Why are the New Age movement and other exotic ideas so attractive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter spiritualwrrior
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Relics do not hold special powers but are merely instruments that God uses to convey His power. They would be like what a favorite brush is to the Artist. The brush cannot paint of its own power but from the power of the Artist. Relics are recognized as some of Gods favorite brushes.😉
Credo in Deum,
I really appreciate this comment. Thanks for “painting” this issue with such clarity. 😉
Anna
 
Many don’t want to discern between sacrifice for others vs. entertainment for self. Feel good religions are more entertaining for the self despite claims of noble intentions. It’s not natural to want to sacrifice for others. People need the romanticism of the Church to want to devote one’s life to family above entertainment for the self.
 
New age stuff is dangerous because it’s mostly theory’s put out by one person, not tested over centuries like our established traditions. So there are bound to be more errors that can really hurt people. These authors make some good points and help people and thats why they get read. The danger in following a new age author blindly is that there is going to be flaws somewhere in their views that could cause serious problems in your life if taken seriously. Echart tolle or James Redfield’s views on relationships for example. The stuff that breaks families up. Whereas the teachings of the great established religions of the world, hinduism, buddism and our catholicism tend to keep families together. Ok can you tell I’m going through a separation yet!
 
I never made that claim.
If you didn’t at the very least implied, then you wouldn’t be so concerned with people owning “pagan” paraphernalia (such as Buddha statues or voodoo masks).
Any Statistics to back up that statement? 😉
Exorcists wouldn’t be so strict with ruling out psychological illnesses if true, authentic supernatural occult was as rampant as you insist on implying. 😉
I’ve had experiences with the spiritual realm since I was a young girl. Spiritual discernment is one of the spiritual gifts and it’s a difficult one for many reasons.
So is having a healthy and balanced sense of skepticism and maintaining a critical mind. You think it doesn’t exhaust me spending hours thinking about all this and arguing with myself? The rarity of supernatural events does not necessarily dispel them from existence but neither does it mean I’m gonna get a visit from the Morgan la Fay for fantasizing about being a descendant of Merlin.
It is not necessary for you to believe me or agree with me; but I think there is some risk involved in ruling this out so completely, especially in light of Holy Scripture. There is a spiritual battle going on all the time, regardless of whether you or not you believe it.
Reducing the probability of something does not equal ruling it out on the exaggerated level you accuse me of doing. Just because I am less likely to get struck by lightning does not mean it can’t happen. It does mean however that I can walk in the rain with a heckuva lot less fear. In that same manner, I can study and collect as much “pagan” artifacts as I am able with little fear of any “evil spirit”. In fact, you never did address the fact that the Vatican plays museum to a lot of such artifacts from Ancient Greece and Rome. You’re not saying that, along with every other major museum in the world, is full of demonic spirits are you?
Your response about talismans:

I will pray for your protection, 🙂
Right, I’m gonna get a visit from Azazel for crafting some random doohickie. :rolleyes:
 
If you didn’t at the very least implied, then you wouldn’t be so concerned with people owning “pagan” paraphernalia (such as Buddha statues or voodoo masks).

Exorcists wouldn’t be so strict with ruling out psychological illnesses if true, authentic supernatural occult was as rampant as you insist on implying. 😉

So is having a healthy and balanced sense of skepticism and maintaining a critical mind. You think it doesn’t exhaust me spending hours thinking about all this and arguing with myself? The rarity of supernatural events does not necessarily dispel them from existence but neither does it mean I’m gonna get a visit from the Morgan la Fay for fantasizing about being a descendant of Merlin.

Reducing the probability of something does not equal ruling it out on the exaggerated level you accuse me of doing. Just because I am less likely to get struck by lightning does not mean it can’t happen. It does mean however that I can walk in the rain with a heckuva lot less fear. In that same manner, I can study and collect as much “pagan” artifacts as I am able with little fear of any “evil spirit”. In fact, you never did address the fact that the Vatican plays museum to a lot of such artifacts from Ancient Greece and Rome. You’re not saying that, along with every other major museum in the world, is full of demonic spirits are you?

