Who Killed Private Pensions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter human_being
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So then the government should hand over what exactly to make up for their Social Security promises?

Should we all get land?

Why just us? What about our children?🤷
Social security is not a pension, it is a welfare program. You have no contractual right to SS.
 
Who said anything about folding the company. You can transfer ownership without shutting down the company. After all, the issue is about the morality of skipping out on an obligation. If there is equity in the company and not enough money to pay pension benefits the pension fund gets the equity plain and simple (up to the amount necessary to fund their obligations). If that gives the pension fund control of the company, then it is the pension funds decision whether to continue or shut down.
No, the control of the company goes to the secured bond-holders, who have first rights to all of the companies assets in the event of insolvency.
 
Then they should hand the business over to the pension fund. .
OK, why exactly would GM’s pension fund even want to have GM? It was going into bankruptcy and losing money hand over fist.

Would YOU have wanted to guarantee your pension on GM stock? Would you want to even now?
 
No, the control of the company goes to the secured bond-holders, who have first rights to all of the companies assets in the event of insolvency.
Yes, the bond holders have first rights. Where did I say anything different?
 
Which is contractual.😉
Correct. And there is a reason that the government enforces these contracts. If it wasn’t so, the minute a company started losing money, no one would lend to it.

Any downturn would pretty much guarantee that a company will end up going out of business.

But I suppose it wouldn’t matter that all the employees would lose their jobs, as long as the pensions are paid to retirees, correct?
 
But I suppose it wouldn’t matter that all the employees would lose their jobs, as long as the pensions are paid to retirees, correct?
Are you saying that we are not morally obligated to make good on the promises we make? If someone doesn’t pay their mortgage, should the bank not foreclose because a family might be homeless?
 
Correct. And there is a reason that the government enforces these contracts. If it wasn’t so, the minute a company started losing money, no one would lend to it.

Any downturn would pretty much guarantee that a company will end up going out of business.

But I suppose it wouldn’t matter that all the employees would lose their jobs, as long as the pensions are paid to retirees, correct?
The pensions was a part of their pay…It is owed…You cannot think it morally acceptable to say.to a 75 year old woma who cannot work anymore that the pension promised to you is now gonna be cut off or something…That wouldn’t be too good, would it?
 
Sure, after you show me a contract that states a company must hand over the keys to pensioners.😛
Do you think somebody who is retired and has budgetted that promised pension into their budget should give it up at the drop of a hat…and what? Live under a bridge?
 
Unless Obama is President. In which case the Union becomes the preferred…whatever.
Not all pensioners are union…but I geuss if they were top level management or nonunion employees…something should be more compasionatelly worked out. Right?
 
The pensions was a part of their pay…It is owed…You cannot think it morally acceptable to say.to a 75 year old woma who cannot work anymore that the pension promised to you is now gonna be cut off or something…That wouldn’t be too good, would it?
If the money isn’t there, then the pensions will not be paid.

Promises or no promises.

If the money doesn’t exist, then the pensions will not be paid.

It can be wished for, demanded, cried over, yell about … if the money isn’t there, then the pensions will not be paid.
 
Like I said, if the management of the company cannot meet the pension obligations which it promised we know that they are incompetent.
Pension fund management is about stuff that will happen in the future.

Requires “actuarial assumptions”.

The operational stuff of today takes precedence over the stuff of tomorrow.

Managers can take care of the future stuff by making promises and wishes and desires.

But, if they don’t fund the pension plan of the future with money of today, then it’s not going to happen.

So, what happens? There is a cash crunch and they defer payments to the pension plan. No body feels it. There is no pain.

Or they make some “adjustments” to the actuarial assumptions and decide that if they jack up the assumed returns by the assets in the pension plan from 6% per year to 8% per year [after all, somebody read an article that 8% is a better number], then that adjusts downwards the payments that are owed to the plan.

OR, even “better”, management “borrows” money from the pension plan … and replace the money with an IOU.

And then one day, someone goes to the pension fund to write some checks to the retirees, and … POOF! … there is no money left.

And the company isn’t doing too well, so the company doesn’t have the cash to replace the IOU’s.

If the pension fund trustees make too much of a fuss, then the company will have to close its doors. OR the company will reform under new management. But there still isn’t any more money for the pension fund.
 
The pensions was a part of their pay…It is owed…You cannot think it morally acceptable to say.to a 75 year old woma who cannot work anymore that the pension promised to you is now gonna be cut off or something…That wouldn’t be too good, would it?
I think the issue is unions demanded and corporations capitulated on pensions that weren’t sustainable over the long run.
 
Do you think somebody who is retired and has budgetted that promised pension into their budget should give it up at the drop of a hat…and what? Live under a bridge?
I think that when people know that they have a “promised pension”, that in fact there may actually be NOTHING for them when the time comes.

They don’t “give it up”. There is nothing to give up.

They know that a “promise” is just a bunch of words that are empty.

[Instead of a promise, the company “could” set up a special retirement account with their name on it and with the person’s control … and fund it.]

[Talk is cheap.]

[Or, as they say, “In God we trust; all others pay cash”.]

What people do, in fact, is recognize in advance that there will be nothing there for them and to plan accordingly. Meaning that they plan by socking away money in diverse ways … mutual funds … a “vacation house” in some place where the living is cheap [Florida? South Carolina? Arizona?] and the weather is not cold. And then when that day comes when their management decides they don’t want old people as employees, then they can just move permanently to their vacation house.

And instead of the “promised” Social Security, the “government” could adopt the Galveston County plan.

ncpa.org/pub/ba514

OR, they can have LOTS of children, and make sure their kids love them a lot.

OR, they convert their “promised pension” into real money … they take advantage of whatever comes their way and take the money out of and away from any control by the company and by the union.

That’s why things like 401(k) accounts and IRA and Roth IRA accounts can be real blessings … because it is YOUR money; the company and the union cannot get their mitts on it.

Some people get “company stock”. Could be good or not good. If you work for the telephone company or UPS, it might be good. If you work for General Motors or an airline or Enron, then not so good. McDonalds, good. KMart, not good.

But some people are forced by circumstances to work through a temp agency. Very limited pension plan options.

Even if they have a 401(k), they get socked with retroactive audits and miserable Federal government rules. Orphan accounts.

Companies can go bankrupt and the stock becomes … are you ready for this??? … “extinguished”.
 
Some people get “company stock”. Could be good or not good. If you work for the telephone company or UPS, it might be good. If you work for General Motors or an airline or Enron, then not so good. McDonalds, good. KMart, not good.
That’s why it’s generally a good idea to cash these out ASAP once you get them, as they are not diverse enough, IMHO.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top