hi everyone
my questions for christians are; why are u a christian? what makes u chose christianity over other beliefs (athiesm, judaism, islam, hinduism etc)? what makes christianity stand out? do u think that u would have became a christian if not born as one?
i await ur replies
When scholarship brings its razor to bear, Catholicism is the only religion to survive, though Liberal Protestantism and Reform Judaism are special cases.
We know that the Torah was not dictated to Moses on Sinai, so the Orthodox Jew must choose between his religion and scholarship. It is pretty obvious that the Koran was not dictated by the angel Gabriel, so the Musim must choose between Mohammed and rational analysis of the text. Hinduism, as the name imlies, is simply a name for the ancient pagan religion of India. Though individual Hindus often believe many wise things, we know that the world is not full of gods and divine figures as Hiduism suggests.
However the gospels and letters of the New Testament were written in the first century and describe a man who lived, and who may have risen from the dead - the only reason for rejecting the Resurrection as an historical fact is if you disbelieve in miracles.
Liberal Protestantism can be rejected on other grounds, notably the shallow, culture-bound nature of its moral rules. It is hard to believe that, in a hundred years time, we will still be talking about homosexual bishops, for example. Extreme social phenomena don’t usually last long.
That leaves atheism. Atheism is an intellectually credible alternative to Catholicism. That’s where the intellectual debate is at.
I can’t give reasons for rejecting atheism here. Note that my book, which you can link to from my sig, does not give reasons for rejecting atheism, it refutes some arguments commonly employed by atheists, which is a rather different thing. You used the “Wicca” argument, by the way.