Which Church is God's true Church, and why? Is it the Roman Catholic Church?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jimmy_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Youre kidding right? What have you proved? You just try to piggy back other people…you are way out of your league…go to bed.
No I’m not kidding, and GROW UP!

You’re acting younger than me! And I’m 15!

I have proved that you are the one bashing and OTCA is the one defending.

Why did I have to spell it out for you? You’re 43!

You are the one out of your league. Now go have fun looking at Uranus.

Oh, wait it was Jupiter I think. My bad!
 
No I’m not kidding, and GROW UP!

You’re acting younger than me! And I’m 15!

I have proved that you are the one bashing and OTCA is the one defending.

Why did I have to spell it out for you? You’re 43!

You are the one out of your league. Now go have fun looking at Uranus.

Oh, wait it was Jupiter I think. My bad!
  1. did I call it or what…go to bed kid. Like I said, youre out of your league. Do yourself a favor, read your Bible, youre still young…you can find Christ and the Truth…
 
  1. did I call it or what…go to bed kid. Like I said, youre out of your league. Do yourself a favor, read your Bible, youre still young…you can find Christ and the Truth…
No one is ever out of their league when it comes to defending their faith.

Is telling me to go to bed your way of shutting me up? Good luck.

Am I young? Yes.

Am I to young to discover the truth? No.

I have already found the truth, Avenger. The truth lies with the Church.

Take a look around. How much support are you getting here? NONE

What are the people saying about you? “He’s crazy”.

Your out of your league, man.

Take a rest old man. You need it.
 
No one is ever out of their league when it comes to defending their faith.

Is telling me to go to bed your way of shutting me up? Good luck.

Am I young? Yes.

Am I to young to discover the truth? No.

I have already found the truth, Avenger. The truth lies with the Church.

Take a look around. How much support are you getting here? NONE

What are the people saying about you? “He’s crazy”.

Your out of your league, man.

Take a rest old man. You need it.
LOL youre funny kid. Wow, no support in a Catholic forum…well thats a newsflash! I admire your tenacity at such a young age…at your age I thought like you…you will see the Truth in time.
 
LOL youre funny kid. Wow, no support in a Catholic forum…well thats a newsflash! I cant work over a kid, so go on your way.
Don’t play me down because I’m younger than you.

I can take you on. Let’s go. I can refute any argument you have. I’ve gone up against anti-Catholics 10 times harder than you.

I want to see you try and beat me.
 
Don’t play me down because I’m younger than you.

I can take you on. Let’s go. I can refute any argument you have. I’ve gone up against anti-Catholics 10 times harder than you.

I want to see you try and beat me.
Kid, this is beyond you…and you have already been found lacking…I admire the tenacity, but let it go.
 
Kid, this is beyond you…and you have already been found lacking…I admire the tenacity, but let it go.
Trying to shut me up? That’s low.

Are you afraid of losing to a 15 year old?

Please, show me where I am lacking. I’m dying to know.
 
Trying to shut me up? That’s low.

Are you afraid of losing to a 15 year old?

Please, show me where I am lacking. I’m dying to know.
kid, Im not getting into this with you…suffice it to say that you need to re-read what you posted to see your lack of substance…really, let this go. I wont entertain a debate with a child.
 
kid, Im not getting into this with you…suffice it to say that you need to re-read what you posted to see your lack of substance…really, let this go. I wont entertain a debate with a child.
So you lose?
 
You wrote:

"“I will tell you this if it were not for the Early Church Fathers who were CATHOLICS who WROTE the SCRIPTURES 300 years or so after Jesus went to Heaven…”

So which is it? Or you cant keep you nonsense straight?
Avenger,

Reading your posts is just mind-boggling. First of all, you come into a Catholic forum showing NO CHARITY whatsoever. There have been protestants in this forum before that are warm, caring, very Bible-literate, and genuine in their beliefs. But the difference is, they’re respectful of our beliefs and want a good, solid, real debate. You come in here insulting Catholics right and left with accusations of ludicrous stoicism and blatant disregard for the scriptures. I find those remarks insulting and ignorant.

Our faith in not innovative, as you’d like to pretend or suppose. Christ established ONE Church on this earth and He charged Peter with its governance. That governance is assured error-free and is directed from the holy spirit. Our faith has not changed but only grown in the various devotions and insights of our myriad of saints, theologians, and geniuses like Augustine, Aquinas, John Paul II and our current pope.

