Who will pay for the wall?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HCTC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I mean not seeing the forest for the trees, being pedantic on one aspect and ignoring the whole policy on border security and immigration
 
I mean not seeing the forest for the trees, being pedantic on one aspect and ignoring the whole policy on border security and immigration
The policy was to build a wall. It hasn’t been built yet and it isn’t clear who will pay for it.
 
The policy was to build a wall. It hasn’t been built yet and it isn’t clear who will pay for it.
At a cost of $18 billion, I wouldn’t call the question of who is going to pay for it pedantic.
 
And thus American consumers will end up footing the bill, since the only other way to collect is via tariffs on Mexican imports.
 
There is a very simple solution to this problem: let’s have all the Trump supporters lend the government the money for the wall, when Mexico ponies up the required funds, they can be paid back. If they really believe Mexico will pay for the wall, they should have no trouble putting up the money.
 
At a cost of $18 billion, I wouldn’t call the question of who is going to pay for it pedantic.
I didn’t say it was pedantic, but I think we should wait to see who actually pays for it once it actually looks like it will be built.
 
The policy was to build a wall. It hasn’t been built yet and it isn’t clear who will pay for it.
No, the Policy goal is to secure our border.
One of the key strategy components was to build a wall.
So far, it looks like the existing wall will be greatly enhanced.

I anticipate we won’t use tariffs or some other scheme to pay for it, Congress will provide the requested $18b over several years.

So he’s not batting 100% but he is connecting with the goal.
 
I didn’t say it was pedantic, but I think we should wait to see who actually pays for it once it actually looks like it will be built.
Sorry, didn’t mean to suggest you did. Another poster called the question pedantic.
 
No, the Policy goal is to secure our border.

One of the key strategy components was to build a wall.

So far, it looks like the existing wall will be greatly enhanced.

I anticipate we won’t use tariffs or some other scheme to pay for it, Congress will provide the requested $18b over several years.

So he’s not batting 100% but he is connecting with the goal.
Chants I remember from the campaign.
  • Build the wall.
  • Lock her out.
Chants I don’t remember
  • Secure the border.
  • We’ll pay for the wall.
 
Were there other chants that I have forgotten or are you just trying to move the goalposts so your guy can make the goal?
No, you are choosing to ignore the clear policy statements that were laid out during the campaign and posted above. You can complain about the disconnect from what you chanted in the audience (you were in 23rd row, right?), but the specifics were made available long ago.
 
No, you are choosing to ignore the clear policy statements that were laid out during the campaign and posted above. You can complain about the disconnect from what you chanted in the audience (you were in 23rd row, right?), but the specifics were made available long ago.
Well, Trump was very clear. Mexico would pay for the wall. So, I’ll wait and see if the wall ends up being built and who pays for it.

And, it may surprise you to know this, but the vast majority of Trump’s rallies were online.
 
Not hard to find the possible actions Trump could do:
  • renegotiate NAFTA. Mexico has a $71bn trade surplus with the US. Some of that can be clawed back.
  • raise import tariffs for goods coming in from Mexico. There is precedent for this as tariffs used to be the main income source for the early days of the US government.
  • raise fees for border-related visas.
Biggest problem is the resistance among those who stand to benefit the most from the ease with which illegals enter the country. Well that’s both parties: Democrats love the new voters and Republicans love the cheap labor.

Taxing remittances sounds good, but I’m not as keen on this as it would simply encourage workarounds and hence won’t raise nearly as much as some think it would. Some version of it might be to ultimately tax only the remittances of the illegals. Anyone else hit can just get their money back on their tax returns. Ah, I still don’t like this one. Too much work for Western Union et al, the IRS, etc.
 
renegotiate NAFTA. Mexico has a $71bn trade surplus with the US. Some of that can be clawed back.
The trade surplus is money that belongs to individuals, not the government.
raise import tariffs for goods coming in from Mexico. There is precedent for this as tariffs used to be the main income source for the early days of the US government.
A tariff is paid for by consumers, not Mexico, so he cannot keep his promise this way.
raise fees for border-related visas.
I doubt you will get $18 billion this way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top