White House: Dont stop all foreclosures...Some are valid

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1voice
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
1

1voice

Guest
… and the oil spill isnt that bad.

Whose side are you guys on??

… And who makes that decision??

“It is a serious problem,” said David Axelrod, who contended that the flawed paperwork is hurting the nation’s housing market as well as lending institutions. But he added, “I’m not sure about a national moratorium because there are in fact valid foreclosures that probably should go forward” because their documents are accurate.

… Sounds like some banker is moving Axelrods mouth.

news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20101010/ap_on_bi_ge/us_foreclosures_white_house

WASHINGTON – A top White House adviser questioned the need Sunday for a blanket stoppage of all home foreclosures, even as pressure grows on the Obama administration to do something about mounting evidence that banks have used inaccurate documents to evict homeowners.

First they create a market where foreclosure is inevitable and then they dont even follow the law in creating and recording the contracts … and now they are the ones that are squealing when the die pack explodes in their hands and they have to unwind the bad deals that they themselves forced on the market…claiming that it could "hurt’ the market

… Got Chutzpah?
 
If the documentation is valid, there is no reason they shouldn’t go through.

If the documentation is technically defective, it isn’t equitable to let homeowners walk from their mortgages.

A morotorium will just introduce even more uncertainty into the housing market. It won’t serve anyone’s interest.
 
If the documentation is valid, there is no reason they shouldn’t go through.

If the documentation is technically defective, it isn’t equitable to let homeowners walk from their mortgages.

A morotorium will just introduce even more uncertainty into the housing market. It won’t serve anyone’s interest.
Whose intrest was served by selling homes to people and then destroying the value of their homes so that they were trapped?

There is no such thing as " technically defective" in the mortgage industry where the Note is concerned. If the note cant be produced … there is no contract.

It is the law with any debt collector. Anyone can stop any collection agency cold… I mean right now by sending them a copy of the law and stating that they require the original signed contract as proof of a legal business contract. They wont be able to produce it and will immediately sell the debt to another debt collector in order to make at least some profit from the debt.
The mortgage lenders are bound by the same laws. Mortgages are routinely sold to third parties for servicing the debt. If the third party loses the contract they have no legal recourse. Thats the law… and … They can not take legal action based on falsified or lost documents. Period. It is the same as court cases being thrown out because the DA didnt follow the rules. Right and wrong has almost nothing to do with contract law. The one that blinks … loses.

… and personally, I hope that every single lender that scammed so many people loses every single time they try to take someones home.
 
Whose intrest was served by selling homes to people and then destroying the value of their homes so that they were trapped?
I’m not sure what you mean here.
If the note cant be produced … there is no contract.
Doubtful. Original notes, as I understand it, are not required for nonjudicial foreclosures.

Is the object here is a free house?
 
Is the object here is a free house?
Someone is going to pay. Somewhere.

If I were in foreclosure and discovered that the paper trail the mortgage holder was supposed to carry was fraudulent, you can bet I would have a lawyer and yes, I would aim for a free house.

But then I do not know all of the complexities to this issue.
 
Someone is going to pay. Somewhere.
I think the problem is the opposite: people aren’t paying.
If I were in foreclosure and discovered that the paper trail the mortgage holder was supposed to carry was fraudulent, you can bet I would have a lawyer and yes, I would aim for a free house.
What did you do to deserve a free house?
 
Not as much doing anything as it would be a punitive measure.
For fraud, and failing to maintain the records.
But then, I know very little of the specifics here.
I don’t know all of the specifics either.

But it seems to me that if you agreed to pay a certain price for a home, you don’t have any good faith basis to turn around and demand it for free, because the paperwork is defective, or even fraudulent.

Asking for assistance from the lender, or even for a reduction in the home price if there was fraud that affected the loan terms, makes sense.
 
My gut tells me that part of the move to stop foreclosures has something to do with trying to keep real estate values from dropping any further, regardless of the stated reason for it. There are too many empty homes on the market right now – which are going to sell for less because banks need to get rid of them – in relation to homes which are for sale for the normal reasons.
 
I don’t know all of the specifics either.

But it seems to me that if you agreed to pay a certain price for a home, you don’t have any good faith basis to turn around and demand it for free, because the paperwork is defective, or even fraudulent.

Asking for assistance from the lender, or even for a reduction in the home price if there was fraud that affected the loan terms, makes sense.
Fair enough.

But who gets to foreclose?
We kick out the homeowner, but have no clear understanding of who exactly takes ownership.

Even worse, assuming the homeowner wishes to make good and stop the foreclosure by paying up, they do not know who exactly should be paid.

Punitive measures should be taken, and there is plenty of blame to go around.
But with the present information I have, the homeowner is the least culpable.

Perhaps I am mistaken? After all, I do not have all the information here.
 
