What is the difference between 1928 & 1979 Book of Common prayer?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JER7177
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“frankly, my 5 year old could have done a better job with” Could you please give me an example? I must admit I have no idea what you could possibly mean. I particularly scrutinised my Catholic Divine Office in order to see to what you may be referring and I am stumped! Please enlighten me. I cannot imagine a Protestant prayer book being preferred by a practising Catholic. I would be afraid to use it, personally, because of the errors within that faith. Or am I being too ‘traditional’?
I agree a traditional Catholic Office would be that way to go.

I don’t know if you read it in Spanish (not presuming) but the ICEL English translation doesn’t use elevated language, and added post-psalm prayers not found in the original Latin, which are vaguely spiritual but often sound like politically left-wing slogans. I got a Latin-English version and that helped for a while but it still uses the four-week format.
 
I agree a traditional Catholic Office would be that way to go.

I don’t know if you read it in Spanish (not presuming) but the ICEL English translation doesn’t use elevated language, and added post-psalm prayers not found in the original Latin, which are vaguely spiritual but often sound like politically left-wing slogans. I got a Latin-English version and that helped for a while but it still uses the four-week format.
I bought mine in a shop in London while on holiday. I bought another one for my friend from Amazon - it was exactly the same but 15 Euro cheaper!! It is the English translation and it is wonderful, imo. God bless.
 
“frankly, my 5 year old could have done a better job with” Could you please give me an example? I must admit I have no idea what you could possibly mean. I particularly scrutinised my Catholic Divine Office in order to see to what you may be referring and I am stumped! Please enlighten me. I cannot imagine a Protestant prayer book being preferred by a practising Catholic. I would be afraid to use it, personally, because of the errors within that faith. Or am I being too ‘traditional’?
You may wish to examine the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom, which is used by Eastern Catholics, who are in communion with the Pope of Rome. In some ways, it is similar to the Anglican service.

The Liturgy of St. Basil is an expanded version of the Divine Liturgy, that is used during Lent and on certain holy days. Some the language in Eucharistic Prayer IV of the modern Roman Catholic Mass is derived from the Liturgy of St. Basil.

Do not be afraid to read anything. As for the possibility of “error,” critical reading, and a secure knowledge of your own faith, will help you out there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top