Who loves anime here?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MrSylvester
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry but I hate anime as well as manga. Actually I don’t really like any Japanese animation or cartoons. I just think they’re very ugly and bizarre even for cartoons. They just look freaky to me. I like a certain aesthetic quality to animation and anime is just very harsh looking. However, I like art and animation and try to keep an open mind so if you guys want to explain why you like it so much I am willing to listen.:cool:
 
Sorry but I hate anime as well as manga. Actually I don’t really like any Japanese animation or cartoons. I just think they’re very ugly and bizarre even for cartoons. They just look freaky to me. I like a certain aesthetic quality to animation and anime is just very harsh looking. However, I like art and animation and try to keep an open mind so if you guys want to explain why you like it so much I am willing to listen.:cool:
Try looking at things that aren’t mainstream, American aired seinen and shonen. Red Garden looks a lot different than Code Geass looks a lot different than Angel Sanctuary looks a lot different than Ceres.
 
Sorry but I hate anime as well as manga. Actually I don’t really like any Japanese animation or cartoons. I just think they’re very ugly and bizarre even for cartoons. They just look freaky to me. I like a certain aesthetic quality to animation and anime is just very harsh looking. However, I like art and animation and try to keep an open mind so if you guys want to explain why you like it so much I am willing to listen.:cool:
Well I share the same views as you except it’s on western animation. I dislike the heavy lack of proportion of many western characters.

Most western mainstream cartoons, when compared to mainstream anime, lack anything you’d call a coherent plot. For kiddie cartoons, it’s either loony land all the way. For ‘adult’ cartoons, it’s nothing more than a greasy, often liberal, stand-up routine in animated form.

Then again, I’m just comparing your tastes to mind. In the end, there’s no deep-seated logical explanation for either of us. You like a certain style. I like cute, large eyes and very angelic figures.
 
Which ones did you see?
Some pokemon,Yu Gi Oh, Fantastic Four: worlds greatest heroes and I’m not sure what the other stuff was. I guess it’s just the style I am not too fond of. The humongous eyes, tiny triangular noses and long,sharp unruly hair. I don’t mean to rain on anyone’s parade but I just haven’t grasped the appeal of that sort of thing. Care to try to explain it to me?
 
Well I share the same views as you except it’s on western animation. I dislike the heavy lack of proportion of many western characters.

Most western mainstream cartoons, when compared to mainstream anime, lack anything you’d call a coherent plot. For kiddie cartoons, it’s either loony land all the way. For ‘adult’ cartoons, it’s nothing more than a greasy, often liberal, stand-up routine in animated form.

Then again, I’m just comparing your tastes to mind. In the end, there’s no deep-seated logical explanation for either of us. You like a certain style. I like cute, large eyes and very angelic figures.
Hey everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Oh yeah I really don’t like those popular adult cartoons or even the kid ones for that matter. But there are a few shows I really liked the art style.Are you familiar with the Ultimate Avengers movies or The Batman tv show? The art and animation was very fluid and to me, appealing. As for plot, I rarely watch cartoons for the plot, but Batman the animated series and Wolverine and the X-men had some of the most interesting plot lines and stories I have seen. I am however, not very familiar with the entire Anime genre. If you want to suggest some good ones I might look into them.It’s just the art style that sort of bugs me, that’s all.
 
Well the latest chart for the Fall is out. Anything look good to you guys?

crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2012/09/10/fall-2012-anime-chart-version-20

Robotics;Notes (from the same folks as Steins;Gate), Hayate no Gotoku, and Little Busters are musts for me this Fall.

Maybe Sakura-sou no Pet na Kanojo because I have yet to meet a character named Shiina that I dislike. However, too much fanservice and I’ll drop it.

Psycho-Pass looks like a pick up because Gen Urobuchi is involved.

Also considering Shin Sekai Yori, Tonari no Kaibitsu-kun, K, Sukitte li na yo, Haitai Nanafa, Chunnibyou demo Koi ga Shitai, and Kamisama Kiss.
 
