Where did Jesus, Mary Magdalene and Joseph of Arimathea go?

[paarsurrey]

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=4814655&postcount=84
The Wedding of Jesus

Originally Posted by Ben Masada:
To predict or to sense? What does this have to do with taking a wife? Besides, Jesus survived the cross and left with Mary Magdalene and Joseph of Arimathea. Look throughout the NT for some word about these three people after Jesus said goodbye to his disciples and was gone. Sorry my friend if things
don’t have to be the way you wish they were.

Ben:

Originally Posted by **Randy Carson: **
If what you say is true, then Jesus was predicting His death, but since he was only a man (and not God), he could not know that he would survive ahead of time. He expected to die. Period.

Again, it would not make sense to take a wife under these circumstances.

I love Jesus

Thanks

 

[Catholic90]

You just really have no grasp of what life was like for Roman soldiers, do you? To fail at their job of killing was to ensure their own death. Romans did not fail.

They were professionals at what they did, and they were very good at it.

 

[paarsurrey]

You just really have no grasp of what life was like for Roman soldiers, do you? To fail at their job of killing was to ensure their own death. Romans did not fail.

They were professionals at what they did, and they were very good at it.

Hi

I wonder what effect the Romans had on the movements of Jesus, Mary Magdalene and Joseph of Arimathea . Kindly expalin the connection in clear terms.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran.

Thanks

 

[S_J_Thaikattil]

Hi

I wonder what effect the Romans had on the movements of Jesus, Mary Magdalene and Joseph of Arimathea . Kindly expalin the connection in clear terms.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran.

Thanks

Paarsurrey, as a Muslim you really should only concern yourself with the life of Mohammad. Christians don’t tell Muslims what they should or should not believe about Mohammad. Leave it to the Christians to sort out for themselves about the life of Jesus Christ. Jesus was crucified in 33 AD in Israel. Mohammad was born in 570 AD in Mecca and had his first revelation forty years later 610 AD.

If you believe in Jesus and Mary, then respect the Christian view derived from eye witness accounts of His life in Israel without forcing Muslim views on Christians, views which stem from Mecca many centuries later. Surely you realize that Christianity was nearly six centuries old and a well established religion, had spread to far away lands, had seats of learning in monasteries, many dioceses with bishops etc in many countries and had even been accepted by a European Emperor Constantine three centuries earlier, before Mohammad was even born?

 

[paarsurrey]

Paarsurrey, as a Muslim you really should only concern yourself with the life of Mohammad.

If you believe in Jesus and Mary, then respect the Christian

Hi

I respect Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran. I have very much concern for the truth.

I love Jesus and Muhammad

Thanks

 

[Eucharisted]

Hi

I respect Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran. I have very much concern for the truth.

I love Jesus and Muhammad

Thanks

So why aren’t you Muslim if you respect Jesus and Mary as mentioned in the Qu’ran? And if you really are concerned about the truth, than why do you not listen to us when we tell you the truth? Stop trolling CAF and go away.

 

[WarriorAngel]

Hi

I wonder what effect the Romans had on the movements of Jesus, Mary Magdalene and Joseph of Arimathea . Kindly expalin the connection in clear terms.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran.

Thanks

Well, not sure what your question is - BUT - if you are asking where Jesus went?

Back in those times, Roman soldiers were placed four feet around any given place they had to guard.
They did not sleep. They took turns being on watch.
IF a soldier failed - they were given the same type death sentence - so failure was not an option.

Now can you imagine being a soldier and losing the body of Christ??

Matthew 27

61 And there was there Mary Magdalen, and the other Mary sitting over against the sepulchre. 62 And the next day, which followed the day of preparation, the chief priests and the Pharisees came together to Pilate, 63 Saying: Sir, we have remembered, that that seducer said, while he was yet alive: After three days I will rise again. 64 Command therefore the sepulchre to be guarded until the third day: lest perhaps his disciples come and steal him away, and say to the people: He is risen from the dead; and the last error shall be worse than the first. 65 Pilate saith to them: You have a guard; go, guard it as you know.
66 And they departing, made the sepulchre sure, sealing the stone, and setting guards.

