What Made You Switch??

  • Thread starter Thread starter Protestant_Me
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you were once Catholic and are now Protestant, what made you change frome one to the other? If you were once Protestant and are now Catholic, what made you change? Please don’t reply with “Because it is the true way,” because that isn’t helping me determine the reason you left.
Thank you!!!
:blessyou:
I switched from a Church of Christ background to the Catholic Church for many reasons, but the primary reason was the realization in college that there was a Christianity prior to the Reformation of Luther, Zwingli, etc. This knowledge in conjunction with the verse that records Jesus as saying the gates of hell will not prevail against His church led me to the conclusion that protestantism cannot be the historical church. .
 
My father was an abusive alcoholic. When I was five, my mom took my little brother and me and we left him. I did not hear again from my father until I was 22 and looked for him.

My mother was Lutheran. I attended Lutheran schools 5 of my 6 elementary school years. We attended church every Sunday; even after my mother remarried (to a man I was not very close to). My intention was to become a Lutheran Minister.

I always had a relationship with God. Then, when I was a sophomore in college, a tragedy occurred. A young girl I knew was needlessly killed in an accident. I became very angry with God. How could He allow this to happen to such an innocent girl when so many animals like Ted Bundy were spared? (note: this was prior to Ted Bundy’s execution). I turned my back on God. I would have nothing to do with a God who cared so little about life.

For the next 2 ½ years, I did not go to church, I did not pray. I simply ignored Him. But it ate at me. After 2 ½ years, I realized I needed Him in my life. As I was making that decision, Mormon Missionaries knocked on my door. I invited them in and we talked. What they had to say made sense. They used all the right words like “Jesus”, “God”, “Holy Spirit”, etc. Additionally, Mormons do not smoke, drink, or drink coffee. When I was 5, after my dad would hurt me, my mother would say, “it is not you, it is the alcohol”. I decided then that I would never drink alcohol. I never have. I have also never smoked or used illegal drugs. And, for some reason, I have never liked hot drinks. The Mormon Church seemed like a perfect fit.

I became a Mormon in 1983. I was already a college graduate, so, though I was asked to become a missionary, I was not pressured like most young Mormons to do so. Most Mormons males go on their missions during their second year of college. As I had already graduated and had a job and fiancé’, I did not feel being a Missionary was a good idea. However, I have always felt a desire to serve God, so, in 1984, I quit my job, left my fiancé” (who then married someone else) and was sent to Honduras to be a Missionary. It was a wonderful 18 months. I was serving God, or so I believed. As a Mormon Missionary, I made no salary. I lived in very primitive conditions. I walked everywhere. I worked very hard and held the record for the most average baptisms per month in the Honduran Mission. I witnessed miracles and was very certain that God was with me. I felt like I was doing what I was called to do- serve God.

continued…
 
After my mission, I attended law school. Every year in law school, I attended various temple ceremonies in various temples, visited Mormon tourist attractions in Illinois and New York, and were very active in the Mormon Church. I served in the Bishopric and the Elder’s Quorum Presidency.

In 1989, I went to the birthplace of Mormonism- Palmyra, New York. I went during a time that the yearly outdoor drama about the Mormon Church was being presented on a hillside each night. I was amazed at the number of anti-Mormons in attendance. One afternoon, I approached a table of these anti-Mormons. We got into a spirited debate. Though I handled myself well, I decided I needed to become a “smarter” Mormon. I vowed that when returned home, I would read every Mormon book I could get my hands on. Big mistake. The more I read, the more I realized that I did not believe what Mormons really believe. I did not believe in the plurality of gods. I did not believe that I was going to be a god and have many wives in heaven. I did not believe many of the things I discovered that Mormons believe. I contacted my bishop and informed him I was going to become an inactive member. I started getting harassing phone calls and visits from Mormons telling me I was going to hell for committing the unforgivable sin of renouncing the Spirit. I was harassed at work, at home, even in the grocery store at all hours of the day and night.

Then, one night, we let some friends baby-sit my son (3) and my daughter (2 months) while my wife and I had a quiet evening. Our friends were Mormon, but I trusted them. The phone rang. A family in Idahocalled my wife. I got on the extension (unbeknownst to them). They told my wife, who did not understand English very well, that there were three plane tickets waiting for them at the Detroit airport. She could either come with the kids or stay with me. If she did not come with the kids, she would never see them again. We raced down to where our “friends” were babysitting. They refused to let me in to the kids. A scuffle occurred. My “friend” was injured. The police were called. He tried to have me arrested for assault. I was working, at that time, during the day and going to law school at night. My boss was the Chief Judge (I was his bailiff/law clerk). I was not arrested. I was asked if I wanted to press charges for attempted kidnapping, but I refused. I did not want to spend the next many years looking over my shoulder.