Right, I’m gonna get a visit from Azazel for crafting some random doohickie. :rolleyes:
Lost Wanderer,

This article might help. 🙂 It is written from the Catholic viewpoint.

SEANCES, SPIRITS AND THE OCCULT A Catholic View, by Fr. Peter J: Elliott
Link: freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/2446217/posts

Peace,
Anna
 
I’ve searched the whole articles for mentions of statues, talismans, and even Buddhism and I find nothing relevant to our discussion.
Lost Wanderer,
Did you actually read the article? The author gives an answer to the OP’s question: Why are the New Age movement and other exotic ideas so attractive?

"A Hunger for Experience

In the cases of young people who get involved in occultism or the cults, curiosity promises a release from listless boredom. Curiosity and boredom may lead to drugs, sex and crime. This combination may also lead to exotic religions, anything from playing with the seance to digging potatoes on a cult commune. Resting on a religious ignorance, the young may put their trust in the stars or submit slavishly to the smug nodding of a plump little Eastern guru. Those who were “into macrobiotic food” last year, may be “into Yoga” this year, and they may be “into spoon-bending, levitation and spiritualism” next year, and into a mental home the year after next."
Link: freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/2446217/posts

Eastern religions are mentioned multiple times in the article as well as the spiritual dangers of the occult.

Anna
 
Eastern religions are mentioned multiple times in the article as well as the spiritual dangers of the occult.
Ah but Occult =/= Trinkets.

You made statements about Feng Shui and Buddist statues that were rather off the mark. You admitted it yourself that a person need not be dabbling at all to purchase such items or adopt certain practical aspects.

It sounds like you have a lot to clarify.
 
How exactly were my statements “off the mark”?
Expressing “shock” at the thought of Christians owning items and applying practices you deem “pagan” when such ownership need not be cause for concern is definitely off the mark.
In what post did I admit that a person need not be dabbling at all to purchase such items or adopt certain practical aspects?
In your own words:
I understand that having a statue of Buddha does not make one a Buddhist.
 
Sufjon,

There is something else that I want to say about your remark:

Some of the most disturbing experiences I’ve ever had came through my own spiritual blindness, after failure to heed a spiritual warning. So, it has nothing to do with any kind of prejudice against those who believe differently than I do.

Anna
Hi Anna: I think I understand what you’re saying to some degree, however, I would be interested to know what you feel spiritual blindness to be. What did you fail to see that caused you to have disturbing experiences, and what were the disturbing experiences?

Your friend
Sufjon
 
You admitted it yourself that a person need not be dabbling at all to purchase such items or adopt certain practical aspects.
. . . .In your own words:
This was the full quote “in my own words”:
Lost Wanderer,
I understand that having a statue of Buddha does not make one a Buddhist. I have had some disturbing experiences with spirits and objects, which I won’t go into on this thread. People who have these kinds of experiences understand. Some, even fellow Christians, who have not had these experiences, can sometimes be either dismissive or judgmental.
Expressing “shock” at the thought of Christians owning items and applying practices you deem “pagan” when such ownership need not be cause for concern is definitely off the mark.
How do you know there is no cause for concern? I posted a Catholic article that spoke of the danger of Eastern paganism. That wasn’t enough.

You wrote about a doll cursed by a witch, and that wasn’t enough.
I’ve had a doll cursed by a witch and it nearly killed my sister. . . . .
If there was no possibility of spirits attaching to objects, there would be no need for a Catholic exorcism of objects.

(Emphasis is mine)
Catholic Encyclopedia
"Exorcism

(See also DEMONOLOGY, DEMONIACS, EXORCIST, POSSESSION.)

Exorcism is (1) the act of driving out, or warding off, demons, or evil spirits, from persons, places, or things, which are believed to be possessed or infested by them, or are liable to become victims or instruments of their malice; (2) the means employed for this purpose, especially the solemn and authoritative adjuration of the demon, in the name of God, or any of the higher power in which he is subject. . . . . .

