Why American Men Are Getting Less Marriageable

  • Thread starter Thread starter HerCrazierHalf
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

HerCrazierHalf

Guest
Robots, they’re taking your marriages…
Dorn and his colleagues find that when towns and counties lose manufacturing jobs, fertility and marriage rates among young adults go down, too. Unmarried births and the share of children living in single-parent homes go up. Meanwhile, places with higher manufacturing employment have a bigger wage gap between men and women, and a higher marriage rate.
 
If you read the article, it talks about how the loss of masculine roles has tended to turn men into worthless or at least less valuable mates. The cure? Teach men not to expect masculine roles.

Fell short of being persuasive.
 
It really is a self-fulfilling prophecy. Destroy the earning potential of men through taxation and over-regulation, flood their communities with drugs, alcohol, and promiscuity, subsidize the wages and employment of women through a thousand different programs, taxes, regulations, and laws, increasingly ‘feminize’ the education system, and then blame the men for their reactions to all this and demand they adapt to new ‘realities’. New ‘realities’ that were created by the very people demanding the adaptation.

Of course, this kind of stuff sells to a ‘certain crowd’ so we get some version of this article once every few days. Interestingly enough, the origin of these articles tends to cross the traditional boundaries of political persuasion, so if we’re looking for unity we need look no further.
 
Last edited:
I remember reading similar in a book called The Pinch. It wrote about how good paying manufacturing jobs in the 1950s or about that time in history, increased marriage numbers and changed the age of marriage downward. People were marring younger.

Then once robotics began to replace good paying jobs Americans and UK citizens began returning to earlier times. Marriages have been fewer with the age of marriage becoming later in life for many.
 
If you read the article, it talks about how the loss of masculine roles has tended to turn men into worthless or at least less valuable mates. The cure? Teach men not to expect masculine roles.

Fell short of being persuasive.
I agree with “fell short”.

If we’re teaching men not to expect masculine roles, how about teaching women to accept those men? Women usually don’t want to marry down; some will, but many won’t “settle” for that. Women usually prefer more masculine men than less; many will marry less masculine men because that’s all that are available. But they mostly won’t like it, hence most of those marriages will not do well. Between the two, the marriage picture doesn’t look good below the upper middle class.
 
I know a fair number of couples in which both husband and wife are professionals. While their incomes are astonishing, their lives aren’t what I would call ideal. Their earnings are on a par, and to advance, neither can really be a “stay-at-home” parent, so neither one is.

On the other hand, I know some in which the wife is a professional and the husband is “just a guy” who drives a truck or is a diesel mechanic or whatever. I know some in which the wife is a professional like a doctor or lawyer and the husband is a “stay-at-home” parent. I also know some in which the wife is a professional and the husband became a full-time “cowboy” running a ranch purchased with the wife’s high earnings.

Funny how those couples seem to differ. The higher earnings of the wife don’t seem to matter too much. What matters is the masculine role of the husband in those circumstances. The diesel mechanic comes home all grimy, but he’s still a man. He put three engines together that day, which few can do. He could break his wife’s arm with one hand, but he can change a diaper with the delicate skill of a surgeon, and will. The “cowboy” smells like manure, and scars the parquet floor with his boots, but he’s a man from head to foot. One of my jobs is to close loans, and “Dr. Mrs.” will defer to “Mr. Cowboy” or “Mr. Diesel Mechanic” in going through the paperwork. He sits closest to the closer and wife sits in the next chair. Interesting how people take their seats at the table. It really is. The one closest to the closer sees everything first, then hands it to the spouse. The closest of the two actually hears more from the closer because the more distant spouse is signing while the closer is explaining the next document.

The “stay at home” guy, or the guy who is not on the note because he’s “between jobs”. Well, that’s a little different. Most of those guys strike me as effeminate; deferential to the wife to the degree that one almost wants to shout at them “Go get a job as a welder, and while you’re at it lift some weights and go outside more”!

I know. I’m retrograde.
 
Last edited:
American men are getting less marriageable because women are becoming more like men…(this should stir things up)
 
American men are getting less marriageable because women are becoming more like men…
Women want equality except when it comes to the divorce courts where women receive the better end of the deal.
 
I know a number of stay at home dads. The ones who can afford to be stay at home dads are usually retired from jobs where they could retire by their early forties.

Fire fighters police officers.

I’d hate to judge a man’s manliness by what his job is or was.

I knew a male nurse who was the primary care giver to the kids. He worked the weekend shift, and perhaps one or two night shifts.
 
Women want equality except when it comes to the divorce courts where women receive the better end of the deal.
Depends. You can Google around and find women who out earn their husbands can end up paying alimony and/or child support. It’s becoming more common in divorces.

In a few decades it might be women pushing for prenups
 
Do they? At least in my jurisdiction, family assets are split down the middle, and where one spouse is disadvantaged financially by the divorce the other spouse will have to pay spousal support (alimony). While it’s more common for the husband to be higher income earner, and thus he has to pay support upon dissolution of the marriage, I have certainly heard of women having to pay spousal support.

Where I find inequity is more in child custody and support.
 
Which is funny because one average, children are far more likely to be abused by their mothers than by their fathers, and definitely by their mother’s boyfriends than their father’s girlfriends.
 
I think the reasoning is that, women usually do most of the childcare.
 
Last edited:
Depends. You can Google around and find women who out earn their husbands can end up paying alimony and/or child support. It’s becoming more common in divorces.

In a few decades it might be women pushing for prenups
Yes it happens, but it is not common. At all. From the Daily Mail (emphasis mine):
The Census Bureau says 243,000 people got alimony last year, 98 percent of them women
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5204741/Taxes-exes-How-tax-plan-alter-alimony.html

The real problem, as stated in this article, is that the since the payer is almost always in the higher tax bracket, the government will get more tax revenue for the same amount of money changing hands in an alimony agreement. In practice, it likely won’t work as well as they think as the payer who has to pay $1000 per month to a payee now has to come up with $1350 of income to pay that if he is in the 35% marginal tax rate bracket. And more if the states that tax income follow suit. Going to be some stubborn guys out there who will resist paying more out of pocket.
 
Last edited:
I think the reasoning is that, women usually do most of the childcare.
I think so too.

A relative of mine is a lawyer who does a lot of divorces. His male clients start out demanding custody. But this lawyer then says they need to work out a plan. He outlines where the child support from the wife will go, and in the course of it outlines the guy’s day.

Up early to get the kids dressed for school and drives them there. Go to work. Return from work to pick up the kids from the sitter (usually the guy’s mom), back home. Prepare evening meal. Help with homework. Get clothes ready for morning. Then mom shows up on Saturday all bright and rested and picks up the kids to go to an amusement park. Oh, and she demands two changes of clothing for her weekend. Dad, of course, does the laundry on Saturday and plans out meals for the week.

The lawyer tells me the men pretty quickly change their minds about custody after the “plan” is devised. “Well, she’s not such a terrible mother…”

I think most men are just not all that geared to day-to-day child care. I remember when our own kids were growing up, I was the “disciplinarian” and “tutor” for homework, the 'storyteller" at bedtime. I put together their (mom-cleaned) outfits for school in their presence: “skeletons” we called them…“let’s put together your skeletons for tomorrow”. (their clothes, socks, shoes, all laid out as if someone was in them) On weekends I was largely the one who took them around to things; the country, the fire station to see the fire trucks, the city infrastructure, the sledding, arrowhead-hunting, “interesting rock” collecting.

But my wife was the one who made every bit of it possible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top