Soon after, I received a letter from my bishop saying I was ordered to attend an excommunication hearing that would decide if I should be excommunicated. One of the charges was speaking against the Mormon Church to my wife in my own home. I replied with a letter stating that attendance to their hearing would indicate that they some sort of authority over me. They didn’t. I did not attend, but was informed by letter later that I had been excommunicated.

I began to attend various churches looking for “home”. Soon after the kidnapping incident, I passed the bar exam and was commissioned as an officer into the Army. I was stationed in Panama where we attended a non denominational chapel for military personnel. An interesting story here: I write poetry and songs, many of my songs are religious. I also sing. One Sunday night soon after joining this chapel in Panama, I was asked to sing one of my songs at the service. After singing my song, the pastor stood up and asked me my name. I told him my name. He asked me if I had ever lived in Honduras. I said yes. I had been a missionary and had taught school. He said, “You may not remember, but one night, there was a party for embassy personnel. You attended that party.” I told him I remembered that party. He continued. “At that party, you sang and played the guitar. After you left, I told one of the teachers from your school who was also at the party that I was a pastor at a church there in Honduras and I wanted to get you involved with my youth group and to sing at church. Your friend told me to forget it. He said that, number 1, you were Mormon, number 2, you were headed back to the United States to go to law school. I was very sad about you being Mormon, so I prayed for you every night for several months. Now here you are.” I became his youth director and was a soloist in his church. God REALLY works in mysterious ways.

Another interesting note: There used to be a U.S. Military presence in Honduras. There was ONE attorney position at that station, and it was a 6-month position. I was able to be assigned there after my duty in Panama and was able to stay for a year. That gave me time to visit all the areas I had worked as a missionary and talk to as many of the people I had baptized as I could to apologize for leading them astray. Again, God works in mysterious ways.

In Honduras, and my following duty stations in Oklahoma and Killeen, Texas, I attended post chapels and non-denominational churches. After I left the military , we moved to Texas. I tried several churches, including the Baptist Church, looking for “home”. Nothing ever felt right.

But I could not find “home”.

And my life went sour. I was terribly unhappy. I divorced my wife of 15 years, hated my job, and could not find “home”. I later remarried her, mostly for our kids, and, predictably, redivorced her. No matter how much I searched or how many churches I attended. No place ever felt “right”.
Then came another horrible blow. My grandfather died. My grandfather was my hero. When we left my dad in 1965, he became my father-figure. He was everything to me. He was the man I had to please. He was also a very devout Catholic.

Continued…
 
In Feb 2002, I had this strange feeling I needed to go visit my grandfather who had been ill. I got the kids and drove from Dallas to Austin that next Saturday. He was very sick. I sat with him for awhile and we just talked. I asked him if he had any regrets in his long life. He said that he was sad that none of his children or grand-children ever followed him in the Catholic Church. That Saturday evening, we drove back to Dallas. The next day, he was rushed to hospital. The following Thursday, he died.

The next weekend, we went BACK to Austin for the funeral. Because I am an attorney and a public speaker, I was asked to do the readings at the Rosary Service and at the funeral. I felt honored. On the day of the funeral, I got to the church early. I sat in the back of the parish and watched a Spanish baptism. While sitting in the pew, I heard a voice very strong behind me. The voice said, “Now you are home”. I looked around to see who had spoken. There was no one there. Then, all of a sudden, I had a strange feeling of peace and contentment that engulfed me.

After the funeral, while on my way back to the town where I lived and served as a city councilman, I called the Mayor, who was Catholic, and told him I needed to become Catholic. He got me the Catechism. I read it cover to cover. I then read book after book after book. I was NOT going to make another mistake like I did joining the Mormon Church. I tried to find fault in Catholic teachings. I couldn’t. I read everything I could get my hands on. I was a constant customer to Sacred Heart Catholic Bookstore. I expected it would take me a year to become Catholic, but, 2 months after I started, the Priest said I was more than ready to be confirmed…so I was- May 19, 2002.

