What is reasonable for taking care of parents?

  • Thread starter Thread starter angell1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

angell1

Guest
I know the catechism says we should provide care for our parents, but how much is enough?

I basically am made to feel like I’m to live at home for the rest of my life and am guilt tripped in to feeling like I owe them something for raising me. and how I have to honour them and if I don’t obey every single thing then I’m not doing that

what would be a reasonable approach?
 
It all depends on how old you are and what your state is in life. It also depends on whether your parents truly need your care or are just trying to control you.
 
Well, what you have written isn’t reasonable.

Are your parents disabled, in some way? Unable to take care of themselves? Any reason that they feel they need you to take care of them?
 
Well, what you have written isn’t reasonable.

Are your parents disabled, in some way? Unable to take care of themselves? Any reason that they feel they need you to take care of them?
no
 
You have to elaborate more on your question. There are to many variables in your question. What is your age? What are their ages? What is their Health? What are they demanding of you? Etc.
 
Maryjk, irishmom, angell, Hh.
I m not the originial poster, but I d love to read (all of) the replies to you.

I take care of my parents and my aunt. 88, 84 and 86 yos.
And it s killing me. It s a really heavy burden, I don t feel I can do it anymore. They are ill, almost can t move, and I can t do it anymore.
They ve always told me it s my obligation. And I TRULY love them, but this is killing me.
I have a brother and a sister, who try to help. But they live far away.
I have a real conflict here. I cannot afford paying for help 24 hrs a day, I cannot pay more. And I ll be dead soon if I continue this way.
I do not know what to to.
My dad had a foot amputated due to diabetes 2 weeks ago, my mom has dementia, my aunt is almost blind an very angry with life.
I feel I m losing my own life and mind here! Plus I m always angry with myself, because they make me so angry.
Please help me.
 
For Maria_i - :hug1:

I also am following this thread and am not the OP.

I’m in my 40’s trying to balance my obligation to my widowed 86yr old mom versus my obligations to my spouse and six children. She has medical issues, but the main thing is just the neediness - she hates being alone, has difficulty fixing her own meals and cannot go out. However, she also refuses to come over to our house (or any other of our family member’s houses) for more than a short time, won’t let any of us cook for her (prefers we take her out to eat at her favorite restaurants - she pays), and in general wants a lot of help - but only on her terms which involve large commitments of time focused solely on her. 😦

I love my mom and I want her happy and at peace (she was also recently formally declared blind) but she drives me crazy with the guilt trips. I just don’t have time after working and caring for my family’s needs to be there as often as she’d like - let alone daily like she’d prefer. Have tried everything I can think of but she doesn’t want to deal with “strangers”, insists that she has no “friends” she can trust, and pouts because my siblings and I don’t step up and be there as she’d like. sigh

Sorry - didn’t realize there was so much inside me till I started typing.

Prayers for all those in stressful situations with their parent(s).
 
I think this must be taken on a case by case basis. I suppose it depends on so many factors …too many.

Angel, it doesn’t sound like it’s necessary for you to be with your parents, at least not right now, though, in my opinion.

To the others, it depends on one’s own health. It depends on the parents’ age, health. other factors.

I suppose one could go to a counselor for advice, resources, options, and guidance, ideas.
 
maria_i

Caring for the physical needs of three elderly relatives with the disabilities that you describe is more than one person can do. Although you cannot afford to pay for 24 hour care, you need to find out what kind of assistance your parents and aunt may be eligible for. Do they have health insurance which will pay for nursing home care? Or Medicaid? Or perhaps their doctors will have some advice. If there is a senior center in your town ask for information about whatever public programs may be able to help them. It sounds like it is definitely time for you to do something like this. And this is a legitimate way for you to fulfill your obligation to take care of your parents and aunt.

It is not always possible for us to physically care for elderly relatives directly. My mom and I took care of my dad (who had multiple strokes and diabetes) for as long as we could. But when he lost the ability to safely stand or walk we had to arrange for a nursing home because we could not lift him or change his diapers or bathe him without injuring ourselves.

After he was in the nursing home, my mom and I visited him very frequently and made sure that he was well cared for.

If you go on as you are, you will become ill yourself – or even cause your own early death through overwork and stress. And then your parents and aunt will have no one to oversee their care or to be their advocate. Please believe me that it is time for you to find help. I will be praying for you.

P.S. While my mom and I were taking care of my dad, we were also overseeing the care of my aunt who had dementia. So I really do understand your situation.
 
maria_i

Caring for the physical needs of three elderly relatives with the disabilities that you describe is more than one person can do. Although you cannot afford to pay for 24 hour care, you need to find out what kind of assistance your parents and aunt may be eligible for. Do they have health insurance which will pay for nursing home care? Or Medicaid? Or perhaps their doctors will have some advice. If there is a senior center in your town ask for information about whatever public programs may be able to help them. It sounds like it is definitely time for you to do something like this. And this is a legitimate way for you to fulfill your obligation to take care of your parents and aunt.

It is not always possible for us to physically care for elderly relatives directly. My mom and I took care of my dad (who had multiple strokes and diabetes) for as long as we could. But when he lost the ability to safely stand or walk we had to arrange for a nursing home because we could not lift him or change his diapers or bathe him without injuring ourselves.

