What's the difference between Mormons and Jehovah's witnesses?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Balcerhouse
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
  1. And finally, 1914 invisible return of Christ to rule as king??? When in Christian History, did anyone teach that Christ wasn’t already King, from conception, and definitely at his resurrection. I would love for you to explain the 1914 math, showing the prophecies that explained it. You know the 7 times, and using wrong dates like 607.
.
And after you explain that, please explain what you make of the WBTS’s false prophecy that the generation who saw the events take place in 1914 would not pass away? How does an organization that claims to be Jehovah’s mouthpiece get that wrong for the majority of it’s history?

The Bible warns us:

"Watch out for false prophets. They come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves. Mat 7:15
 
They didn’t “include” a golden calf in their worship to God, they worshiped the golden calf as God.
They knew who brought them out of the Egypt, look

Exodus 32:8-These are your gods, Israel, who brought you up out of Egypt.

So they worshipped this calf to represent the God that rescued them. Do you really think it mattered how they worshipped the calf or the fact that they worshipped the calf period? Most would agree that it doesn’t matter how the calf was worshipped whether it replaced God or was a physical mediator to try to worship him it was still something disgusting to God. This is what I mean by not peering into the truth. People are so concerned with word play rather than the issue at hand. Do you believe anything can be worshipped other than God, or with God? Secondly, how can you have a relationship with someone and you don’t even know their name only their title…God. YHWH instructed us to use his name…

Genisis 3:15 instructed Moses to give the name and told them to honor this for generation after generation…

15 And God said moreover unto Moses, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, the LORD God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, hath sent me unto you: this is my name for ever, and this is my memorial unto all generations.

the Lord. 6 4:5 Ge 17:7,8 De 1:11,35 4:1 2Ch 28:9 Mt 22:32 Ac 7:32

this is my name for ever. The name here referred to is that which immediately precedes Yehowah, which we translate Lord, the name by which God had been known from the creation of the world, and by which he is known to the present day. Yehowah, from Hawah, to be, subsist, signifies He who is, or subsists, i.e., eminently and in a manner superior to all other beings; and is essentially the same with eheyeh, I AM, in the preceding verse.
 
Seamless? I don’t know the level of your affiliation with the JW, but from your speech and use of key JW scriptures, it seems you are already a member. I will ask you about 3 very strange doctrines that are not seamless in view of the Bible, and ask that you just have to answer one.
  1. When in Christian History before Rutherford and maybe even CT Russel was the teaching that Christians would be divided into two groups? That somehow the majority of Christians are not part of the Body of Christ, do not have Jesus as their mediator, but benefit from the mediation between the little flock and Jesus? That despite John 6, eating and drinking the body and blood of Christ is not necessary for life, ever, not even the one time a year the option is even available? Passing the bread and wine around, while all refuse to eat, to only throw it away after the little party is over; seamless Christian tradition alright.
  2. When did Jews or Christians ever believe that we are not judged on our lives right now? You do realize that JW teach that almost everyone will be resurrected, good and bad, and only then will their lives be what they are judged on.
  3. And finally, 1914 invisible return of Christ to rule as king??? When in Christian History, did anyone teach that Christ wasn’t already King, from conception, and definitely at his resurrection. I would love for you to explain the 1914 math, showing the prophecies that explained it. You know the 7 times, and using wrong dates like 607.
I hope you realize that there are great thinkers in the Church and always have been, just because the Church doesn’t force its people to learn it all, does not make them bad. You have to take responsibility for yourself if you need the extra knowledge.
Great thinkers…The bible describes this differently…
Zeph 3:9“For then I will purify the lips of the peoples, that they may all call on the name of Yahweh, to serve him shoulder to shoulder."
worldebible.com/zephaniah/3.htm

You seem to have a fair dislike for the history of JWs, they can be annoying with all the knocking on doors. You have raised 3 important topics, and from my brief study of the scriptures I would love to answer your questions. I would like to answer your questions individually in order to really find truth, but before I answer your questions I would like to know if you understand the history of the Israelites. What is the significance of the Levites, this will help us understand question 1?

What is the significance of the Levites???
 