This was not easy. As a Mormon, I was conditioned that the Catholic Church was the Church of the Devil. I was set to reject the Catholic Church.

All of this was happening during the sex scandal in the Church. Many of friends could not believe I was considering Catholicism. I was asked by one friend if the Priests involved with the scandal were hurting my faith. I responded that the Priests did not give me my faith, God did, so how could they hurt it?

No matter what I studied, I believed the Catholic was where I needed to be. It was the Church Jesus started. And if Jesus started it, who was I to reject it? I could not believe that Jesus would start a Church and then not take care of it. All the scandals over time could not change that.

God brought me home.

God is truly great.

That is my story…hope it did not bore you.
 
TexanKnight, thank you so much for posting this.

Very moving and most certainly not boring. 👍
 
Wow, TexanKnight, God has surely been working in your life. Thank you for sharing your story with us!
 
That is my story…hope it did not bore you.
Bore me? What a joke it enthralled me, your story is amazing and I got goosebumps when I read about the “voice”. You know God always gets you at the back of the pews. If you look up a few pages you can see mine. I pray things are going wonderfully for you now. The Lord be with you.
 
Thank you very much for sharing your experience with me! I am unlike most Christians. I have done my fair share of research on this religion, and have been very open minded about it. But there are several things that I just don’t agree with. Going beyond the typical Communion and petty problems. I am also Methodist and I don’t believe it is too radical or strict a religion. Please feel free to enlighten me more!!! God bless!!!
Your story is amazing. I love how God works!

Thanks to everyone for your kind words
 
Hello there!
WOW! Some really great stories here!
I too was raised by a very abusive alcoholic father. When he married and impregnated his much younger wife (she is only 2yrs. older than me), I kind of lost my mind! The thought of him rising another child to inflict pain on was unbearable!! I can remember shaking my fist at Heaven and screaming at GOD and telling Him that I didn’t even believe in Him! I see the absurdity of this now. Why would I scream at Someone I didn’t believe in? I really did lose my mind though. Being a victim of child sexual abuse, I was so deeply wounded!!! I tried to kill myself. Now, as an adult, I have to look at the scars from my cuts forever!! Fortunately, as an adult I found a Church of Christ and I fell in love with the fellowship there. I was baptized and became a member. After a few years there, the pastor moved away and the new pastor that came in was NOT so nice! He showed up at my house one evening and made sexual advances to me. Needless to say, I never went back there! Years went by and I never found a church where I fit. My walk with the Lord was formal at best. I struggled with my sins and found that I went for LONG periods where I didn’t talk to Him at all. A few years ago I joined an Independent Fundamental Baptist church. The people were warm and welcoming. I was even asked to teach Sunday school for a toddler class. Life was good…except I had no REAL walk with Jesus! I had periods where I felt so consumed with guilt over this or that, that I didn’t speak to Him at all. I was also struggling A LOT with some of the teachings. ONCE SAVED ALWAYS SAVED, and THE RAPTURE being the 2 main ones. I didn’t believe and they did! Then the unthinkable happened! A family member was sexually assaulted by a church member. The family refused to press charges against the 15 year old boy, but they really wanted to intervene in this boys life. They tried to talk to his family directly, but that went nowhere, so they asked me to go to the preacher. They thought because I was a teacher in the church, he would be more likely to listen to me. The main issue of concern was that during the assault, the boy said that HE WAS THE MAN AND SHE HAD TO DO AS HE SAID so therefore, she had to consent to the encounter! Our feeling was that since the teachings in this church had lead this boy to believe that, the preacher should at the very least, go to this young man and make sure that he understood that what he had done is NEVER acceptable. He refused!! We ended up leaving. I suddenly found myself without a church again. I made up my mind that I wasn’t going to get mixed up in the drama of the church scene again. But I felt so empty! I decided to do a HOME BIBLE STUDY. I typed in a computer search and the first hit was A CATHOLIC HOME BIBLE STUDY. When I checked it out and found that it was completely FREE of charge, I sent away for the materials. The first book in the course was a study on MARY! I started reading it (equipped with my trusty KJV Bible) to disprove any errors that I might encounter. Much to my surprise, I not only couldn’t disprove anything but I found that I agreed with everything I was reading. Then I became very angry!!! All of my life I had heard all of these ANTI-CATHOLIC remarks!!! If they were wrong about Catholic’s and how they REALLY feel about Mary, what else were they wrong about?!! I started reading EVERYTHING Catholic that I could get my hands on!! I started watching EWTN (The Journey Home) is an excellent resource, and I REALLY started praying!!! I mean I talked to Jesus like I had never really talked to Him before. I truly felt like I was being guided into the Catholic Church and that scared me A LOT!! I finally realized that the next step had to be attending a Mass. I went for 2 nights and sat outside too afraid to go in. The third night I finally took the big leap of faith and went in! I sat on the very BACK pew! I had no idea what to do! I knew NO ONE! But I had the most overwhelming sense of peace that I had EVER had!! I couldn’t explain it. When the Mass was ended and they started to turn the lights out I found myself screaming on the inside “NO! PLEASE WAIT, I DON’T WANT TO LEAVE YET!” I had no idea why I felt that way!! I didn’t realize that the True Presence was there right in front of me and that it was Him that I was longing to be near! I cried all the way home that night! I worked up my nerve to introduce myself to Monsignor and he invited me to RCIA class. I went that week and every week after!! That was January 2011. As Easter Vigil approached, I went to Monsignor privately and pleaded with him. I told him that if I had to wait a whole year before I could receive the Eucharist that I would just die! I LONGED for The Blessed Sacrament. I felt His Presence! I knew He was TRULY there! BODY, BLOOD, SOUL and DIVINITY! Monsignor approved and I was confirmed at Easter Vigil, just 4 months from the time I first walked through the doors on a cold winters night! Jesus is TRULY there!! I know that His Spirit is everywhere, but His Physical Presence is in EVERY CATHOLIC CHURCH!! What a gift I’ve been given! I hope my story will help someone out there who might be struggling with the decision to join the Catholic Church or not. COME HOME!! JESUS IS WAITING FOR YOU THERE!
 