If you go on as you are, you will become ill yourself – or even cause your own early death through overwork and stress. And then your parents and aunt will have no one to oversee their care or to be their advocate. Please believe me that it is time for you to find help. I will be praying for you.
.
Hi everyone,

I feel for all of you and know where you are. My widowed mother is 93 suffers from demetia, with anxiety attacks, anger and depression. My brother is far away and cannot offer much actual physical help and will soon be leaving the country until New Year’s. It is a difficult situation. He helps with some things but the burden is day to day. But Mari_i you definitely need help from your siblings. Try to discuss equal responsibility and support with them. They just have to share the sacrifices and abuses that pop up on a day to day basis. It will also be easier to find a solution for your 3 patients together with your siblings. I can sympathize with the others posters as well. There are so many similarities that by just reading your responses has been a great comfort for me. It comes knowing that there are others in the same situation with conflicted feelings.

I offer it up to the Lord at mass everyday and have put it in the hands of Our Lady Undoer of Knots and a little solution presented itself with my mother consenting to try out a retirement community for a short period of time which helped with the burden. I am there almost everyday to help and now hope that things work out even though it has been an unpredictable roller coaster ride without a foreseeable end.

I pray for patience, gentleness toward her and to always try to treat her with respect even when it is hard. But as many of you, I get frustrated and fail but comfort comes when I can take it to Him and try to start again. My advice is like that of hodgewyfe. Look into help from public programs and your siblings but take time each day for yourself to connect with our Lord even for a little while before the Tabernacle. This has helped me tremendously, and strengthened me in an amazing way. Mass everyday has done real wonders so that I can better help and deal with this difficult situation. Remember you are never alone.

I will pray for you and your relatives for a solution. :console

Memorare (Prayer to Our Lady)
Remember, O most gracious Virgin Mary, that never was it known that anyone who fled to your protection, implored your help, or sought your intercession, was left unaided.
Inspired by this confidence, I fly unto you, O Virgin of virgins, my Mother. To you do I come, before you I stand, sinful and sorrowful. O Mother of the Word Incarnate, despise not my petitions, but in your mercy, hear and answer me. Amen
 
If you parents are in good health and you are an adult you have no obligation to live with them. Sometimes cultures other than the US have expectations that adult children will live at home until they are married.
If your parents are in good health and can take care of themselves financially, reasonable care would mean you visit them and maintain a relationship with them.
 
My mother and father (but mostly my mother) takes care of her parents who are 92 (father) and 82 (mother). My grandfather can no longer walk and wears diapers, while my grandmother is afraid to do much. Though my grandmother is getting better, she drives my mom crazy sometimes.

But the worst part is that it seems like my uncle just dropped off my grandparents off with my mom. Literally, he came a few days after Christmas and dropped my grandparents off with my mom. At the time, my grandmother couldn’t walk (no she’s doing much better now). But my uncle rarely helps, other than with some money (he and his wife are both doctors). He’s paying for his in-laws to be in a home, but leaving my mom to take care of his parents. Meanwhile, my uncle owns 6 or 7 homes and has a lot of money.

My mom is obviously mad at my uncle. It’s unfair because my mom can’t be with her grandchildren as much as she would like. Of their 5 kids, only my one sister lives close enough to visit several times a week. I can usually only visit once a month or less. My one brother can visit only once or twice a year, while my other brother maybe twice a month. My other sister doesn’t have kids, but it would most-likely be once or twice a month too.

My grandparents can afford to hire an orderly 3 days a week for a few hours to bath my grandfather, which helps. But it’s set I’ll too much for my mom.

I pray for my mom, that she will be able to keep her wits and stay mentally strong. And that they can find more help.

I will also pray for all of you on this thread.

God bless you all, who are taking care of your elderly parents. You are true saints.
 
It all depends on how old you are and what your state is in life. It also depends on whether your parents truly need your care or are just trying to control you.
👍
You need to step back and take as honest a look as you can at the situation, ask someone you trust to help you evaluate. Then, take steps to move forward the best you can, helping when you are really needed and ignoring the guilt trips the best you can. I can tell you this because I had to do it and this is the way I live, you will be in my prayers.
 
Hi Angell1

It could be that since you are blind, they are projecting this “need” to take care of them onto you because they secretly “need” to take care of you. What I mean is, many cultures view disabled people even, mildly disabled as completely helpless. As you have told us, you are in college, you are on a sports team, you come and go pretty well, and you are undertaking a very rigorous academic field. You seem fairly independent except for their constant pulling you back.
I would suggest, continue to be as independent as you can…and if they get upset, then they get upset in little increments., Eventually they will become accustomed to you having a mind of your own, and a life of your own.
We have to respect our parents, but it’s clear you do. If they are from a culture that is somewhat submissive, they will see this as defiant of course. But, it’s a learning curve for everyone, no? You are learning your way in the world, and they need to focus on each other maybe…a new stage in their life besides watching your every move.
It’s frustrating yes. Pray for them, and give yourself a break. If you need to do other things, just GO. Do what you need to do. It doesn’t mean that you don’t love them, and if they try to guilt you into that it’s their issue. Kids grow up. And parents sometimes go through those growing pains.
If they were critically ill, that would be a whole differ thing, as others have so heartbreakingly said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top