Our faith is sacramental, charitable, kind, and holy. Our faith is honest not giving people an empty promise of salvation through simple intellectual assent to faith. You make the silly charge that our Church teaches works as salvific. You obviously haven’t read the catechism but heard all this off of some lunatic anti-Catholic website. Our religion is based on works plus faith. If you can’t see Christ admonishing us to do good works and live our faith right and left in the Gospels, then you’re the one in need of Bible study.

You also don’t place your denomination in your profile…something to hide?

The Church came before the scriptures were even written and long before the cannon was finalized. The early church fathers, whom you seem NOT to respect, give us much insight into what the early church looked like. It was sacramental, episcopal in structure, had a firm faith in the Eucharist and the real presence therein, believed in the intercessions of the saints and Mary, and was definitely NOT a sola scriptura bible study group like you’d like to believe.

Now maybe you think you’re going to get brownie points with your pastor or even God by coming in here and blasting us lowly Catholics with your ‘enlightened’ Bible wizardry that you learned on an internet study coarse or at Holy Harvest Reformed First Church of God down the street, but you’re not impressing anyone. You’re also not winning followers or converts by treating people with rampant disrespect and condescention. You’re behaving like an angry troll on a forum for Catholics.

If you want to debate, do it with civility and kindness. But if all you have is insults and the tired and corny “you Catholics don’t read the bible!” boloney, give us all a break!
 
nice post gurneyhalleck1… haven’t seen you around lately… how ya doin?
 
Avenger,

Reading your posts is just mind-boggling. First of all, you come into a Catholic forum showing NO CHARITY whatsoever. There have been protestants in this forum before that are warm, caring, very Bible-literate, and genuine in their beliefs. But the difference is, they’re respectful of our beliefs and want a good, solid, real debate. You come in here insulting Catholics right and left with accusations of ludicrous stoicism and blatant disregard for the scriptures. I find those remarks insulting and ignorant.

Our faith in not innovative, as you’d like to pretend or suppose. Christ established ONE Church on this earth and He charged Peter with its governance. That governance is assured error-free and is directed from the holy spirit. Our faith has not changed but only grown in the various devotions and insights of our myriad of saints, theologians, and geniuses like Augustine, Aquinas, John Paul II and our current pope.

Our faith is sacramental, charitable, kind, and holy. Our faith is honest not giving people an empty promise of salvation through simple intellectual assent to faith. You make the silly charge that our Church teaches works as salvific. You obviously haven’t read the catechism but heard all this off of some lunatic anti-Catholic website. Our religion is based on works plus faith. If you can’t see Christ admonishing us to do good works and live our faith right and left in the Gospels, then you’re the one in need of Bible study.

You also don’t place your denomination in your profile…something to hide?

The Church came before the scriptures were even written and long before the cannon was finalized. The early church fathers, whom you seem NOT to respect, give us much insight into what the early church looked like. It was sacramental, episcopal in structure, had a firm faith in the Eucharist and the real presence therein, believed in the intercessions of the saints and Mary, and was definitely NOT a sola scriptura bible study group like you’d like to believe.

Now maybe you think you’re going to get brownie points with your pastor or even God by coming in here and blasting us lowly Catholics with your ‘enlightened’ Bible wizardry that you learned on an internet study coarse or at Holy Harvest Reformed First Church of God down the street, but you’re not impressing anyone. You’re also not winning followers or converts by treating people with rampant disrespect and condescention. You’re behaving like an angry troll on a forum for Catholics.

If you want to debate, do it with civility and kindness. But if all you have is insults and the tired and corny “you Catholics don’t read the bible!” boloney, give us all a break!
Nothing to hide …no denomination to claim…Ive spent all day responding to diatribe as this all day, wont do it again here
 
Avenger,

Reading your posts is just mind-boggling. First of all, you come into a Catholic forum showing NO CHARITY whatsoever. There have been protestants in this forum before that are warm, caring, very Bible-literate, and genuine in their beliefs. But the difference is, they’re respectful of our beliefs and want a good, solid, real debate. You come in here insulting Catholics right and left with accusations of ludicrous stoicism and blatant disregard for the scriptures. I find those remarks insulting and ignorant.

Our faith in not innovative, as you’d like to pretend or suppose. Christ established ONE Church on this earth and He charged Peter with its governance. That governance is assured error-free and is directed from the holy spirit. Our faith has not changed but only grown in the various devotions and insights of our myriad of saints, theologians, and geniuses like Augustine, Aquinas, John Paul II and our current pope.