Hello there!
WOW! Some really great stories here!
I too was raised by a very abusive alcoholic father. When he married and impregnated his much younger wife (she is only 2yrs. older than me), I kind of lost my mind! The thought of him rising another child to inflict pain on was unbearable!! I can remember shaking my fist at Heaven and screaming at GOD and telling Him that I didn’t even believe in Him! I see the absurdity of this now. Why would I scream at Someone I didn’t believe in? I really did lose my mind though. Being a victim of child sexual abuse, I was so deeply wounded!!! I tried to kill myself. Now, as an adult, I have to look at the scars from my cuts forever!!

Fortunately, as an adult I found a Church of Christ and I fell in love with the fellowship there. I was baptized and became a member. After a few years there, the pastor moved away and the new pastor that came in was NOT so nice! He showed up at my house one evening and made sexual advances to me. Needless to say, I never went back there!

Years went by and I never found a church where I fit. My walk with the Lord was formal at best. I struggled with my sins and found that I went for LONG periods where I didn’t talk to Him at all.

A few years ago I joined an Independent Fundamental Baptist church. The people were warm and welcoming. I was even asked to teach Sunday school for a toddler class. Life was good…except I had no REAL walk with Jesus! I had periods where I felt so consumed with guilt over this or that, that I didn’t speak to Him at all. I was also struggling A LOT with some of the teachings. ONCE SAVED ALWAYS SAVED, and THE RAPTURE being the 2 main ones. I didn’t believe and they did!

Then the unthinkable happened! A family member was sexually assaulted by a church member. The family refused to press charges against the 15 year old boy, but they really wanted to intervene in this boys life. They tried to talk to his family directly, but that went nowhere, so they asked me to go to the preacher. They thought because I was a teacher in the church, he would be more likely to listen to me. The main issue of concern was that during the assault, the boy said that HE WAS THE MAN AND SHE HAD TO DO AS HE SAID so therefore, she had to consent to the encounter! Our feeling was that since the teachings in this church had lead this boy to believe that, the preacher should at the very least, go to this young man and make sure that he understood that what he had done is NEVER acceptable. He refused!! We ended up leaving.

I suddenly found myself without a church again. I made up my mind that I wasn’t going to get mixed up in the drama of the church scene again. But I felt so empty! I decided to do a HOME BIBLE STUDY. I typed in a computer search and the first hit was A CATHOLIC HOME BIBLE STUDY. When I checked it out and found that it was completely FREE of charge, I sent away for the materials. The first book in the course was a study on MARY! I started reading it (equipped with my trusty KJV Bible) to disprove any errors that I might encounter. Much to my surprise, I not only couldn’t disprove anything but I found that I agreed with everything I was reading.

