Who "Gets it", and by how much?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tomcmaj
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tomcmaj

Guest
On a scale of 1 to 10, where 10 means “Totally gets it” and 1 means “Doesn’t get it at all”, Catholicism is a 10 and Satanism is a 1.

How would you rate these other religions on this scale?

Anglicanism/Episcopal
Baptist
Presbyterian
Evangelical Ecumenical
Mormonism
Lutheran
Methodist
Judaism
Islam
Hinduism
Buddhism
Bahai
 
Catholicism = 5
Anglicanism/Episcopal (conservative) = 6 (liberal) = 3
Baptist = 8
Presbyterian=5
Evangelical = 10 Ecumenical (what’s an “evangelical ecumenical”?)
Mormonism = 3
Lutheran = 4
Methodist = 6
Judaism = 5
Islam = 3
Hinduism = 1
Buddhism = 2
Bahai =1
 
Catholicism = 10
Anglicanism/Episcopal = 7
Baptist = 7
Presbyterian = 6
Evangelical Ecumenical = 7
Mormonism = 2
Lutheran = 7
Methodist = 7
Judaism = 5
Islam = 2
Hinduism = 2
Buddhism = 2
Bahai = 2
 
On a scale of 1 to 10, where 10 means “Totally gets it” and 1 means “Doesn’t get it at all”, Catholicism is a 10 and Satanism is a 1.

How would you rate these other religions on this scale?

Anglicanism/Episcopal
Baptist
Presbyterian
Evangelical Ecumenical
Mormonism
Lutheran
Methodist
Judaism
Islam
Hinduism
Buddhism
Bahai
Anglicanism/Episcopal is 9 (as is Eastern Orthodox) because they’re the closest
All the other Mainlines: Lutherans, Methodists, Presbyterians are 8 because of the liturgical stuff
Baptists and Evangelical Ecumenicals are 7 because they’re doctrines are farther and they’re non-Liturgical
Mormons are 6
Jews and Muslims are 5 because they’re Monotheists, and since 5 is half of 10, Jews and Muslims are 5 because they have half-the truth (the other truth being Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior)
Bahai is 4
Buddhism and Hinduism is 3
 
(what’s an “evangelical ecumenical”?)
I didn’t want to single out any one Evangelical Church. But there is a large group of them that call themselves Ecumenical (afaik): they have different viewpoints, but are happy to get together and talk about them! It was an ecumenical Evangelical group that translated the NIV BIble.

If you think it would make more sense to describe them otherwise, lemme know and I’ll make the change!
 
Ok. I’m Pentecostal and evangelical. I’ve never heard “Evangelical Ecumenical” used. Wasn’t sure if it applied to the ecumenism practiced by the National and World Councils of Churches which is certainly not advocated by evangelicals.

But strictly going by the actual definition of “ecumenical” it makes since. There are a lot of evangelicals willing to cross confessional and denominational lines as long as they can do so without compromising the central message of the gospel.
 
On a scale of 1 to 10, where 10 means “Totally gets it” and 1 means “Doesn’t get it at all”, Catholicism is a 10 and Satanism is a 1.

How would you rate these other religions on this scale?

Anglicanism/Episcopal
Baptist
Presbyterian
Evangelical Ecumenical
Mormonism
Lutheran
Methodist
Judaism
Islam
Hinduism
Buddhism
Bahai
Fun! 😃

Anglicanism/Episcopal - 9.3
Baptist - 8.6
Presbyterian - 8.65
Evangelical Ecumenical - 8.59
Mormonism - 4.9
Lutheran - 9.4
Methodist - 8.7
Judaism - 4.4
Islam - 4
Hinduism - 2
Buddhism - 1.9
Bahai - ?

It was sort of challenging. Eastern Orthodox I give a 9.41. Tough challenge. But who am I to judge 🤷.
 