When He rose again - He left a miracle behind for humanity to see and know He was here…
www.shroud.com/examine.htm <~ Click
or ~> http://www.shroud.com/menu.htm

 

[S_J_Thaikattil]

Hi

I respect Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran. I have very much concern for the truth.

I love Jesus and Muhammad

Thanks

Paarsurrey, you should know that Christians treat as heresy any account of Jesus Christ that contradicts eye witness accounts of His life as mentioned in the New Testament.

As a Muslim you are free to believe what is written in the Quran.

 

[paarsurrey]

eye witness accounts of His (Jesus) life as mentioned in the New Testament.

Hi

I don’t think there is any “eye witness accounts of His (Jesus) life” in the NTBible. For example on the event of Crucifixion all the disciples had fled, I think it is also mentioned in the NTBible.

The only eye-witness was the All-Seeing and All-observing God Allah YHWH; who says that they could not kill Jesus on the Cross. Lone Witnessing of God Allah is sufficient; needs no further witnessing, in my opinion.

This is what I believe from Quran; others could believe differently as per their faith with sound reasons, no compulsion.

I love Jesus

Thanks

 

[S_J_Thaikattil]

Hi

I don’t think there is any “eye witness accounts of His (Jesus) life” in the NTBible. For example on the event of Crucifixion all the disciples had fled, I think it is also mentioned in the NTBible.

The only eye-witness was the All-Seeing and All-observing God Allah YHWH; who says that they could not kill Jesus on the Cross. Lone Witnessing of God Allah is sufficient; needs no further witnessing, in my opinion.

This is what I believe from Quran; others could believe differently as per their faith with sound reasons, no compulsion.

I love Jesus

Thanks

The problem Paarsurrey is that you insist only what is written in the Quran can be true. It may seem that way to you as a Muslim. I’m not about to convince you otherwise.

But in the Bible if you read carefully enough you will notice that the crucifixion of Jesus was a public event witnessed by many Jews, including Roman soldiers who actually crucified Him. Remember the mother of Jesus, Mary Magalene and Apostle John at the foot of the cross, how His body was handed by the Roman soldiers to Joseph of Arimethia for burial etc?

It is written that the disciples of Jesus fled when He was first arrested in the garden, but Peter followed Him at a distance. We know for certain John was at the foot of the cross just before Jesus died. It is logical to assume other disciples, except Judas, followed Him at a distance after first having run away in fear, and were in the crowd witnessing the crucifixion. How could John, the mother of Jesus, Mary Magdalene, have suddenly appeared at the foot of the cross otherwise?

If you choose to ignore all of that written in the Bible as a Muslim simply because the Quran does not record it, what do you want Christians to do? Throw away their own Scripture and accept the Quran instead? Is that a realistic expectation?

 

[swariffin]

Hi

I don’t think there is any “eye witness accounts of His (Jesus) life” in the NTBible. For example on the event of Crucifixion all the disciples had fled, I think it is also mentioned in the NTBible.

The only eye-witness was the All-Seeing and All-observing God Allah YHWH; who says that they could not kill Jesus on the Cross. Lone Witnessing of God Allah is sufficient; needs no further witnessing, in my opinion.

This is what I believe from Quran; others could believe differently as per their faith with sound reasons, no compulsion.

I love Jesus

Thanks

Do you discount the gospel of John as well as the letters of Paul? John was underneath the cross together with Mary mother of Jesus and Mary Magdalene. Many people told you so, and you don’t even care to check, but continue saying that none is the witness of the Cross. Please read the gospel of John again, and don’t run away from questions directed to you, OK?

I

 

[paarsurrey]

Do you discount the gospel of John as well as the letters of Paul? John was underneath the cross together with Mary mother of Jesus and Mary Magdalene. Many people told you so, and you don’t even care to check, but continue saying that none is the witness of the Cross. Please read the gospel of John again, and don’t run away from questions directed to you, OK?