Our faith is sacramental, charitable, kind, and holy. Our faith is honest not giving people an empty promise of salvation through simple intellectual assent to faith. You make the silly charge that our Church teaches works as salvific. You obviously haven’t read the catechism but heard all this off of some lunatic anti-Catholic website. Our religion is based on works plus faith. If you can’t see Christ admonishing us to do good works and live our faith right and left in the Gospels, then you’re the one in need of Bible study.

You also don’t place your denomination in your profile…something to hide?

The Church came before the scriptures were even written and long before the cannon was finalized. The early church fathers, whom you seem NOT to respect, give us much insight into what the early church looked like. It was sacramental, episcopal in structure, had a firm faith in the Eucharist and the real presence therein, believed in the intercessions of the saints and Mary, and was definitely NOT a sola scriptura bible study group like you’d like to believe.

Now maybe you think you’re going to get brownie points with your pastor or even God by coming in here and blasting us lowly Catholics with your ‘enlightened’ Bible wizardry that you learned on an internet study coarse or at Holy Harvest Reformed First Church of God down the street, but you’re not impressing anyone. You’re also not winning followers or converts by treating people with rampant disrespect and condescention. You’re behaving like an angry troll on a forum for Catholics.

If you want to debate, do it with civility and kindness. But if all you have is insults and the tired and corny “you Catholics don’t read the bible!” boloney, give us all a break!
Now hold on here a minute. None of you can show a shread of evidence that the Roman Catholic church was the Early Church. I can see him pressing any and all of you for the information and all you can do is be strength in numbers upon one Protestant. But not one of you has answers; it’s just more of the same lame arguments about being ignorant of Catholic faith and so on and so on. Put your money where your mouth is if you are expecting everyone else to.
 
Which Church is God’s true Church, and why? Is it the Roman Catholic Church?

I believe that it is the Roman Catholic Church.

What are your thoughts? Please support your opinions with facts. I will provide information, which all goes to support the fact that the Roman Catholic Church is the true Church, founded by Jesus Christ and the Church that God intended for all men…
just pick up a bible and one will find out that you are indeed correct…how else would you been able to know that the bible you just picked up is indeed the word of God.
 
Now hold on here a minute. None of you can show a shread of evidence that the Roman Catholic church was the Early Church. I can see him pressing any and all of you for the information and all you can do is be strength in numbers upon one Protestant. But not one of you has answer; it’s just more of the same lame arguments about being ignorant of Catholic faith and so on and so on. Put your money where your mouth is if you are expecting everyone else to.
OMG…thank you!!! I thought it was me…
 
Now hold on here a minute. None of you can show a shread of evidence that the Roman Catholic church was the Early Church. I can see him pressing any and all of you for the information and all you can do is be strength in numbers upon one Protestant. But not one of you has answers; it’s just more of the same lame arguments about being ignorant of Catholic faith and so on and so on. Put your money where your mouth is if you are expecting everyone else to.
With all due respect… can any other Church trace their line all the way back to the apostles? Or can any other church lay claim to publishing and guarding the writings of the ECF’s? Historically we can prove both…

Who possesses the earliest of Christian writings? Who most closely follows the teachings of the ECF’s? That would be the Catholics and the Orthodox…
 
Now hold on here a minute. None of you can show a shread of evidence that the Roman Catholic church was the Early Church. I can see him pressing any and all of you for the information and all you can do is be strength in numbers upon one Protestant. But not one of you has answers; it’s just more of the same lame arguments about being ignorant of Catholic faith and so on and so on. Put your money where your mouth is if you are expecting everyone else to.
Yes, absolutely we can indeed prove that the Roman Catholic Church is in line with the early church.

First of all, the notions of the Eucharistic sacrifice shown in the Didache are respected and offered in the RCC.

The Eucharist, real, not symbolic, the true presence of Christ, His flesh and blood, are spoken of by the early fathers Clement, Polycarp and Ignatius. We still teach and celebrate this Eucharist.

Confession is spoken of by the Fathers. We practice this belief.

A high honor and adoration for Mary is spoken of by the fathers. No one adores and loves Mary like the RCC and EO.

Rome is spoken of highly in the NT as a prestigious church and especially by the early Fathers, Ignatius and Clement.

Matthew 16 most obviously names Peter as the head of the Church. Peter founded the Church of Rome, you know that already.

The Roman Catholic Church single-handedly carried Christianity through the sacking of Rome by the barbarians into a frightening and uncharted world of the Middle Ages. It was Rome that preserved Christ’s teachings and made Christians of the barbarians. Most (not all) of Western Europe was made Christian through the power of the papacy.