Orthodoxy - 9.99
Anglicanism/Episcopal - Anywhere from 5-8
Baptist - 4
Presbyterian - 5
Evangelical Ecumenical - 4
Mormonism - 3
Lutheran - 6
Methodist - 5
Judaism - 4
Islam - 2
Hinduism - 3
Buddhism - 3
 
Anglicanism/Episcopal = 5
Baptist = 5
Presbyterian = 5
Evangelical Ecumenical = 5
Mormonism = 2
Lutheran = 5
Methodist = 5
Judaism = 3
Islam = 1
Hinduism = 1
Buddhism = 1
Bahai = 1

IMHO
 
Well, my take is this:

Catholic 9
Anglicanism 9
Episcopal 5
Baptist 6
Presbyterian 5
Evangelical Ecumenical 5
Lutheran 10
Methodist 5
Judaism 4
Islam 1
Hinduism 1
Buddhism 1
Bahai 1
Mormonism 1

Mormanism isn’t Christian, it belong with grouping of Bahai, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Islam. All of these should be rated as a 0.
The Episcopal Church along with the ELCA are almost apostasy.
 
Anglicanism/Episcopal - 9
Lutheran - 8
Methodist - 8
Catholic - 8
Presbyterian - 7
Baptist - 6
Evangelical Ecumenical - 6
Mormonism - 4
Judaism - 3
Islam - 3
Hinduism - 2
Buddhism - 2
Bahai - 2

I consider Islam and Judaism roughly equal - the Koran adds belief in Christ to the faith, but explicit denial of His divinity comes along in the package. Mormonism accepts (sort of) this doctrine, so it gets one point higher, but still two below my least-favorite brand of orthodox Christianity.
 
Islam = 3
Hinduism = 1
Buddhism = 2
Bahai =1
Islam = 2
Hinduism = 2
Buddhism = 2
Bahai = 2
Islam = 1
Hinduism = 1
Buddhism = 1
Bahai = 1
Islam 1
Hinduism 1
Buddhism 1
Bahai 1
Mormonism 1
Islam - 3
Hinduism - 2
Buddhism - 2
Bahai - 2
The OP says “Satanism is a 1” and I’m wondering why you guys are putting Bahá’í roughly on a par with Satanism. You detest the Bahá’í message that humanity is one family? For it being against all bigotry and prejudice? For it teaching there is one God? You admire the Islamic Republic of Iran for persecuting it? Some other reason? Please explain, you obviously know a lot more than me about religions like Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism to rate them as you do so it would be very educational, all I really know is the CAF rule on respecting all religions.

*The Bahá’í Faith is the youngest of the world’s independent religions. Its founder, Bahá’u’lláh (1817-1892), is regarded by Bahá’ís as the most recent in the line of Messengers of God that stretches back beyond recorded time and that includes Abraham, Moses, Buddha, Krishna, Zoroaster, Christ and Muhammad.

The central theme of Bahá’u’lláh’s message is that humanity is one single race and that the day has come for its unification in one global society. God, Bahá’u’lláh said, has set in motion historical forces that are breaking down traditional barriers of race, class, creed, and nation and that will, in time, give birth to a universal civilization. The principal challenge facing the peoples of the earth is to accept the fact of their oneness and to assist the processes of unification. - bahai.org/*
 
Woah! Someone actually read my entire post!

:cool:
Sorry…

Roman Catholicism is 10
Anglicanism/Episcopal is 9 (as is Eastern Orthodox) because they’re the closest
All the other Mainlines: Lutherans, Methodists, Presbyterians are 8 because of the liturgical stuff
Baptists and Evangelical Ecumenicals are 7 because they’re doctrines are farther and they’re non-Liturgical
Mormons are 6
Jews and Muslims are 5 because they’re Monotheists, and since 5 is half of 10, Jews and Muslims are 5 because they have half-the truth (the other truth being Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior)
Bahai is 4
Buddhism and Hinduism is 3
and Satanism is 1
 