Then I became very angry!!! All of my life I had heard all of these ANTI-CATHOLIC remarks!!! If they were wrong about Catholic’s and how they REALLY feel about Mary, what else were they wrong about?!! I started reading EVERYTHING Catholic that I could get my hands on!! I started watching EWTN (The Journey Home) is an excellent resource, and I REALLY started praying!!! I mean I talked to Jesus like I had never really talked to Him before. I truly felt like I was being guided into the Catholic Church and that scared me A LOT!! I finally realized that the next step had to be attending a Mass. I went for 2 nights and sat outside too afraid to go in. The third night I finally took the big leap of faith and went in! I sat on the very BACK pew! I had no idea what to do! I knew NO ONE! But I had the most overwhelming sense of peace that I had EVER had!! I couldn’t explain it. When the Mass was ended and they started to turn the lights out I found myself screaming on the inside “NO! PLEASE WAIT, I DON’T WANT TO LEAVE YET!” I had no idea why I felt that way!! I didn’t realize that the True Presence was there right in front of me and that it was Him that I was longing to be near!

I cried all the way home that night! I worked up my nerve to introduce myself to Monsignor and he invited me to RCIA class. I went that week and every week after!! That was January 2011. As Easter Vigil approached, I went to Monsignor privately and pleaded with him. I told him that if I had to wait a whole year before I could receive the Eucharist that I would just die! I LONGED for The Blessed Sacrament. I felt His Presence! I knew He was TRULY there! BODY, BLOOD, SOUL and DIVINITY!

Monsignor approved and I was confirmed at Easter Vigil, just 4 months from the time I first walked through the doors on a cold winters night! Jesus is TRULY there!! I know that His Spirit is everywhere, but His Physical Presence is in EVERY CATHOLIC CHURCH!! What a gift I’ve been given! I hope my story will help someone out there who might be struggling with the decision to join the Catholic Church or not. COME HOME!! JESUS IS WAITING FOR YOU THERE!
I made some paragraphs for you. I like to think of them as friends. 😃
 
I’m currently a Pagan but if I see I’m wrong I will be joining the catholic church! How long does this usually take?
 
I’m currently a Pagan but if I see I’m wrong I will be joining the catholic church! How long does this usually take?
A couple of years, give or take, depending on individual circumstances. This is to give you all of the time you need to begin living the Catholic lifestyle, and to acquire the habits that you’ll need to have, as a Catholic. 🙂
 
I made some paragraphs for you. I like to think of them as friends. 😃
Well I was to a Christian but non denominational , I actually left because I was going to prove to a friend the bible was legit! Only to be debunked and confused with many contradictions! I am for some reason back but this time seaking question from Catholics instead, I hope you guys can helP as this will be my final attempt , thanks
 
A couple of years, give or take, depending on individual circumstances. This is to give you all of the time you need to begin living the Catholic lifestyle, and to acquire the habits that you’ll need to have, as a Catholic. 🙂
A couple of years? Really
 
A couple of years? Really
Yes, really. There is a lot to learn, and a lot to “un-learn” and this process takes time.

I have found that even if you try to speed up the RCIA classes so that people can get done in six months, the people still drag their feet, and still take 18 months to two years from the time of their first interview until they have made a full exit from their previous lifestyle, and started living as a Catholic. It just takes that long, for most people. 🤷
 
A couple of years? Really
RCIA was about 9 months for me, but I was already convinced of the Truth in the Catholic Church. You are welcome to start attending Mass and taking part in the parish events sooner. If you are having questions, this is a great place to ask them, but I would also recommend finding a Priest to help you. Most are busy, but are more than happy to take time with you.👍
 
SMARTY PANTS!!!

HE!HE!HE!

I am NOT very computer savvy, but THANK YOU!

It looks MUCH better!
You’re welcome. It doesn’t take any computer savvy by the way.

Just hit a double return every few sentences and voila you have paragraphs!

Like these. 😃 (Of course these are just one sentence ones because I didn’t have a lot to say:))
 
You’re welcome. It doesn’t take any computer savvy by the way.

Just hit a double return every few sentences and voila you have paragraphs!

Like these. 😃 (Of course these are just one sentence ones because I didn’t have a lot to say:))
Thanks

for

the

tip!!

I’ll remember next time!!!

God bless you!😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top