Why Aren't the Jewish People more Pro-life?

  • Thread starter Thread starter oneofmany
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“To the Law and the Prophets; if they don’t speak according to this method; it is because there is no light in them.” (Isa. 8:20) That’s the test to decide which position is the Jewish
position par excellence. The rest is commentary.
Before Rabbi Hillel, Rabbi Jesus, and Rabbi Akiba, the Torah (Leviticus) says that “Loving thy neighbor as thyself” is the essence of the Law and, implicitly, all the rest is commentary. I think Jesus adds “Loving thy enemy” although the Law states “Rejoice not when thy enemy falls.”
 
Before Rabbi Hillel, Rabbi Jesus, and Rabbi Akiba, the Torah (Leviticus) says that “Loving thy neighbor as thyself” is the essence of the Law and, implicitly, all the rest is commentary. I think Jesus adds “Loving thy enemy” although the Law states “Rejoice not when thy enemy falls.”
First of all, Meltzerboy, when you quote, please don’t mention only the book. I mean the chapter and verse too. If not for any other reason, that you are being integral.

Now, about “Loving thy neighbor as thyself,” it is impossible. Love is an emotion, and emotions are not dictated upon. When they happen, whatever comes as a result of it, just happens. I am aware that Torah mentions it as in Deut. 6:4. But we ought to interpret it as respect. To respect our neighbor as we would respect ourselves. Respect yes, it can even
be demanded, but not love. And to love our enemies! Mercy fits better here. We can have mercy on someone else but not love. Unless one is a masochist. “Rejoice not when thy enemy falls.” Behold! That’s something viable, but to love him is a joke.
 
Jharek, a little Psychology here would be of a greater help to understand the Theology of a commandment than religious fundamentalism. Please, no offense meant.
 
Yes, I am aware of that concept. It is Pauline. He is the one whom I learned it from. But it has nothing to do with the effects of emotions that are independent of our will.
 
One quick question. why is that Jews follow the “The Mourner’s Kaddish”? If there is no belief in afterlife what is the point of prayer for the dead?
 
One quick question. why is that Jews follow the “The Mourner’s Kaddish”? If there is no belief in afterlife what is the point of prayer for the dead?
The Mourner’s Kaddish has no mention of death; rather, it is a memorial prayer in praise of G-d. Likewise, the period of mourning for the departed (traditionally lasting for eleven months) is for the dual purpose of showing respect for the dead and comforting the living. Nonetheless, I maintain there is indeed a belief in an afterlife in Judaism, in which those who follow the commandments of the Torah–essentially loving G-d by means of expressing charity toward others–will be rewarded.
 
The Mourner’s Kaddish has no mention of death; rather, it is a memorial prayer in praise of G-d. Likewise, the period of mourning for the departed (traditionally lasting for eleven months) is for the dual purpose of showing respect for the dead and comforting the living. Nonetheless, I maintain there is indeed a belief in an afterlife in Judaism, in which those who follow the commandments of the Torah–essentially loving G-d by means of expressing charity toward others–will be rewarded.
Thank You for clarification.😉
 
One quick question. why is that Jews follow the “The Mourner’s Kaddish”? If there is no belief in afterlife what is the point of prayer for the dead?
The Mourner’s Kaddish has nothing to do with the dead but as a prayer of praising God for the evidence of God’s providence to give and take life. “God gives and takes away; so, praise to His name.” There is no reference at all to the dead in the sense of asking God for a good destination for his soul. We all know that the dead is going to the world to come
which is the grave.
 
The Mourner’s Kaddish has no mention of death; rather, it is a memorial prayer in praise of G-d. Likewise, the period of mourning for the departed (traditionally lasting for eleven months) is for the dual purpose of showing respect for the dead and comforting the living. Nonetheless, I maintain there is indeed a belief in an afterlife in Judaism, in which those who follow the commandments of the Torah–essentially loving G-d by means of expressing charity toward others–will be rewarded.
Jews do not obey God’s Law with an eye in rewards. We obey the mitzvot for the sake of obedience to the mitzvot.
 
Shibolet, Meltzerboy - so the Kaddish is not said in order to help the soul to ascend to paradise? I had got this idea from this site - is it wrong?
chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/282566/jewish/Kaddish-Ends-Soul-Ascends.htm
Yes Vanes, according to Judaism, there is no such a thing as ascendance to paradise. That’s not a Jewish doctrine. Besides, the soul is not something that exists independent of the body. According to Genesis 2:7, when the Lord formed man from the dust of the earth, He breathed in his nostrils the breath of life and he became a living soul. As you can see, soul is something we become and not something we have. Therefore, we are living souls. At death, the body goes back to the dust and the breath of life goes back to God, Who gave it. The soul then, becomes as if it never existed. In other words, the soul is by definition the composition of the body with the breath of life. From the moment one is out of the other, the soul is gone.
 
I see, thank you! Just one more question: why is it said for 11 months?
The Mourner’s Kaddish (for parents) is technically for one year. However, it is felt that one would have to be quite wicked to need a full year of prayer, so it is by custom reduced to eleven months. Again, contrary to Shibolet, I was taught that we DO pray for the souls of the departed to be cleansed so that they can enter the World to Come (not the grave). The latter concept comes later in Jewish tradition than that of the here-and-now world, which is nonetheless still the major focus in Judaism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top