The OP says “Satanism is a 1” and I’m wondering why you guys are putting Bahá’í roughly on a par with Satanism. You detest the Bahá’í message that humanity is one family? For it being against all bigotry and prejudice? For it teaching there is one God? You admire the Islamic Republic of Iran for persecuting it? Some other reason? Please explain, you obviously know a lot more than me about religions like Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism to rate them as you do so it would be very educational, all I really know is the CAF rule on respecting all religions.
Originally Posted by Tietjen
Islam = 1
Hinduism = 1
Buddhism = 1
Bahai = 1
Since you included my response, I’ll answer as to my reason for including Baha’i at a rating of one (As I did for Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism). None recognize the divinity of Jesus Christ. As was brought out by another poster, the definition of “IT” was never defined. Therefore, “IT” was left to each individual reader to interrupt for themselves. Since the above mentioned religions refuse to recognize the divinity of Christ, what other “IT” matters? Baha’i may very well demonstrate kindness toward man, but does that “IT” while denying Christ as being the Son of God, cause the Father to smile upon them?

I interrupted “IT” to mean pleasing to God; since that is really the only “IT” that matters. I don’t know the mind of God, but I can speculate that denying the divinity of Christ while at the same time belonging to a meditative and/or peaceful religion, will not be the “IT” God favors in the end.

Having said that, I rated other denominational Christian groups at a higher level than the ones mentioned above because to varying degrees they are Christian. So, I then defined “IT” as being how much TRUTH do the various other denominations recognize. Do they deny the real presence? Do they recognize the authority of the Church? What is their position on salvation? Scripture? etc.

This is how I came to the numbers I entered. Inocente, you claim that you’re Baptist. Will the Baha’i member who stands before God fare any better than the Satanist? If so, then perhaps you are correct and perhaps it’s me who just doesn’t get “IT.”

And incidentally, I do respect all religions (in keeping with CAF rules), but I will not say that a non-Christian religion is equal to or even approaches the Truth found in a Christian religion (specially the Catholic Church and to varying degrees other Christian denominations). That would simply be a lie for the sake of political correctness, and anyone that knows me, knows where I stand on political correctness.
 
On a scale of 1 to 10, where 10 means “Totally gets it” and 1 means “Doesn’t get it at all”, Catholicism is a 10 and Satanism is a 1.

How would you rate these other religions on this scale?

Anglicanism/Episcopal = 6
Baptist = 8
Presbyterian =7
Evangelical Ecumenical =6
Mormonism =3 (Cult)
Lutheran =9
Methodist =7
Judaism =8
Islam =4
Hinduism =2
Buddhism =3
Bahai=1
 
Inocente, you claim that you’re Baptist.
Tietjen, you claim that you’re Catholic.

Though saying it that way sounds like I might not really believe you, no? 🙂
Will the Baha’i member who stands before God fare any better than the Satanist? If so, then perhaps you are correct and perhaps it’s me who just doesn’t get “IT.”
Yes, definitely they will fare a lot better, and I hope to convince you.

Let’s take Islam instead as there are a lot more Muslims than Bahá’í. From what you said, you rated Islam the same as Satanism not because you believe it’s intrinsically evil but because you think God doesn’t smile on Muslims for only venerating Jesus as a prophet (I think the Bahá’í do the same).

A Muslim could then rate Catholicism the same as Satanism because of something she believes and you don’t. You say God doesn’t smile on her, she says God doesn’t smile on you, voices get raised and pretty soon you may both forget we’re all one people before God - these things happen.

I believe Almighty God looks beyond all of that to see what is really on our hearts, and all of the religions on the list “get it” in their different ways.

You’re obviously going to say Catholicism is closest to the truth, that’s to be expected, but it’s OK to accept that the other religions are not far behind. Anyway, that’s what the Church seems to teach - vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_decl_19651028_nostra-aetate_en.html
 
Catholicism - 7
Anglicanism/Episcopal - 10
Baptist - 8
Presbyterian - 8
Evangelical Ecumenical - 10
Mormonism - 6
Lutheran - 10
Methodist - 9
Judaism - 5
Islam = 3
Hinduism - 2
Buddhism - 4
Bahai - 4
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top