JW’s believe in the bible, and follow the teachings of Jesus the closest of any religion. They seem to be very misunderstood, and if you actually listen to their message it flows together seamlessly. I have studied with them and was charged with proving the scriptures they gave me wrong. Honestly I couldn’t, and it was ok for me to have to adjust my way of thinking about the scriptures after careful study. Look…

They believe that due to Adam/Eve’s sin
Code:
Genesis 3:15 -And I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.
This refers to Jesus dying for our sins to reverse the sin we inherited. Jesus is bruised in the heel by Satan, then he bruises him in the head at the conclusion of things. They also believe that through Jesus (Jesus means YHWH is salvation) humans are able to be saved.
Code:
John 3:16- For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
They also don’t believe God and Jesus are the same person, and this was difficult for me…But after analyzing how the previous Israelites and Christians lived during Jesus era, they recognized God as YHWH. Look…
Code:
 Exodus 3:15-And God said moreover unto Moses, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, the Lord God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, hath sent me unto you: this is my name for ever, and this is my memorial unto all generations.
Look at how it is translated from the Septuagint (70 who translated Hebrew scrolls to Greek during Jesus Day, and these are the same manuscripts used by Jesus and his disciples)
Code:
 Exodus 3:15-God said moreover to Moses, "You shall tell the children of Israel this, 'Yahweh, the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, has sent me to you.' This is my name forever, and this is my memorial to all generations.
Interestingly enough Barnes’ Notes “ The name signifies that by which God makes Himself known, the memorial that by which His people worship Him.” Notice this applies to all generations…Also take a look at this scripture found at
Code:
Psalms 83:18-That men may know that thou, whose name alone is Jehovah, art the most high over all the earth.
This scripture haunted my belief that I held on to dearly about God Jesus being equal. This is from Jesus’ lips…
Code:
John 13:16-Verily, verily, I say unto you, The servant is not greater than his lord; neither he that is sent greater than he that sent him.
From reading John 3:16 we clearly see that Jesus was sent by YHWH, and he is in constant submission to YHWH, who resurrected him on the third day.
I have to say I tried to defend my belief with everything I had, but it just makes too much sense to me. I will honestly say I learned more in studying for 3 months than I have learned in my entire life. I have never been encouraged to read the bible myself, and try to find error. I couldn’t, the difference I found is that JW’s know the bible, and their beliefs are strictly based off the scriptures….Please if anyone can find error in what I have presented please show me that I may make a solid defense.
Of course the council of Nicea kind of settled the dispute regarding the divinity of Jesus. I know its difficult by pulling a verse here or these and building an argument for or against something, but doesn’t the Gospel of John pretty much say that Jesus is divine? If it didn’t, why do the JW’s need to change John 1? Who do you say that I am ?

Also, the JW’s believe the church went into heresy right after the death of the apostles. Does this make sense? The people directly taught by the apostles perverting the gospel? So, if this is true, then how can you trust the later councils that selected the books that would become the NT? Weren’t they full of heretics? You can read Justin Martyr, Clement, Polycarp, etc, etc and they must all be heretics?

You see, once you throw away Tradition, there is really no foundation to stand on. The Bible is a mirror of Tradition. Just read the history of how the selection of NT books was done, based on Tradition. So you now have a NT based Tradition, but someone later comes along and says, Wait, that tradition is not in the Bible. Not very logical. That’s the way I see it at least.
 
Great thinkers…The bible describes this differently…
Zeph 3:9“For then I will purify the lips of the peoples, that they may all call on the name of Yahweh, to serve him shoulder to shoulder."
worldebible.com/zephaniah/3.htm
You seem to have a fair dislike for the history of JWs, they can be annoying with all the knocking on doors. You have raised 3 important topics, and from my brief study of the scriptures I would love to answer your questions. I would like to answer your questions individually in order to really find truth, but before I answer your questions I would like to know if you understand the history of the Israelites. What is the significance of the Levites, this will help us understand question 1?
What is the significance of the Levites???
I really hope that you are not insulting the saints in your silly, out of context quote of Zephaniah. It sounds as if you are saying that the JW are the people that God has purified their lips, because they all follow the exact same ideas. I hope you realize that the Catholic Church has always had unified beliefs that its members must accept. The difference being that the Church’s Dogma is purely scriptural and from ancient Christian History/Tradition; and the JW’s being from men in New York, USA, based on pyramids, visions, purposeful twisting of scripture, wanting to stand out as different.