We kick out the homeowner, but have no clear understanding of who exactly takes ownership.
Here I suppose I lack understanding. “We” are not kicking out the homeowner. Some bank or mortgage company is, which is presumably the latest entity that the homeowner has been paying, and presumably paid good money for the note. I don’t get the sense that another bank is clamoring for a piece of the property - I get the sense that the homeowner is raising issues that no one else is - at least that’s my impression.
Even worse, assuming the homeowner wishes to make good and stop the foreclosure by paying up, they do not know who exactly should be paid.
There is a payment address on foreclosure notices.
 
… and personally, I hope that every single lender that scammed so many people loses every single time they try to take someones home.
There were NO scams.

Just really easy ways to get a mortgage. Where is personal responsibility?
I was in the mortgage business for 20 years… yes, these poor homeowners knew what they were signing. They wanted a house.

They have now lost value or lost their job… so they can not refinance. There is no scam…

It isnt YOUR house until you pay it off… until you pay it off… the bank actually owns the house.

I now work with banks on foreclosures… people arent paying for 2 years. Pretty generous amount of time banks are giving people.
 
Whose intrest was served by selling homes to people and then destroying the value of their homes so that they were trapped?

There is no such thing as " technically defective" in the mortgage industry where the Note is concerned. If the note cant be produced … there is no contract.

It is the law with any debt collector. Anyone can stop any collection agency cold… I mean right now by sending them a copy of the law and stating that they require the original signed contract as proof of a legal business contract. They wont be able to produce it and will immediately sell the debt to another debt collector in order to make at least some profit from the debt.
The mortgage lenders are bound by the same laws. Mortgages are routinely sold to third parties for servicing the debt. If the third party loses the contract they have no legal recourse. Thats the law… and … They can not take legal action based on falsified or lost documents. Period. It is the same as court cases being thrown out because the DA didnt follow the rules. Right and wrong has almost nothing to do with contract law. The one that blinks … loses.

… and personally, I hope that every single lender that scammed so many people loses every single time they try to take someones home.
More “victim” garbage! Those people knew exactly what they were doing when they bought houses they couldn’t afford using loan strategies that they knew would double and triple their interest payment in a few years. They thought the housing prices would rise forever and they would make a fortune when they cashed out out. Well they got caught. The banks acted immorally in issuing those loans but ultimately it was the greed and stupidity of the buyer that closed the deal.

Those who failed to make loan payments due to job lose are the only ones I feel sorry for but why should I pay their mortgage; the government is already trying to tax me into poverty and grab what little pension I earned, I can’t afford any more.
 
If the documentation is valid, there is no reason they shouldn’t go through.
No, it is about the rule of law and blatant perjury in state courts. They messed up, they should have to take the punishment. Jail time, huge fines, and huge losses are in order.

At any rate, it’s much bigger than that. The main point being discussed are the homeowners, but that’s not the BIG DEAL. The big deal is that these mortgage dealers packaged these faultily-documented mortgages and sold them on the market. They sold defective securities on the market as top-rated. That opens them up to get sued all sorts of ways by the investors who bought the worthless paper.

Guess who one of the biggest purchasers was? The Fed. It is very likely that the Fed is now holding huge amounts of fraudulent securities.

As to the homeowners: all of the foreclosures are actually generating uncertainty, as house prices near foreclosures tend to drop rapidly. Nobody is buying these houses, and inventory is starting to back up. Calling a moratorium will help to stabilize prices, at least in the short term.
There is a payment address on foreclosure notices.
There are actually scams where they send fake foreclosure notices to people. I’ve received a few. Those in arrears will then start to send these fakers their mortgage money.

Often, even the banks themselves are unsure of who should be paid, so they just keep the money for themselves, despite having sold the mortgages on. There are also cases where numerous banks have foreclosed upon the same house, and nobody knew who held title. The paper trail is there for a reason.

If the last person holding a valid title is the homeowner, then they got lucky and everyone else is tough-out-of-luck. The state would have to invalidate contract law to change that now, which would send the entire bond market into chaos. They tried to do something like that, and the Pres was right to veto it.
 
… and the oil spill isnt that bad.

Whose side are you guys on??

… And who makes that decision??

“It is a serious problem,” said David Axelrod, who contended that the flawed paperwork is hurting the nation’s housing market as well as lending institutions. But he added, “I’m not sure about a national moratorium because there are in fact valid foreclosures that probably should go forward” because their documents are accurate.

… Sounds like some banker is moving Axelrods mouth.

news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20101010/ap_on_bi_ge/us_foreclosures_white_house

WASHINGTON – A top White House adviser questioned the need Sunday for a blanket stoppage of all home foreclosures, even as pressure grows on the Obama administration to do something about mounting evidence that banks have used inaccurate documents to evict homeowners.