Hey everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Oh yeah I really don’t like those popular adult cartoons or even the kid ones for that matter. But there are a few shows I really liked the art style.Are you familiar with the Ultimate Avengers movies or The Batman tv show? The art and animation was very fluid and to me, appealing. As for plot, I rarely watch cartoons for the plot, but Batman the animated series and Wolverine and the X-men had some of the most interesting plot lines and stories I have seen. I am however, not very familiar with the entire Anime genre. If you want to suggest some good ones I might look into them.It’s just the art style that sort of bugs me, that’s all.
Some anime with interesting, unique art styles and animation are Kemonozume, Kaiba, and Dead Leaves. But the anime with the most fluid animation tend to be films, due to higher budgets. For shows it can vary widely even within a single show. Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex had some very well animated action sequences, but when the scene was just dialogue there was nothing animated except for the characters’ mouths. And that could go on for so long that it felt a little creepy how static everyone was.
Well the latest chart for the Fall is out. Anything look good to you guys?

crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2012/09/10/fall-2012-anime-chart-version-20

Robotics;Notes (from the same folks as Steins;Gate), Hayate no Gotoku, and Little Busters are musts for me this Fall.

Maybe Sakura-sou no Pet na Kanojo because I have yet to meet a character named Shiina that I dislike. However, too much fanservice and I’ll drop it.

Psycho-Pass looks like a pick up because Gen Urobuchi is involved.

Also considering Shin Sekai Yori, Tonari no Kaibitsu-kun, K, Sukitte li na yo, Haitai Nanafa, Chunnibyou demo Koi ga Shitai, and Kamisama Kiss.
Litchi DE Hikari Club sounds fresh, but possibly too disturbing for my tastes. BTOOOM! is by Madhouse, so it could be good. Same with PSYCHO-PASS by Production I.G. The Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica movies and the Ashura movie are the only other ones that look interesting. The rest, I’ll wait and hear others’ opinions first.
 
Hey everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Oh yeah I really don’t like those popular adult cartoons or even the kid ones for that matter. But there are a few shows I really liked the art style.Are you familiar with the Ultimate Avengers movies or The Batman tv show? The art and animation was very fluid and to me, appealing. As for plot, I rarely watch cartoons for the plot, but Batman the animated series and Wolverine and the X-men had some of the most interesting plot lines and stories I have seen. I am however, not very familiar with the entire Anime genre. If you want to suggest some good ones I might look into them.It’s just the art style that sort of bugs me, that’s all.
In terms of story, superheroes are just a little bit better. Alas, they’re also rife with the same plot inconsistencies as their comic book counterparts. :\

I’m also not so fond about anatomy either. Lips that are often too detailed really turn me off. Although, I find compromise with art like this: goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/03/Runaways-copy.jpg
 
Some pokemon,Yu Gi Oh, Fantastic Four: worlds greatest heroes and I’m not sure what the other stuff was. I guess it’s just the style I am not too fond of. The humongous eyes, tiny triangular noses and long,sharp unruly hair. I don’t mean to rain on anyone’s parade but I just haven’t grasped the appeal of that sort of thing. Care to try to explain it to me?
Funny enough, but I was first attracted to anime because of the idealistic beauty of both character and background designs.
 
I guess the biggest beef I have with this style of art is the depiction of the men. I have yet to see any guy who isn’t really feminine looking. They are all so skinny with long-ish hair and their noses are almost nonexistent. Sometimes I can’t tell whether I am looking at a male or female character. Why do they make them so wimpy looking? The girls I don’t have such a big problem with.
Anyway, I’ll take a look at some of the examples you guys gave.👍
 
For whatever reason, I never got into anime. I remember watching Dragonball Z and thinking it was stupid, but that was about it. A while back, I was browsing Netflix and saw a show that for some reason, caught my eye. It was the anime series Claymore. I watched it and really liked it. The problem now is that I’ve watched a few other series but haven’t found anything that’s even come close in terms of how much I liked it.
 
I guess the biggest beef I have with this style of art is the depiction of the men. I have yet to see any guy who isn’t really feminine looking. They are all so skinny with long-ish hair and their noses are almost nonexistent. Sometimes I can’t tell whether I am looking at a male or female character. Why do they make them so wimpy looking? The girls I don’t have such a big problem with.
Anyway, I’ll take a look at some of the examples you guys gave.👍
As a girl, let me explain:

IN Japan, and no even common in the US, the “pretty boy” aesthetic in anime is NO DIFFERENT thatn why young girls are so attracted to boys like Justin Beiber or, in my age group back in the day, NSync or Hanson. Young, looking, pretty boys are non threatening when you’re young. Grown, masculine men seem too old for you, and too frightening.