And as far as the Levites, yes I know about the priesthood of the tribe of Levi. And I know where you are going with that, but you are traveling backwards through salvation history, and if you are going to travel backwards, you must go all the way backwards, not conveniently stop where you want. Do you realize that all the tribes were to have priests from their firstborn, but because of the sins of the israelites, the tribe of Levi was chosen? Also if you continue going back to Abraham, you notice the whole world would be made sons and daughters of him, and Noah too. And to further shy away from the priestly class of Levi, Jesus was made priest and he was from the tribe of Judah. This was to specifically show God’s choice, not a line of decent. And all of this doesn’t even matter as far as the chosen after Christ’s first coming, because now we are made members of God’s kingdom by our baptism, not because of Levi. Also, it was never taught that just because you were part of the tribe of Levi, you would go to heaven, and if not you go to paradise earth. JW don’t even believe that, so any significance of the “anointed” with the tribe of Levi is just pointless.

So to get back to my question, which really has nothing to do with priestly classes, when in “Christian History” was there a division between Heaven and Earth inhabitants? Some worthy to eat and drink Christ, and others not worthy because they are merely Paradise hopers. When in fact did the idea that Heaven and Earth having to be separate happen? The Church has always taught that in Christ’s second coming and the resurrection, that all things will be made new, and all of Earth will become part of Heaven.
 
Before anyone goes too far down the rabbit hole of debating "sola inscriptura " with a JW, the JW should back up and agree not to use the flawed Watchtower “translation”, or else defend the Watchtower’s competence and authority to edit scripture.
 
What is a christian to you?
**A Christian is someone who believes Jesus was God, as God, from all eternity. Because of the consubstantiality of the Trinity, He, the Second Person of the Trinity, is the One Supreme God - the One Supreme Triune God. ** (It was only at some point in human time (not even at the beginning of human time) that He united His eternal Divine nature to our human nature.)

Mormons do not believe that Jesus was God, as God, from all eternity.
Mormons believe Jesus is subordinate to God the Father. They believe God the Father alone is the Supreme Being (in this universe).
(As of yet, I’ve been unable to discover if they believe there are many other inhabited universes with a “Supreme Being” at the head of each of those universes.)

JW’s do not believe Jesus is God.
IMO, belief that Jesus Christ is God is crucial to be called a "Christian". It is the first thing one must believe about Him to be considered a “Christian”.
All kinds of people believe the person called “Jesus” existed.
All kinds of people believe He taught a good message and lived a good life. But that does not make them a Christian. (Eg. Mahatma Ghandi)
 
JW’s believe in the bible, and follow the teachings of Jesus the closest of any religion. They seem to be very misunderstood, and if you actually listen to their message it flows together seamlessly. I have studied with them and was charged with proving the scriptures they gave me wrong. Honestly I couldn’t, and it was ok for me to have to adjust my way of thinking about the scriptures after careful study. Look…

They believe that due to Adam/Eve’s sin
Code:
Genesis 3:15 -And I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.
This refers to Jesus dying for our sins to reverse the sin we inherited. Jesus is bruised in the heel by Satan, then he bruises him in the head at the conclusion of things. They also believe that through Jesus (Jesus means YHWH is salvation) humans are able to be saved.
Code:
John 3:16- For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
They also don’t believe God and Jesus are the same person, and this was difficult for me…But after analyzing how the previous Israelites and Christians lived during Jesus era, they recognized God as YHWH. Look…
Code:
 Exodus 3:15-And God said moreover unto Moses, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, the Lord God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, hath sent me unto you: this is my name for ever, and this is my memorial unto all generations.
Look at how it is translated from the Septuagint (70 who translated Hebrew scrolls to Greek during Jesus Day, and these are the same manuscripts used by Jesus and his disciples)
Code:
 Exodus 3:15-God said moreover to Moses, "You shall tell the children of Israel this, 'Yahweh, the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, has sent me to you.' This is my name forever, and this is my memorial to all generations.
Interestingly enough Barnes’ Notes “ The name signifies that by which God makes Himself known, the memorial that by which His people worship Him.” Notice this applies to all generations…Also take a look at this scripture found at
Code:
Psalms 83:18-That men may know that thou, whose name alone is Jehovah, art the most high over all the earth.
This scripture haunted my belief that I held on to dearly about God Jesus being equal. This is from Jesus’ lips…
Code:
John 13:16-Verily, verily, I say unto you, The servant is not greater than his lord; neither he that is sent greater than he that sent him.
From reading John 3:16 we clearly see that Jesus was sent by YHWH, and he is in constant submission to YHWH, who resurrected him on the third day.
I have to say I tried to defend my belief with everything I had, but it just makes too much sense to me. I will honestly say I learned more in studying for 3 months than I have learned in my entire life. I have never been encouraged to read the bible myself, and try to find error. I couldn’t, the difference I found is that JW’s know the bible, and their beliefs are strictly based off the scriptures….Please if anyone can find error in what I have presented please show me that I may make a solid defense.
I would say the JW’s “know” what THEY THINK the Bible to BE; they know something that is a departure from the REAL Bible… their New World Translation is a deliberate & deplorable departure from authentic RCC translations. No Biblical Scholar worth his salt would give a plug nickel for it. First year Greek students can easily find the errors deliberately placed within it’s worthless pages.