"Other exorcisms

According to Catholic belief demons or fallen angels retain their natural power, as intelligent beings, of acting on the material universe, and using material objects and directing material forces for their own wicked ends; and this power, which is in itself limited, and is subject, of course, to the control of Divine providence, is believed to have been allowed a wider scope for its activity in the consequence of the sin of mankind. Hence places and things as well as persons are naturally liable to diabolical infestation, within limits permitted by God, and exorcism in regard to them is nothing more that a prayer to God, in the name of His Church, to restrain this diabolical power supernaturally, and a profession of faith in His willingness to do so on behalf of His servants on earth."

Link: newadvent.org/cathen/05709a.htm

Lost Wanderer, exactly what is your disagreement with my posts?

Anna
 
Lost Wanderer,
I understand that having a statue of Buddha does not make one a Buddhist. I have had some disturbing experiences with spirits and objects, which I won’t go into on this thread. People who have these kinds of experiences understand. Some, even fellow Christians, who have not had these experiences, can sometimes be either dismissive or judgmental.

Anna
Anna, it is very common for those who take a more serious stance against paganism, whether it is in the context of real religion, or fantasy elements, to be dismissed as reactionary and over-zealous. It has happened to me in the past, and I expect it will ocntinue into the future.
 
Anna, it is very common for those who take a more serious stance against paganism, whether it is in the context of real religion, or fantasy elements, to be dismissed as reactionary and over-zealous. It has happened to me in the past, and I expect it will ocntinue into the future.
StTommyMore,
You are right. I always tell myself I’m not going to get involved int these types of discussions for the very reasons you mentioned; but it’s difficult to see what Christians will allow to enter their lives. I’ve been guilty of this so many times myself, and have suffered the consequences. I enter the discussions hoping to spare others of what I have suffered; but sometimes I seem to be no help at all.

Peace,
Anna
 
Hi Anna: I think I understand what you’re saying to some degree, however, I would be interested to know what you feel spiritual blindness to be. What did you fail to see that caused you to have disturbing experiences, and what were the disturbing experiences?

Your friend
Sufjon
Sufjon,
My most disturbing experiences are intensely personal; and considering the general tone of some of the posts on this thread; I’m not sure anything would be accomplished by sharing them.

Anna
 
Er, not to be nitpicky, but I wouldn’t put the two in the same boat.
I find Feng Shui naturally stupid. I personally arrange my things purely based on what seems most convenient and not on some obscure Chinese spirituality.

On the other hand, having a statue of Buddha in your home does not necessarily mean you are a Buddhist. Otherwise, the Vatican might be guilty of paganism as it houses plenty of statues of Greek and Roman gods.
Lost Wanderer,
Having a statue of Buddha may not make you a Buddhist; but that doesn’t mean Christians should have a statue of Buddha in their homes.

Some Catholic viewpoints:

Link: catholicvu.com/newpage800htm.htm
APRIL/MAY 2011
ASK A PRIEST
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

CatholicView Staff: Is a statue of Buddha okay to keep or should I get rid of it? It’s for decoration and in no way does it represent an idol to me. Thank you for being there. - Diane

". . . . . .Christians have no need to have a Buddha in the house. Usually, people will say that they don’t believe in Buddha and they don’t see it as an idol, but people have it as a good luck charm…which in itself is considered a talisman, hence against Old Testament prohibitions concerning false gods. Trust in God. He will always fulfill your needs no matter how insecure you feel about the future.

Diane, **for the sake of those who do not know your intentions, I would discard the statue of Buddha. ** Even though you do not use it for religious purposes, it is something that does not represent your faith. Some may consider it an idol. May the Lord continue to guide and bless you. - CatholicView Staff"

Link: fisheaters.com/home4.html
Atmosphere of the Home
“. . . . .Just as we are variously affected as regards our bodies by the material atmosphere in which we live,–by its heat and cold, by the gases and germs and minute particles of dust that it holds: so, too, are our souls affected by the sensible objects around us; and the aggregate of such objects is accordingly quite appropriately called moral atmosphere.”

