What languagues did Moses and Elijah speak?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Big_Dummy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow!!! Thanks for that info. Sometimes I forget that the United States is NOT the only place that has dialects.
Dude, what’re you talking about? I lived my whole life in places which did have dialects! 😃

For the record, if we’re going to make a Jesus film and have everyone speak American English, would that mean the Galileans (read: Jesus and His ilk) would speak in something like Southern American English? “Ah’m saying this: y’all need to be nahs to yer enemies!” (apologies in advance to any Southern speakers for mangling their tongue 😊)
 
Moses ofcourse spoke Egypcian as he grew up in the Farao’s Household. Afther that he fled into the dessert and lived with some beduins for a couple of years. There he should have picked up some sort of Arabian. When he came back to Egypt he communicated mainly with the Jewish people, thus he should have know or learned some Hebrew to.
AFAIK, Exodus 2:10 does say that “when the child grew up, [the child’s mother] brought him to Pharaoh’s daughter, and he became her son.” This does not necessarily mean though that he was reared in the royal court like a prince, but I did hear it possible that he may have been a ‘child of the kap’, that is, he could have been educated in the manner of foreign princes taken in charge by the Pharaoh. The kap was a sort of institution at the royal court where children of both Egyptian and foreign nobility were brought to be raised in a manner that was meant to ensure future loyalty to the Egyptian king. ‘Children of the kap’ were usually placed in positions of standing once they reached adulthood, although these rarely included higher positions within the government. This most likely is the manner in which he acquired the knowledge necessary to serve in the royal administration. So unlike Hollywood’s ‘crown prince Moses’ the other alternative here is that Moses was a sort of official under the service of the king (and probably not a high-ranking one at that; cf. Exodus 2:14), though we couldn’t know for certain as the Bible is silent in this regard.

Yet another interpretation for the record focuses on the words “when the child grew up,” or in the Hebrew, wayiḡədal hayyeleḏ “and the child got big.” We oftentimes assume that this only refers to the point when the baby was weaned, though in other instances in the Bible another word for ‘weaned’ is used (cf. Genesis 21:8, where it speaks of Isaac: “he got big and was weaned”). In this idea, Moses is brought to the court when he is old enough to at least know who he is - which probably also includes the knowing the slaves’ language!

And, it ain’t really Bedouins (there’s Cecil B. DeMille’s ghost again! :D) that Moses visited but Midianites. Unfortunately we know little about them - where they exactly lived (they are mentioned as living in diverse areas, which leads some to propose that ‘Midianite’ is a catch-all term for different groups of ethnic peoples) and what language they spoke.

For the record, before the advent of Islam there was actually a variety of languages and dialects spoken in the Arabian Peninsula. At the south for example you have the Old South Arabian languages (all now extinct): Sabaean, Minaean, Qatabanian, and Hadhramautic. At north you have Ancient North Arabian and various related dialects, the only surviving descendant of which is Classical Arabic.
I do think the Hebrews maintained their own language during their captivity in Egypt. I mean, many Mayen or Aztec tribes still speak their thong in combination with Spanish and they have been integrated under Spanish domination for 500 years now.
As for Elijah…I don’t know…Hebrew aslo. I think it is possible to state that Hewbrew does not differ that much from Arabian, considering that the Arabs also believe they are decendents of Abraham (Ibrahim). Maybe there was some kind of proto-Middle East Language that was spoken throughout the region at that time. Only the Egyptians would have spoken a distinguished language.
Well, Arabic and Hebrew (as well as Phoenician, Eblaite, Akkadian, Aramaic, Syriac, Amharic, Tigrinya, Maltese, Ge’ez, and others) are what we call Semitic languages. Hebrew belongs to the Canaanite subfamily of Northwest Semitic. Both the Northwest Semitic languages and the various Arabic languages belong to the Central Semitic group.

It is said that the main distinction between Arabic and the Northwest Semitic languages is the presence of broken plurals in the former. The majority of Arabic masculine non-human nouns form plurals in this manner (called inanimate plural), whereas almost all nouns in the Northwest Semitic languages form their plurals with a suffix. For example, the Arabic بيت bayt (‘house’) becomes بيوت buyūt; the Hebrew בית bayit becomes בתים battīm.

As for Egyptian, it is actually related (albeit more distantly) to Semitic languages, in that they are both grouped together in the Afroasiatic (aka Hamito-Semitic) language family.
 
Dude, what’re you talking about? I lived my whole life in places which did have dialects! 😃

For the record, if we’re going to make a Jesus film and have everyone speak American English, would that mean the Galileans (read: Jesus and His ilk) would speak in something like Southern American English? “Ah’m saying this: y’all need to be nahs to yer enemies!” (apologies in advance to any Southern speakers for mangling their tongue 😊)
OK, you did see my location? Sour Lake, Texas?!? Sir, you’ve just owe-fended me!!
 
OK, you did see my location? Sour Lake, Texas?!? Sir, you’ve just owe-fended me!!
Time to offend somebody else then! 😛
But seriously, I think only a handful of folks has ever seen the value of local dialects and accents on film, especially Jesus films, where (especially in the older ones) you get the impression based on language alone that everyone is British, especially Jesus, a highly dignified RP speaker. 😃
 
Time to offend somebody else then! 😛
But seriously, I think only a handful of folks has ever seen the value of local dialects and accents on film, especially Jesus films, where (especially in the older ones) you get the impression based on language alone that everyone is British, especially Jesus, a highly dignified RP speaker. 😃
Yes, the Jews and the Romans always spoke the Kings English. That used to trip me out!
 
For the record, before the advent of Islam there was actually a variety of languages and dialects spoken in the Arabian Peninsula. At the south for example you have the Old South Arabian languages (all now extinct): Sabaean, Minaean, Qatabanian, and Hadhramautic. At north you have Ancient North Arabian and various related dialects, the only surviving descendant of which is Classical Arabic.

Well, Arabic and Hebrew (as well as Phoenician, Eblaite, Akkadian, Aramaic, Syriac, Amharic, Tigrinya, Maltese, Ge’ez, and others) are what we call Semitic languages. Hebrew belongs to the Canaanite subfamily of Northwest Semitic. Both the Northwest Semitic languages and the various Arabic languages belong to the Central Semitic group.

It is said that the main distinction between Arabic and the Northwest Semitic languages is the presence of broken plurals in the former. The majority of Arabic masculine non-human nouns form plurals in this manner (called inanimate plural), whereas almost all nouns in the Northwest Semitic languages form their plurals with a suffix. For example, the Arabic بيت bayt (‘house’) becomes بيوت buyūt; the Hebrew בית bayit becomes בתים battīm.

As for Egyptian, it is actually related (albeit more distantly) to Semitic languages, in that they are both grouped together in the Afroasiatic (aka Hamito-Semitic) language family.
Does the story of the shibboleth in Judges 12 add anything to this discussion?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top