Additionally, girls series, or a series with a large female audience, tends to be far more dramtic and overly emotional than boys. Like a soap opera, or a primetime drama, or a Lifetime Movie. The beautiful, delicate asthetic works for that. You can’t use a powerful, masculine looking man for those roles, any more than you’d want Clay Aiken in an action film!
 
As a girl, let me explain:

IN Japan, and no even common in the US, the “pretty boy” aesthetic in anime is NO DIFFERENT thatn why young girls are so attracted to boys like Justin Beiber or, in my age group back in the day, NSync or Hanson. Young, looking, pretty boys are non threatening when you’re young. Grown, masculine men seem too old for you, and too frightening.

Additionally, girls series, or a series with a large female audience, tends to be far more dramtic and overly emotional than boys. Like a soap opera, or a primetime drama, or a Lifetime Movie. The beautiful, delicate asthetic works for that. You can’t use a powerful, masculine looking man for those roles, any more than you’d want Clay Aiken in an action film!
Fair enough I guess, but the majority of the fans I have seen seem to be guys. As for the masculine characters I think it’s just a matter of taste. I have seen way too much fangirl hype than I care to remember over Chris Hemsworth and his brother and they are both big tough looking dudes.To each his( or her )own.
 
I guess the biggest beef I have with this style of art is the depiction of the men. I have yet to see any guy who isn’t really feminine looking. They are all so skinny with long-ish hair and their noses are almost nonexistent. Sometimes I can’t tell whether I am looking at a male or female character. Why do they make them so wimpy looking? The girls I don’t have such a big problem with.
Anyway, I’ll take a look at some of the examples you guys gave.👍
Son Goku, skinny?
 
I guess the biggest beef I have with this style of art is the depiction of the men. I have yet to see any guy who isn’t really feminine looking. They are all so skinny with long-ish hair and their noses are almost nonexistent. Sometimes I can’t tell whether I am looking at a male or female character. Why do they make them so wimpy looking? The girls I don’t have such a big problem with.
Anyway, I’ll take a look at some of the examples you guys gave.👍
I’m actually fond of the bishounen style but they are certainly NOT the only way guys in anime are drawn. And as Juney said, these are usually targeted towards girls. Some shounen titles (even asides Dragonball) have pretty buff guys.
 
Currently am reading the Kenshin manga. It’s very, very good, as good as the anime.

Celticcatholic, anime is appealing not so much because of it’s art style so much as the deep stories it has. Most anime as has been said, has an actual plot and characters. I don’t mind the bishonen look at all; in fact, as a guy, I don’t even notice at all. The men just look slightly feminine but they don’t act feminine at all. Hell, Kenshin Himura is probably the most bishie character around and he’s the most awesome one as well:



Anime just needs a great story to be appreciated. I actually love the anime art style and contrary to what you think, it really isn’t that pervasive. You will not notice the stylles you watch a good anime, I gurantee it. Check out Rurouni Kenshin, Elfen Lied, FullMetal Alchemist Brotherhood or Death Note to start out. Kenshin, especially the Shishio arc is jsut a mastterpeice all around… except the episodes (witha few exceptions) after episode 63 which don’t follow the manga story at all and are just filler. If you want a short but very good anime, watch Elfen Lied, Death Note, Cowboy Bebop or Clannad. All are below 50 episodes with Clannad being the longest. Maybe you could even get experienced enough to watch masterpieces like Rurouni Kenshin, Higurashi or Monster.
 
Ok thanks Mr.Sylvester, I’ll check em out.
As someone who draws and sketches almost constantly I am slightly more interested in the artwork, so if any of you want to make up a list of your favorite depictions of anime or manga I will probably look them up. Maybe I’ll actually gain some appreciation for this art style. And if anyone is really curious i can recommend some of my favorite artists. If anybody is interested.
 
Fair enough I guess, but the majority of the fans I have seen seem to be guys. As for the masculine characters I think it’s just a matter of taste. I have seen way too much fangirl hype than I care to remember over Chris Hemsworth and his brother and they are both big tough looking dudes.To each his( or her )own.
Like I said; it’s primarily a Japanese asthetic, considering they’re Japanese cartoons. But considering most of the fans I know are girls who read girls series, I can attest that there is some truth to this stateside
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top