I

Hi

Where was John standing and saw Jesus on the Cross? Kindly quote from Matthew, if he was there.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in the Quran.

Thanks

 

[S_J_Thaikattil]

Hi

Where was John standing and saw Jesus on the Cross? Kindly quote from Matthew, if he was there.
I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in the Quran.
Thanks

Paarsurrey, you should begin by quoting when Mohammad who was born in 570 AD was at the foot of Jesus’ cross in 33 AD.

 

[paarsurrey]

What do you want Christians to do? Throw away their own Scripture and accept the Quran instead? Is that a realistic expectation?

Hi

I never say to Hindus to throw away their scriptures, or to Jews to throw away their Torah, or to Buddhists to throw away their Scriptures; so how I can say to the Christians to throw away their scriptures.

I only say to all that accept only the TRUTH in them. How could one close one’s eyes to the Truth?

This is what i believe sincerely; others could believe differently out of their free will but with good reason and rational arguments.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran.

Thanks

 

[jblake]

S J Thaikattil;:

If you choose to ignore all of that written in the Bible as a Muslim simply because the Quran does not record it,

The irony here is that the Torah, The Psalms,and the Gospels are also canonical for Islam.

jonathon

 

[S_J_Thaikattil]

Hi
I never say to Hindus to throw away their scriptures, or to Jews to throw away their Torah, or to Buddhists to throw away their Scriptures; so how I can say to the Christians to throw away their scriptures.
I only say to all that accept only the TRUTH in them. How could one close one’s eyes to the Truth?
This is what i believe sincerely; others could believe differently out of their free will but with good reason and rational arguments.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran.

Thanks

PaarSurrey, there is only one minor flaw to your efforts at propagating your truth. You want Jews and Christians to accept the Quran as the truth. What rational arguments do you bring except to say the OT of the Jews and NT of Christians are wrong because the Quran says so and you believe it to be the truth? It is your truth. So keep it. But don’t be surprised if Christians don’t accept it. They have their own Scripture you know.

 

[Cluny]

Jesus ascended into heaven.

St. Joseph of Arimathea went to Britain–Cornwall, I believe.

St. Mary Magdalene went to Asia Minor.

That is, if you REALLY want to know, paarsurrey.

 

[Kaninchen]

St. Joseph of Arimathea went to Britain–Cornwall, I believe.

Brits would have you believe that he went to Glastonbury (Somerset, not Cornwall) so that’s why they have a huge Popular Music Festival every year (and get rained-on).

The second part is a joke but only partly - Glastonbury is supposed to be very ‘spiritual’, so that’s why the Festival started, they also often get rained-on.

 

[jblake]

Cluny;:

St. Joseph of Arimathea went to Britain–Cornwall, I believe.

Glastonbury

St. Mary Magdalene went to Asia Minor.

One legend sends her to the south of France. A different legend sends her to Glastonbury. A third legend sends her to Egypt ---- though that usually is only as a way station to either France, or England. There is also a tale of her being in Kashmir.

The problem with most of these legends, is that the earliest record of them, is centuries after the fact.

jonathon

 

[paarsurrey]

Originally Posted by **Cluny: **

St. Joseph of Arimathea went to Britain–Cornwall, I believe

Originally Posted by jblake:
Glastonbury

Originally Posted by **Cluny: **
St. Mary Magdalene went to Asia Minor.

One legend sends her to the south of France. A different legend sends her to Glastonbury. A third legend sends her to Egypt ---- though that usually is only as a way station to either France, or England. There is also a tale of her being in Kashmir.

The problem with most of these legends, is that the earliest record of them, is centuries after the fact.

jonathon

Hi

Thank you for bringing us on the topiec.

Kindly quote all the legendry sources if there are no in the NTBible; nevermind.

I love Jesus and Mary as mentioned in Quran.

Thanks