business people vote the same way. Leftist.)

Why @dvdjs brought it up to you was puzzling (“Whom do blacks vote for?” Here). At least to me. (The conclusion doesn’t follow from the premise.)

Native Americans probably overwhelmingly vote for the leftist-socialist politicians too.

But to draw the conclusion that the leftist-socialists are somehow good for these Native Americans (politically), and that’s WHY they must favor them, would be erroneous. At least potentially.


The leftist-socialists want their “citizens” (and “their” businesses) as wards of the state.
At least that is my opinion.

Keep up the good work Jeanne_S and thanks for your insightful posts.
 
Last edited:
The point is that if as you claim, governments are only responsible for repairing injustice that happens under their rule, then the Jews had no right to claim Israel from Palestine because it didn’t happen under modern day Palestine’s rule.
We are talking about a war in this situation, not government obligations.

The Ottoman Turks who ruled Palestine did not have the responsibility of compensating the descendants of displaced Jews who had been driven out by the pagan Romans in A.D. 40.

Just because the Ottoman rulers did not have this obligation says nothing about the rights and wrongs of someone kicking them out or fighting wars against them or against other people supporting different states.

The British who ruled Palestine after the fall of the Ottoman Turk empire at the behest of the United Nations also had no responsibility to anyone’s descendants regarding previous claims of injustice. Again, that did not give them immunity from either Arabs or Jews wanting to kick them out.

You are talking about war instead of a stable, continuing and universally respected and approved state and it’s responsibilities.

One is the responsibilities of a government and the other is whether people have a right to violently overthrow a state. These are separate things.
 
Last edited:
In your response to Jeanne S in Post 123 you identified her as projecting a stereotype

No stereotypes in this post. Nope, none at all.
[/quote]

Please read again your response to me in post 102 where you say

it doesn’t really matter how much of the white vote or the black vote Obama got. Obama was bi-racial. He was as much white as he was black. ( My comment)
This isn’t really how these racial identities work. People with white and black parents are basically always considered to be black.
(your response)

Your response sounds like a stereotype to me “always”
 
Why was I notified of this post? Have you confused me with niceatheist? We are two different people.
 
I can’t think of anyone here at CAF who has opposed anti-trust measures more than you.
Antitrust measures isn’t remotely related to this thread, but I’ll correct a misunderstanding. I’m not against them at all provided that due-process has been followed. I won’t say any more on that within this thread.
 
It seems to me that I don’t see a lot of non-hate from either side.
 
Native Americans probably overwhelmingly vote for the leftist-socialist politicians too.
The votes of Hispanics and Asians also swing strongly to Democrats.
But to draw the conclusion that the leftist-socialists are somehow good for these Native Americans (politically), and that’s WHY they must favor them, would be erroneous
It simply falsifies the nonsense about “who is actually the party of racism”.
 
Anyhow, I am having trouble concentrating today.
I’m so sorry to hear about your concentration issues. So frustrating for you, I’m sure. Hope you’re getting better today and can continue to have better concentration.

I do agree with you that many of our government aid programs pull back their aid if a person makes even a small advancement in earnings or job status. I would like to see some of the government officials who make these rules try to live on some of those incomes and in the physical circumstances where some of their clients live. It’s not right to yank a rug out from someone who is truly trying to keep walking forward.

This is one reason why I believe in private sources of aid for the poor, the under-educated, the homeless, etc. There is more accountability when a private source (e.g., a church) is responsible for helping a person or family to advance their living circumstances.

An on-going and friendly relationship can develop between the recipient of the aid, and the organization or individual(s) dispensing the aid. “Street savvy” is gained by those who regularly work with aid recipients, and this savvy will prevent con artists and cheats from getting aid that they don’t need.

But the organization or individual(s) can also continue aid and even increase it when they know their clients and know that the aid is truly helping them to continue to gain more education, more job skills, and more stability in their employment and living situation.

I think that one reason why churches are losing members all across the denominational spectrum is that they aren’t doing what the Lord tells them to do–use the gifts that the Holy Spirit has distributed in the churches to follow Jesus’ commandments to help the poor, feed the hungry, visit the prisoners, etc. We have become comfortable with the government doing it for us.

Government aid is rife with inefficiency, waste, and lack of personal contact and followup.

My father (R.I.P.) owned many properties, and he agreed that one of those properties would be used by the government, who would find tenants and pay their expenses and rent. This seemed like a good deal for my father–and it was! He received a massive rent check every month–three times what he would have charged a tenant!–plus an additional large check for maintenance and upkeep of the property, far beyond what he needed!

And the lady who received the free rent was supposed to be attending school–she enrolled in the local community college every semester for many years, never attended class–and dropped out by the drop date EVERY SEMESTER! But the government didn’t know that and continued to pay her rent.

Dad used to shake his head at how stupid the government was. He actually tried to tell them what was going on, but they didn’t take him seriously.

Government aid, especially the federal programs, to the poor should be phased out and the churches and individuals, as well as local/community governments, should be prevailed upon to do their compassionate duty and help those in need.
 
Last edited:
BTW, the topic of this thread is “one side defining hate.”

It’s not hatred to offer aid to people who are want to improve their circumstances–get an education, get a job, stay away from crime, avoid addictions, get married and then have sex and have children, and be good citizens and neighbors.