LDS believe in the Bible insofar as it is 'translated correctly", a silly but effective manipulation flung at adherents; how & when if ever do they do their homework? Who guides them through the process? The wolf in sheep’s clothing perhaps? :hypno:

NEITHER JW or LDS know who JESUS really IS…

If you don’t get God/Jesus/Holy Spirit right, then not much else REALLY MATTERS! It just all falls flat doesn’t it? :stretcher:
 
Upon what truths do we build a relationship with Mormons? To shepard them to the truth? Or do we just let them go to hell?

How do we build relationships with them without being condesending?
 
So they worshipped this calf to represent the God that rescued them. Do you really think it mattered how they worshipped the calf or the fact that they worshipped the calf period? Most would agree that it doesn’t matter how the calf was worshipped whether it replaced God or was a physical mediator to try to worship him it was still something disgusting to God. This is what I mean by not peering into the truth. People are so concerned with word play rather than the issue at hand. Do you believe anything can be worshipped other than God, or with God? Secondly, how can you have a relationship with someone and you don’t even know their name only their title…God. YHWH instructed us to use his name…
Greetings and peace ChristianAD,

Sorry I’ve been out but we had a funeral service for my cousin. May he rest in peace O Lord!

I see you decided not to open any new threads for these different topics so I guess we will have to continue defending these untruths here until we are stopped by the mod. But I do wish you would answer my question that has been avoided twice now.

Until then I don’t mind now discussing “worship” as it is a favorite subject of Catholics that we have perfected.

JWs like to use the whole “gesturing” or “posturing” argument to prove, in a visible way, one worships an object or person they shouldn’t be worshiping. (i.e. golden calf, Mary, the pope, the flag…).

The Greek words for worship in the NT is “proskyneo” and “sebo”. Together they are used 70 times in the KJV. In the NWT when referring to God this word is translated as “worship” 100% of the time. The same word, when referring to Jesus translate to “obeisance” (honor) 100% of the time. Even in the passages where there is a double action reference like Mt 2:11 …they saw the young child with Mary its mother, and, falling down, they did obeisance to it [him]NWT.

If what JWs say is true that when we bow to an object/person we are worshiping it/them – why wouldn’t the NWT translate “proskyneo” as “worship” the many times people “fell down and…”, “dropped to their knees and…” “prostrated themselves and…” to Jesus? Either the JWs must recognize Jesus as being worshiped and not just be honored or they must recognize all gesturing/posturing/honoring by others could be just that honoring or obeisance. Right?

Peace be with you always!!!
 
The scriptures also reveal that the early Church had established the custom of meeting on the first day if the week. See Acts 20:7. To understand why this day was selected, see John 20:19, and all four gospels treatment of the resurrection.
 
My answer has been posted by others! But worshiping multiple gods is not christian, good enough?
So my next question is Why an easter bunny and what does Easter mean? Research the history of this…
 
I’ll never understand why anyone would give credibility to either religion. Both are rooted in anti-Catholicism, and assert themselves as the authoritative replacement. WHY is this trust given to 19th century organizations and people? What is the allure?
 
the scriptures also reveal that the early church had established the custom of meeting on the first day if the week. See acts 20:7. To understand why this day was selected, see john 20:19, and all four gospels treatment of the resurrection.
yes and constantine declared this in 321ce dies solis…

Do your research…notice everything took place on the 1st of the week after sabbath…could it be that they were respecting the sabbath?

Treasures are usually buried those who seek will find…
 
Hey, instead of bringing up more and more topics, why don’t you answer one of the 3 questions about the seamless theology of the JW that I gave you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top