Why is Yoga incompatible with Catholicism?
catholiceducation.org/articles/religion/re0275.html

Demonic Influence on Rise in Conciliar Church
Catholic exorcist: Demonic influence is strong in today’s world
By John Thavis
8/29/2006
Catholic News Service (www.catholicnews.com)
". . . . .Father Amorth said he thought one reason why the devil’s influence was high today is that Christian faith has weakened, replaced in many cases by superstition and an interest in the occult, which he said “open the way to demonic influences. . . .”

I think we must be careful in our answers and posts regarding spiritual matters. We are not simply talking with each other. The other members of this thread are not the only ones reading our conversation. This thread has already had almost 4,000 views. So, what we say matters.

Peace,
Anna
 
I’m sorry I haven’t read all the pages of this topic yet, but I can offer my two cents.

There are many reasons I now identify myself as pagan. What is perhaps the greatest draw off the beaten spiritual path is the self-discovery of it all. I have no church teachings, no spiritual leaders I answer to. I gather information from life experiences, from various religious texts, from various spiritual leaders, and from others following their own paths. I process that information, note what I think are good ideas, bad ideas, possibly true, or impossible. At the end of it all, I have a perfectly tailored religion for myself that is constantly changing and developing. I’m not a Wiccan or a reconstructionist or a Christian. I have animist leanings, do some minor magic (though some Wiccans would argue that it’s not magic because I don’t cast a circle), and believe in the equality of all humanity. I do not believe Jesus is the son of God, nor do I believe in hell. I do not believe most of what is in the bible, but see it as a collection of myths as useful as that of any other society or religion. I’ve yet to commit to many solid beliefs, preferring for now to consider what does and does not make sense (and honestly, fairies make more sense than hell to me), but that’s okay for pagans. Paganism does not demand that you know what you want to believe in right off the bat, and it’s okay to take your time.
 
How do you know there is no cause for concern? I posted a Catholic article that spoke of the danger of Eastern paganism. That wasn’t enough.

You wrote about a doll cursed by a witch, and that wasn’t enough.
Because I studied my country’s own ethnic pagan myths and folklore with little to no spiritual harm. I’ve played games that “dabbled” with such pagan mythologies and wrote plenty of stories and fanfiction yet never even once suffered a symptom of demonic influence as prescribed in books such as that of my own country’s leading exorcist Fr. Syquia of the Manila Archdiocese.
If there was no possibility of spirits attaching to objects, there would be no need for a Catholic exorcism of objects.
I repeat:

Less probability =/= No possibility
Lost Wanderer, exactly what is your disagreement with my posts?
That you believe in an unhealthy and unlikely probability towards non-Christian items as if they are sources of demonic influence.
Anna, it is very common for those who take a more serious stance against paganism, whether it is in the context of real religion, or fantasy elements, to be dismissed as reactionary and over-zealous. It has happened to me in the past, and I expect it will ocntinue into the future.
Ad homs do not reduce the quality of people’s arguments.
Lost Wanderer,
Having a statue of Buddha may not make you a Buddhist; but that doesn’t mean Christians should have a statue of Buddha in their homes.

Some Catholic viewpoints:

Link: catholicvu.com/newpage800htm.htm
APRIL/MAY 2011
ASK A PRIEST
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

CatholicView Staff: Is a statue of Buddha okay to keep or should I get rid of it? It’s for decoration and in no way does it represent an idol to me. Thank you for being there. - Diane

". . . . . .Christians have no need to have a Buddha in the house. Usually, people will say that they don’t believe in Buddha and they don’t see it as an idol, but people have it as a good luck charm…which in itself is considered a talisman, hence against Old Testament prohibitions concerning false gods. Trust in God. He will always fulfill your needs no matter how insecure you feel about the future.