First they create a market where foreclosure is inevitable and then they dont even follow the law in creating and recording the contracts … and now they are the ones that are squealing when the die pack explodes in their hands and they have to unwind the bad deals that they themselves forced on the market…claiming that it could "hurt’ the market

… Got Chutzpah?
I’m confused by your post. Are you aware that on Friday Obama “pocket” vetoed a bill that would have made it easier to foreclose on homes by making it harder for homeowners to contest flawed foreclosure documents? The statement was simply clarifying that Obama does not want to stop all foreclosures, but he is refusing to give banks a pass when they have not properly documented a foreclosure. He is not siding with banks against homeowners, just the opposite.
 
No, it is about the rule of law and blatant perjury in state courts.
I think perjury should be punished. As to the rule of law, I don’t see how the legal system collapses if homeowners are required to pay loans they admit they owe.
The big deal is that these mortgage dealers packaged these faultily-documented mortgages and sold them on the market. They sold defective securities on the market as top-rated. That opens them up to get sued all sorts of ways by the investors who bought the worthless paper.
Maybe, but that doesn’t have anything to do with original promissory notes, or statements as to the chain of documents, or whether the homeowner owes money
The Fed. It is very likely that the Fed is now holding huge amounts of fraudulent securities.
Derivatives were unregulated, so I doubt that the securities were illegal.
As to the homeowners: all of the foreclosures are actually generating uncertainty, as house prices near foreclosures tend to drop rapidly. Nobody is buying these houses, and inventory is starting to back up. Calling a moratorium will help to stabilize prices, at least in the short term.
I’m not an economist, but I tend to disagree. A hypothetical rational homebuyer, knowing of the morotorium, will either delay entering the market or bid very low, because he or she knows that there is a foreclosure backlog that will one day burst with an even greater glut of foreclosed properties. Allowing homeowners to walk from loans in large numbers will increase bank losses and even further restrict lending, which will also have a negative effect on the market. I still think the major effect of a morotorium will be uncertainty - because no one can predict when it will end, or what the fallout will be until the end, and the market will seize up.
There are actually scams where they send fake foreclosure notices to people. I’ve received a few. Those in arrears will then start to send these fakers their mortgage money.
And that should be prosecuted.
Often, even the banks themselves are unsure of who should be paid, so they just keep the money for themselves, despite having sold the mortgages on. There are also cases where numerous banks have foreclosed upon the same house, and nobody knew who held title. The paper trail is there for a reason.
I have a hard time believing this is prevalent. However, even if it is, why stop foreclosures from legitimate lenders?
If the last person holding a valid title is the homeowner, then they got lucky and everyone else is tough-out-of-luck.
If there is genuine doubt about who holds the loan, so that Bank of America and Wells Fargo are fighting over foreclosure rights, that is certainly a problem. But, if the only problem is original signatures, or someone signing a document attesting to the chain of title, and the homeowner, who can’t afford the loan, just wants an out, then I just don’t see the fairness in giving out free houses. If you have a truth in lending disclosure, payment coupons, mortgage interest tax statements, etc., it’s a sure bet that there was a legitimate loan, even if the original note is just a photocopy.
 
Well they got caught. The banks acted immorally in issuing those loans but ultimately it was the greed and stupidity of the buyer that closed the deal.
Why isn’t the greed and stupidity at least equal on both sides of the table? Shouldn’t the bank be expected to be more sophisticated than the average homebuyer?
 
Okay, my point is that this wasn’t just a mix-up or a misunderstanding. This was blatant criminal felony. I used to work as an auditor (not a CPA, in an engineering company) and my job was not to “rubber stamp” the paperwork. My job was to carefully inspect each document, sign off on the acceptable ones, and reject the unacceptable ones. It’s a job that seems banal unless there is an unacceptable one. That’s when it gets interesting, that’s when your elevated paycheck gets justified.

I once had to appear before our board and refuse to sign-off on a multi-million dollar production line that was set to get going the very next morning, and that was already running behind schedule. I had the whole board and upper management literally screaming at me and getting up in my face until I started crying right there in front of everybody. But I didn’t sign the release note. They overrode it, started producing anyway, and then ended up spending a few million on a safety recall. And then they got sued by their customer for overriding my decision.

That sort of backbone is what you get paid for. These notaries and lawyers where rubber-stamping the foreclosure filings and literally getting up in court and lying that they had personally looked through the documents themselves. They hadn’t done so, they received their income fraudulently, and they should be handcuffed and dragged off to prison like the criminals they are. If their employers encouraged that sort of thing (which they probably did, and which can probably be proven), then they should end up in the cell next door.

That’s the law, and that is what this is all about. You don’t lie to a court and you don’t falsify documents.
 
Why isn’t the greed and stupidity at least equal on both sides of the table? Shouldn’t the bank be expected to be more sophisticated than the average homebuyer?
The banks new the homebuyers couldn’t afford the mortgages. That’s why they sold them off to people stupid enough to buy their MBS. They were playing “hot potato”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top