D
Dr_Meinheimer
Guest
Do you also blame women for their own rapes if they go back intoxicated to a man’s house with him?
I hold the rational and legally established view that anyone participating in negligent behavior increases their probability of an unfortunate event and thereby, as a statement of fact, shoulders a portion of that blame.Do you also blame women for their own rapes if they go back intoxicated to a man’s house with him?
Well, in the real world where things can’t usually be over-simplified to the point of fallacy into one of two hyper-narrow ideological camps…
…again, this is just the real world I’m describing…
…we run into this situation were the blame for complex problems is virtually never the property of one sole party.
Like the woman who shot her husband. She planned it out and straight-up murdered him. 100% she’s to blame, right?
Not if you factor the years of emotional and physical abuse the man put her through, often laced with enslaving promises of “if you ever leave me, I’ll kill you” or something like that.
The only people I know of that still credibly believe in black-and-white, “blame goes here and not here”, radically oversimplified explanations are children.
Children .
When one sees a mob, drive away from it it. If they decide to go through it, they assume ownership of some of the fault of anything that can potentially happen with unruly mobs. This is the educated, adult perspective.
And hey, I’m smart enough to know that there are 1% situations that can’t be avoided. The 1% doesn’t condemn the other 99%.
I’m also smart enough to know that when something bad happens, people usually omit the parts of the story that might make them seem like they could share a little of the fault-pie. “I was just a sweet little babe in the woods and this big, bad wolf came up!”
Sure…
You are wrong here Hume.Well, in the real world where things can’t usually be over-simplified to the point of fallacy into one of two hyper-narrow ideological camps…
…again, this is just the real world I’m describing…
…we run into this situation were the blame for complex problems is virtually never the property of one sole party.
Where are you getting this from Hume?Events where a “sweet, innocent babe in the woods” is suddenly and seemingly randomly attacked by a “big, bad, black wolf” is largely a children’s story.
Completely agree.A woman doesn’t rape herself. Particularly when she is intoxicated and vulnerable, and not in a position to defend herself, a man taking advantage of her is especially despicable, and he needs to be held responsible for his actions.
Analogy fail“I walked into the lion preserve with raw cutlets dangling from my belt …