Diane, **for the sake of those who do not know your intentions, I would discard the statue of Buddha. ** Even though you do not use it for religious purposes, it is something that does not represent your faith. Some may consider it an idol. May the Lord continue to guide and bless you. - CatholicView Staff"
Two things are being ignored here.

1.) People can collect such statues for purely aesthetic reasons such as decoration or appreciation of a certain style/culture.

2.) Nobody is ever responsible for the misconceptions formulated by shallow individuals who judge people by superficial aspects such housing decorations. There are plenty of despicable individuals out there yet have their houses full of saint statues and altars.
Link: fisheaters.com/home4.html
Atmosphere of the Home
“. . . . .Just as we are variously affected as regards our bodies by the material atmosphere in which we live,–by its heat and cold, by the gases and germs and minute particles of dust that it holds: so, too, are our souls affected by the sensible objects around us; and the aggregate of such objects is accordingly quite appropriately called moral atmosphere.”
Seeing as how fisheaters doesn’t rank as a decent site with its blatant Traditionalist bent, it’s not exactly a fair and balanced source of information.

Furthermore, I’ve been dabbling with fantasy and reading up mythology for over ten years. You’ll find that I don’t so much as twitch at holy water being splashed on me. Neither will you find me an Aleister Crowley despite the presence of so many books and comics depicting such myths.

You find a bigger source of “infection” from my parents’ collection of New Age self-help books. :rolleyes:
I think we must be careful in our answers and posts regarding spiritual matters. We are not simply talking with each other. The other members of this thread are not the only ones reading our conversation. This thread has already had almost 4,000 views. So, what we say matters.
Indeed it matters which is why I do my best to defend those who have interest in non-Christian culture and art as well as those who draw inspiration from non-Christian folklore and myth.

No doubt even Tolkien himself will take you upon your claims that studying the myths of pagan peoples and owning their artifacts purely for aesthetic and academic reasons is somehow a gateway to the demonic.
 
Because I studied my country’s own ethnic pagan myths and folklore with little to no spiritual harm. I’ve played games that “dabbled” with such pagan mythologies and wrote plenty of stories and fanfiction yet never even once suffered a symptom of demonic influence as prescribed in books such as that of my own country’s leading exorcist Fr. Syquia of the Manila Archdiocese.

I repeat:

Less probability =/= No possibility

That you believe in an unhealthy and unlikely probability towards non-Christian items as if they are sources of demonic influence.

Ad homs do not reduce the quality of people’s arguments.

Two things are being ignored here.

1.) People can collect such statues for purely aesthetic reasons such as decoration or appreciation of a certain style/culture.

2.) Nobody is ever responsible for the misconceptions formulated by shallow individuals who judge people by superficial aspects such housing decorations. There are plenty of despicable individuals out there yet have their houses full of saint statues and altars.

Seeing as how fisheaters doesn’t rank as a decent site with its blatant Traditionalist bent, it’s not exactly a fair and balanced source of information.

Furthermore, I’ve been dabbling with fantasy and reading up mythology for over ten years. You’ll find that I don’t so much as twitch at holy water being splashed on me. Neither will you find me an Aleister Crowley despite the presence of so many books and comics depicting such myths.

You find a bigger source of “infection” from my parents’ collection of New Age self-help books. :rolleyes:

Indeed it matters which is why I do my best to defend those who have interest in non-Christian culture and art as well as those who draw inspiration from non-Christian folklore and myth.

No doubt even Tolkien himself will take you upon your claims that studying the myths of pagan peoples and owning their artifacts purely for aesthetic and academic reasons is somehow a gateway to the demonic.
Lost Wanderer,
And so my friend, we end our discussion just as it began–with neither of us having convinced the other to change the beliefs we hold.

Peace to you, brother in Christ,
Anna
 
Sufjon,
My most disturbing experiences are intensely personal; and considering the general tone of some of the posts on this thread; I’m not sure anything would be accomplished by sharing them.

Anna
Sorry - I didn’t realize they were personal. I thought since you had made reference to them that you would be able to relate your experiences. My intent was not to pry.

Your friend
Sufjon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top