As I've said from time to time, I come from a mixed Catholic-Protestant heritage. As a result I have attended Catholic and Protestant churches, depending on who, what, where, etc. I haven't heard religious prejudice (like I read here) at all from the pulpit. I don't really understand why this thread gives so much attention to nobodys like Chick. Is that his name? It's like digging up Fr. Coughlin (sp?) and presenting him as representative of Catholicism. Or, such persons, baptized Catholics, like Franco or a Mussolini or a Hitler? Would that be helpful or instructive or fair in any way whatsoever?
Yes, many Protestants were fearful of Catholicism because they honestly believed that Catholicism was likely to suppress religious freedom if it ever became dominant. That seemed to be the tenor of - for example - the "Syllabus of Errors" of Pius IX, not so long ago. About 1870 as I recall, when my grandparents were already alive. Vatican II helped change all this, when Catholics were allowed by their church to enter Protestant churches for ecumenical services as well as baptisms, weddings, funerals, etc. That was strictly forbidden less than 50 years ago, until 1963 or so. I am old enough to recall the change. Almost overnight the taboos disappeared and suddenly Catholics and Protestants were singing shared hymns together. Today Catholic missals are full of hymns by Protestant authors. This shows how much they have in common.
There are pockets of anti-Catholicism, especially among strict Protestant fundamentalists who also are anti-most-other-Protestants. Ironically, these are likely to be the same Protestants who have most in common with Catholics on some key social issues. They are most outspoken in their avid opposition to all abortion and gay marriage, and sometimes artificial birth control. Mainline Protestants as well as moderate evangelicals are not anti-Catholic although they disagree with Catholicism on several doctrines or other matters. Conversely, Catholics disagree with them.
Imagine that the Supreme Court had been predominately Catholic since the country was founded and now it was to have no Catholic on it at all. Donohue would be having a fit. Now the Supreme Court, until recent times always overwhelmingly Protestant, will soon have not a single Protestant. How much protesting do you hear from Protestants? Think about it. If anti-Catholicism were rampant you would hear angry screams from all across the country. Six Catholics, three Jews, zero Protestants in a country where the majority still is Protestant.
What I am asking is this: how healthy is it for Catholics to dwell on little bits and pieces of anti-Catholicism that remain in the USA? Catholics have done very well in America with its Protestant majority. Even now about twice as many Americans are Protestant than are Catholic. Protestant anxiety might have increased as its majority has dwindled. Instead, they realize that democracy, freedom of religion, has become deeply rooted in Americans, whether Protestant or Catholic, and that's comforting..
Growing up, I always thought it was the Catholic side that was much more prejudiced. That's the way it seemed. They were the ones who would not attend family gatherings in Protestant churches, while the Protestant relatives were quick to attend Catholic churches. Thank God that his changed. But to focus on Protestant extremists may give Catholics some weird sort of pleasure, but it provides such far-out cranks and crazies with attention they don't merit - and it makes me sick.
God bless Catholics, Protestants and all creatures and creation. May religion become a bridge and not a barrier.