Read the countless commentaries by saints like Cyrprian, Ambrose, Augustine, Justin Martyr, Clement, Polycarp, on and on and on and on and if you can’t see that Rome held a preeminence and highest place of honor in Christendom, then there’s nothing left I can say. You just haven’t done the reading and haven’t looked at history with clarity or honesty.

Of COURSE there are more Catholics in here than protestants, SIA!! IT’S A CATHOLIC FORUM!! What do you expect?? Do you expect everyone in here to LIKE the Church being insulted and ripped-on by people who are ignorant of her teachings? Seriously, man?

It’s like going onto a San Francisco Giants board and being shocked at them getting angry at the insults of the Dodgers fan! Come on!!

Catholicism has trucked along for 2,000 years proudly protecting the fullness of Christ’s teachings boldly. It hasn’t changed. It doesn’t bend to the whims of society as protestantism does. That drives some people crazy. Sorry about that. It is a stubborn faith, stubborn for Jesus and it doesn’t bend.

Catholicism offers so MUCH to the Christian—7 sacraments, like medicine for a troubled, sick soul. Confession as a shot in the arm to take away sins, the Papacy for sure doctrine so one doesn’t drift into his own arrogant world of creating his OWN Jesus, Mary the Mother of Christ who leads us to her Son, saints praying for us endlessly, liturgy that gives glory to God, oh and heck it also preserved and created much of Western Civilization as well as preserved and protected the works of the classical age of the ancient Greeks, Romans, and scholastics…

Have you ever ONCE had anything GOOD to say about Catholicism, SIA?? Seriously!

If you read my posts, many times I have complimented protestantism and have discussed its role in western civilization, its great contributions, and its strengths. But not ONCE have I heard you say anything good about the faith that most in this forum profess. Why do you come in here, I guess that’s my question? Perhaps you’re searching and you suspect the faith that you turned your back on IS the real deal and deep down you do respect it. That’s my suspicion. I know because when I left Catholicism to be an Anglican, I talked a big talk about how lousy Rome was and how I didn’t believe in the papacy and how I didn’t give a DANG what the popes or saints had to say. My Anglicanism was a reaction to my anger at Catholicism. Over time I realized that my OWN UNWILLINGNESS to OBEY was at the heart of my leaving the Tiber for the Thames. Thank goodness the Holy Spirit revealed this to me and I came back. I pray that you’ll do the same someday. God bless.
 
nice post gurneyhalleck1… haven’t seen you around lately… how ya doin?
Hi Blest,

I have been around here a lot lately actually. Honestly, I went away for a while to the Anglican Church, my old parish, frustrated with the silly things. My wife and I had struggled with NFP and our priests wouldn’t get back to us, we’d felt that our parish had lousy pastoral care, and I got down on Catholicism. My wife did, too. We wanted to do what we wanted without rules and to feel affirmed in our own ideaology. So we left. When we went to the old Anglican parish we left, after a few weeks, we realized we were not in the Church at all. We were NOT IN A church at all, we were with a bunch of kind-hearted, caring, and yet misguided folks. When we heard the talk of “women priests” and the attitude that Anglicans have toward authority and obedience, etc. we realized how insane we were to be there. We also noticed that every ex-Catholic there was just a refugee from authority. Some wanted to divorce and remarry so they went Anglican. Some wanted to cohabitate, so they went Anglican. Some wanted to use birth control. Some wanted lady priests, some wanted no pope. But I noticed none of them went there LOOKING for something, but rather running from something.

Then it dawned on me, SO WERE WE! We were in a “Quo Vadis” moment, running from Christ’s will to a place where we thought we could have the outward Catholic liturgy with a “hey man, no hangups” theology. In the end, both of us decided to RUN BACK to Rome at 100mph. We went to confession a few weeks ago and praise God I am more thankful for authority and Peter running the show than ever!

I’ve been protestant twice, and both times the Holy Spirit told my wife and I we were on a dark path. This time we’re here for good. I’m more on fire for my Catholic faith than ever and more sure than ever that it’s the real deal.

I feel so sad that I ever doubted her (the Church) but I’m sure glad to be home!
 
OMLord!!! What a testament! I know in my younger days I struggled with birth control and a few other things, but thankfully, every time I went to another church with a friend… I missed home and came right back.

“Just click your heels 3 times…if you believe then you’ll be there”

“There’s no place like home” Click
“There’s no place like home” Click
“There’s no place like home” Click

Don’t feel sad… feel thankful that God doesn’t give up on us silly humans!

WELCOME BACK!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top