What true hatred is is to give people freebies and assume that they will never improve their circumstances–never succeed in graduating from (free) public high school, never gain any employable skills, never succeed in getting a job that pays a living wage, never stay off drugs and alcohol, never stop having children out of wedlock, never avoid getting involved with crime…

That is hatred–to think so little of others and look down upon them as incapable of improving their lot in life, and to KEEP them in their “deplorable” circumstances but claim that we are “helping them.” It’s a lie. Just look at the statistics of what public aid has done to stop poverty, crime, domestic violence, homelessness, out-of-wedlock births, sex crimes, gang activity, addictions, etc. Very little.

These are not easy problems to solve. There are no quick and easy fixes, no “miracle cures.” When people have no bootstraps, they can’t pull themselves up by them.

But what we’re doing right now in the U.S. isn’t helping, and we need to stop “toxic charity.”
 
Last edited:
What true hatred is is to give people freebies and assume that they will never improve their circumstances–never succeed in graduating from (free) public high school, never gain any employable skills, never succeed in getting a job that pays a living wage, never stay off drugs and alcohol, never stop having children out of wedlock, never avoid getting involved with crime…

That is hatred–to think so little of others and look down upon them as incapable of improving their lot in life, and to KEEP them in their “deplorable” circumstances but claim that we are “helping them.” It’s a lie.
Please consider that the idea that people think these things is the lie that is being sold.
Many partisan pundits may tell you this, but can you name anyone who really thinks this way?
 
Last edited:
Can you cite any positives that have occurred in say the past fifty years re these issues? We still have many in the black community struggling,there is as much or more violence in the inner cities.Welfare pimps like Al Sharpton ,getting wealthy at the expense of his own people,constantly fomenting hatred and screeching racism when he is a big part of the problem. No,The Dems ARE the party of racism,elitism,anti life,religion you name it they own it.May not have been that way to this extent decades ago but has been steadily become their platform for the past fifty years.
Having said that,I know that those of you so married to this party will refute and deny this reality. So really this is all an exercise in futility and I’m not going down the rabbit hole.Carry on if you must.
 
40.png
Jeanne_S:
Let that sink in re who is actually the party of racism.
Just in case you have not noticed that is the past.
Wow! So why can’t you on the left apply that same logic with regards to reparations???
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So why can’t you on the left apply that same logic with regards to reparations???
I cannot speak for “you on he ™left”, but can point out the difference.
  1. Racist events from the past, broken down along political party lines, were suggested by a poster to be indicative of present party attitudes, notwithstanding the abundant evidence, through present voting patterns, of a complete reversal.
  2. Racist events form the past have had an enduring disadvantageous legacy that, insofar as it is feasible, should be mitigated. As Catholics we understand such enduring legacy as we are heirs to the sin of Adam, and to redemption from it.
While there is a common thread of past racists events in both matters, the difference between them should be very clear.
 
Last edited:
Can you cite any positives that have occurred in say the past fifty years re these issues?
What issues?
Education, mitigation of poverty, jobs, household incomes, … of course there is evidence.

But the problem with here is not just the issue of efficacy of programs, it is the wholly unsubstantiated mendacious idea that the the people advancing the programs are willfully hating and hurting others. BI suppose that comes from a steady diet of talk show hosts talking giving their all on “what the ‘Dems’ and the ™left really believe”.
 
insofar as it is feasible, should be mitigated.
But to make those who had absolutely nothing to do with the sins of past generations pay for their mistakes, as many on the left propose is ludicrous! Can’t you comprehend the great division that this would add to an already deeply divided nation???
 
ThinkingSapien . . .
Antitrust measures isn’t remotely related to this thread . . .
Yet you are the one who brought into this thread a video that used antitrust to show how “progressive” liberals had morphed suggesting some sort of a political inversion from
your past bigotry that you admit (not “you” personally).

And I am saying the transformation on your bigotry (not “you” or “your” personally but the leaders of these idea holders and propagators, the socialists [aka the democrat leadership]) has not been so “complete” as your guys fantisize on the antitrust issue.

And in my opinion anyway, likewise the transformation of your (not “your” personally) admitted bigotry has not shaken off as much as your guys fantisize either.

ThinkingSapien . . .
I’m not against them (antitrusting a company) at all provided that due-process has been followed. I won’t say any more on that within this thread.
(Parenthetical mine for context)

To the readers here. This is absolute malarkey. This is an example of someone who shifts his feelings, and now thinks it is reality.

Don’t listen to what Cathoholic says here against this.
Don’t listen to what ThinkingSapien says here FOR this.

Go back and READ what I have said about antitrusting companies. See it for yourself.
Read ThinkingSapien’s responses. TS’s responses invariably will be there (because he virtually always opposes my calls for anti-trusting).

Go back and see for yourself how ThinkingSapien has opposed these measures on virtually every incidence.
(I’ll bet MANY of you here already KNOW it from reading it directly. ThinkingSapien virtually always takes a BIG Business position and opposes antitrusting even “MEGALOCORPORATIONS” like Google.)

See for yourself. Check it out. Just do a word search.
“Cathoholic” plus “antitrust” and the same for “ThinkingSapien”.

Read and draw your own conclusions.
You won’t need me to tell you what to think.
You will almost always come to the correct conclusions.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top